Preview

Aristotle's Flawed Way Of Communication With The Deaf

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1527 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Aristotle's Flawed Way Of Communication With The Deaf
Deaf education is a relatively new educational resource when you look back on history. The first American School for deaf education was founded in 1817, a mere 200 years ago. Even Greek philosophers, such as Aristotle claimed that “"Deaf people could not be educated without hearing, people could not learn." (“ASL Timeline”) He even proclaimed that the deaf were “deaf and dumb,” because he felt that deaf people were incapable of being taught, lacked the ability to to learn, and that procured a lack of reasoned thinking. In Aristotle's flawed way of thinking, if an individual could not use their voice in the same way as hearing people, then there was absolutely no way that this person could develop cognitive abilities. (Deaf Heritage, by Jack …show more content…
Thomas Gallaudet."). Clerc was in London to share his methods of communication with the deaf. This method is now known as FSL (French Sign Language). The way in which the French educated the deaf amazed Gallaudet. Sicard, who appreciated Gallaudet's enthusiasm, offered to teach him his methods at no charge. Gallaudet happily agreed. The free public institution of learning where teachers and students use sign, rather than oral speech, would be the model of learning and teaching that he would bring back from Europe to share with Cogswell. This method is still widely used …show more content…
In the auditory-oral approach, much of the focus is on speech and proper sound production. Teachers use different types of ‘modelling’ to show the child how to speak correctly and form the proper sounds orally. (“Auditory-Verbal Therapy VS Auditory-Oral”) While in the auditory-verbal approach, the focus on listening is much more important. In the auditory-verbal approach, the implementation of hearing aids or cochlear implants may be used to foster better hearing abilities as

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Redefining D.E.A.F

    • 776 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Ryan Commerson, producer and host of the movie “Media, Power & Ideology: Re-Presenting D-E-A-D”, states that all the preconceptions societies have about people being born deaf is because of “ideology”. He uses Valentin Voloshinov’s definition of the word to later explore its significance in more depth. Ideology: “The dimension of social experience in which meanings and values are produced”. Furthermore, he continues exploring the first persons that tried to describe deaf people back in the 18th century. He explains that at first these persons, like author John Conrad Amman, one of the first ones to write about speech and how deaf people could learn how to communicate, had many misinterpretations of how deaf people really is and what are they capable to. Commeron continues saying that even thou they used very degrading terms to describe deaf people they were judging them wrongly since most of deaf people grew up without any education. The fact that all these people wrote about them, Cammeron says, it brings this false ideology to our present.…

    • 776 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Through Deaf Eyes is an insightful documentary detailing the history of both deaf culture and deaf education and describing many of the struggles which were encountered during the deaf communities fight for recognition. There were several points of interest in the film that I feel are crucial to understanding the deaf community; first, is the method used to educate deaf children. The early 19th century was a time of reform, especially in the religious community; it was believed that anyone could be saved as long you chose to believe. Many teachers of deaf students saw their role in the child (rens) life as slightly missionary. They could help save the deaf child from eternal damnation and in the process return the child to the hearing world.…

    • 219 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this book, Deaf in America, by Carol Padden and Tom Humphries, the two authors wrote stories, jokes, performances, and experiences of Deaf people. They also wrote Deaf culture and Deaf people’s lives from various angles. This book is great navigator of Deaf world for hearing people and even Deaf people as me. There are several factors attracting reader. To begin with, I could learn about backgrounds of deaf people and hearing people. Authors wrote about a Deaf boy who was born into a deaf family. Until he discovered that a girl playmate in neighborhood was “hearing”, he didn’t notice about “Others”. Authors explained, “She was HEARING and because of this did not know how to SIGN; instead she and her mother TALK” (Chapter 1). This story strongly impressed me. I was born into a Deaf family too, but I grew up with hearing grandparents. In my childhood, I did intensive oral training with my grandparents. So, I can sign JSL and talk Japanese smoothly. Therefore I never felt emotion like this occasion, “Others” to hearing people. The next factor is difference of “Deaf” and “deaf”. For example, the capitalized “Deaf” people are not only “deaf” but also user of Sign Language. I haven’t known the meaning of “Deaf” and “deaf” exactly before, thanks to this book, now I can understand. When I analyzed myself, I identified as “Deaf” because I truly cherish Sign Language. In addition, Sign Language is explained as a primary mode of communication for Deaf people including me. It has full access to communication for us. Unfortunately, some hearing people misunderstand that Sign Language is a kind of gestural communication. Authors wrote about it, “ASL are often thought to be direct representations of spoken words” (Chapter 3). In my country, Japan, there are some misconceptions about JSL too. Sign Language has both iconic and abstract concept.…

    • 620 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    As I read in surdam memoriam: Karl Jaekel, it showed me how society during the 1800’s throughout the 1900’s had a very negative view on Deaf people and sign language. Hard of hearing and or deaf-mute people used to be considered as a lower class. For a family to assume that a deaf child became “Deaf and dumb” by accident was not uncommon. American parents of that day were much more comfortable admitting to congenital than to adventitious deafness in their offspring. Uncle Charlie was enrolled in the Pennsylvania Institution for the Deaf and Dumb where he was enrolled in the shoemaking department, one of the three industrial programs open to boys, and the other two were tailoring and printing. They only kept records of the pupils attendance and work instead of academic enrollment and progress. The training programs saved the state of Pennsylvania a great deal of money by putting the pupils to work for the state. Etiology statistics in 1800’s stated that the deaf should be carefully advised in the defect to be transmitted from generation to generation and that the future of their offspring and their own should be prudently considered before entering upon a condition so fraught with possibilities of misfortune and happiness. (Annual Report, 1887-88). The connection between articulation and eugenics is not as transparent today but when Charlie was in school it was widely believed that Deaf people would cease to marry each other if the sign language that they could only communicate with would somehow be wiped out and they were forced to speak. The views are different now in 2011 because the science and generation has grown which has made families more aware as to why certain people are born or become deaf and it is certainly more…

    • 309 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    First, this book allowed me to see the negative way in which deaf people were perceived. This book is not old by any means, and I was taken aback by the way deaf children were perceived by not only others in the community, but often times by their own parents as well. The term “Deaf and Dumb” is one that I had never heard before, yet one that was used far too often. It is appalling to think that this was used for all deaf people, by not only a few of the more ignorant people who did not understand, but by doctors, teachers, and even the parents of deaf children. This term is offensive and just plain wrong. It is very apparent to me that deaf people are well educated and that their inability to hear has no affect on their ability to learn. Before reading this book I would have never guessed that so many people thought differently not so long ago.…

    • 923 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    credibility. By this, it can be threatening, in some cases the stigma that the Deaf are incapable,…

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Gm vs Ford

    • 1438 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Initially a Deaf child’s journey begins with family and starts at birth but it’s not till the deafness is detected that important decisions start to be made. Interactions with the child are important as are the ways the child is interacted with. Choices have to be made by the family that will result in how a child is educated and socialized. These most important family influences can greatly help in positive development of the child or the lack of it. Some decisions that have substantial impact are: How will the child be educated? The choice between institutional and hearing schools. Should we opt for cochlear implants? These are just a couple many important decisions and choices that are made by the parents or caregivers.…

    • 1438 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    history as it intersects the experiences of Deaf people. Education has been perhaps the issue in this story. "Through Deaf Eyes" traces the evolution of deaf education, from the founding of the first school for the deaf in 1817 to the 1864 chartering of Gallaudet University, in Washington, D.C., the only place that deaf people could earn a college degree in a signing environment, to the late-20th century "mainstreaming" movement.…

    • 1212 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Educational systems rarely stress the importance of training the ability of enlightening individual complications like nutrition, though less has been done to challenge the minorities and the disabled. Thanks to the works of Humphries and Padden, they stressed out to emphasize the cultural uniqueness of the deaf subculture in the American system. Humphries and Padden drew on their individual experiences as being deaf to illuminate the culture and life of deaf Americans, myths, and their everyday life (Armstrong, 2005). The essay centers on the authors' articulation in the book "the deaf in American voices" to explore the authors' biases. It focuses on how people can be deaf and not deaf as well as the essence of the deaf community in making…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    “Our greatest glory is not in never falling, but in rising every time we fall.(“Brainy Quote)” -Confucious. The unique heritage of hard of hearing culture is very affluent and astonishing. Understanding the desires of others wanting to learn about the history behind the hearing impaired will come across critical events like the “Deaf President Now” movement that essentially granted Gallaudet University its first ever deaf president, learn about the expansion of personal hearing assistive technology past and present, read about the vicious segregation in schools for the deaf, and learn about the thousands of historical figures that were hard of hearing.…

    • 1511 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cohecular Implants

    • 341 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Many members of the deaf community are content with their unique culture and do not regard deafness as a disorder or something that needs to be cured. Within the deaf community, particular scorn is reserved for the practice of placing cochlear implants in young children. The National Association of the Deaf, maintains that there is no evidence that deaf children who receive implants early are better able to acquire English or have greater educational success than other deaf children.…

    • 341 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    British Sign language (BSL) is a widely used and recognised communication method for deaf people, and anything that can be spoken in English can be translated into BSL.…

    • 2659 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Some even had the hope of starting their own families in the future (Sutton-Spence). The new schools for the deaf and blind provided so many new chances for these children to grow, develop and feel normal. A current day study revealed that people who are hearing impaired don’t identify themselves, rather, they see themselves as people who see the world visually and use sign language (Sutton-Spence). This can also be assumed about the deaf in the 1800s. Originally there hadn’t been schools for them or ways from them to learn.…

    • 1169 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    My sister is deaf, I myself am a part of the deaf community; I have attended sign language classes and also deaf events.…

    • 551 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    A Deaf child has the right to learn just as much as a hearing child does. A Deaf child should not be limited to what he/she learns in a classroom setting. The child can attend a hearing school although educating Deaf children should be done in a surrounding with other people from the Deaf culture so that they are learning and having social interactions with other people. A deaf child might be placed into a “special needs” in a public school, but if they were to attend a school for the Deaf the child would be placed into a regular classroom. A child being educated in a hearing school might face isolation from students and teachers, whether or not it is intentional or not it could happen because the hearing may not know a way on interacting with the Deaf.…

    • 443 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays