Preview

Band Of Brothers

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1337 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Band Of Brothers
“The only hope you have is to accept the fact that you’re already dead.” [The Band of Brothers] In 1942, the U.S. army assembled a volunteer parachute regiment to jump behind enemy lines. Embedded in this unit was a company of men who landed to fight at the forefront of the war in Europe. That company was Easy Company. The brave men parachuted behind enemy lines in the early hours of D-Day in support of the landings at Utah beach and much more. Doing so, the company sustained one of the highest casualty rates of WWII. Although there were a few minute inaccuracies within Band of Brothers, the show is well produced and accurately depicts the training of the paratroopers, the horrors of how the Jews were treated during the Holocaust, and the battles …show more content…
We see pilots flying too fast, too low, deviating from their designated flight paths, panicking in the face of fire, etc. The problem with these portrayals in the show is that they are based upon interviews with 101st Veterans only, not pilots or other crew members of the C-47’s that took part in the airborne drops at Normandy. “Once we get into combat, they only people you can trust is yourself and the fella next to you.” [Lambert] Flying an aircraft in 1944, especially at night and in combat, is not a mindless task, and it still took a lot of skill and effort to get the majority of Airborne Forces over Normandy in one piece, regardless if they hit the correct drop zones or not. The paratroopers knew they had to be “prepared to die for each other; more important, they were prepared to kill for each other” (“The Society”). Missed drop zones did happen and mistakes were made by the troop carrier pilots, but their portrayal as seen in Band of Brothers is not necessarily fair nor accurate in regards to how things really unfolded during the Normandy Operation.
Other inaccuracies appear throughout the show as well. For example, is shown where Blithe (paratrooper) is wounded in the neck during the Normandy campaign and then later dying of his wounds in a hospital four years later. “I’ve thought about this often. That man and I might’ve been good
…show more content…
army. “And he wandered into the woods, found a barn and slept for a couple of days.” [Shimmin] Apart from the early American confrontations with the German assault, there is also the absence of the actual weather conditions in which the real battle was fought, such as cold weather and snow; there is no trace of snow at all in the major tank battle scene. Hitler launched a massive offensive into the Ardennes woods of Belgium, which caught allied forces by surprise. “There are many kinds of victory. For the German Army to survive, for us to remain in uniform - that is our victory.” [Smith] The series does realistically capture some major aspects of the battle, representing how inexperienced American replacement troops positioned in the Ardennes were initially overpowered and how confused the situation

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Apush Dbq 11 Essay

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages

    27. Battle of the Bulge—a 1944-1945 battle in which Allied forces turned back the last major German offensive of World War…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Battle of the Bulge, also known as the Battle of Ardennes, was a major battle fought in northern France during World War II that took place in the Ardennes Forest of Belgium which is a mountainous region of dense forest. The Battle of Ardennes was given the nickname of the Battle of the Bulge because, as the German troops pushed back the center of the Allied forces' line, it created a deadly "bulge" pushing into Allied defenses. On the Allied side, most of the troops were American, which is why it is considered one of the greatest battles ever fought by the United States military. In fact, Prime Minister of Britain, Winston Churchill, said "This is undoubtedly the greatest American battle of World War II.”…

    • 964 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Apush Dbq War

    • 2805 Words
    • 12 Pages

    The battle strategy of D-Day was quite complex. Allies wanted to convince the Germans that their intended target was Pas de Calais, 50 kilometers from the British coat, when it was actually going to occur in Normandy. To disguise the location of the attack, Allies launched preliminary attacks, with fake planes, landing crafts and tanks to mislead German intelligence. Paratroopers were first dropped behind enemy lines to capture and secure strategic points, then bombers attacked German defenses and finally, in the darkness of night, troops began arriving by ship and stormed the beaches of Normandy.…

    • 2805 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In fall of 1917, the Canadian armies were sent North Belgium after their great success at the Vimy Ridge battle in April. The battle occurred in Ypres area of Belgium, where the Passchendaele is located; it was the scene for several First World War Battles. However, it is understood the Passchendaele is mentioned as the horrific fighting condition. Because the area was made up of flat, low land and filled around with sticky mud which turned the battlefield dip into the sea of mud during the raining days.…

    • 418 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Battle of Belleau Wood

    • 2337 Words
    • 10 Pages

    In March 1918, with nearly 50 additional divisions freed by the Russian surrender on the Eastern Front, the German Army launched a series of attacks on the Western Front, hoping to defeat the Allies before U.S. forces could be fully deployed. In the north, the British 5th Army was virtually destroyed by two major offensive operations, Michael and Georgette around the Somme. A third offensive launched in May against the French between Soissons and Reims, known as the Third Battle of the Aisne, saw the Germans reach the north bank of the Marne river at Château-Thierry, 95 kilometres (59 mi) from Paris, on 27 May. Two U.S. Army divisions, the 2nd and the 3rd, were thrown into the Allied effort to stop the Germans. On 31 May, the 3rd Division held the German advance at Château-Thierry and the German advance turned right towards Vaux and Belleau Wood.[3]…

    • 2337 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Source B is written by a sergeant in the British army and it supports the statement and it is reliable since it is neither written by Haig himself to avoid blame for the Battle of the Somme, nor by someone who wasn’t at the battle. Source B gives us a first person view of the battle as Sergeant Cook was there…

    • 685 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Though the German defense was not as strong as Omaha, the Allies took heavy damage from enemy machine guns and snipers (123). Another problem for the Allies were the German mortars with support from machine gun fire, which was the main weapon that killed Allied soldiers (118) Because the German resistance built up during the attack as the Allies gained more of a foothold on the beach, they suffered major casualties (Bishop and McNab 141). Although the German forces were strong, they lacked certain advantages such as high ground like the forces at Omaha (Symonds 281). Even though the Germans at Juno were losing the battle, Hitler had forbidden any withdrawal of troops, making it easier for the Allies to attack (Der Vat 139).…

    • 1082 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Black Hawk Down

    • 1171 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This is a movie about the Battle of Mogadishu or commonly known as Black Hawk down. It started on the 3rd of October with what was supposed to be a quick “snatch and grab” operation. The operation was only to last thirty minutes. Under the command of Capt. Mike Steele they were to insert soldiers to capture two top lieutenants of a warlord Mohamed Farrrah Aidid. Things went terribly wrong when a black hawk was shot down by an RPG (rocket propelled grenade). It then became a rescue mission to save the soldiers from the crash site. The next thing they knew there were hundreds of Somali gunmen. They were now fighting for their lives. In the process of fighting their way to the crash site another black hawk was shot down. Now Rangers and Delta Force were fighting their way to two crash sites. In the process they secure the first crash site and are blocked in almost every direction. At a certain point in time two Delta Force snipers volunteered to cover the second crash site until a convoy could help get the downed pilot CW4 Michael Durant and in turn gave their lives defending him. They fought through the night facing thousands of militia, women and children. On the morning of the second day they secured the second crash site while the pilot CW4 Durant was captured. Then was the move to get out of the city alive. A convoy made up of UN and 10th Mountain Div. were to extract the injured soldiers. With not enough room in the vehicles the remaining soldiers had to get out of the city on foot. Running through the city running low on ammunition and energy they made it to the stadium in the UN Safe Zone.…

    • 1171 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Battle of the Rhineland. American forces in Belgium fought back against Germany's surprise attack in the Ardennes Forest. A huge offensive to drive the enemy across the Rhine River. It fell to the First Canadian Army to clear the area between the Maas and Rhine Rivers.…

    • 481 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Two of these lessons clearly stand out: Overconfident leadership, and ignoring the intelligence. There was clearly a lack of communication, coordination, and planning at all echelons. Information sharing is key to plan such a large scale airborne operation that involved numerous airborne and ground units. No matter how much of the operation was planned, if the information is being stovepipe, then the mission is doomed for failure. In Market Garden senior leadership jockeyed for position and assets; therefore sparred amongst themselves. I truly believe these leadership errors lead to ignoring the intelligence. Regardless of the Germans will or lack thereof to fight, their sheer numbers on the ground were much larger than what Montgomery wanted to truly believe. Logistical lines suffered with limited maneuverable passages; but more importantly because of all these issues, not all the bridges to Arnhem were secured in time for Garden to advance to Arnhem. Market Garden will be one of the most analyzed operations in history not only due to its failure, but also for its the overzealous leadership and the rush to end the…

    • 1447 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    To truly understand the men’s view of death in the war, we must pay attention to…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Empire Strikes Back

    • 477 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The story of America is the story of white imperialism. After the Civil War Radical Republicans set out to punish and colonize southern states. The North wished to create a satellite region, isolated politically but raped for its Negro votes and economic value. Steamrolling through southern politics with the help of Negros, scallywags and carpetbaggers, Radical Republicans instigated drastic economic change, as well as a political revolution caused by northern occupation in the south.…

    • 477 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Bridge Of Spies

    • 439 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I actually enjoyed the movie Bridge of Spies, even though I never heard of it. It is funny how on one side we as people wanted to make sure the book was thrown at Mr. Rudolph for being a spy but we send spies out to do the same thing yet when they are caught we want them freed and return home safe and sound. Mr. Donovan was the only person who put his personal believes to the side and focused on the case through the eyes of the law. He know and wanted to address from the beginning that the evidence found was fruit of the Poisonous tree because there was an arrested warrant but no search warrant.…

    • 439 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Mission Command

    • 2076 Words
    • 9 Pages

    With German forces on the run following the Allied success at Normandy and the breakout and pursuit across France, Allied forces were staged to enter Germany in late summer 1944. Both Field Marshal Montgomery and General Bradley clamored to be given the priority of effort. General Eisenhower chose Montgomery’s Operation MARKET GARDEN as the plan for action. It called for airborne forces to open the route for a ground force to move more than sixty miles up a single road, ending up north of the Rhine River near Arnhem, Netherlands. By accomplishing this task, the German Ruhr industrial heartland would be within easy grasp. But the operation failed. The ground force did not make it to the last bridge; it was six more months before Allied forces crossed the Lower Rhine River near Arnhem. Between 17 and 26 September 1944, there were 17,000 Allied casualties including eighty percent of the 1st Airborne Division (UK). The historical evidence overwhelmingly shows that the British 1st Airborne Division lost the Battle of Arnhem because of poor planning. This paper will prove the failure of The Battle of Arnhem was not solely the fault of MG Roy Urquhart. Although this was his first command of such a division (being an "outsider") could he have not completed his wartime mission any better despite having inexperienced leaders planning airborne operations, bad intelligence, allowing the Air Force to plan the DZs based off what was best for the air movement plan and poor execution. This paper examines MG Urquhart, the commander of 1st Airborne Division (UK).…

    • 2076 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Men in Black

    • 553 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Men in Black, are they a group employed by the government to cover up knowledge of extra terrestrials, aliens themselves, or merely a modern urban legend started by the mentally unstable. We are unable to answer this, but we will do our best to give you the proper information to have your own opinion.…

    • 553 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays