Preview

Analysis Of Religion, Media And Movies: The Passion Of The Christ

Best Essays
Open Document
Open Document
3450 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Analysis Of Religion, Media And Movies: The Passion Of The Christ
1
3085 Words

Religion, Media, and Movies: A Passion for Theatrics
Introduction: A Road Map
For decades, media sources have long been a dictator of how people perceive the world around them. People, events, opinions, and beliefs have played center stage in media outlets such as movies, TV shows, news broadcasts, radio, and various literary platforms. Religion, its history, and its people are frequently portrayed in the media through the means listed above. Some of the most famous and infamous interpretations of religion have stemmed from the media. Such media interpretations lead to questions surrounding the importance and consequences of such presentations and how they impact greater religious discussions.
In this paper I will
…show more content…
What happens when this sole contact turns into the foundation for one’s position when they enter into a larger conversation concerning a religious matter? Media interpretation of religion can drastically affect one’s beliefs about said religion. In the following case examining Mel Gibson’s Passion of the Christ, a media interpretation can be shown to be harmful and clouding to a broader conversation.
The Passion of the Christ: A Background
A useful case for understanding the harmful relationship between media interpretation of religion and broader religious conversations is the film The Passion of the Christ, written by Benedict Fitzgerald and Mel Gibson, and directed by Mel Gibson.
The controversial film was released in the United States on Ash Wednesday, February
25, 2004. The R-rated film focuses on the last day of Jesus’ life, from his betrayal in the
Garden of Gethsemane, his trial and conviction, and his scourging, to his ultimate crucifixion. In Christianity, such a depiction of the last 12-hours of Jesus Christ’s life is

5 refereed to as Christ’s “Passion.”a In an attempt to stay true to the historical
…show more content…
However, further investigation concludes that this is not true. While Mel Gibson never claimed his movie was historically accurate, he did cite that his aim was to make the movie as true to the gospels as possible. When asked “How do you find the balance between staying true to
Scripture and your creative interpretation?” Gibson replied,

“Wow, the Scriptures are the Scriptures—I mean they’re unchangeable, although many people try to change them. And I think that my first duty is to be as faithful as possible in telling story so that it doesn’t contradict the scriptures.” (Webb, 2).

Following the release of the movie, Gibson was forced to allude to another text from which he claims he drew “filler.” This other text is the controversial book The Dolorous
Passion of Our Lord. While the German text does not outright contradict the Gospels as
Gibson points out, the images chronicled in the text are so graphic, violent, and detailed in nature that they dispute the writings of the Gospel. While the main thread of the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    He does tie it into his own text and injects his own opinion by stating that all of Ebert's…

    • 127 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Andy wrote a lot of good points to back up his topic, however he didn’t put any quotes in the paragraphs. He did state in his paragraphs that “Wikipedia wrote the following about the film: It was greeted with positive reviews upon release, and became only the second film to earn more than $500 million at the North American box office, setting numerous other records in the process. It is also the fourth highest grossing film worldwide and only the fourth film to earn more than $1 billion, worldwide.” However he did not put quotes around it as I just did. This is plagiarizing what the resource said. It is important that you make sure you always quote what another person has said just so that way you don’t get in trouble. Andy could have put maybe a couple more resources in there to persuade the readers just how popular the movie really was. So, that way it would lure readers to go and rent the movie to see it. Being…

    • 665 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    If a movie states, “based on a true story”, it doesn’t necessarily mean that all history or facts portrayed in the movie are true. Most of the time directors of the movies place such words in the beginning of the movie to gain more support of the public and depict instances that may or may not be one hundred percent accurate. Taking history down a creative route can have its positive notes and its negative. Portraying history in a movie allows filmmakers to make a point about a modern issue or promote an ongoing historical topic. Just exemplifying history in a movie, doesn’t depict the fact that it is accurate. “Gangs of New York ” directed by Martin Scorsese in 2002, and set in 1863, explains the Irish immigration and ongoing Civil War. This movie is quiet t historically accurate, but still has some minor inaccuracies.…

    • 658 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Along the sides of the nave, are paintings of the Stations of the Cross. With these paintings we see symbolic, iconic, and anionic images of Jesus. The Stations of the Cross are fourteen images of Jesus as he is condemned to death, carries the cross, is nailed to the cross, dies on the cross, and is then laid in the tomb. At each Station of the Cross, there is a prayer that follows along with the story. The First Station has an image of Jesus Christ being tried and condemned to death. In this iconic image I saw that Jesus…

    • 843 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Have you ever read a book, then watched the movie on it and wanted to throw the book at the director’s face and tell them to actually read the book? This is what happened when I read a novel titled Where The Rivers Flow North by Howard Frank Mosher, and then watched the movie on it. In 1927, in Kingdom County, Vermont, a large dam is to be built; however, Noel Lord, a logger and cedar-oil harvester, won't give up his lifetime lease on the land. The dam company increases its offer of cash, but Noel refuses time after time. He asks for a trade; the white pines for his lease. Noel, meanwhile, talks with his wife, Bangor, about them moving to Oregon and buying a saw mill. She wants him to take the company's money; but he’s stubborn. His stubbornness is what ultimately leads them to their death, causing them both to be victims. Yet in the movie, only one of them meets with their untimely death. Between the book and the movie, three major differences were Noel’s death scene, Bangor’s death, the showing of the panther and Noel becoming a legend and story to tell just like his ancestors. I’m not satisfied with these differences because they don’t portray the book accurately. These key differences can really impact ones thoughts on both the book and the movie and the way one feels about how the director and producers of the movie chose to represent the book.…

    • 1007 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cool Hand Luke

    • 1063 Words
    • 5 Pages

    of silver and gave information that led to Jesus arrest. Jesus was crucified on a cross where he was beaten and tortured. His hand and feet were nailed to the cross…

    • 1063 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Trouble With Angels was based off the biography of the book Life With Mother Superior by Jane Trahey. This biography was about her own high school days at a Catholic High School near Chicago in the 1930’s. Trahey actually attended a day high school and most of her experiences mentioned in the book came from her time at Mundelein College which is located in Chicago. The movie was filmed in the months from September to December in 1965. The “St. Francis Academy” was really St. Mary’s home for children located in Pennsylvania. Ida Lupino directed the movie. The producer is William Frye. The writer of the screenplay is Blanch Hanalis. The famous actors/actresses in The Trouble With Angels are Rosalind Russel as Mother Superior, Hayley Millis as Mary Clancy, June Harding as Rachel Devery, Binne Barnes as Sister Celestine, Gypsy Rose Lee as Mrs. Phipps, and Camilla Spray as Sister Constance. This movie was nominated at the Golden Laurel Awards in 1966. It received 5th place for comedy. Rosalind Russel received 4th place for comedy performance by a female. IMDb gave the movie 7 out of 10 stars.…

    • 579 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jesus Movie Analysis

    • 700 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the film Jesus, Joseph seemed to be one of the most important things in Jesus’ life, but in the Bible, there is almost no description of Joseph’s role as a father. Jesus cared about Joseph very much like his own father just like Joseph loved Jesus as his own. In the film, Jesus became very depressed and didn’t want to go preach to the world without his guidance when Joseph died. Joseph was his role model and Jesus did look up to him. Joseph did teach him how to be a carpenter and taught him how to be a servant to God.…

    • 700 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    These works challenged the Christian doctrine, which was a major source…

    • 523 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In a country where those in power regard the news media as fake and irrelevant, a story of investigative journalism fighting for those without a voice might change a few minds. This idea is not original to present day, as the events that occur in the film Spotlight, directed by Tom McCarthy, show the risks and rewards reporters face when trying to take down dominate forces in society. This film follows the experiences of the spotlight department at the Boston Globe Newspaper, and their efforts to shed light on the horrific events surrounding Catholic Priests and their youngest parishioners. It does an excellent job displaying the perils and pitfalls the team faced while going after this religious staple of the Boston Community. The actors in the picture, bring realism and expressive emotions to a film that is troubling for anyone who regularly practices religion around the world.…

    • 1709 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Unless we withdraw to some sort of spiritual ghetto where we could sever ourselves off completely from the persuasion of the media, we have to learn how to deal with the challenges produced by it. The media may not have the political authority to embody the views and concerns of the people, there is still a position in our budding culture for a further relaxation of government control over the media. Of immense significance to us as Christians is that if we allow the sinfulness of humankind as we should, there are more grounds for us to increase extra checks, through other media sources. If being obvious is what we want our political structure to be, an independent media can contribute to a more transparent society where no public servant and political leader can conceal his or her sins. It should be our Christian concern to defend truth and honesty. While vigorous rivalry among the extended (and hopefully expanding) media factions should be encouraged, there is a need to insist that truth will not be surrendered in the name of convenience when information is published without giving enough adequate time for determining correctness and reliability of the account. I think in the past, the truth has been compromised when the major media groups in the United States reported on the results of the presidential elections. The television stations tried to outdo each other by announcing unconfirmed results which turned out to be a political soap opera rather than a reliable news reporting. I think that in the most recent elections, this has become a thing of the past. But there is a place for the Church to recognize the mechanisms of the media and use the media to have a say to the shaping of public values and ethical vision for the sake of the common good. This ultimately means that the Church must be apprehensive about the downside of being fed by media that are closely linked with any particular interest group, including the government.…

    • 450 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The media over exaggerates their representation of the Muslim population portraying them as violent terrorists and a threat to most nations/countries. Stereotypes abound in any and every form of media we can listen to, read, or watch today. Stereotypes create recognition in people and stir emotions - from anger to fear, or even empathy. News reports on religion generally use outrageous stereotypes of the population of the particular religion. This is evident in the representation of Muslims whenever they pop-up in news stories. Our views and opinions are often shaped by the media - the news, TV shows, movies, magazines and newspapers. Many people take the views depicted in these and claim them as their own without thinking or researching it more. Cultural Theorist Stuart Hall states that the messages in media, "intersect with the deep semantic codes of a culture and take on additional, more active ideological dimensions." This means that they build on the cultural and social anxieties of a given time and also reflect then back into the culture, therefore reinforcing them and adding to them. The problem with this is that the media almost always leaves bits and pieces out and portray only the parts they think we want to see to meet our expectations.…

    • 663 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In analyzing religion as it is displayed in the media, one can view a number of patterns that news media use to report on this controversial subject. The book Secular Media, by Mark Silk, discusses several commonly accepted moral themes, called topoi, that are present in the news media’s coverage of religion. Several themes, including good works, inclusion, and opposition to false prophecy, can easily be found when religion is examined in this light. Silk’s writing helps readers to understand what forces are at play when a newspaper decides to write an article on religion by revealing these topoi that allow their stories to be generally accepted by the populace. Indeed, the media both shape and are bound by the moral views of the populace.…

    • 1441 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Mel Gibson’s Braveheart is routinely named in polls of film critics as the worst movie ever to have won the Academy Award for best picture, and it is easy to see why. The acting in the film ranges from the blandly unmemorable to the mortifying. Negligible as Scottish history, but it is undeniably a political film. Gibson clearly did not intend to venture into a political debate—the film is structurally and visually standard Hollywood fare, a costume drama of the sort normally considered a “prestige picture” or “Oscar bait,” and the Academy swallowed it whole and awarded Braveheart the 1995 Academy Award for Best Picture.…

    • 3877 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    “The Passion of the Christ” was the complete creation of Mel Gibson, a unique project…

    • 3355 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays