Essaying Through a Narrative As I stated earlier, I did end up receiving a very good grade on my narrative. Throughout writing the paper, this had been my objective, to write an A-worthy piece of work. Although my main goal was to achieve a good grade, I believe that the greater accomplishment in my writing was what I took out of the paper. The way I wrapped up the paper in the end showed how our team 's unwillingness to give in and succumb to their early lead kept us in the game. When we were all distraught and out of place, we somehow kept our heads and rallied together to come back and win. This is what I believe I learned from writing this paper, because before writing the paper, I just remembered the game being memorable and fun for it 's face value. But after writing through the game 's key moments, I realized the diversity we had overcome. I learned more about the game in this writing exercise than I could have by just telling someone about it. Thomas Recchio says, “As Graham Good argues in The Observing Self, 'The essay is an act of personal witness. The essay is at once the inscription of a self and the description of an object ' (1988, 23)” (281). Essentially, in essaying, the writer and, in my case, the experience, “define and transform themselves reciprocally, aspects of each becoming understood in relation to the other (Good 1988, 8)” (281). After writing an essay on the game, I now understand fully what I took out of it, and how it changed my way of thinking about sports. This game, which happened over four years ago, taught me that no matter how bad your situation is during a game, if everyone has a winning attitude, anything is possible. It is safe to say that my writing experience as a high school freshman was very closely related to what Recchio believes is “essaying.” I wrote about a topic I was very interested in, and in writing about it, my relation to the topic changed. In a sense, my writing experience was a learning experience, which Recchio argues is sometimes not allowed by the standard five paragraph essay. Unfortunately, throughout the rest of my high school career, the five paragraph essay was expected by my teachers, which may or may not have stunted my growth in writing. I can easily say that in my writing, I was truly essaying. In Thomas Recchio 's On the Critical Necessity of Essaying, Recchio tries to define the essay and encourage his way of “essaying,” while discussing how the standard five paragraph essay is often a detriment to learning. Recchio writes, “Reflecting a critical orientation toward self and other, the essay, as both attitude and writing practice, is Janus-faced; it looks inward and outward simultaneously, implicitly and/or explicitly registering the relationship between the person writing and the context of the writing”(284). In my own words, I 'd say Recchio believes the essay changes the relationship between the writer an the topic. He believes that while the writer can put what they want into an essay, they can also take something out of it. Recchio also believes that their needs to be some critical aspect to writing. He says, “If the fundamental goal of freshman writing courses is to empower students as critical thinkers through writing, critical about their objects of study and about themselves, we need to invite them not just to look but to think, not simply to perceive but to probe, not to accept but to question, all qualities of the essay as a record of the mind at work” (288). Recchio believes that writers will learn by questioning and probing deeper to find things out for themselves. By having a critical orientation towards a topic, the writer can challenge authority and make an opinion for themselves. To Recchio, this is a 'critical necessity ' in learning and furthering knowledge about a topic. In addition, Recchio outlines what he believes essaying is not. Recchio writes, “ 'In the essay, ' he argues, 'it would seem that [the] key rule is that there be a thesis which the essay proves” (1971, 631). He characterizes that key rule as the '[formal] tyranny of essay writing, ' a tyranny that 'is based on the need of those who are in control to make the appearance of the expression confirm a desired idea of which there is no doubt ' (1971, 631, my italics). Skepticism, uncertainty, openness to possibility have no place in such a form” (284). It is clear that Recchio is against the typical five paragraph essay in which the rule is the writer must prove a thesis. Recchio would rather see qualities incorporated in an essay such as skepticism, uncertainty, and openness to possiblity. I believe that my essaying was very closely related to what Recchio 's ideas reflect. My work did not have any thesis, and I was not trying to prove anything. My essay was written, and as I recalled my experience, I expressed what I felt and this reflected what I learned from it. I believe Recchio 's approach is extremely valid, mainly because my experience with writing in his way got me an A. One benefit of Recchio 's writing style is that the writer can learn about the topic while they learn more about themselves. Another benefit is that the writer gains the ability to challenge an authority and develop their own opinion of a topic as opposed to conforming to society 's standards. The only shortcoming of the Recchio essay is that there is limited form. There is no thesis to be proven, and it doesn 't have to be five paragraphs. In a society where we constantly search for answers and desire form, Recchio 's writing style lacks rigidity and structure. However, I believe that from a gaining knowledge point of view, Recchio 's essay is far more advantageous than the typical, rigid, five paragraph essay.
Works Cited
Recchio, Thomas. “On the Critical Necessity of 'Essaying. '” Resources for Teaching Ways of Reading, Eighth Edition. Eds. David Bartholomae and Anthony Petrosky. Boston: Bedford/ St. Martin 's, 2007. 281-291. Print
Cited: Recchio, Thomas. “On the Critical Necessity of 'Essaying. '” Resources for Teaching Ways of Reading, Eighth Edition. Eds. David Bartholomae and Anthony Petrosky. Boston: Bedford/ St. Martin 's, 2007. 281-291. Print
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Samantha McPherson R.Bishop English 1312 Comp II Online 6 Oct. 2011 Miss Brill & Miss Emily Emily Grierson from “A Rose for Emily” and Miss Brill from the story “Miss Brill” are two women that are trying to relive their past in the present time. In these stories, you are taken into the lives of two elderly women living very different lives, yet sharing many characteristics. You wouldn’t think to compare these two characters, but if you do, they are strikingly similar in many ways. In addition to being significantly alike, they also have their obvious differences. From the very beginning of both stories, we can tell that the women are lonely.…
- 835 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Madame Defarge is a murderer and brutal human being. She has killed many people and will keep killing no matter who tries to stop her. Madame Defarge has a very revengeful mind and doesn’t think about anyone but herself. I hate that Madame Defarge thinks that she has all the power and can do whatever she wants. She doesn't take anyone's feelings into consideration and just does what she feels like doing even if it hurts the people around her. No one knows much about Madame Defarge because she is secretive and doesn’t show much emotion which I admire very much about her. Sometimes I think I can be a little bit like Madame Defarge on some instances. Such as having hatred or wanting diminutive revenge on someone that I believe deserves it.…
- 619 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The author Tina Fanning in the newspaper article “cars no longer sustainable”, which was written in July 2007, contents the effect of car usage on global warming and the effect on the future of our children that proves the high level of harmfulness that global warming causes. The audience in this article is aiming at car users and state governors.…
- 414 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
This last paragraph should summarize the three main supporting ideas made in the body of the essay and relate these points to the thesis statement…
- 2714 Words
- 11 Pages
Powerful Essays -
* Discuss how artists have differed in their practice over time. Use examples to support your answer.…
- 1341 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
You and I live in a world were modernism is reaching new heights every day. One day that touchscreen phone is considered new, and then next week it’s old news. These two stories that I am going to compare are about the role of technology, science and how it affects me and you. Based on how it uses new technology and modern science A Sound of Thunder is a better sci-fiction story.…
- 615 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
ValiantCorp is a corporation that earned $3 per share before it paid any taxes. ValiantCorp retained $1 of after tax earnings for reinvestment, and distributed what remained in dividend payments. If the corporate tax rate was 30% and dividend earnings were taxed at 12.5%, what was the value of the dividend earnings received after tax by a holder of 100,000 shares of ValiantCorp?…
- 442 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
‘Is year of wonders primarily a study of grief and loss, or does it offer the reader an uplifting, optimistic message?…
- 1809 Words
- 8 Pages
Good Essays -
Science fiction is a really weird genre. It has some odd stories. These are some more oddballs.…
- 636 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
For this essay I read “ Map: The British Colonies”, “Religion and Slavery”, “Philadelphia”, “The African Slave Trade and the Middle Passage”, and “Abolitionism”. For the short sections (the ones highlighted in blue) I read “Slave with Iron Muzzle” and “The Meaning of July Fourth for the Negro”.…
- 781 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
When involved with life’s daily routines it seems as if time on earth will go on without end. Priorities become distorted, but vanitas paintings remind us that life’s journey has an end, and the things we concern ourselves with aren’t all that important when looking at the big picture of life and death. Although the mortality theme is in each vanitas, the artists express their meaning individually with use of color, iconography, and other artistic techniques. Two vanitas that are worth comparing are the Wheel of Fortune that was painted in 1977 by Audrey Flack and Vanitas, painted by Juan de Valdes in 1660.…
- 587 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Topic: To what extent is the protagonist conditioned by his or her physical and social environment?…
- 658 Words
- 3 Pages
Powerful Essays -
In an article written by Thomas L. Friedman entitled "While I was Sleeping" starts his journey traveling to India on a quest to help him understnad why they had become such an important pool for the outsourcing of service and information technology work from America and other industrialized countries. He also llos at how advanced technology plays an important role in growing businesses within the U.S.…
- 514 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The article, “On the Purpose of a Liberal Arts Education” written by Robert Harris explains how vital and essential a liberal arts education can be in society. Liberal Arts is an area of study (literature, language, and history) that is set to give general knowledge rather than specific skills for a single profession (Merriam-Webster, n.d.). Skills that can be gained at a liberal arts institution include: critical and creative thinking skills, increased ability to learn new ideas, intelligent opinions, and a better understanding of diverse knowledge and professions (Haidar, 2014). Robert Harris describes the brain as a muscle and like a muscle, the brain can enhance by many types of studies thus strengthening the mind.…
- 650 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Cited: Begrens, Laurence; Rosen, Leonard J. Writing and Reading Across the Curriculum. 7th ed. New York, Longman, 2000. 320-322.…
- 1413 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays