• Among the two factions discussed by him, the first is to remove its causes which is destroying its liberty which is essential to its existence. Taking away liberty and making the existence impossible will be of no use and this remedy would become more of a problem rather than the original disease.
• The latent causes of faction are sown in the nature of man. It means that the causes of faction are built in the nature of the man deep inside and they have become like their own nature which cannot be changed. Among people different opinions about their religions, cultures, on government and many other aspects concerning their lives. Discriminating people with their life styles, the status, different opinions on different lifestyles has divided into groups depending on their opinions, and so they developed groups which formed more like opposing each other rather than being together. I am from India. Andhra Pradesh is one of the states and it has been recently divided into two different states, before this bill passed I was totally against for dividing the state, but as of the political strategies and everything, the state has been divided. So I always had an opinion about people who supported for not dividing the state and for people who wanted the state to be divide. Now nothing can be done as the state has been divided and now I have opinion on people who made this happen.
• That form of government in which the powers of sovereignty are vested in the people and are exercised by the people, either directly, or through representatives chosen by the people, to whom those powers are specially delegated. Let’s say there's an island of 1 million people, running a direct democracy, in order for a new law to be passed, they must hold a national election. If instead they had a republic in which a small number of people were elected to represent different parts of the island, you can pass a law without needing a national election and all the trouble that brings (time it takes to count votes for example). This is simply because you can reduce the amount of people needed to vote on a law from 1 million down to less than 100 depending on how you divide up the island. That form of government in which the sovereign power resides in and is exercised by the whole body of free citizens directly or indirectly through a system of representation, as distinguished from a monarchy, aristocracy, or oligarchy. Direct Democracies can also be quite unstable, so many people voting can result in rapidly shifting consensus meaning that rather than Power residing with the People it either just resides with the most Conservative or with those who can manipulate the largest number of people.
• The Federalist Paper No.10 argues that a republic is capable of controlling the effects of faction, more so than a democracy. The reason put forward is that a system of representation is more capable of protecting the rights of individuals and minorities, as well as being better able to balance the needs of the public good. Madison notes that representatives are more divorced from the issues being raised by factions and consequently better able to create just legislation that is compatible with rights and the public good. In the essay Madison argues that a danger of a representative system is in having too few representatives as the passions or corruptions of an individual representative can skew the system. From this Madison argues that the republican system scales better and works more effectively the larger the republic is.
• Madison's devotion to the principles of a republic and liberty was uncompromising and despite the pressures of the war he refused to enact legislation or measures that would compromise this. Unlike later presidents such as Abraham Lincoln of George W. Bush who both suspended habeous corpus in times of pressure on government. Madison believed that adherence to the principles of a republic gave America an advantage over Britain and compromising that through government oppression would make the US no better than a monarchy. He was proved correct as the US was able to thwart British attentions on the US. Madison sees faction as an unavoidable in a polity of maximum liberty, and consequently seeks to minimize the violence of faction through the system; in other words controlling the effects of faction. Representative government is the process by which Madison seeks to temper this. Madison uses this argument toward the notion that a democracy is flawed as it allows individuals to be judges in their own case. This supports the Aristotelian view that an understanding of common good and hence virtue is exclusive to the idle and ruling classes. This is a repugnant meme. If taxpayers had greater control over where their tax contributions were going, it would over-whelming be to common good programs such as public transport, medical research and far, far less on farming subsidies or the industrial-military complex.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
"That whenever any form of government becomes destructive of these ends it is the Right of the people to alter or abolish it, and to institute new…
- 463 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The people have also complained that government will ignore the public’s health. 3. Describe the two methods of removing the causes of factions? - One method for removing causes of factions would be destroying liberty, another method of removing causes of factions is by giving every citizen unprejudiced opinions, infatuations, and interests. 4.…
- 388 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
- destroy liberty (freedom): factions can’t exist w/o liberty, Remedy is worse than the disease.…
- 477 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
1. According to Madison, why should a government not try to remove the causes of factions? Madison believed that these factions would have a negative effect on individual freedoms and liberties.…
- 157 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
In Federalist paper 10 Madison argues that if an extended republic was set up including a multiplicity of economic, geographic, social, religious, and sectional interests, these interests, by checking each other, would prevent American society from being divided into the clashing armies of the rich and the poor. Thus, if no interstate proletariat could become organized on purely economic lines, the property of the rich would be safe even though the mass of the people held political power. His solution for the class struggle was not to set up an absolute and irresponsible state to regiment society from above; he was never willing to sacrifice liberty to gain security. He wished to multiply the deposits of political power in the state itself sufficiently to break down the sole dualism of rich and poor and thus to guarantee both liberty and security.…
