Preview

Zoos As Model Of Imperialism And Cultural Dismemberment By Malamud

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
190 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Zoos As Model Of Imperialism And Cultural Dismemberment By Malamud
2. Zoos as Model of Imperialism and “Cultural Dismemberment”
In his essay Malamud critically analyzes the relationship between humans and zoo animals.”What audiences see at the zoo, if we look carefully and thoughtfully, is that we cannot see” (Malamud 115), in this line Malamud comments on the ignorance of the zoo's viewers. Although the zoos' visitors see “sad, constrained and displayed animals”, they do not question the zoo's educational purpose and the execution thereof. The visitors accept the animals in their catatonic behavior and therefore ignore the deception provided by the zoos' sponsors and proponents (Malamud 120). Malamud also eagerly criticizes the humans' willingness to extract animals from their habitat and place them in visibly

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    (Par. 2)” This is a verse from a poem entitled The Panther by Rainer Maria Rilke describing the life of a panther that is locked within a cage for the use of entertainment. We will now be discussing the negative aspects of animals being used for entertainment purposes and why this will be the downfall of this wide span of businesses. To begin, stated in Green Garage’s blog about pros and cons of having zoo animals, when they are enclosed in these containers they will start to develop mental and physical health conditions, the natural born behaviors in which specific animals have will become altered due to not being able to execute a normal day as if they were in the wild, even though zoos can be used as educational means not only do many people ignore that fact but critics find it somewhat of a jokes that that still try to pawn that off to consumers as a reason to go and visit zoos. On top of that many zoos are not able to keep their place clean and not only does that affect the pull of visitors coming in which will lead to them not being able to pay for the right equipment to care for the animals. As well if they can not keep the park clean then how are the cells of the animal being up kept? (Par. 7). These points that were touched upon are very crucial in realising that the main purpose of zoos are not being used the way they were intended to, as well as revealing the harm that happens to the…

    • 1304 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Some argue that zoos are fundamental to the education of their children. Additionally, some believe zoos allow children to bond with the animals. However, since animals are trapped in smaller environments, they act differently than they do in the wild. Therefore, there is no real educational value in observing these trapped animals. Animals in confinement do not hunt, play, or act as they do in their natural habitat, hence children are learning false behaviors of animals. Zoo advocates also espouse the belief that zoos are instrumental in protecting endangered species. Nevertheless, only seventeen percent of the species in zoos are endangered (“Zoo Statistics”). Many of the endangered species in zoos are stolen from the wilderness and the chances of being released back are nearly impossible because zoos need them for money (Russo). Furthermore, zoos do not release endangered animals because their ability to survive in the wild has greatly diminished as a result of time spent in captivity (Russo). The best way to preserve animals in danger of extinction is to protect them in their natural habitats, not imprison them in…

    • 1252 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    That being said wild animals that are captured for zoos are in desperate need of our empathy as well. I personally growing up have had a somewhat positive view of zoos. As I got older and learned more about them my option of them has drastically changed. In our age of smartphones and laptops, we are in desperate need of a positive influence to get kids interested in animals and the natural world. Growing up I always believed that zoo’s played a big role in this. This changed however after I read “Thought To Exist In the Wild” By Derek Johnson. Derek Johnson systematically tears apart the argument that zoos are educational when he equates zoos to pornography; they are just a superficial representation of the real thing. The whole idea of keeping animals in an enclosure teaches children that animals are inferior beings in need of our support. Which leads to believe that it is ok to treat them cruelly. Children do not even have the desired learning outcomes that we would expect. Derrick Johnson points out that when you go to a zoo you don’t see any awe or wonder. You just see children making faces at the animals and poking on the glass (Jensen, 2007). Anyone who has spent a reasonable amount of time at a zoo would have a hard time arguing with him. If children are not even learning more about animals the only reason we have zoos is purely for entertainment. Now some people…

    • 1954 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    | Dixon, T 2009, Zoos, viewed 3 March 2010, International Debate Education Association (IDEA), <http://www.idebate.org/debatabase/topic_details.php?topicID=1>.…

    • 2023 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Imagine being trapped in a confined alteration of your natural habitat. An alteration created by a foreign species who are convinced that they know what’s best for you. Seems like living a nightmare, doesn’t it? This is exactly what Yann Martel claims to believe be good for the animals in, “Life of Pi.” He creates zoos, a confined and controlling place and turns them to sanctuaries in the reader’s mind. Behold, fellow readers, this is the rawest form of manipulation.…

    • 402 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The state of Florida is considering whether or not to ban the captivity of wild/exotic animals . I think this consideration should be a action since animals are mistreated by being caged or malnourished and more .…

    • 221 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Zoo’s are an attraction for many each year, but not enjoyed by the animals behind the steel bars and glass windows. Would being locked in a cage and have visitors looking in while pounding the glass and rumbling the bars be a day worth enjoying? Of course, not. These actions are what the animals facial and body expressions reveal to visitors taking pictures. The zoo’s guests, being excited to be there and admiring the animals, cannot place themselves on the other side. Visitors sees only how everything appears to be perfect for their viewing pleasure. Simply stated, animals should not be locked in cages. For instance, elephants that are…

    • 1934 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Forensic Rhetoric

    • 1945 Words
    • 6 Pages

    For Centuries, the world’s populace have had an irresistible interest in animals and have flocked to zoos and other animal habitats such as Sea World or San Diego Zoo. Ever year, millions of families go on whale watching tours and aboard safaris or enjoy a Circus performance. However, the interest in animals is nothing new: Zoos have been around and brightening the smiles of many since the first collection of animals in our early periods of Chinese, Mesopotamian, and Egyptian civilizations (Rutledge). The term zoo is an abbreviated form of “zoological garden” and it was created in the nineteenth century (Rutledge). The reasons behind captivating wild animals are associated with the deep core study of animals, restoration, preservation and educational needs. For an extensive period, zoo authorities claimed to have contributed to the restoration of endangered animal species; due to the up rise of vocals in organizations dealing with animal rights, a matter of abuse on zoo animals has become apparent. The issue of keeping animals in captivity or not is argued on several websites and blogs. This matter has become the source of passionate disputes taking place throughout the world.…

    • 1945 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Defense of Zoos the author highlights all of the positive aspects of zoos and everything there doing right for the animals. The article states “zoos are a necessary and vital part of efforts to conserve them and other endangered animals” because of deforestation and poachers but does not provide any information on the benefits of the wild. Its conveyed in the article that the “wild” is not all its cracked up to be and is more of a fairytale certain people and groups tell themselves. For example, to try and give there claims basis the article mentions the gorilla Harambe that became very famous after his death following an incident with a child. The author talks about how Harambe the gorilla had a good life and due to being born in captivity…

    • 198 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Arguments Against Zoos

    • 698 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Scholars G.R. Hosey and Gareth Davey seem to overlook how the effect of zoo visitors could be turned positive as well as what is needed to stop the negative interactions between visitors and the animals. They do not cover the importance of governmental regulation on Britain zoos in order to make certain that they are meeting the minimum animal welfare standards. However, Paul Koene addresses how the prevention of the opportunity to act naturally has no effect on zoo animal health without considering animals that were not raised in the zoo but placed there further into adulthood. Each of these arguments contain gaps that lack information and other views of the issue. Scholars Chris Draper, William Browne, and Stephen Harris fill these gaps in their own research as they display their argument on the unsuccess of formal inspections in Britain zoos in regulating whether or not they meet welfare requirements. The research of these men not only covers all examined causes of low zoo animal health, but also narrows in on the originator of the issue: the lack of solid and strongly enforced rules and regulations. As successfully expressed in the research of these intellectuals, the laws and rules regarding Britain zoo animal welfare standards need to be better enforced and supervised…

    • 698 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Controversy About Zoos

    • 1869 Words
    • 8 Pages

    There are many controversies when it comes to the topic of the Zoo. The question to ask is if zoos are good or bad for the animals? And reading on in this essay with the main point you will be able to decide for your own will. Discuses in the rest of this essay will be the living conditions of animals, if they’re able to have families, how they are treated, and if they are able to reproduce. These animals suffered with poor health because they had a natural food diet that they’re weren’t used to. According to S. Mary P. Benbow, “Unsuitable feeding practices of captive animals’ still continue”, which is sad because people who don’t know about this goes to the zoo not knowing what goes on behind closed doors. “In 1992, Masha, an elephant in the Moscow Circus, died after being fed a diet of vegetables, meat, red wine, sugar, and a brew of vodka”, said Benbow in her article.…

    • 1869 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Persuasive Essay On Zoos

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Stampeding elephants rushing through verdant fields. Slithering snakes creeping along the Amazon floor. Gazelles grazing through the undisturbed prairie. SNAP, the feasting wolf captured the innocent gazelle as it devours it alive, then scrimmaging through the bones for any extra meat of the gazelle that is no more. Sadly, this is a true reality, and in zoos, animals are completely safe and don’t take the risk of being eaten alive each and every day. This world needs zoos for reasons such as: protection, conservation, education, and research.…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    There are Zoo's all around the world and they have a lot of exotic animals you don't see every day but some of those animals are suffering because it is not their natural habitat. Some animals in the Zoo can suffer, According to ''Zoos:Myth and reality'' by Rob Laidlaw, it explains that 'Studies have shown that animals can suffer physically, mentally and emotionally.'' Another reason is that animals are having misery according to article ''Zoos:Myths and reality'' by Rob Laidlaw it explains that ''Animals held captive causes misery and death.''…

    • 124 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why Do Zoos Matter

    • 453 Words
    • 2 Pages

    This article highlights that without all the zoos in the world, we would be hopeless. The events in the story occur to remind people of the hope that the zoos have to preserve the last of all…

    • 453 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In addition, living in zooos has a terminal affect and eventually ruins the lives of animals. "Living in a zoo or protected environment can restrict all of these innate or inborn behaviors," states the article, 'Do Animals Lose in Zoos?'. There are many zoos that have isolated animals in small areas, away from others of their own kind. To see these animals not allowed to choose their own mates, and be active not only hurts the animal, but also humans who actually care about the lliving creature. When animals are held in unnatural habitats their room to roam is limited, as well as their natural diet. Furthermore, visitors do not get the full effect of the animal. The article, 'Do Animals Lose in Zoos?' states that "Seeing majestic animals in a controlled environment creates a sense of amazement and wonder," but it also says that "When animals are not bahaving as they normally would in the wild, visitors are not observing natural behaviors." When animals seen in zoos are doing things constantly and are not shown the way a television shows them, it is an outcome of the damage a zoo has done to the…

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays