Winterbourne View Hospital Summary

Andrew Phelvin article, “Winterbourne View Hospital and the Social Psychology of Abuse” compares the ideas of a social psychologist, Phillip Zimbardo, to different experiments that have happened over the years. The focus of the scholarly journal is the Winterbourne View hospital situation that happened in early 2011. He briefly summarizes the reason as to why the hospital is included in his article. A BBC reporter secretly filmed the Winterbourne View Hospital in 2011. This caught on film the abuse of residents in the hospital who suffered from mental illness. Phelvin also talks speaks about two other events that are similar to the Winterbourne view mistreatment. The Stanford Prison Experiment in particular continues the steady theme of controversial psychological experiments. Phelvin includes definitions of behavior that people who are involved in these experiments may have stimulated within them. Dispositional factors are when the personality traits or the motives of people change from the different circumstances at which they are involved. When they are free to choose their choices may become deeper desires that they want to do but not always morally right. This idea specially connects with
This journal is a reliable source because it has information from the psychologist himself. There are also other articles used in the text that are reliable pieces of information also. This journal was not biased. It did not include any personal opinion and quoted information from the psychologist behind the Stanford Prison experiment. The purpose of the article was to inform the reader on the experiments and other mistreatments in hospitals or prisons, but it also wanted to show the correlation between having power and the righteousness of the action. This compared to the other sources in the annotated bibliography because it showed various examples of how power can be manipulated and taken advantage of by moral