Preview

Bayard Character Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
941 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Bayard Character Analysis
Bayard defines himself in two different ways at two different times in the book. Early on he defines himself by responding to the murder of Granny; seeking revenge, and killing Grumby. It wasn't satisfying and it left him with an emptiness of the soul. He wasn't sure what life was all about because he wasn't acting from love or for himself; he was acting from hatred. When Bayard is faced with a most similar situation to that of the murder of Granny, he made a decision, which was the polar opposite of what he did before. Redmond, a man antagonized perpetually by Bayard’s dad, John Sartoris, had grown so tired of the constant aggravation that he ends up shooting Sartoris. Everyone told Bayard to avenge his father’s death, as they did with Granny, …show more content…
If you try to find out what is moving you to do things, and you can answer that question honestly then you will always be pointed in the direction of good, and you will always choose the good. He believed that reason of the mind is what actually drives you to action. Frankfurt takes a different approach and says that wholehearted love is what will move you to get it right, not just pure reason. He says that good can only be grown from yourself, and that you cannot be an extension of someone else’s soul. Even if someone else wants the exact same thing for you as you want for yourself, unless you are being driven to action by yourself, and your wholehearted love then you are not a fully self determining being. Hume also disagrees with Socrates. He believed that “reason ought only to be the slave of the passions”. His combat model is very similar to Frankfurt’s because he says that our nature, dispositions, and habits filter the desire that is presented to us. Frankfurt and Hume both presume you actualize yourself through acting on loving impulses because acting based on hate leads to the emptiness that Bayard experiences when he killed Grumby. Plato’s constitution model says that reason not only filters our choices but it has the last say in whether it drives us to action or not. If a person only moves …show more content…
To make sense of what was going through Bayard’s mind during the time of his father’s death we need to start at the most basic level, which is Socrates’ character model. Bayard, by disobeying the people around him, and not killing Redmond, was placing his cares in the state of his soul rather than being concerned with upholding his reputation in his community. He knew that to maintain his status of man of the house, and to continue to be respected he would have had to kill Redmond, but he valued his soul, or the “good stuff”, over honors or reputation, the “bad stuff”. But you need to dig deeper than that to get a full understanding of the remarkability of his actions. That is where the philosophy of Frankfurt and Hume come in. Bayard was not just moved by reason telling him this or that, he was moved by Frankfurt’s wholehearted love and Hume’s passions. Humans are creatures of emotion not creatures of reason, so to believe that what Bayard did was strictly because of reason is erroneous. That does not mean that reason did not have any say whatsoever, but it did not have the last word in his decision

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    People say that Canada lacks a unique identity, but Strange Brew took this opinion as a challenge with its extreme, satirical exaggeration of the stereotypical Canadian. Everything from the language to clothing is a Canadian exaggeration. The plot takes a Canadian pastime, beer, and revolves the story around it. What this really shows is the true identifier for Canadians, the ability to be at the butt end of our own joke. From the toque to the skates and all the Canadian stereotypes in between, scratch Strange Brew and it bleeds red and white.…

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the short story “The Threshold” by Amy Frazier, addresses an abusive relation between Ricardo and Vanessa. Alcohol converted the high school sweethearts into enemies. Unfortunately, domestic violence is a common problem in Hispanic families. There are three types of abuse that predominate in this story, physical, verbal, and psychological. Due to Ricardo’s frustration and unsuccessful life, he starts beating Vanessa which is a clear example of physical violence. Although, Ricardo shot her in the middle of the story . The worst physical aggression, it is when Ricardo beats Vanessa while she was pregnant with her second son Thomas, causing the loss of his defenseless baby. This is the most severe type of physical abuse…

    • 338 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    ‘It is through the characters that the themes of a novel come to life.’ Without characters the author would not be able to expand on the themes and provide depth into the novel. There would be no emotion in the novel and it would not be interesting to read. ‘A Bridge to Wiseman’s cove,’ by James Maloney, uses characters such as Carl, Harley and Justine to make the novel come to life through the themes of friendship, abandonment and support.…

    • 579 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The author immediately starts off by mentioning Mrs. Mallard’s heart trouble, which could symbolize her unhappy marriage. Chopin also tells of how Mrs. Mallard doesn’t take the bad news of her husband’s death as most women would, but, instead, “she wept at once, with sudden, wild abandonment,” (page 1)…

    • 353 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The distinction between a wanton and person is that when a person acts, their desire originates from reflection. On the other hand, wantons actions do not reflect or can guide their will. Furthermore, Frankfurt contends that second-order volitions are associated with the freedom of the will. A freedom of the will can be an issue for people. This is the situation because of the way free will is difficult because the fact that we should have the ability to guide our desires in relationship to our will for us to have the possibility of freedom. The possibility of the freedom is just valid if one's desire is connected to one's volitions. Moreover, Frankfurt contends there is a particular distinction between the freedom of will and freedom of action. The freedom of action refers to the state where one is free to do what one needs while freedom of the will is the freedom for one to need what one needs to have. The freedom of the will is when one acts just on the desires that they need to need. Moreover, in freedom of the will, one is free to have a will that one really need, and it is accordingly just free when one follow up on the will one needs. For Frankfurt, the possibility of freedom is different than…

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Many would question what second-order desires have to do with this work on freedom of will. In his own words, Frankfurt explains: "For it is only in virtue of his rational capabilities that a person is capable of becoming critically aware of his own will and of forming volitions of the second order." This means that only a creature with the capabilities of reason can realize that it has its own will and can make volitions of the second order, and thus is a person.…

    • 682 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    As F.Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby comes to a close, Jay Gatsby is killed at the hand of Wilson. Wilson then goes on to end his own life. We are supposed to believe that Wilson killed Gatsby as some kind of vengeance for his late wife –Myrtle- who Wilson believes was killed by Gatsby. However, prior to this event, Wilson knew very well that Myrtle was not being faithful. Even before this news surfaced, Myrtle was never kind to Wilson and their relationship was a rather rocky one. With this knowledge, the reader is left asking “Why would a perfectly sane man kill for a woman that did not love him?”…

    • 679 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout Raymond Carver’s “Cathedral,” the nameless narrator, the main character develops emotionally through a situation that creates fear in an already introverted man. He does not want to go outside of his comfort zone and he is caught off guard when he is forced beyond his current developmental state. But, through a lesson from the blind narrator finds himself enlightened to the sentiments of the handicapped.…

    • 518 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mrs. Mallard died from the sorrow and awareness of her husband’s existence. In “The Story of an Hour”, it states, “She wept at once, with sudden, wild abandonment, in her sister’s arms. When the storm of grief had spent itself she went away to her room alone” (Chopin). At first, Mrs. Mallard expressed grief towards the passing of her husband. Although, she kept her real feelings toward the event inside. Mrs. Mallard put on a shield to the world for the characters in the book to believe that she was mourning for her spouse. She used that sorrow to prevent anyone from perceiving her secret. She started to overlook the demise of her partner and started to focus on the freedom perspective when she said, “… that bitter moment along procession of…

    • 394 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mallard reaction to her husband’s death is very much justified but one could argue that she was also very self-involved. After she received the news of her husband’s passing, she did become very distract but not too long afterwards, she slowly began to start thinking about her life now and what the future holds for her. The thought of her whispering to herself “free, free, free!” and the phrase “Free, Body and soul free!” that she was chanting over and over would make you wonder why that of all things would come to mind. Is it because she has been trapped in a bad relationship for years and was yearning to dissolve…

    • 576 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The very beginning of the story gives the reader a strong depiction of who the protagonist of the story is, “in one definition”mallard” means male duck: Mrs.Mallard’s identity is certainly determined by the socially sanctioned prerogatives of the male, particularly the defining power to name.”(Emmert np.). When the death was diagnosed by doctors at the end, they said she had died of heart disease--”of joy that kills”(Emmert np.). Throughout the story, it is the thought of freedom and happiness that made her want to live past her husband's death, but when she finds her husband alive, it causes a grievance that kills her because of her heart…

    • 1153 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mallard’s actions are wise although her choice is unjust. As we can see she cries with abandon in her sister’s arm for only a while when her husband died, and then she seats back in the secrecy of her room to odor the moment. Commonly, most of women want to have someone by their side to comfort them in the bad situation. However, Mrs. Mallard doesn’t permit anyone to care or follow her. She realizes that she needs freedom, so she keeps her delight in secrecy. On reading of Mrs. Mallard’s apparently improper reaction to the tragedy including her husband. We will rapidly assume that she is selfish and cold, but she is just overprotection by her husband; it leads into dependence. Thus, she goes from being obedient wife to a feeling of freedom with the death of her husband. The new leaves on the trees sway in the light wind; the fresh breath of spring rain, the notes of a distant song, and the white clouds on the blue sky are all that she desires. She wants to touch, taste and feel the world outside the house. Therefore, Mrs. Mallard keeps whispering that she needs to be free for three times. We can imagine that she looks like a bird that is trapped in the cage for a long time with no freedom. She wants to get out of that trapped marriage to start her new independent life without obeying her…

    • 695 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After reading the story the reader may be curious as to what the characters in the story believed caused Mrs. Mallard’s death. The first thing that is said in the story is that Mrs. Mallard is afflicted with heart trouble, “Knowing that Mrs. Mallard… news of her husband's death.” As the story progresses the reader, along with the characters, thinks that Mrs. Mallard is having a hard time letting the news of her husband soak in. At the end of the story Mrs. Mallard dies when she sees her husband. Trying to put the pieces together the characters in the story assume that Mrs. Mallard was heartbroken when she heard the news about her husband’s death. But then when she saw her husband walk in she was overwhelmed and filled with mixed emotions, her…

    • 690 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Mallard just wanted to be an individual and a free women. She did not care so much about her husband, however, she did care about how her life was going to change for the better when she thought her husband was dead. Mrs. Mallard just wanted to be a person who had her own choices to make and become a individual who is a free…

    • 282 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    With Death Comes Rebirth

    • 979 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The opening line in Chopin’s story is, “Knowing that Mrs. Mallard was afflicted with a heart trouble, great care was taken to break to her as gently as possible the news of her husband’s death.” (Chopin 705) To me this shows that Brently Mallard’s friend, Richards, was trying to be the chivalric hero by ensuring that the devastating story is broken to Mrs. Mallard easily. It seems he assumed she would be in shambles when she heard the news about her husband’s death. Perhaps he thinks she is weak, and will have a hard time accepting the truth. The news could possibly cause her already frail heart to fail because surely she cannot survive without her husband. “…hastened to forestall any less careful, less tender friend in bearing the sad message.” (Chopin 705) He seemed to think that he was the only one worthy…

    • 979 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays