Preview

Argumentative Essay On Women In Combat

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
931 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Argumentative Essay On Women In Combat
Cynthia Martinez
Danica Cantu
English 1301
3 March 2016
PMS and Combat Women and combat have always been considered to have little in common. Women have always been associated with emotion, caring, and passionate. Women today have the opportunity to enter the army, and are allowed to enter combat and fight alongside their male counterparts. Due to the lack of upper body strength, the inability to cope with combat stress and it situations, male and female romantic interaction, and the added mental stress on the female’s male counterparts women should not be in a combat environment. The first, and the most obvious argument is that in most cases, woman lack the adequate upper body strength. Strength is necessary to perform effectively in any
…show more content…
Men are naturally compelled to stop and help a woman in need. From changing a tire to lifting the heavy grocery bags out of the shopping cart. This does not change in a combat environment. Seeing female hurt quickly creates problems within the service member’s ability to think rationally when thinking rational is sometimes all you have in an extremely reactive environment. With that said, seeing a woman in need, a dangerous situation can become even more dangerous with an irrational decision because of the situation. This can also lead to the the romantic interaction between the genders in a combat situation. In an environment that seems like romance would be last on any service members thought process, it is still a conflict that is faced. The first and foremost concern is that of rape. With combat stress, the threat of a woman becoming a victim increases drastically. A male service member can make a bad decision and look for comfort from the female service member. Though wrong to start with, if the feeling isn’t mutual and the male not thinking correctly may decide to take anyway. Not only has a crime been committed but has now creating a situation where an entire mobile unit is no longer combat effective. Then comes the possibility that a male and female service member do become romantically involved and an accidental pregnancy occurs. In a combat environment this can become detrimental to all

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Mucciaroni Case Summary

    • 468 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Consider the efforts to change tax and agricultural policies described by Mucciaroni (1994). Begin an analysis of those events using the multiple streams approach described in the Zahariadis (2014) reading. For each case provide answers to the following three prompts:…

    • 468 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women in combat In the article, “Military women in Combat: Why making it official matters” composed by Jena McGregor, the author clearly makes a strong stance regarding women in the military. One point being, that at least 14,00 new jobs were made unrestricted, while 250,00 jobs in the military still remain restricted to men only. The main point in the article is difficult to point out at first , because the author seems to be in favor for women’s advancement in the military without combat and gives example to support her argument.…

    • 921 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When a woman is in close confines of a combat unit, that unleashes eros, the sexual kind of love. This type of love can hinder the success of the goal of the military. When sexual intercourse occurs, the chances of women becoming pregnant dramatically increase, thus making the woman unable to perform her job and taking her out off of the field. You can call love, love, but do not confuse brotherly love or comradeship with…

    • 934 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The rationale of this bibliography is to find sources of information on the role of women in the military and their role in combat. The bibliography looks at sources that are against having women in combat roles, sources that advocate women playing combat roles. The bibliography also looks at the performance of the women that have had combat roles and the challenges they have faced.…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Women should be able to fight in battle. I mean why shouldn’t they? Men fight in battle, why can’t women fight? Women could be just as strong and as fast as a man in battle. There are some women today and throughout history that have gone to the battlefield in secret.…

    • 102 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    There was a shortage of populations and resources in Canada during the wartime. The Canadian War effort at home was fuelled by volunteers and wives and family members left behind; among which women of Canada had made great contributions and sacrifices on the homefront in various ways, through working, joining organizations and at home.…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The main difference between past wand present wars is the ever increasing number of women who are seeing combat on the front lines. Women are being tasked to fill more and more lethal combat roles as the war on terror continues and women appear to be more susceptible to PTSD than their male counterparts. Studies indicate that many of these women suffer from more pronounced and debilitating forms of PTSD than men, a worrisome finding in a nation that remembers how many traumatized troops got back from Vietnam and turned to drugs and violence, alcohol and suicide. (Scharnberg, 2005).…

    • 1166 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Annotated Bibliography

    • 1643 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Bibliography: for Women on the Front Lines Thesis: It is the duty of the Pentagon to protect the service men and women of the nation’s military. Therefore, the Pentagon should reverse its decision to allow women in combat because service women have a higher risk of injury or death due to their feminine weaknesses. "APFT Standards." US Army Basic APFT Standards Comments. N.p., n.d. Web. 22 Feb. 2013. This document issued by the Pentagon and US Army illustrates the physical standard differences between men and women soldiers. The document shows that women are expected to perform at a lower standard than their male counterparts in all categories of exercise. The document also shows the gap between men and women physical standards increasing with age. I will use this document to argue that women are too weak to serve in combat if they cannot perform the same amount of physical exercise as their male enemies. Hopkins-Chadwick, Denise L. "The Health Readiness Of Junior Enlisted Military Women: The Social Determinants Of Health Model And Research Questions." Military Medicine 171.6 (2006): 544-549. Health Source: Nursing/Academic Edition. Web. 12 Feb. 2013. In this study, Hopkins-Chadwick focuses on the general life and health of military women. The study found that only a few women in the military hold high ranking…

    • 1643 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Women in Combat

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Speaking from a woman who is in the military I’m going to elaborate on why I think that women shouldn’t serve in combat positions. It’s scientifically proven that women doesn’t physically perform at the same level as men. For an example, the Army Physical Fitness Test (APFT) is broken down into two categories’, women and men and in which they have different age groups in which women are held to a lower standards than men. The APFT have different requirements when you turn a certain age meaning your body can’t handle as much as it did when you were younger. Same thing with women and men you can’t hold them to the same standard when their body is constructed differently. Physically a woman skeletal system is less dense and prone to have more breakages than a man. Psychological concerns are that women would be place on the front line and then get pregnant to escape from combat. Another reason I think women shouldn’t go into some combat positions such as sniper school is because you have to be aware that they camp out for days, but a woman can’t do that especially if they are on their menstrual cycle. We as women have to realize is that we can’t do everything as men.…

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Now over 100,000 are in the military and many people have difference views on this. Women in the military today are viewed in both positive and negative ways. Quil Lawrence and Marisa Penaloza wrote an article called “Off The Battlefield, Military Women Face Risks From Male Troops”. This article talks about how women are viewed in a negative way by some soldiers. In this article, Dora Hernandez, Sabina Rangel, and Jamie Livingston all have been sexually assaulted while…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    But why you ask? Here are just a few things people might say to argue against women being able to cooperate in combat duties. Opposing side: There's always the risk of a woman getting pregnant. They've had woman getting pregnant right before deployment or finding out during their deployment and have to get shipped back immediately. Me: Yeah, if a woman was serious about her job, she would take better precautions before going out. If anyone does get pregnant, neither the man nor the woman is ready for the job then. Opposing side: They don't have the strength. What if they were going out into battle and one of their men collapsed, and couldn't get up on his own. Not only would they be able to pick them up, there's like 30 more pounds of equipment on them. Me: They don't let women with no strength out into combat. They get training, a lot of training, and only the strong, smart, fast women get sent…

    • 806 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    “… When young women wonder how high they can rise in our military, they can look at General Ann Dunwoody and her four hard earned stars. They can see that it's real. When they ask what kind of jobs they can do, they can look to women like all of you who've played just about every kind of role imaginable. And when they ask whether they can cut it -- whether they have what it takes to succeed -- all they have to do is to look at your lives, to look into your lives and to look at the careers that you've developed that inspire us all," the US First Lady Michelle Obama stated addressing women in combat (Moving History Forward). I greatly agree to her statement because women have not been given combat roles in the military. Women have served in the United States army but in the roles not given to men. I highly support the lifting of the ban on women in military. President Barrack Obama has oversaw the lifting of the ban to ensure more women serve in the military. Women are fit enough to serve in combat roles that are demanding and of specialty. I will address the reasons why women…

    • 977 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sometimes there’s just things men to that women weren’t made to do and aren’t able to do. The first and most common stereotype when it comes to women in the army is that women aren’t as strong and are physically inferior to the men, this is true. Women don’t have the same build as men, plain and simple. We weren’t made to lift heavy objects and do hard labor work, but should we need to, we find a way for it to get done. Many would think that women would stick together in the armed forces, women don’t typically befriend their fellow women soldiers, they’re either in competition with them, “I wish I could say that there was a special camaraderie amongst the females, but the truth is I had few female friends” (Stephanie Christopher officer in artillery unit) Minsburg, Talya. Women Describe Their Struggles, 2015. The women stay in competition with each other because nobody wants to be seen as the weaker soldier. Also by doing this they try and make one another look weaker, hiding all their own weaknesses so well. If a woman is seen with another woman that’s considered the weak link then by she herself is assumed to also be weak just by association with that individual woman and can potentially lead to further…

    • 2014 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In an incensed yet condemnatory manner, Greg Sheridan, in a Newspaper Editorial for ‘The Australian’ titled “Women have no place in combat” (29/09/2011) contends that Women are too weak both physically and morally to be of any adequate use in combat roles for the ADF. This piece appeals to its target audience of a male dominated society,…

    • 909 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    All men are created equal; this includes women as well. Over a decade of years, women certainly have come a long way to gain the same kind of equal equality as men, such as being able to vote and being able to join the armed forces and fight alongside men. As growing up I was always told that playing dolls is a girl’s toy and playing a car is a boy’s toy. In my cultural, I was taught that girl couldn’t work in a male job, and I was taught to do housework while the men did nothing around the house. In my house/culture, the men are the provider while the women in my opinion are the servant in which caters to every male in the household. If people were to think about combat in the army many just picture a male behind the military ACU (advanced…

    • 1118 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays