Icahn accused Blockbuster of overpaying Chairman and CEO John F. Antioco, who had served in that capacity since 1997, receiving $51.6 million in compensation for 2004. Icahn was also at odds with Antioco on how to revive profit at Blockbuster; Antioco scrapped late fees in January, started an Internet service, and wanted to keep the company independent, while Icahn wanted to sell out to a private equity firm. [29] In 2007, Antioco left the company, reportedly due to continued controversy over his compensation. He left with a $24.7 million severance package. …show more content…
However, after a due diligence review of Circuit City's financial books by Blockbuster (pushed for by Carl Icahn), Blockbuster withdrew its offer in July 2008. Analysts were not favorable to the proposed deal, viewing it as a desperate effort to save two struggling retailers rather than a bold turnaround initiative. [31] It even earned CEO James Keyes a spot on Jim Cramer's Mad Money Wall of Shame before the offer was withdrawn. Subsequently Circuit City filed for bankruptcy on November 10, 2008 and, after liquidating all of its stores, ceased operations on March 8, 2009.