Preview

Assisted Suicide Debate

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1502 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Assisted Suicide Debate
Assisted suicide is a huge topic in the world of debate. The definition of assisted suicide is a physician providing a patient the means to take his or her own life through the means of medicine. This is now legal in five states and more are currently considering passing the law to take one’s own life. Many agree with this law as long as the person that wants to kill themselves has an incurable disease and is not going to have a good quality of life left for them. One of the major reasons that this topic is widely diverse and debated, is that Christians believe that we are not supposed to have the power to play God and take someone’s life, even if it is our own. Kuo says “For people of faith, it’s a bitter assignment. And any policy …show more content…
We don’t want them to suffer. We want to help. But as Pope Francis observes, assisted suicide gives us a “false sense of compassion.” Choosing suicide at any point is the same sin Adam and Eve committed in the garden: the pride of wanting to be God, not simply to serve him. True compassion is surrounding a terminal patient with love, support, and palliative care.” My solution is that all states pass a law to make it legal to medically kill yourself as long as you meet the criteria of someone who is terminally ill. One of the big problems people have with the topic of assisted suicide is that we, as Christians or believers of God, should not be able to play the role of God. Many people agree that the moral ethics of being able to kill one’s self are wrong and we, as human beings, should not be able to make that decision. People of the Christian faith believe that we shall die when God …show more content…
After going through many articles and journals, the main argument that was found is that we should not be allowed to play the role of God. Priest and Physician Mark Miller says “For those who can get it, "good care means living while you are dying -- for some people it's the richest part of their lives, when they know that the important thing is knowing you are loved and still loving." Yet too many physicians, he adds, "slough it off as the realm of the death specialists, while the Church tends to get off on moral issues without necessarily doing the practical stuff that needs doing." It's a "misuse" of the principle of autonomy to say what individuals do with their lives (or deaths) has no effect on others. "At the end of the day, the very concept will change society; there will be pressure -- on the elderly who don't want to be a burden, on the disabled, on anyone who feels they are living a life that others don't think a rational person would consider worth living.". We are not ment to mix church and state but this goes hand and hand with both moral and economical ethics. Another argument made is that the doctor administering the medication would feel guilty that he is allowing it to happen. Whether the doctor wants it to happen or not it is ultimately not his choice. Everything is decided by the patient wanting to kill themselves. Sure their decision is

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    ENG 111 Final Paper

    • 3005 Words
    • 9 Pages

    In today 's society one of the most controversial issues is physician-assisted suicide for the terminally ill. Many feel as though it is wrong, regardless of their health condition to ask their health care provider to end their life. Others feel it is their right to be able to choose how and when they die. For those who believe physician-assisted suicide should be their choice, they feel it should be legal because: they don 't want to go through the suffering caused by the life-threatening illness, they fear the loss of their independence, becoming a burden to their family and friends, and the fear of dying alone.…

    • 3005 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Every person knows what the circle of life consists of- to be born, to grow and to die. The lines between the right and wrongs of each are fuzzy and unclear. Assisted suicide brings up one of the biggest moral debates and there are so many questions with no clear answers: who should and shouldn’t be allowed to assist in suicides? Should assisted suicide be just for the terminally ill, or for all? What protection will there be for the people? and the biggest question of all- is it right or wrong? Those who are considered “pro-death”, believe that being able to choose how one dies is their own right. That there is a significant “difference between killing a patient and allowing a patient to die” (Breslow). Others however, believe The Suicide…

    • 161 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Moral and ethical debates attempted to resolves controversial issues but never seem to end with everyone agreeing. Often these ethical and moral debates are complex and involve opinions persuaded by religion or customs and have legal implications to consider. Physician assisted death is one of these very complex and controversial issues that all people will never agree on. Many questions arise in the debate of physician assisted death such as patients’ rights, physicians controlling the right if someone lives or dies, a patience’s mental state, a family member’s rights, religious beliefs of the parties involved and the law. Philosophers attempt to explain the different theories that people will use to argue their belief systems in terms of logic and reasoning. For example, some people may take the position of a deontologist who would argue that it is our moral duty to support and sustain life therefore assisted suicide should not be allowed. Unfortunately, this very emotional thought provoking debate is not a “black and white issue,” as most ethical arguments are not. In the situation of physician assisted death I disagree with the deontologist point of view that it is immoral for a physician to assist a patient in suicide. I believe as some relativist due, that as long as the patient is fully capable of making this decision and the patient is in a constant state of agony, then the patient has the right to make the choice to live or die. A relativist believes that morals are only relative to that particular society and if physician assisted death was considered moral in that group then it would be considered a moral act. Neither theory is without flaws as some deontologist even share my point of view and some relativist can be very extreme in what they feel is relative to being morally right or wrong. The bottom line is that people will probably never completely agree on this subject.…

    • 2640 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The act of killing is restricted by all religions. Religions possess that life is a gift from God and human beings are valuable. Islam totally opposes euthanasia. Furthermore, The Qur’an says that Allah created all life and everything belongs to him. In addition, Christianity also is against euthanasia. The arguments are usually based on the beliefs that life is given by God, and that human beings are made in God's image. However, some churches emphasize the significance of not being involved with the natural procedures of death. For instance, choosing the time and place of a person's death is God's decision. Yet, if doctors were to seek medical…

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Most people would agree that the right of a competent, terminally ill person to avoid any unnecessary excruciating pain seems as though it should be a basic human right. To have someone go through more suffering than absolutely necessary seems as though it would fall under the description of an inhumane act, and frankly an injustice against the basic human right of bodily autonomy and integrity. Due to these almost undeniable arguments, physician assisted suicide, in many cases, is seen as a basic human right that we need to be granted access to. Activists argue that it is simply an additional choice that we will be able to make, and that it will surely never be pushed onto anybody or used sinisterly (Maynard 2014). Although this claim is something that we cannot be entirely sure of, as I have continued to research the pros and cons behind physician assisted suicide, I have come to the conclusion that in many cases it truly does seem that the legalization of physician assisted suicide is the best option for everyone involved. It is a means to cease any unnecessary suffering that a person may be going though, and provides a sense of comfort for them during a time in their lives where they are not given many choices besides to deal with what they are going through and try to survive. Additionally, with many of the extreme medical advancements of the 20t century, our goals have been clouded by the quest to…

    • 1407 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Some would base their argument off their religious beliefs that suicide in general is immoral. However, the United States government tends not to make religion a factor when making law, for example: it is illegal to murder someone else, both religiously and legislatively, but we still go to war if need be. Suicide is often frowned upon within the texts of most religions and it is even a felony in some states. Physician-assisted suicide should not be misconstrued to fall under these descriptions, as it would only be for the terminally ill, a demographic which will die regardless of external influences and factors. Some people would argue that physician assisted suicide goes against the Hippocratic Oath which is an ancient oath doctors live by in their practices that states everything they do is to the benefit of their patients (Friedman 18-22). However, Doctor and physician-assisted suicide activist Jack Kevorkian stated that the Oath was never administered nor enforced during his learning at his medical school (Opposing Viewpoints…

    • 924 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Imagine laying in bed, unable to do anything for yourself; your quality of life is slowly diminishing to nothing. Now, imagine having the worst pain imaginable. This is what life is like when having a life threatening disease, like terminal cancer. Terminally ill patients have the most unbearable pain, yet have to die suffering. What if there was an option to end one's life with dignity, to be able to still make a choice while you could? This option is called physician-assisted suicide, and people should have the right to make this type of very difficult decision if ever needed to. It goes against the Hippocratic Oath a physician takes (www.pbs.org); but, this oath is not required for modern medicine schools. As long as a person is of sane…

    • 641 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    With a treatment such as assisted suicide, there comes religious concerns. Catholic leaders believe that God’s most basic gift that he can give is life. Catholics declare a moral obligation to take care of their life and health and when they need help, they must seek care from others. They must never purposely cause their own death, or the death of anyone else.…

    • 886 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Physician Assisted Suicide

    • 2492 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Similarly in her article, “Physician-Assisted Suicide: Development, Status, and Nursing Perspectives,” Theresa F. Rose gives background on the history of physician assisted suicide. She investigates the perspectives that nurses have on the issue and their personal views on the subject. Joris Gielen and his coworkers show a different angle in their article, “Religion and Nurses’ Attitudes to Euthanasia and Physician Assisted Suicide.” Their goal was to find the viewpoint of nurses on physician assisted suicide in regards to their religious beliefs. There are many different viewpoints on physician assisted suicide and they come from many different…

    • 2492 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Physician assisted suicide is a highly controversial bioethical issue that has been increasingly debated in recent years. Advocates of physician assisted suicide argue that it champions patient autonomy and reduces suffering while opposers suggest the benefits outweigh the risks and that there are other acceptable alternatives to the practice. This paper attempts to demonstrate the permissibility of physician assisted suicide as a regulated, medically reliable end-of-life option that can help end the suffering of individuals struggling with terminal illnesses. This will be achieved while still providing a comprehensive view of both opponents’ and supporters’ perspectives on the issue, specifically regarding the nature of the death that comes…

    • 1640 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Even though many believe that Physician assisted suicide should be legalized because it allows one to make their own choice of when to die, as well as dying with dignity. It also allows better care because of all the rules and regulations. Doctors also need to learn to handle the fact that they helped someone die. That is something that can be difficult to accept and sometimes gets to be too much for the doctor to handle. They also need to be able to handle the situation…

    • 1974 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    First, I oppose euthanasia because I believe that it is a doctor’s duty to keep patients alive. If doctors were allowed to preform euthanasia I believe that it would put a lot of physicians in the difficult place of deciding weather to treat a patient to the best of their ability or to end the patient’s life. I believe that it is a physician’s duty to offer patients the highest level of care. Physicians would also be put in a position where their own personal beliefs and moral bias would play in to their treatment plans. A non-religious objection to PAS would be that its legalization could inspire a lack of respect for human life (Mosser, 2012).…

    • 844 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Those in favor of physician-assisted suicide argue that the patients that seek it as a viable option do so because their disease is beyond treatment and other options do not preserve their dignity and right to a peaceful death. In choosing physician assisted suicide, the patient maintains control over their final days and even hours on this earth. They can prepare themselves and their loved ones for their death and knowing when it will happen can often provide a sense of peace. (Cite info in favor of pas here)…

    • 1087 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    People against the law want to prevent abuse and protect patients from evil doctors (ProCon.org). In the states where this is legal, there are extensive legal and requirements to the point where abuse is nearly impossible. People are concerned that patients will be pressured to make a choice that would end their life (ProCon.org). Patients could have as much time as they need, this is a life ending decision. Doctors might not feel comfortable, morally, knowing medicine prescribed by them killed someone (ProCon.org). Doctors would not have to perform the act if they don’t want to, the patient could find someone to prescribe it to them instead. People are worried about people making the wrong choice, but nothing is set in stone. If they want to change their mind, then they can.…

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the face of death, science and rationale, is it unethical to safely assist those who are suffering and have the desire to die with dignity and purpose? Physician-Assisted Suicide has and will continue to be a very controversial topic of discussion when talking about the health and dignity of the terminally ill. Although none of us ever want to think of our loved ones becoming ill, rates of devastating diseases such as cancer are rapidly increasing around us. This makes the probability of one of our loved ones being affected much higher. With only five states in the US allowing legal Physician-Assisted Suicide, leaving the majority of patients unequipped with all of the options for end-of-life care plans. Despite strong push-back from some concerned about…

    • 1552 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays