Preview

A River Runs Through It

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
489 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
A River Runs Through It
A River Runs Through It

Fly fishing is not what this story is all about, although it might seem so at first. Neither is it about religion, even though the father's first line is: "In our family, there was no clear line between religion and fly fishing." Yes, these two things are themes that run through the story and add to its power. But there is so much more. It depicts a place of beauty, history, myth, and mystery, it is a triangle of earth in Montana where the writer grew up. And it captures a space of time in the not-so-distant past with a sensitivity that is both witty and poetic. Robert Redford loved this story and turned it into a handsome movie. Read it yourself or watch the movie, and you will learn something about fly fishing, but you will learn more about the wonders of nature and the strengths and frailties of man. Author Maclean was truly a man of words—well chosen words! The story traces the relationship between two brothers growing up in an emotionally constricted household headed by a Presbyterian minister. The scholarly Norman follows in the footsteps of his stern, stoic father, going to college, marrying and settling down. His older brother Paul, daring, handsome and athletic, chooses the more glamourous career of newspaper journalist. These two very different brothers are brought together through the years by a mutual love of fly fishing instilled in them by their unyielding father. As Norman watches his brother's seemingly charmed life dissolve under the influences of gambling and alcohol, the art of fly fishing becomes a touching metaphor for the love their father was unable to express in any other way. The events of this story are simple enough; the narrator, and his younger brother, Paul, have learned from their father the art of fly fishing. The narrator's wife and mother-in-law ask both brothers to take a never do well brother-in-law fishing, as if fishing might somehow cure the brother-in-law of fool-headedness and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Brief Synopsis of the Story in Your Own Words: Lyman tells a story of his past about his dead brother Henry, and the adventure they had one summer in a flashy convertible car, before Henry went off to fight in the war; and how Henry was changed when he returned from the war, and their fun-loving relationship was never the same.…

    • 301 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tobias Wolff is a well-known American writer, who is famous for his novels and short stories. One of the most popular is the work The Rich Brother. This story discusses the life and feelings of two siblings, whose names are Peter and Donald. The author starts the novel with describing Peter travelling to rescue his brother. During a long trip to this character’s home, Wolff reveals the inner traits of brothers, their past and feelings.…

    • 365 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This Boy's Life, set in America in the 1950’s, is a compelling memoir by Tobias Wolff, whom recreates the frustrations and cruelties faced throughout his adolescence, as he fights for identity and self-respect. During this period of time, America underwent major changes in the political and economic spheres, which in turn were responsible for its social makeover. Society in this time was geared toward family; marriage and children being part of the national agenda. The 1950’s was also an age of male dominance, where even if women worked, their assumed proper place was at home. Throughout the memoir, the protagonist, young Jack Wolff, makes it difficult for the reader to feel much affection towards him, as his actions prove to be troublesome and unruly. However, as the memoir progresses, Jacks struggle reveal the reasons for his actions which sequentially shape his character, providing the readers with understanding and sympathy towards his inexorable situation. The fraudulent lies and deceitful ways of Jack can be frustrating upon the reader; though we come to realise that he does this in order to be accepted by the people around him. Jack also engages in fights and unfaithfully betrays his best friend Arthur, although it becomes evident that he only does this in order to gain Dwight’s approval of him. The lack of a real father figure in Jack’s life has a profound impact on him and his desperate attempt to develop his identity, which further supports the readers’ emotions of sympathy towards him.…

    • 1592 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The environment the boys grew up affects them in different ways. Growing up the boys were taught how to properly fly fish and how one must respect the art behind fly fishing before one can catch a fish. Fly fishing is very important to them because it is an escape from reality. The river is one place where they can all be family and something they all love. Paul loves the river and fly fishing because it gets him away from the world and helps him see the simple things in life. for Norman it is the one thing he that reminds him of Montana and his family. The environment of growing up under a priest helped Norman get a better education but for Paul it made him seek more of a defiant man. They grew up in a tough era, shown by how both the boys love fighting and…

    • 859 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “The Bass, the River, and Sheila Mant” the main characters are the boy and Sheila. The main conflict is that the boy likes Sheila but she hates fishing and he had to choose between both. He had thrown away the fish because he didn’t want Sheila to see it. Later, he regretted it. The resolution was that Sheila left him anyway, when he was trying so hard to impress her. The main character changes by feeling regret, and dumb for letting go the biggest fish he had caught over a girl who didn’t like him and didn’t like him for who he is and judge him that fishing is stupid. You shouldn’t have to hide who you really are even if someone else doesn’t like it because they should accept you for who you are.…

    • 569 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    How Does Guilt Affect Men

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Norman Broker was a member of Alpha Company; One night he tried to save Kiowa from getting stucked down under the sludge in a muddy field. Norman pulled but he couldn't help Kiowa from sinking into the sludge. After Kiowa died Norman felt like crap and what made it worse that they now had to search for his body. The book goe into another chapter that tells about Norman Brokers life. The chapter is based on the fact Norman is back home and drives around this lake many times and while he does he thinks about what if he had saved Kiowa and received the silver star. Norman then thinks about how his father would be proud of him and how he would tell the people in town and the girl he once loved but now was married. Norman drives around the lake many times and then goes to the drive in restaurant where he almost tells the order taker his story. I think Norman not only felt guilt about Kiowa but also about now receiving the silver star. If Norman would have received the silver star he thought how his father would talk to him and people in town throw a parade. Later Norman committed suicide, I think from depression of not feeling useful and having no place to…

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In conclusion, this memoir really touched me. It has its funny moments and it also has its sad moments. Kinship is a great part of the novel because if it weren’t for kinship, none of the gangbangers would’ve gotten along in the first place. Father Greg Boyle makes a good decision in making Homeboys Industries and creating kinship between gangbangers who decide to change their…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Fly-fishing figures prominently in this poignant tale of two brothers growing up in Montana in the early 20th century under the stern rule of their minister father. While both boys rebel, Norman channels his rebellion into writing, but Paul descends onto a slippery path of self-destruction. Also, throughout ¡°A River Runs Through It,¡± Maclean intertwines the art of fly-fishing and his vivid descriptions of a virgin Montana to narrate the tale of the Maclean family and their religion, both in the chapel and on the river. The idea of nature and God being synonymous is not a new one, but Maclean adds meaning to this old saying though a father and his sons reveling in the spirituality of an untouched world, a coming back to ones roots. Specifically, in ¡°A River Runs Through It¡± what keeps the family together is their love for fishing and their belief in God. The family said they made little distinction between fly fishing and religion. Fly fishing was their relationship with nature, it was the place for the men in the family to be close with nature and appreciate all of the scenery and life around them Nature should make its way back into all of our lives so we can all say in the end a river ran through it. Every time they went fishing they united as a family and were able to experience nature together even though the two brothers and their father were so different. I think "Eventually all things merge into one, and a river runs through it." that sentence is a rather simple statement that many people will probably say has some deep philosophical meaning dealing with time and life and…

    • 288 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Fly Fishing Norman Essay

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Norman MacLean’s reflection on character reverts his entire conception of order and success. In meditating, he ponders the idea of Paul having a stronger character and being more independent than him. These thoughts are shaped largely by the meaningful context that Norman is experiencing. MacLean journeys to these thoughts during his last fishing trip with his brother, the trip that is supposed to be about Norman receiving help, rather than giving it. This inversion of roles, along with a deep reflection on Paul’s utter lack of desire for external help, demonstrate an extensive shift in Norman’s thinking. MacLean’s pensive view of his brother Paul suggests that help, meaning, and hope are most valuable when they come from within, and that Paul…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Boat

    • 446 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In “The Boat” by Alistair Macleod, the boat, and the ill-fitting clothes he wore significantly represent the confinement and the father’s inability to break free from tradition, reinforcing that tradition can suppress one’s dream for greater things. To begin, the boat itself is a symbol of the fathers bounding to the sea, showing his obligation to follow customs. The boat is categorize with a “marine clutch and a high speed reverse gear and was painted on an oblong plate across her stern. Jenny Lynn had been my mother’s maiden name and the boat was called after her as another link in the chain of tradition”(Macleod 3) The high speed reverse gear depicts how the father is not moving forward along with the light green name of Jenny Lynn that demonstrates the father’s sacrifice for the fishing custom to support his family. The Jenny Lynn that he receives through tradition gives him a constant reminder that his way of life may never change and that his dreams are out of his reach. Furthermore, the clothing in his closet symbolizes the father’s imprisonment with tradition. The narrator mentions “his ill-fitted serge suit, the two or three white shirts that strangled him and the square black shoes that pinched” (Macleod 4) The square black shoes that pinched him means that the life of fishing that he inherits does not fit, the life he lives is simply to overpowering that it damages him. The white shirts that suffocates him shows the struggles he faces everyday that he is unable to separate from. His attire is so inflexible that it was leaving him trapped in one place incapable to grasp his own desires. Lastly, at the father’s death his departure speculates that it is suicide to liberate his son and himself from an unhappy future bringing the fishing tradition with him. When the father’s body is discovered “the white green stubble of his whiskers had continued to grow in death. Physically as he lay there with the brass chains on his wrist and seaweed in his hair”(Macleod…

    • 446 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This story is about two brothers named Paul and Norman growing up in Montana during the 1920s. Their father John is a Presbyterian minister and raises them based on his strong religious beliefs. The film also revolves around the brother’s and father’s love for fly-fishing. In the opening dialogue Norman says, “In our family there was no clear line between religion and fly-fishing.” He goes on to say that his father told them about Christ’s disciples being fishermen and how he and his brother Paul believed that John was a dry fly-fisherman. (Redford, 1992)…

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In a little town in Montana two brothers grow up. One of them is Norman (Craig Sheffer) the other is Paul which is played by (Brad Pitt). Their father is Reverend Maclean and they grow up with his lessons that has to do with religion, and the lessons of fly fishing. In this movie fly-fishing represents life, a little. Their father really enjoyed it but they…

    • 229 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The reader then begins to feel the danger of the jaunt as Maupassant starts to describe the men walking to their fishing spot. Morissot and Sauvage begin to face realization of the danger to obtain this one pleasure they adore. “A strip of bare ground remained to be crossed before they could gain the river bank. They ran across this, and, as soon as they were at the water’s edge, concealed themselves among the dry reeds”. They had made it to their favorite fishing spot. Once relieved they were there, they once again were able to forget their surroundings and begin to fish.…

    • 660 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Third and Final Continent

    • 1304 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In spite of being ambitious, the narrator is an ordinary man, coming from a middle class Indian family. His father’s death had left his mother insane and forced his brother to leave the school in order to run the house. As a result, the narrator does not having the luxuries of having a…

    • 1304 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    in the story He tries to pull the fish in put the moves away which the old man…

    • 350 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays