Preview

Australia, Bran Nue Dae and the Stolen Generation

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1216 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Australia, Bran Nue Dae and the Stolen Generation
Briana Gomes
Dr. Ann Finegan
FT345: Australian Cinema
8 February 2013

Question 2: Luhrmann’s Australia and Perkins’ Bran Nue Dae could be said to approach the apology to the Stolen Generations from different perspective. Discuss with reference to style.

Director Baz Luhrmann and Director Rachel Perkins both addressed Australia’s cruel and racist history and the aboriginal’s Stolen Generation in Australia and Bran Nue Dae, respectively. Both films follow the lead of Australian government and made an effort to apologize the Stolen Generation. Unfortunately, neither Australia nor Bran Nue Dae was entirely effective in their apology to the Stolen Generation. While they both had good intentions, those intentions were not successfully executed. Both film show promise and realize some of their goals, they still fall short in many aspects. It’s argued that Australia was “fraudulent and misleading” (Greer) while Bran Nue Dae “makes light of [the]…mistreatment of Aboriginal people.” (Howell)
Luhrmann’s film Australia approaches the apology to the Stolen Generation through drama and romance. The film is about an English aristocrat who inherits a ranch and the cattle driver who helps her protect her property from English cattle barons. Australia demonstrates some of the hardships that the Aboriginal people had to face during the World War I era in Australia. However, Germaine Greer claims that Australia “bears more relation to fairytale than fact.” Greer goes on to say that “the fantasy is designed to promote the current government policy of reconciliation.” The fallacies and myths portrayed in the film truly hinders Luhrmann’s attempt at the apology to the Stolen Generation. While Luhrmann makes a substantial effort at the apology, she seemingly looks at Australia’s hard past through rose-colored glasses. She over exaggerates the kindness and openness that Drover and Lady Sarah would have toward the Aboriginal people during this time. These softer hearted



Bibliography: Greer, Germaine. “Once upon a time in a land, far, far away.” Rev. of Australia. Dir. Baz Luhrmann. The Guardian 15 December 2008. Howell, Peter. “Bran Nue Dae: Tie me dancing fool down, sport.” Rev. of Bran Nue Dae, Dir. Rachel Perkins. Toronto Star 23 September 2010. Nilsen, Richard. “Bran Nue Dae” Rev. of Bran Nue Dae. Dir. Rachel Perkins. The Arizona Republic 23 September 2010 O’Sullivan, Michael. “A musical romp to nowhere.” Rev. of Bran Nue Dae. Dir. Rachel Perkins. The Washington Post 10 September 2010.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In the ‘Introduction’ the editor Carmel Bird accentuates her own sympathetic attitude towards the inhumane treatment of the members of the Stolen Generation. Bird’s value of compassion and egalitarianism challenges and compels us to form our own voice concerning the Aborigines and agree with view that the Australian government must apologies and take action for reconciliation. Carmel Bird uses highly emotive languages, which powerfully demonstrate her emotive appeal to the reader’s sense of sympathy and compels the audience to emotionally react and rectify the wrongs committed against the stolen children. She ends with the short imperative, “Listen to their voices”, which illustrates that it is a moral duty of our generation to understand the pains and continuing cries of agony of the Indigenous people. Her emphatic tone and sympathetic personal voices allows us to gain insight into the common voice of white Australians for reconciliation with the Aboriginal community.…

    • 812 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Contrastingly, Baz Luhrmann`s vision of Australia was of a form of multiculturalism. He comprehends his vision through a theatre play called “strictly Ballroom”. He became famous in a movie called “Australia”. It was expressed, where people embrace, respect, adore and express themselves through various activities each other. Stephen Johnson exhibits his idea of vision of Australia by a film called “Yolngu Boy”, where three boys search for their identity, rite of passage and the implications of belonging regardless of their dreams and visions. It explains how the aboriginal people can feel belong, respect and the preservation of different cultures and identities within a unified society or…

    • 507 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Demographic transformations in the Australian populace guaranteed that, for the first time, Australians born in Australia outstripped persons born abroad. Satisfactorily than condescending the colonist scene and existence, as had the migrant generation as “relocated Englishmen”20, the endeavor was sort out throughout the 1890s to institute a exclusively Australian national identity, demonstrating Australian qualities without turning in a “servile imitation of England”21. Contradictory action to the national recoil earlier, the originators were mainly authors and illustrators aware of their place in the crusade. Their philosophical anxieties distorted into props of an Australian spirit: patriotism and race predisposition. Evidently resulting from the working-class and distinctive understandings of the Australian wilderness, this macho fabricated character of fairness, collectivism, and mateship offered the bushman as the perfect character signifying Australia and its morals, which categorically comprised a ‘White Australia’.…

    • 1859 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Australian Film Belonging

    • 1171 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Film and television has taken over the world we live in, becoming one of the most popular ways for different personalities to express their stories in local and worldwide settings. Film allows auteurs to capture the essence of time, emotional circumstances and cultural differences in order to create stories that linger in the minds of their audiences. In particular, this is demonstrated in Australian film. Historically, Australian film tends to explore the cultural difficulties associated between Indigenous and ‘white’ Australia. The relationship between these two very different cultures is showcased in the early years of film in an incredibly marginalised, stereotypical fashion, often portraying Indigenous Australians as mysterious, mythical…

    • 1171 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Noel Pearson

    • 423 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Noel Pearson’s speech, ‘An Australian History for us All,’ explores the divides between our community and the issues that prevent us as a nation from achieving reconciliation. Ultimately, throughout his exordium Pearson is excessively humble, ‘it is my honour to have been invited… Alas, I cannot promise my teacher’s rigour ,’ this diminution of his prominent political position equalises Pearson with his audience. He successfully characterises himself as being selflessly modest, a successful tool in capturing our attention, his choice to do this in the exordium is also an example of kairos, his appealing attitude is naturally attractive, guaranteeing our fixated attention throughout the duration of his speech. Pearson additionally employs a variety of quotes to both enforce his credibility and portray society’s ignorant attitude towards reconciliation. We see this when he quotes Professor Bill Stanner, the ‘Great Australian Silence,’ becomes a metaphor of our refusal to address the Aboriginal struggle on a national level, objectifying the Australian nation as absent minded. Furthermore, Pearson makes noticeable appeals to pathos and logos, encouraging an emotional and logical response identifiable by all of us. Pearson in his battle for reconciliation, provides syllogistic reasoning and structure on solving the inherent ‘guilt’ issue, ‘it is not about guilt. It is about opening our hearts a little bit… and to have an open and generous heart…means that when you acknowledge the wrongs of the past, you might try to do so ungrudgingly… there must be some respect for that.’ Additionally, the inclusive pronouns that Pearson employs in this statement make his proposed solution exclusive, applying to both indigenous and non indigenous peoples as such he unites his audience, generating logos through the universal nature and structural flow of his statement. Additionally, Pearson goes on to compare the reasoning he provides to the internationally notorious issue of Jewish…

    • 423 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    One aspect of Australian Identity explored in this novel is mistrust. When the refugees came to Australia, they were seeking freedom from the horrible past they had endured. The refugees told their stories to the immigration officials in hope of freedom, but they were not trusted and sent to a detention centre in Woomera. The repetition of “we were kept in a prison” emphasises the desperate need of the refugees who are being ignored by the Australians who refuse to let them free. We are encouraged to despise the mistrust shown and to understand their desperate situation.…

    • 647 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Racism In The Sapphires

    • 310 Words
    • 1 Page

    The strong presence of racism among Australian communities as depicted in the film caused such events, namely the Stolen Generation, to occur. This significant event was a period in late 1800s-1960s where children from both Indigenous, and non-Indigenous (i.e. ‘white’) origins were forcefully taken away from their families as a result of official Australian Government policy. In relation to the film, Gail’s recall of a bitter memory associated with Kay particularly sheds light upon this key historical event.…

    • 310 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Cultural heritage defines who we are as a person or society. It is a bond that ties the people of a region or community together. This is learned and passed from the elders to the new generation but to achieve this, it has to be translated into representations such as art, language and religion. Hence to force a human being to reject and change these things is subduing or taking control over their culture. This action is practically taking away their identity and forcibly changing their values. The importance of culture lies in the fact that it is a link between people and their value systems. The ‘Stolen Generation’ which refers to the generations of children that were an Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander descent who were taken from their families by the Australian Federal and State government agencies and church missions, under acts of their respective parliaments, is an epitome of this damaging action. This action of subduing of a culture lost was a significant theme represented in Matt Ottley’s remarkable multi modal work entitled Requiem for a beast. Ottley cleverly utilised several visual conventions, symbolic codes, and written techniques that enhanced my understanding of this theme.…

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The stolen generation was a shameful period in Australia’s history. They, the stolen generation, were a large amount of aborigines called half-castes that were taken away from their family if they were part non-indigenous. These half-castes would have been taken away without any notice, then brought to an orphanage like place, where the girls would have been trained to become a domestic servant and the boys would be trained to become stockmen. The plan for the stolen generation was to breed aboriginal blood out, which was why it was mostly girls that were taken away.…

    • 346 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Module B Speeches

    • 1177 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In his speech, Noel Pearson addresses the need to acknowledge the past mistreatment of Australian Aboriginals. As an Indigenous Australian politician, Pearson gave his speech at the Chancellor’s Club Dinner in the University of Western Sydney to advance equality of Aborigines. Pearson quickly introduces his purpose, “our popular understanding of the colonial past is central to the moral and political turbulence we are still grappling with as Australians”. The illustrative use of turbulence is used to highlight the prevalence of past disharmonies and he uses the inclusive pronoun “we” as a synecdoche for all Australians to unify the audience. By directly quoting authorities such as John Howard and Bill Stanner, Pearson supplements his ethos and strengthens his case by evaluating both sides of the situation. The metaphor, “cult of forgetfulness” has negative connotations in order to challenge the common social mindset regarding the recognition of the past and induce a desire for change. Pearson effectively uses a cumulative list, “You have taken from us not just our land and not just all of the icons of Indigenous Australia…” to illustrate past injustices. The diction is divisive between Indigenous and European Australians, but deliberate emphasis is placed on the past tense to suggest hope for the future. Thus Pearson…

    • 1177 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Indigenous Australians are a prominently disadvantaged group that are subject to extreme discrimination impacting on their life’s. The Stolen generation had severe negative impacts on the victims of the stolen generation and has continued to negatively affect future generations. Further negative implications have stemmed from this extreme action. And it is the cause of many issues of inequality today among Indigenous Australians. This essay will define the stolen generation, outline and discuss the negative impacts that have stemmed from it and then link the impacts of assimilation to theories such as functionalist theory, structural, etc.…

    • 1035 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Stolen Generation was a time of grief, sorrow and sadness for many indigenous people. To say that it is something of the past would be distorting the seriousness of the issue, the Stolen Generation was and always will be a contemporary issue affecting indigenous people. Although race relations in Australia have been signified for many decades there still remains a historic distinction between ‘black’ and ‘white’ people and this is why Australians are faced with the implications of recognizing the need for national healing.…

    • 1954 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Cited: Meyer, Michael. The Bedford Introduction to Literature Eighth Edition. Boston: Bedford/ St. Martins, 2008. Print.…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    A difficult issue that is facing society is whether or not Australians should apologize to the Stolen Generation. The Stolen Generation is the Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children who were forcibly taken away from their families. This took place in 1909 until 1969. Governments, churches, and welfare bodies all took part in the event (Reconciliaction, 2012). They were then placed into institutional care with non-Indigenous families and were expected to work as labourers and servants. While many records have been lost, it has been that 100,000 children were taken during this period (Reconciliaction, 2012). Although some people think Aboriginal people are better off because they were removed from dysfunctional families, I believe Australians should apologize for three main reasons.…

    • 579 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In conclusion, the reason I chose this artwork is because I admire the way Vernon Ah Kee has illustrated how the Aboriginal Australians felt when they were being oppressed by the European…

    • 305 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays