Women could not participate in politics, could not contribute to family wealth, and even could not concern themselves with affairs beyond the range of home. Awakened by the weakness of women’s voices at that time, many predominant feminists emerged, such as Beecher and Stanton. They devoted themselves passionately and profoundly to fighting for women’s rights, though there were still some differences between one another. Beecher wrote A treatise on domestic economy conservatively to express women’s desires to be independent and Stanton published the famous women’s “declaration of independence”—Declaration of Sentiments radically claimed “all men and women are created equal” (Stanton 201). By comparing their works in politics, family status and jobs and education; past and modern society, feminists have made progress and have figured out that the more democratic and fairer status women possess, the more respect society shows to women and the more advanced society it will be. People’s right to vote is their basic right to publish their political opinions and their desires. Back to the mid 19th century, Beecher is more conservative compared to other feminists. She discouraged women participating in politics, but supported the idea that women should be more effective and active in educating young males, not to speak of vote right. The opposed notion from Stanton strongly advocated that “It is the duty of the women of this country to secure to themselves their sacred tight to the elective franchise.” (Stanton 202) She is an active and strong supporter of everyone’s equality, as in Declaration of Sentiments, Stanton used the same format as Declaration of Independence to protest men’s tyranny of ignoring and repressing women’s rights. During the progressive era, Stanton even put into practice a fight for suffrage which contributes more to the victory of gaining right to vote: “Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Susan B. Anthony, and Lucy Stone organized the Equal Rights Association (1866). However, conflict over the Fifteenth Amendment, granting black male voting rights, resulted in the first feminist schism and the creation of two separate woman suffrage organizations. The more radical Stanton and Anthony formed the American Woman Suffrage Association." (Moon 41)
While in the modern era, Beecher's statement is no longer valid, Women now can vote as independent individuals. During the presidency of President Wilson, Wilson agreed to grant women the right to vote but not in constitutional amendment. After more years' struggle and cooperation, finally women's suffrage is ratified by the States. (Hill 75) In comparison with women's numb appearance before this when they did not care about any politics, the fulfillment in suffrage not only urges women to perform more actively, but also increases women's confidence in themselves which can make the country more vigorous. Moreover, it stimulates women to learn more so that they can be more responsible and thoughtful in political affairs. Thus, the right for women to vote has achieved great success and satisfied Stanton and many other feminists' pursuit. This also remarks women's progress in approaching equality and democracy. Branching from women’s limited roles in the politics, women’s employment was once another concern and struggle in the history. In Beecher's mind and observations, women are more likely to behave exaltedly as good educators, influencing mothers and sagacious guides without participating in any other careers especially in politics; “commit the exalted privilege of extending over the world those blessed influences, that are to renovate degraded man.”(Beecher 200) Nevertheless, Stanton resisted men’s monopoly on “nearly all the profitable employments”. (Stanton 201) Indeed, at that time, women could not take up occupations because men thought women could not hold any properties at that time. Employment opportunities were limited: high paid jobs were not given to women like teachers, lawyers and doctors (Stanton 201); only pink-collar professions like nurses and waitresses were available, which are all low-paid work. (Moon 25) Nowadays, women’s professions pervade in every field because of the diversity of jobs. It’s no longer like what Beecher said, that women should stay at home to focus on household and educating kids. Later on, women entered the workplace like mills and factories. (Lapsansky 287) As more and more women have rights, they began to ask for better working conditions, such as working hours and wages, however, their wages belong to their husbands earlier. In the early postwar years, labor movement focused on protective labor legislation, but by the 1960s, wage justice for all became a priority. (Moon 185) Until now, women have received the same treatments and requirements as men do and they are completely independent at work. People believe that women can do everything that men are capable of. The work issue has been addressed perfectly too, which reached Stanton’s ideal view about employment. Gender equality is depicted at large and meanwhile women’s wisdom or different perspectives make work more effective and successful. The work rights for women also helps cultivate a competitive consciousness for men, functioning as a stimulus for everyone to work hard. Based on this understanding, it shows more developed, more democratic, and more just a society that embraces contribution of intelligence from various sources.
Education is an essential part as it is a foundation to achieve more advanced vocations. In the early era, women were considered being inferior, intelligently and morally, and that is also what Beecher thought. Many early feminists like her believed women were uneducated. The opposite view about education is against that all colleges were closed against women from Stanton. She wished to “encourage women to speak and teach, as she has an opportunity, in all religious assemblies”. (Stanton 202) However, time is changing and people’s thoughts are improving: “In the post-Civil War years, women established clear connections between raising children to be good citizens and betterment of their own lives through education. Between 1865 and the 1890s, several women’s colleges opened, and many colleges instituted coeducational programs. This growth of college and universities programs provided new opportunities for both men and women.” (Moon 25)
What Beecher and early feminists thought now certainly is not valid any more. Currently, everyone can go to colleges if they have enough ability to handle school work, with no gender discrimination and no class discrimination. Education now becomes a necessity that everyone needs to possess. There even is a statistic that, at present, the number of women in college is higher than that of men. This trend proves the advancement that feminists have achieved. Education will make women perform better in every area in life. It is enlightened that women have huge potential to be explored as a result. Marriages serve as turning points in women’s lives. In the past, Beecher preferred the view of subordination that "there must be relations between magistrate and the subject." In the case of marriage, women can follow their own wills to choose married or single, which husband to marry. (Beecher 198) It is more like a granted right to choose the obedience by own wishes, which agrees with modern society. In the same position, Stanton similarly opposed "making her civilly dead if married". (Stanton 201) In fact, Stanton worked hard to pass a law--"Married Women's Property Act" which granted many property rights for women. (Lapsansky 290) Before that, husbands could abuse wives, women's rights and properties would all belong to husbands if they married, women even would be taxed if they worked outside home. However things improved smoothly: "Romantic love and a belief in a more equal marriage relationship took firm foot in this era…because of the increase in female labor and the previous suffrage victories that empowered women to rethink their status in society. "(Moon 86) In marriage case, Beecher's words is universally right till now. Women sticked to this idea to encourage each other reject men's mistreatments in marriages. The movement in marriage followed the right path and achieved the women's independence successfully. It ensures women's voice to be announced, women's rights to be protected and women's equality in marriage to be balanced and respected.
Women's rights now have successively secured by the efforts devoted by large groups of feminists and years of protesting and movements. There are still some deficiencies about women's status and rights in today's society; yet compared to the past one and a half centuries, women have effectively strived for their properties in politics, employment, education, marriage and other areas, based on these outstanding feminists and their theories.
Source:
Beecher, Catharine E. A Treatise on Domestic Economy (excerpt) in Opposing Viewpoints in American History. William Dudley, ed. San Diego: Greenhaven Press, Inc., 1996. Print.
Hill, Jeff. Woman's Suffrage. Detroit, MI: Omnigraphics, Inc., 2006. Print.
Lapsansky-Werner, Emma J. et al. United States History. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education Prentice-Hall, inc., 2010. Print.
Moon, Danelle. Daily Life of Women During the Civil Rights Era. Santa Barbara, California: Greenwood, 2011. Print.
Stanton, Elizabeth Cady, “Declaration of Sentiments” in Opposing Viewpoints in American History. William Dudley, ed. San Diego: Greenhaven Press, Inc., 1996. Print.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Following the victory of the Suffrage movement with the passage and ratification of the 19th amendment in 1920 many in the women’s movement were left wondering, what’s next? Suffrage was the attainment of a goal of generations of women, and with its passage, to paraphrase Plutarch, what worlds were left to be conquered? Writing in the Historian, Peter Geidel states that it was at this point that the women’s movement splintered into schools: The Social Feminists and the Feminists”. According to Geidel the Social Feminists were more numerous and considered “feminism as only part of their reform program”. Women who considered themselves Social Feminists were not interested in full equality with men because they saw it as a threat to various…
- 336 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
During the 1920s was a time of great change in America. The role as a woman was changing in a big way not only at home, but also in the workplace and society. On August 18, 1920 the congress ratified and passed the 19th amendment, which guarantees all women the right to vote. In Crystal Eastman’s essay “Now we can begin” she gives her view of feminism during this time period and how it was viewed as negative since all the feminist leaders at the time was associated with socialism or communism. This negative social view prevented progressive movement in feminism. In “Now we can Begin” Crystal Eastman effectively uses examples on how the women’s right to vote in the 1920s would lead to social changes, economic changes, and women’s freedom overall which were unpopular at the time.…
- 727 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Women would attend abolitionist meetings and hold debates in order to get other men in women to join the movement. Two notable authors of the time, Catharine Beecher and Elizabeth Stanton, each wrote about their different opinions on women’s involvement in politics. Catharine Beecher’s essay “The Duty of American Females” is a response to women’s involvement in politics and especially…
- 658 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Crystal Eastman was an American lawyer, antimilitarist, socialist, journalist, and most importantly, a feminist at the end of the women’s suffrage movements. Her words inspire the women of America. She breathed life into the Bill of Rights as a major leader in the suffrage and equal rights movements in the early twentieth century. Eastman displays several ideas that propel the ideology of not only the roles of women, and their independence in the work force, but also to the men and their role within the home. Through addressing women and their capacity to work alongside men, an impression of equality and identity is given to women.…
- 1092 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Throughout history, struggles have defined groups of people and focused their resolve to alter the course of human history. For women, the early trials seemed insurmountable, but with the birth of a single female, woman acquired an advocate and spokesperson who would forge a new and fiery path for the women’s rights movement. Elizabeth Cady Stanton was a remarkable woman who from an early age recognized and despised the patriarchal society which heaped inequality and servitude upon woman. As a matter of fact, she realized that woman had fewer rights than the previously reviled black man. Stanton spent her life changing the perceptions and imposed…
- 3972 Words
- 16 Pages
Better Essays -
Women gaining the right to vote is otherwise known as Woman Suffrage. “The woman suffrage movement was a full-fledged political movement, with its own press, its own political imagery, and its own philosophers, organizers, lobbyists, financiers, and fundraisers” (RFW, 2007). It is considered to be one of the most important and “largest enfranchisement…
- 909 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
1840-1890’s women’s activists in the intellectual, social, economic, and political spheres effectively challenged traditional attitudes about women’s place in society” Asses the validity of this statement.…
- 508 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Throughout the lifetime of a human, countless misfortunes may need to be faced and endured. For several people, the severity of pain and adversity they experience could comparably surpass the amount of hardships of others. Such an example of this occurred during the early to mid-1800s in which numerous citizens of the United States pushed for reform of various conditions. One specific group that was a driving force for the reconstruction of society included brave and determined women. At the time, women were not viewed or treated as the equal counterpart to men.…
- 798 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Throughout this time period, women in Western Europe’s role in traditional society transitioned from child providing home keepers, as they were relied upon to raise children, to revolutionary idealists, as writers such as Mary Wollstonecraft advocated for equality of sexes, to being reduced once more to home keepers, after the Industrial Revolution reduces their roles to their traditional importance. Through the 18th century, women’s roles were ones of raising children and centered on menial housework, staying true to traditional beliefs of women and coinciding with their inability to participate in agricultural work anymore. During the 19th century, advocates for women’s equality led to the stirring up revolutionary ideals, and the induction of more significant rights for women. Nearing the 20th century, many parts of the world gave women the ability to vote, demonstrating the…
- 861 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In today’s society, women could be seen working at hospitals or schools or maybe some decide to be a housewife. In the early 1800s and before, women were seen as mere objects with immunity, freedom or priority. Women had no claim in literacy, in government, in owning land, saving earnings have a profession or ballot. Elizabeth Cady Stanton fought for what she believed was honorable in the female gender. Stanton placed confidence for women to have the ability to vote and have women suffrage. Also she place logical reasoning into why women should have the same equal right as men. Lastly Stanton used a more emotional appeal to attract more supporter. At Seneca Falls Women’s Convention in 1848, Stanton wrote the Declaration of Sentiment, Stanton…
- 1024 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The American movement for women’s liberation and rights was undoubtedly the most progressive in the decades that followed the Second World War. The second wave of feminism that ensued in the 1960s and 70s redirected the goals and ambitions in the fight for gender equality in many aspects. This new wave of liberal reform allowed women to break free from the domestic sphere from the conservative restraints of the 1950s, which have traditionally limited a women’s access to the same political, economic, and educational rights as men. While the fight for women’s equality started to make real headway post World War II, the fight for women’s rights has existed long before then. This can be seen in the Antebellum reforms or the first wave of feminism from the early 19th century to the early 20th century.…
- 839 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In most modern governments, such as the United States of America, give the right to vote to almost every responsible adult citizen. There were limiters on the right to vote when the US Constitution was written, and the individual states were allowed to setup their own rules governing who was allowed to vote. Women were denied the right to vote until the Nineteenth Amendment to the Constitution which was passed in 1920. In order to understand how women struggled to obtain the right to vote, some key factors must be looked at in further detail; why suffrage rights were not defined in the Constitution, the efforts that women put forth to obtain the right to vote, why there are present-day restrictions on voting, and the implications of Suffrage in current political policy.…
- 2809 Words
- 12 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Although any general definition of feminism would no doubt be controversial, it seems undeniable that much work in feminist theory is devoted to the tasks of critiquing women 's subordination, analyzing the intersections between sexism and other forms of subordination such as racism, heterosexism, and class oppression, and envisioning the possibilities for both individual and collective resistance to such subordination. Insofar as the concept of power is central to each of these theoretical tasks, power is clearly a central concept for feminist theory as well. And yet, curiously, it is one that is not often explicitly discussed in feminist…
- 10735 Words
- 43 Pages
Powerful Essays -
In Western Europe during the late eighteenth century, single women had almost no protection under the law, and married women lost their legal identity. Women couldn’t vote, sign contracts, retain a lawyer, have rights over their children, or inherit property. Mary Wollstonecraft caused a sensation by writing A Vindication of the Rights of Woman. She declared that both women and men were human beings endowed with inalienable rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. She insisted women should be free to pursue professional careers, enter business, and vote if they wished. She called for women to become educated. “I speak of the improvement and emancipation of the whole sex,” (Wollstonecraft 253) she declared. “Let woman share the rights, and she will emulate the virtues of man; for she must grow more perfect when emancipated” (281). Mary Wollstonecraft is often referred to as the Mother of Feminism, and her beliefs produced a major shift in the way women were viewed. She inspired change throughout the Western world. If she had not challenged the status quo, modern women would not enjoy the liberties…
- 1374 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Although most of the current leaders may be men it is actually women who control the world. Ladies and gentlemen, this is my focus for this afternoon's speech; that women are ultimately more powerful than men.…
- 403 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays