The movie showed what the war was like and how brutal it was.
I don't think it was completely accurate with the brutality of the war, but if it were completely accurate, not many people would be able to handle that level of violence. The scene where they sent the 5 condemned soldiers into no-man's land was very inaccurate. "throwing them into no-man's land, such things were simply not done." The French army was not as brutal as it was portrayed. Soldiers would sometimes be executed for self-mutilation, but they would suffer the penalty (executed); although, there were few records of French soldiers being executed for
self-mutilation. I usually do not like romance movies, but I liked this movie quite a bit. The setup of the movie, how it would explain some event that happened and then do a flashback to the event, was very good. Its balance between the romance and the darker war parts, was good but not great. The ending to the movie, I absolutely did not like one bit; although it did not do a cheesy, predictable ending, it was a poor way to end it. overall, I would give this movie 2.5 out of 5 stars.