- 868 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Federalist Paper No. 10 is considered one of the most important documents in American political history. The paper examines how the writers of the constitution defined government, specifically the part that would focus on protecting the minority and their rights from the more organized factions. These factions planned to pass legislation that would eventually cause harm to the liberty of the minority groups and the overall good of the country. Factions are inevitable, given the nature of man. People have different opinions, wealth status, and property, therefore resulting in the formation of factions (people with similarities fraternizing with the people who seem to be the most similar to them concerning their social circumstances).…
- 2051 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Madison made his concern of tyranny known especially in the 10th Federalist Paper, with some mention in his other papers, and writings including the Constitution in which his contributions were heavily influenced by his concerns. Factions were a legitimate threat, and the greatest of the potential evils for the United States because the good of the public would be disregarded by the majority faction, and they would make hasty decisions that would harm the country. The greatest cause for factions as described by Madison in the tenth federalist paper is different degrees of possession of…
- 1153 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The first solutions is to remove its causes, the second solution is to control its effects. He also offers two solutions for the causes of faction. First to destroy the liberty in which it exist, and second to give every citizen the same opinions, and interests. He explains that it is difficult to get rid of factions entirely because these are part of our human nature. We have been divided and held split opinions on a number of issues that cause groups to promote their own self interest.…
- 599 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
James Madison defines factions as a group of people united by a common interest. Madison thinks the cause of factions were unequal distribution of property. Madison felt that factions would lead to tyranny by the majority. He said there are two ways to eliminate the negative effects of a faction; first being to eliminate common interest which is impossible, the second being to increase the republic so majority factions cant be formed so easily.…
- 1019 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Madison states, "The latent causes of faction are thus sown in the nature of man," (Madison, Paragraph 5) so the solution is to control their effects. He makes an argument on how this is not feasible in a moral democracy but practical in a republic. Effects of a faction vary depending on whether the faction is a majority or minority faction. Madison argues that the only strenuous effects to control will come from majority factions. He states that the concept of popular sovereignty should keep minority factions from acquiring an influence. “But the most common and durable source of factions has been the various and unequal distribution of property. Those who hold and those who are without property have ever formed distinct interests in society” (Madison, Paragraph 5). However he argues that undesirable passions can spread from a small size to a majority faction fairly quickly. “. The regulation of these various and interfering interests forms the principal task of modern legislation, and involves the spirit of party and faction in the necessary and ordinary operations of the government” (Madison, Paragraph…
- 1116 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
James Madison begins his famous Federalist 10 paper by stating that a strong argument in favor of the Constitution is the fact that it creates a government in control of the chaos, violence, and destruction caused by the factions in society. James Madison defines a faction as group of people who collectively work together to protect and promote their own economic interests and political opinions. In my opinion, these factions are inevitable, and this because of human nature and attraction theory. When people hold certain ideologies, possess specific amounts of wealth, and possess different amounts of property, they will most likely associate themselves with people who are most similar to them. Factions in society are completely opposite and…
- 295 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
According to Madison factions create “instability, injustice, confusion and violence.” By factions federalist No. 10 clearly states “a number of citizens, whether they amount to a majority or a minority of the whole. The two main groups that Madison refers to are the minority and majority groups. The first consisting of “considerate and virtuous citizens.” In other words the wealthy and well educated privileged persons. The latter being “an interested and overbearing majority ”consisting mostly of day-to-day laborers poor in education and rich in numbers. Factions are formed because people are either united or separated by common interest regarding their own and the rights of other citizens. Factions are formed over issues like private faith, personal liberty… Madison admits that the first object of government is to protect the diversity in the faculties of men, which enable him to acquire property. This is the main issue responsible of forming factions, the acquisition of property. However men have “unequal faculties of acquiring property.” Madison further explains the existence of factions: “as long as man finds a connection between his reason and self love his opinions and his actions will have an equal influence on each other.” This is why both minority and majority factions are dangerous. Both groups separately pursue and act in favor of their own interest thus creating “unsteadiness and injustice” with in the public administrations.…
- 2782 Words
- 12 Pages
Good Essays -
Even though factions are different than each other, but often they work against the social matter on the rights of others. Factions are problems that have causes, hence there are ways to eliminate the causes of factions.…
- 693 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
There are more than 7,000 chemicals in a single cigarette. Those chemicals can be very harmful. Smoking cigarettes should be illegal because you can get lung cancer and secondhand smoke harms other people that are around you.…
- 553 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Cigarette smoking is the number one cause of preventable disease and death worldwide. Smoking-related diseases claim more than 480,000 American lives each year. Smoking cost the U.S. at least $289 billion each year, including at least $150 billion in lost productivity and $130 billion in direct healthcare expenditures. Cigarette smoke contains more than 7,000 chemicals, at least 69 of which are known to cause cancer.…
- 427 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays