Preview

Analysis Of Greg Graffin's 'Survival Of The Fittest'

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
529 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Analysis Of Greg Graffin's 'Survival Of The Fittest'
Long before Charles Darwin’s theory of natural selection became publicly known, scientists have been observing the changes in both plants and species. Darwin’s theory remains widely known because it explains the reasons for these changes in nature; he suggests that organisms that are more fit are able to survive and reproduce better than organisms who are not. Based off of this idea that only the fittest survive, many Americans believe that because our military force is strong and our enemies are often destroyed, we are entitled some sort of dominate power. Greg Graffin co-author of “Anarchy Evolution” uses this exact theory to explain why this theory of national superiority not true. In “‘Survival of the Fittest’ is a Sham,” an article released from Time Magazine in September of 2015, Greg Graffin convinces the audience through tone and logos that American superiority is nonexistent. …show more content…
Within the first few sentences, Graffin establishes a perspective and reveals his overall tone to the audience by questioning the credibility of American views on transcendentalism. Furthermore, Graffin asks his audience if “destroying enemies really make us superior?” This aggressive tone is used to forcefully convince the reader to agree that national superiority is an outrageous term. He further suggests that “[a]t the root of this debate is an oversimplification of evolutionary science.” Although there are numerous ways to address his naysayers, Graffin uses tone to emphasize the ideal of an “oversimplification” being made within the debate. That emphasis proves that even though science may sound like an effective way to defend an argument it is not in this

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Social Darwinists justified expanding American power overseas by suggesting that nations competed with each other, and only the strongest would survive.…

    • 2157 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to Turner, the hardships required to perpetuate social evolution along the frontier had shaped the political process in America at the time. His theory, being from a Westerner’s perspective, did not receive much acknowledgment at the time. However, many thinkers of this era were of a post Darwinism understanding. Political and socioeconomic evolutions are due in part to the settler mindset that is deeply instilled into the western frontier of America. To Turner, America imposes a Composite nationality. The people who inhabited the frontier early on were primarily servants. This promoted a population of people from various cultures around the world. Not only did this promote individualism, but it also allowed communities to redefine themselves and become something new. Turner believes that it is from here, and not European influence, that we found our economic and political voice as a nation.…

    • 487 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Darwin’s theory of survival of the fittest = U.S the fittest, take over other nations and make better…

    • 495 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    One often wonders if they would be able to survive in a time of crisis, some spend a bunch of time and money preparing for a crisis. Survival of the fittest refers to natural selection which is “the idea that species that acquire adaptations that are favorable for their environment will pass down those adaptations to their offspring” (Scoville 1). Survival of the fittest means “the best physical specimen of the species and only those in the best shape and best health will survive in nature” (Scoville 1). In Pat Frank’s Alas, Babylon survival of the fittest comes into play in time of crisis; Randy Bragg, Edgar Quisenberry and Preacher Henry find this out the hard way after The Day. The Day is a day on which a nuclear war was started between the Soviet Union and the United States. The Soviet Union dropped a huge amount of bombs all over the United States laying waste to many towns .…

    • 1789 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    has made me look at American people through the lens of an outsider. Although I moved here when I was young, and I am currently a U.S. citizen, I still fail to understand some aspects of the logic of the American people. I have merged my Bosnian culture with bits and pieces of American culture to become who I am today, however, my culture predominantly focuses on my Bosnian heritage. In all the years that I have lived here, I have discovered that Americans believe they are supreme. You may ask, “Why do they believe this?” It is because it is what they have been told and what they have come to believe after hearing it so many times. Americans are very focused on themselves. We have the best economy, the richest people, the nicest houses, the best cars, the smartest people, and the most advanced technology, so why shouldn’t we be labeled as “the best.” If everyone acted like Americans, then perhaps the world would be a better place. However, it appears that this is not the case. Horace Miner’s article and Laura Bohannan’s story proves us all wrong. We are not the best and we are not as logical as we think we…

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Graff was feeling “what it felt like to propose generalization, restate and respond to a counter-argument, and other intellectualizing operations” (Graff 239). These components are all used in order to properly argue your perspective on a topic discussed in an academic setting. Arguing about sports and toughness involved Graff to look through “academic eyes” on a non-academic subject which made those non-academic…

    • 624 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The teachings of survival of the fittest had a great impact on the start of imperialism. In Document 5 William L. Langer states “…the economic side…must not be allowed to hide the other factors. Psychologically speaking…evolutionary teaching [about the “survival of the fittest”] was perhaps the most critical.” Langer is basically saying that the teaching of survival of the fittest is what helped the economy grow. He also claims that it only brought out competition, struggle, and ruthlessness. Survival of the fittest is a theory that the strongest will survive, and the weakest will parish. Everyday someone was trying to gain more money and or power. Survival of the fittest is what caused people to want to stretch out and conquer land. Based on his theory the teachings of survival of the fittest had a great impact on the start of imperialism.…

    • 644 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The lands of the earth are limited, and soon will be taken…” quoted from Minister Josiah Strong. Many Americans felt it was not only our responsibility and duty but it was also a command from God. Minister Strong argued that America was in a race with other nations to dominate the world and obtain resources that we needed. So because America claimed that it was their duty to uplift and “Christianize” the foreign people they used this as an argument for imperialism. As Charles Darwin states “In the struggle for survival, the fittest win out at the expense of their rivals because they succeed in adapting themselves best to their environment." America had gone into a state of “social Darwinism”, where they thought that the earth belong to the fit and strong, which in this case is America. And so, if U.S. wanted to survive in competition of modern states, it too would have to become an imperial power. According to Beveridge, "...and thanksgiving to Almighty God that He has marked us as His chosen people, henceforth to lead in the regeneration of the world..." This embarks that they were even told that America was the chosen people, and the people who would change the entire…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Word "Retard"

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Bauer’s argument is not organized or structured, which makes it very hard to follow. Bauer does not follow the basic rules for a good argument. She does not give the reader enough information at the beginning of the story to tell them what the argument is about. Firstly, this essay lacks an introduction or thesis statement. From the start of this paper, the reader has no idea what the argument is about. Secondly, Bauer jumps randomly from one paragraph to another with no structure to her thoughts. She provides examples of the movie Tropic Thunder, and…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Callicles on Moral Realism

    • 1391 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In reference to the first premise which states that, “In nature the strong dominates the weak;” In my opinion this undoubtedly refers to natural selection- those who…

    • 1391 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Golding's “Lord the flies”, many british boys are stranded on an unknown island from a plane crash during world war two. The boys, especially Ralph and Piggy in the beginning, do not realize how long they are stuck on this island. When they are discussing their fathers, Ralph says “When he gets leave he’ll come and rescue us” indicating that he believes his father is coming. Afterwards, when they find the other choir boys using the conch shell, their sense of survival beings. As the book progresses, the boys forgivably do what they need to do in order to survive because of their desires, sense of group belonging and denial. Many of them are forced to make challenging decisions that not everyone would agree on whether or not it was necessary. Although majority, if not all, would of gone as far as the boys did in order to survive.…

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    America has always had the desire to be the most efficient and potent country in the world, while other countries attempt to be like America. There is no country like America, for Americans are always one step ahead of the competition: “dinosaurs are distinctly American, not only because our scholars have so often been at the forefront of fossil discoveries and paleontological theory but because the popular dinosaur is a wholly owned projection of the nationalist psyche of the United States” (Hitt 128). Hitt notes that the tyrannosaurus rex was generated from Americans ambitions and how Americans wanted to see T. rex, for America had basically found most of these dinosaurs through archeological digs. In Hitt’s essay, countries like China tried to make new dinosaurs based off of their own desires, but America quickly shot them down because the image did not accommodate what Americans wanted dinosaurs to be. Hitt explains that through Americans aspirations, America had used the T-rex to create the powerful country that it is today, making the T-rex our mascot. America may be a dominant country compared to other countries, but that does not mean that everything is done in everyone’s best interest. Kingsolver says, “But I only have to stand still for a minute and watch the outcome of thirty million years’ worth of hummingbird evolution transubstantiated before my eyes into nest and egg to get knocked down to size” (Kinsolver 213). Kingsolver presents the idea that America can get to the stature it wants to be by following the example of the hummingbird, as the hummingbird has done just fine by itself over the billions of years without technology. Kingsolver explains that America is efficient like a hummingbird, but ultimately gets to that desired efficiency through an unethical approach. America’s…

    • 1776 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Stanley Kauffmann 's play "The More the Merrier" begins with the two main characters Emily Stringer and Raphael Thumbs professing their love to each other and agreeing to marry. They were so enamored to one another that Raphael wanted the wedding to take place immediately that night or the following day but to which Emily countered because it was so soon. She still had to shop for a trousseau and the banns (declarations made in church) that take three weeks to complete. Raphael then expressed his desire to begin a new life "cut off from everyone else" to which Emily agreed. It was only when he uttered his yearning to "cut loose from the past" that Emily began to question what it was that he wanted to cut loose from. After confirming that the "past" Raphael was talking about was really trivial, they went about establishing their need to "wipe the slate clean" such as banishing their unhealthy habits and getting away from people they didn 't want to see anymore. They basked at the thought of purging away their past and further sealing their undying love for each other by a sordid recollection of how they fell in love with each other.…

    • 1317 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    America, our great country, is strong, powerful, and influential. Americans exemplify positive values, selflessness, hospitality, and the American way of life. The mighty oak tree that stands taller, bigger, and older than all others best represents this grand country. Each part of the tree illustrates a facet of our nation. <br><br>Shapely emerald leaves covering the tree symbolize the values many Americans hold concerning themselves, others, and their nation. Leaves help the tree grow and flourish just as our value of caring for our neighbors help us to unite and become more successful as a whole. The beautiful shade and distinct shape of these leaves make the tree more attractive and unique. Our values often differ from values of other countries due to cultural contrasts such as with religious, racial, and education issues. We give much more freedom than many other countries do to those of different races and religions. Also, he hold education in a much higher regard than other countries. It is these differences which sometimes make our country seem more appealing to those of foreign lands. Without leaves in the spring, the mighty oak would have no means of nourishment and would die. Our common American values bind us together as one unit just as all the leaves work together to benefit the oak. Without them we would be millions of separate bodies aimlessly wondering about a common ground, and our country would fall to pieces. Thus, there would be no country as there would be no tree. <br><br>The lonely oak's long, gnarled limbs seem to reach out as far as they can just to touch another tree. One limb reaches far to the east until it finds a maple. Our brave troops fought in the east to fend off the Czechoslovakians and Serbians from nearly defenseless Bosnia. Another limb bends down and softly touches the fresh buds of a young sapling. Many Americans give years of their lives in South Africa to the Peace Corps to touch the lives and hearts of many villagers. Yet…

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The essay is consistently relevant to the title and there is evidence of real ambition and some attempt to use profound ideas (specifically Gödel’s ideas (lines 20–26) and the evolutionary ideas of lines 96–97). However, the ideas are not always used effectively; there is clearly some understanding but it falls short of a “good” understanding. In particular, there is awareness that the idea of “truth” is problematic (for example, the introduction and lines 18–19) and its meaning is explored in different areas of knowledge (mathematics, art, history, ethics, religion) and everyday events (the Iraq war, the table), but the handling of the issue is uneven and at times inconsistent.…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays