A Comparison Of Freud And Carl Rogers Theory In Social Care

The therapist barely engaging within the sessions startles me and makes one think how the client would feel comfortable enough to divulge any personal feelings the individual is experiencing. I believe that in social care there is a huge emphasis on building relations with clients and this theory totally overlooks that. In total contrast to Freud, Carl Rogers theory ' Person centred theory' conflicts this element. Rogers believed an empathic, integrated relationship with the person is required. The therapist needs to be genuine and open with the client to form and build a relationship to which this theory thrives on. (Nelson-Jones, 2015). I have witnessed these types of therapeutic relationships whilst on placement. It was made up of trust
and honesty that made the client willing to receive the help that he needed. It showed the importance of well built relations with clients.
All in all, the model of psychoanalysis remains most significant for me. The idea of using techniques to pursue the deep rooted issues that create our behaviours is invaluable in social care. Freud’s theory has its strengths and weaknesses and many theorists used and build on this to form other psychological concepts. Although many theorists criticised Freud's work, most of the theory's that followed seem to be in some way influenced by his work. Other theories such as CBT and client centred theory although have very different approaches, they are important for dealing with problems or disorders too. Not all individuals are suited to one treatment. This theory will be a great aid to my career in my work in social care.