Preview

Abortion: Subjectivism And Utilitarianism

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
555 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Abortion: Subjectivism And Utilitarianism
: Two arguments that goes against late-term abortion being immoral is subjectivism and utilitarianism. Subjectivism portrays that everyone has his or her own set of morals and that there is no one right way. A subjectivist’s opinion on the subject would argue that a person's view and choice in terms of late abortion is personal to their specific position. According to English, she is arguing that, “Though the fetus is itself innocent, it may pose a threat to the pregnant woman’s well-being, life prospects or health, mental or physical. If the pregnancy presents a slight threat to her interests, it seems self-defense cannot justify abortion” (English, 2). This is simply portraying that a woman has the ability to decide whether or not she wants to keep the baby if it is going to affect her happiness and …show more content…
She could escape this threat by the simple expedient of running away (English, 3). This relates to Sue’s position because Sue does not feel that she is ready to have a child, but it is too sad to give it up to someone else. For example, this defends Sue’s position because if Sue does have the baby and has to give it up due to financial reasons, then this can cause unwanted guilt or stress that can extend onto even serious matters such as depression. Utilitarianism also opposes my opinion on Sue’s decision because utilitarianism seeks to bring the greatest good to the greatest amount of people. Utilitarian ethics is a system where acts are judged according to their consequences, so the end justifies the means. In Sue’s defense, a pro-utilitarian, would argue that having a late-term abortion serves the comfort and happiness of all the women who are in

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    V. Significance of the Case: To protect women’s right to have an abortion at their own risk, and their choice.…

    • 1485 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thomson Handout 1

    • 951 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The extreme view consists if the mother is going to die with the pregnancy if she doesn’t get an abortion what would one do is to not kill the fetus because it has the right to live and so does the mother but in this case one must prefer to let someone die thin to kill someone innocent do an abortion should not be performed.…

    • 951 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Anti-abortionists often refer to abortion as, ' the intentional killing of unborn babies', and see it as an evil deed, committed only by those who do not appreciate the value of human life. Although, it seems that, in many cases it is quite the opposite. In cases such as one night stands, rape or underage pregnancies, mothers often tend to choose abortion with the fear that they cannot give their child the life they deserve. These pregnancies are unwanted, accidental even. The mother does not plainly wish to kill her child for selfish reasons, but…

    • 1652 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In this argument, a woman buys the best mesh screens (a metaphor for birth control) that are designed to keep out the seeds, but as it is possible, a screen is defective and lets a people-seed into the home. This, being a metaphor for voluntary intercourse where a woman is aware of the inherent risks of pregnancy, argues that, even though a woman may become pregnant unintentionally, that does not necessarily mean that the fetus has a right to the body of the mother. She uses an analogy of an intruder to show this: just because a woman opens a window, knowing that someone could enter through it, does not rob her of her right to rid her house of an intruder if one would happen to enter. This is likened to rape, where a woman would retain her right to remove a fetus from her body. Thompson identifies that some opponents of her argument would say that someone could simply choose to live in a home with bare floors and furniture or a home with sealed doors and windows to avoid the threat of a people-seed, but Thompson then likens such an arrangement to choosing to get a hysterectomy, just so a woman can safeguard herself against the possibility of being raped and impregnated. Clearly, this would be an extreme measure to take for the sake of…

    • 1643 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Personally, I think that any form of abortion is tantamount to murder, and should never be permitted. This article only brings to my attention that women who wish to have abortions are only concerned for themselves, as the argument is based upon the health of the woman. Although the author’s argument may be valid concerning some facets of the issue, I believe the focus of the subject should shift from the mother to the living creature inside and its right to…

    • 434 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    She gives the example that the mother is trapped in a tiny house with a large baby that is already pushing her against the walls and soon will crush her to death. This argument is not consistent with a case of abortion in that it placed the baby outside of the fetus and the baby being oversized. The mother would also have other places in the house to go to possibly avoid getting crushed by the enlarged baby. Even though it says the house is tiny, she is freely able to move and avoid being crushed. The baby that is in the fetus can only be predicted that it will endanger the mother's life. There is not an absolute to that, which makes the abortion a precaution rather than a last resort. If it is a case of consensual sex, the mother took the risk of taking actions that have a product that can lead to this. Instead of killing one person in the abortion, it can be looked at as trying to save two lives instead of one by not having the abortion, thus avoiding the right to life case by deciding which right trumps the other and having the potential to save more than just one life. Even in a case of rape, there is still an outcome where both the mother and child both live instead of one being decided to be the only one to…

    • 1830 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the Anna Quindlen’s article I believe her greatest argument was the quote“for years I believed that a woman’s right to choose was absolute, but now I wonder. Do I, with a stable home and marriage and sufficient stamina and money, have the right to choose abortion because a pregnancy is inconvenient right now? Legally I do have that right; legally I want to always to have that right. It is the morality of exercising it under those circumstances that makes me wonder.” So we can easily understand that woman have the rights to choose to go through the abortion process or choose to not to go through it and no one can take that from them. With this essay, I believe people can also understand that making the decision to have an abortion and give up your baby can be the hardest decision you can ever make because it can mentally and physically leave an impact on your life.…

    • 528 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    A simple way to display this formulation is through a basic pro and con list. While an abortion may seem like the easy route, it does not provide many benefits with one of the only ones being sheer convenience. It would be convenient not to have a baby for the financial aspect, relationship aspect, and possibly your health aspect, but convenience cannot make something right. It would be more convenient for an individual to keep walking instead of holding the door; is that the morally right thing to do? No. With utilitarianism in mind, more good would arise if he or she held the door since a relationship would have formed, other good deeds could spread, and simply the door was held upon for everyone versus the door was held open for one with some convenience factor. It is evident how this adds up. Now going back to abortion, it was concluded the benefits are convenience in a multitude of ways. But let us take a look at the cons associated with this. One, murder. Two, neglects an opportunity for adoption with parents who are not fortunate enough receive the gift of life within them. Three, does not allow for the experience to empower women to overcome impediments. Four, does not give women responsibility. Five, does not allow the child to experience life, limiting so many societal possibilities, some cliches being he or she could find the cure to cancer or develop into our next…

    • 1405 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Pretend for a moment you are a woman or young girl, and try to place yourself in their place in the following scenarios. Case #1: A 13-year-old girl crying confused and frightened watches her boyfriend walk out of her life after she tells him she is pregnant. She thought he loved her. Case #2: A woman finds out she is pregnant with her sixth child. Her husband is out of work and the five children they already have must go to bed hungry most nights. She asks herself, how can I feed another one? Case #3: A career minded young woman having just earned her nursing degree finds out she is pregnant. Her husband, a doctor, is already putting in loads of overtime at the hospital. When would they have time for a baby? Case #4: A woman is about to go home after shopping all day, and on the way to her car she is forced into an alley at gun point, and brutally raped. Case #5: A super model finds out she has gotten pregnant after an affair with her photographer. Of course she can 't have a baby, having a baby would end her modeling career. Case #6: A woman while pregnant contracts a disease which in nine out of ten cases causes birth defects, and therefore her doctor advises an…

    • 1769 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    goodwill

    • 1161 Words
    • 5 Pages

    For the same reason, Thomson says, abortion does not violate the fetus' right to life but merely deprives the fetus of something—the use of the pregnant woman's body—to which it has no right. Thus, it is not that by terminating her pregnancy a woman violates her moral obligations, but rather that a woman who carries the fetus to term is a 'Good Samaritan' who goes beyond her obligations…

    • 1161 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the western world's most controversial ethical issues in today's society is the act of abortion and its legislation. Abortion is the process in which a baby is killed whilst still in the mother's womb. This is performed for a variety of reasons. Due to the severity of the consequences of an abortion and the moral and religious elements involved, this is an ethical controversy and has divided people for decades.…

    • 1936 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This paper explores the two contrasting views on abortion by giving arguments against and for abortion. These views are broken up into both pro-choice or pro-life activists and their beliefs on abortion. Pro-choice activist believe that a woman should ultimately make their own decision to their bodies. In contrast, pro-life activist believe that all life should be preserved. This paper examines the ceaseless debate from both parties and the different pressures in life that can influence a woman to have an abortion.…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “Abortions in America,” a study states, “…51 percent had problems with a relationship or wanted to avoid single parenthood (Waldman, Ackerman, Reed, Greenburg, Cutter, Sieder, and Lavelle)…” Henceforth, more than half of abortions occur because of relationship problems or the avoidance of single parenthood. So, if these women had their right of abortion revoked, they would have had to either leave the child in the care of the adoption system, file for welfare which may not help very much, or raise the child alone which could lead to mentally stressing both the parent and the child creating an environment unsuitable for a child to be raised. Thus, abortion should be legal to prevent this from happening more frequently in the United States and around the world. Moreover, in “Missing the Boat on Pregnancy Prevention,” it states, “almost three-fourths of births to single women began as unintended conceptions, and more than one-half of the births to formerly married women are a result of unintended conceptions (Hogue).” Therefore, to help prevent these women from having to deal with single motherhood because of unintended pregnancies, they should have the legal right to choose abortion. This is able to be seen when single motherhood can cause social strains on both the mother and the child but can also lead to family…

    • 1233 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Opposing Viewpoints Online Context defines abortion as a medical and surgical procedure that ends during the first 28 weeks of pregnancy. Abortion became legal in the U.S Supreme Court in the year of 1973 because it is now considered “safe”. The reason it is considered safe because of modern medicine and more modern surgical tools (Abortion Facts). Many women have reported to have an abortion due to domestic violence, financial problems, and being raped. Even though the U.S. Supreme court considers abortion “safe”, there are many complications that comes with abortion. Some complications that comes with abortion include fever, minor infections, bleeding, chronic abdominal pain, and vomiting (Abortion Facts). The women who want to have an abortion…

    • 602 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This would be a specific type of deontology, in which morality of an action is based only on the compliance of the action itself, not on the action’s consequences. Overall, nobody should merely be used to obtain a goal. According to Kant’s second formulation, a person is obligated to account for the dignity and value they possess in oneself and in others. It is the argumentation and their position as rational and noble beings. In Sue’s case she decided she was not ready to have a baby, but was too afraid to let someone adopt it. Once the infant is born, it can no longer pose any threat to the woman’s life or health since she is given the opportunity to put it up for adoption. For some women, having the baby be raised by someone other than themselves may sound scary, so they take the abortion route. Yes, a lot of women may suffer from the idea that their child is being thrown into the adoption system, and the mother will be worried about the child’s happiness, education or health, but in the end the mother should have been more responsible to discuss these things with her family or husband in order to avoid late-term abortion. Surely, there are better ways of dealing with these problems than permitting late-term abortion in such cases. For any killing where the victim did have a valuable future like ours, having that future by itself is sufficient to create the strong presumption that the killing is seriously wrong (Marquis, 4). According to Marquis, killing a fetus is just as wrong as killing a human being after birth. The loss of the future of any human being by killing or by abortion is unjustified. In essence, a seven-month old fetus is not that much different in appearance from a newborn, and has measurable brain activity.…

    • 752 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays