Preview

Operation Market Garden Battle Analysis

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1447 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Operation Market Garden Battle Analysis
Operation Market Garden: The Battle for Arnhem
CW3 Kris V. Williams
Battle Analysis: Operation Market Garden WWII Dr. Dastrup
February 22, 2016

The successful Allied victories in Normandy during World War II forced the rival Germans to retreat to the Netherlands. These events enabled the Allied Forces to attempt the largest airborne operation in history Operation Market Garden in an attempt to make a final push to permanently defeat the Germans and end World War II. Unfortunately, this plan was destined to fail from the beginning. Overzealous leadership planning, limited logistical support, bad weather, and poor intelligence all being contributing factors to the failure …show more content…
Operation Market would have three and a half airborne divisions drop into the vicinity of Grave, Nijmegen, and Arnhem to seize bridges across several canals and the Maas, Waal, and Neder Rijn rivers. They were to open a corridor more than fifty miles long leading from Eindhoven northward....In a companion piece named Operation Garden, ground troops of the Second British Army were to push from the Dutch-Belgian border to the Zuider Zee, a total distance of ninety-nine miles. The main effort of the ground attack was to be made by XXX Corps from a bridgehead across the Meuse-Ascaut canal a few miles south of Eindhoven on the Dutch-Belgian frontier. (Macdonald, …show more content…
Two of these lessons clearly stand out: Overconfident leadership, and ignoring the intelligence. There was clearly a lack of communication, coordination, and planning at all echelons. Information sharing is key to plan such a large scale airborne operation that involved numerous airborne and ground units. No matter how much of the operation was planned, if the information is being stovepipe, then the mission is doomed for failure. In Market Garden senior leadership jockeyed for position and assets; therefore sparred amongst themselves. I truly believe these leadership errors lead to ignoring the intelligence. Regardless of the Germans will or lack thereof to fight, their sheer numbers on the ground were much larger than what Montgomery wanted to truly believe. Logistical lines suffered with limited maneuverable passages; but more importantly because of all these issues, not all the bridges to Arnhem were secured in time for Garden to advance to Arnhem. Market Garden will be one of the most analyzed operations in history not only due to its failure, but also for its the overzealous leadership and the rush to end the
Continue Reading
View Writing Issues

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Battle Analysis: Hamburger Hill
    • 1815 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Battle Analysis: Hamburger Hill

    As one of the most famous battles of Vietnam, the battle of Dong Ap Bia provides a useful case study for the concept of mission command. Infamously known as Hamburger Hill, the high casualties and subsequent abandonment of the mountain caused critics to question the decision of military leaders. As with many battles in Vietnam, the commander, LTC Honeycutt, contended with the enemy while attempting to exert control with incomplete information in jungle-covered mountains. Although he was generally successful in fulfilling the six imperatives of mission command, it does not prove decisive to the U.S. Army’s ultimate victory. LTC Honeycutt’s approach to mission command is both lean and blunt, focused on success in combat.…

    • 1815 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Operation Husky Mission Command
    • 1542 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Operation Husky Mission Command

    On 9 July 1943, the Allied Forces initiated the invasion of Sicily, or “Operation Husky”. This invasion was the largest amphibious operation conducted during World War II and utilized over 2,590 vessels and involved approximately a half million soldiers, sailors, and airmen. While this invasion was a victory for the Allies and provided them with a launch pad for its invasion of Italy, senior leaders made many mistakes in their planning, execution, decision making, and coordination. As a result, analysis of this operation provides excellent lessons learned that are still relevant today for future joint commanders and staff. Lastly, of the six joint functions integrated into joint or combined operations, this paper focuses on evaluating, at the…

    • 1542 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Vimy Ridge Battle Analysis
    • 238 Words
    • 1 Page

    Vimy Ridge Battle Analysis

    This article, “Hundreds gather throughout GTA to mark century since Vimy Ridge battle” is about the gather for the Vimy Ridge battle. This big gather took place in North York. Very many people from both Toronto and Brampton wanted to take place in this respectful gather. John Tory was honoured to speak about the young men who fought for Canada. He spoke of the 3600 men killed and the 7000 men wounded. This three-day battle is an unforgettable event to all the people at North York. This North York event has much messages that everyone will look back to.…

    • 238 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    How Did D-Day Affect The Momentum Of World War II
    • 927 Words
    • 4 Pages

    How Did D-Day Affect The Momentum Of World War II

    Operation Overload, as it was technically called, is the largest amphibious operation in history. It started on June 6th, 1944 in Normandy, France. Even with the extensive planning, General Norman Cota, a strong operational leader, warned his troops to expect the unexpected. There were minimal German forces defending the area, concluding that Operation Bodyguard had worked. 14,674 sorties(one round trip to target and back by plane) were flown in a mere 8 hours. During the invasion, Dwight D. Eisenhower, A five star general and later, the 34th president of the United States, talked in a broadcast to the people of German-occupied Europe promising their liberation. Strategy on D-Day was critically important to this massive invasion. For example, two bridges, called the Pegasus and Horsa bridges were key for German reinforcements to reach Normandy. The night before the attack, two gliders landed near these bridges, carrying a couple Allied soldiers. The soldiers easily defeated the German guards and captured the bridges. This prevented reinforcements from meeting the landing troops. Allied troops were dropped out of planes to capture the Merville battery. The anti-aircraft guns on the battery scared the pilots and the paratroopers were dropped too early and critical supplies like mortars, radios, and mine detectors were lost or too damaged to use. Even with these problems, the Allied troops ousted out the…

    • 927 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Flawed Victory at Omaha Beach
    • 528 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Flawed Victory at Omaha Beach

    Compromise: Overall Operational plan took element of each. Daytime landing with air support...but failed (FLAWED VICTORY)…

    • 528 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Battle Of Shiloh Analysis
    • 1955 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Battle Of Shiloh Analysis

    Throughout the war, the use of mission variables can make or break your operation. The Union in the Battle of Shiloh demonstrated just that. They did not analyze their situation efficiently before getting attacked. They denied that the enemy was near, they did not take their cover and concealment completely serious, and instead of preparing and rehearsing for the enemy to attack, they conducted the less critical priorities of work. Although, after they were bombarded by the Confederates, the Commanders were able to reconsolidate and analyze the mission variables appropriately. Inevitability, they successfully completed their mission at the…

    • 1955 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    How Did Jackson Agree That The German Invasion In 1940 Was Primarily A Military Defeat?
    • 468 Words
    • 2 Pages

    How Did Jackson Agree That The German Invasion In 1940 Was Primarily A Military Defeat?

    Jackson did say that all of these reasons accumulated to a French loss. However, Jackson states that the invasion in 1940 was primarily a military defeat. The German tactics, based on the notion of blitzkrieg, were much superior to the French’s doctrine of defense and slow, methodical movement on the battlefield. They found themselves utterly confounded by the speed of German maneuvers, while their men were shocked by the German air attack and armored penetrations. “The main charge is that the French military had not adapted to the idea of mobile warfare and had neglected to possibility of grouping tanks together so that they could be deployed offensively and autonomously rather than playing an infantry support role as in the Great War.”…

    • 468 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    The Fighting Ground Summary
    • 1021 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Fighting Ground Summary

    Wars can be a difficult subject for students to grasp and understand. The Fighting Ground is a well written historical fiction text written by Avi in 1984. This story takes place in New Jersey on April 3-4, 1778. TheAmerican Revolution is being fought and the main characterJonathon runs off to join the war effort. This story is simple and doesn’t contain any milestone Revolutionary battles, but it does provide a view of a skirmish through a young boy’s eyes. While out fighting on his first day the protagonist is captured by Hessian mercenaries. Jonathon learns that war is not as thrilling as he originally thought it would be. The text helps readers recognize that much can be learned from the smallest events, even though they may appear insignificant.…

    • 1021 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Why Was the First Day of the Battle of the Somme Such a Disaster?
    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Why Was the First Day of the Battle of the Somme Such a Disaster?

    The first problem was that the Germans had established their positions first and had made deep trenches out of steel and concrete. The Allied intelligence had under estimated the German defences. They were 30 feet wide and had shell proof underground bunkers. The Germans had also placed their trenches in the best land which was the ridges so it was even harder for the Allied infantry to get to them.…

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Why The Battle Of The Bulge
    • 1069 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Why The Battle Of The Bulge

    Allied tactics involved holding out for enemy forces to run out of fuel and moral, utilizing tough terrain to hinder the enemy’s advancement towards objectives, and initiating counterattacks when the weather permitted the use of airstrikes or supply drops from Allied forces. Enemy forces that depend heavily on fuel and pushing forward into friendly supply lines to capture fuel supplies intact are engaged in a tactic that was used by Nazi forces. When Nazi’s were unable to take supply lines intact their mechanized forces ability to advance could only move one third of the distance to the objective without a proper resupply. If captured supplies are sabotaged or destroyed to deny enemy forces access to a quick resupply, they are entrenched in a weaker position from their offensive maneuver. Also, roads and terrain were too muddy or icy for Panzer units to advance on Allied forces adding more problems for them to push forward on Allied defense positions.…

    • 1069 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Pros And Cons Of Blitzkrieg
    • 402 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Pros And Cons Of Blitzkrieg

    Hitler’s army was not an efficient one. Though the Blitkrieg was astoundingly successful in Poland, The Low Countries, and France their true faults become apparent in the rocky terrain of the Balkans and the muddy swamps on the Eastern Front. The strategy of Blitzkrieg…

    • 402 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Why The United States Won World War II?
    • 1371 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Why The United States Won World War II?

    D-Day is considered to be one of the largest amphibious military assaults in history. The Americans planned out a diversion to keep German forces busy while they attacked different parts of France. General Robert Patton set up a phantom army, fake equipment, and fake radio transmissions in the narrowest point between Britain and France, Pas-de-Calais. While German forces lined up for the attack on Pas-de-Calais, 156,000 forces landed on 5 beaches along Normandy covering up to 50 miles of land (The Way We Won: America's Economic Breakthrough During World War II). The forces were able to push North and liberate France from German rule.…

    • 1371 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Were the Normandy Landings a Success?
    • 1678 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Were the Normandy Landings a Success?

    The question of whether or not the whole of the 2nd Front, or just the landings, was a complete success, is still debated all around Europe today. However, there is one definite fact that the Allies had a victorious to the end of the war. The journey to the victory was tough, and I will be talking about that journey over the next few 1000 words or so. In direct competition, for every success there is a corresponding failure, so I will also look to “the other side” in order to try to understand the much less documented reasons for their failure – which no doubt aided our success. I will look at some of the key personalities on both sides to assess their impact on the outcome.…

    • 1678 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    The Evacuation of Dunkirk
    • 1874 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The Evacuation of Dunkirk

    Through a careful and in depth analysis of the events leading up to the evacuation of Dunkirk and the evacuation itself, it is easy to understand what went wrong and how current leaders could profit from the mistakes made in the past. Few would contest that what happened at the tiny coast town of Dunkirk in May of 1940 was nothing short of a miracle. In military terms, the evacuation was a retreat, yet scholars years later would concur that this retreat was one of the most brilliant moves made by the Allied High Command. In a dazzling display of courage and patriotism, over 330,000 Allied troops were rescued from certain capture and imprisonment during this daunting endeavor. But why was this retreat necessary, what led up to this retreat, and what can we learn from it in modern times? All this and more are important things to consider as we take a closer look at the turning point of World War II, the battle of Dunkirk.…

    • 1874 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Mission Command
    • 2076 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Mission Command

    With German forces on the run following the Allied success at Normandy and the breakout and pursuit across France, Allied forces were staged to enter Germany in late summer 1944. Both Field Marshal Montgomery and General Bradley clamored to be given the priority of effort. General Eisenhower chose Montgomery’s Operation MARKET GARDEN as the plan for action. It called for airborne forces to open the route for a ground force to move more than sixty miles up a single road, ending up north of the Rhine River near Arnhem, Netherlands. By accomplishing this task, the German Ruhr industrial heartland would be within easy grasp. But the operation failed. The ground force did not make it to the last bridge; it was six more months before Allied forces crossed the Lower Rhine River near Arnhem. Between 17 and 26 September 1944, there were 17,000 Allied casualties including eighty percent of the 1st Airborne Division (UK). The historical evidence overwhelmingly shows that the British 1st Airborne Division lost the Battle of Arnhem because of poor planning. This paper will prove the failure of The Battle of Arnhem was not solely the fault of MG Roy Urquhart. Although this was his first command of such a division (being an "outsider") could he have not completed his wartime mission any better despite having inexperienced leaders planning airborne operations, bad intelligence, allowing the Air Force to plan the DZs based off what was best for the air movement plan and poor execution. This paper examines MG Urquhart, the commander of 1st Airborne Division (UK).…

    • 2076 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More

Related Topics