Preview

Bound Feet and Western Dress

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
928 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Bound Feet and Western Dress
Traditions in Chinese culture are long-rooted and are taken very seriously from generation to generation. However, there must always be room for modern change in order for society to grow and strive across the globe. In Bound Feet and Western Dress the conflict between Chinese traditions and modern change arises. With this conflict it is important to discuss the different meanings of liberation for men and women and they way in which Chang Yu-I was able to obtain liberation throughout her life. Liberation in China means two different things for a man and a woman because of the gender differences that are prevalent. In traditional China women are treated unequally and are simply seen as a piece of property to their husband. They must abide by his demands and remain a slave to his family and traditions. As Yu-I told her niece, "You must remember this. In China, a woman is nothing." For a Chinese man, liberation means becoming stronger, more powerful, and of higher prestige. While with a Chinese woman, liberation means being equal to that of a man and being able to live a life on her own terms rather than that of her husband's.
Liberation for a woman is more about being independent and being treated like she is of importance in this society. Traditionally, women are seen to be child-bearers and that is their main role in any marriage. For example, the woman is really only seen to be useful in that she can bare children for her husband, and even at that, the husband wishes that the child be male so that the family name and traditions may be carried on. If the child born is a female than she is seen to be of no use to their family because she will eventually become the property of her husband, his family, and traditions. A woman's liberation is far different from a man's because of the old Chinese traditions that have been established for generations. Chang Yu-I understood woman's liberation as the tool for changing the Chinese culture. It was

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Jan Wong starts out as a naïve, nineteen year old, Canadian student who is displeased with the capitalistic nature of her surroundings. It was the early seventies and to the author, she was experiencing a cultural revolution all her own. Opposition to the Vietnam War was strongly prevalent, the notion of feminism was beginning to arise, and there was a strong desire against conformity of any nature. The author grew up middle class to second generation Chinese citizens and was fueled by bourgeois guilt, and by a feeling of separation from her roots. “Curiosity about my ancestry made me feel ashamed that I couldn’t speak Chinese and knew so little about China” (14). After devouring every morsel of information that she could, she firmly believed Mao and his “comrades” were the only people who had a legit shot at establishing a utopic society. It was official. Jan Wong was going to Beijing.…

    • 1587 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This memoir of Ma Bo’s sent shock waves throughout China when it was published and was even first banned by the Communist Government. This passionate story paints a clear picture for what the Great Chinese Cultural Revolution was really like. Many Chinese living today can attest to similar if not identical ordeals as expressed in Ma Bo’s story. The toils of being a young Red Guard in inner China were experienced by many if not millions. The horrors and atrocities were wide spread throughout the country, not just in Inner Mongolia. The experiences illustrated in Blood Red Sunset uniquely belong to Ma Bo’s entire generation of mislead Chinese. As expressed in the books dedication the Cultural Revolution produced victims, people who suffered from unspeakable wrongs, not limited by any criteria but all segments of society. All parts of China were turned completely upside down. Along with the turmoil came more than just suffering, but pure tragedy. Even the strongest unit throughout all of China’s millennia’s of history, the tight knit family unit, was broken. Particularly profound is the exhibited brutality, victimizing, and sheer loss of humanity that the common people of China subjected each other to during this tumultuous period. This sad theme was seen over and over again throughout the memoir. The devastation Mao Zedong’s Cultural Revolution inflicted on China has the country still in recovery today. The oldest still standing civilization in history became lawless and un-secure for an entire decade. This resulted in millions of atrocities and injustices taking place throughout the country. Injustice ran rampant everywhere and humanity itself struggled to survive. It awakened the most malicious side of mankind ever seen on such a large scale. To truly appreciate the Communist China 1966-1976 national aberration known as the Great Cultural revolution it is necessary to read an account of a person who actually lived in…

    • 1499 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    CCOT Song and Tang

    • 611 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Many things in modern day China are the same as the Tang and Song Empires from around 618-1279. The Tang, Song, and modern day China are all getting ruled by one ruler for all the people in their country. In the Song dynasty, the people took it upon themselves that they should educate the women so they can at least read simplified versions of Confucian philosophy.…

    • 611 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Death of Woman Wang, by Jonathan Spence is a historical novel pertaining to average people living in northeastern China. Spence’s book is unlike the “typical” social Confucian society China was thought to resemble during the seventeenth century. In this book, ideas of a Confucian family are challenged and can be seen as alternative but non-the-less, Confucian throughout human interaction and specifically in individual behavior. The Confucian ideas of filial piety, suicide, and being subservient are present, yet not as prominent as historians might think in a small town known as T’an-ch’eng.…

    • 495 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the Primary Source Ban Zhao’s Lessons for Women, Zhao’s writings reinforce patriarchy and Confucianism. Her writing conforms to the standards of the society and allows her to become a product by educating women on…

    • 776 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Eng 101 Paper

    • 1364 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The Chinese practiced foot binding for over a thousand years in the Song and T’ang dynasties. Some people found it very cruel, and then some found it fascinating. The ‘Golden Lotuses’ were the art and symbol for the wealth and beauty of ancient China. For any other culture, one would ask what foot binding is? Or, how did foot binding in Ancient China compare to John Fairbank’s text “Footbinding”? Also, how does the history of ancient China and Fairbank’s text differ and how are they similar? Then, how can foot binding be defended? In this paper, one will be able to understand the cultural significance of foot binding.…

    • 1364 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Footbinding covered all aspect of the core social, political, moral, and economic institution of Chinese society:”The Chinese family was both the root and microcosm of a highly centralized and stratified political system. “The root of the empire is in the state” … The root of the state is in the family” (Greenhalgh 11). “Feet and shoe were advertisement for upbringing, cultural level and accomplishment, family background and temperament. Impossibly small, these feet were originally a source of great pride. Small feet added prestige to a family” (Ross…

    • 4926 Words
    • 20 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Both China and India, like most classical empires, were patriarchal societies which allowed women little to no independence. Women were inferior to men and were restricted to domestic lives as wives and mothers. Chinese women were forced to spend their days at home because of Confucian values which emphasized the importance of a wife’s obedience to her husband. Foot-binding emerged during China’s classical era and further confined women to the home. Yin and yang, the concept of contrasting forces in the world, also limited Chinese women’s opportunities because it described women as the weak counterpart to men. In India, women at first had some property rights and some families were even matrilineal. However, Hindu laws set more restrictions on women, especially on those in upper classes. For example, a wealthy woman would have to conduct the ritual of sati and cremate herself at her husband’s funeral. Indian women, similar to Chinese women, were confined to their homes, and they were forced to cover themselves from head to toe when they came out. The only exceptions to restrictions on women of the classical era were a Chinese woman being able to exercise authority as a mother-in-law and an Indian women gaining independence by becoming a Buddhist nun. While both empires had similar gender hierarchies, the differences in their social hierarchies are what set them apart.…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ccot China

    • 402 Words
    • 2 Pages

    When analyzing the social changes from the Tang to Yuan, it is important to note that there was a change in belief systems. In the Tang dynasty, Buddhism started as the main religion/practice until it was eventually oppressed by Confucian officials who encouraged the emperor to wipe away Buddhism. With Confucianism now leading the way, the Song and Yuan dynasties had a social foundation based off of Confucianism. This was bad news for women. In the Tang Dynasty, with Buddhism at its peak, women were given opportunities and rights because of the liberal views of the Buddhist leaders. However, as Confucianism took over, women were enslaved and subjected to harsh rituals such as foot binding. As the social status of women declined from the Tang, the status of the scholarly elite rose. This was because Confucianism favored the elite and valued scholars for their knowledge. Also, the Civil Service exams that began in the Tang created a larger gap between social classes because the ones who didn’t pass the exams were not as valued as the ones who did pass. To pass the exam meant great honor, and with it more prestige in China.…

    • 402 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This essay is aim to compare the two countries with long shining history. China has got 2000 years’ feudal history which leads to the deep-rooted patriarchy and sexual discrimination. The UK used to be the empire on which the sun never sets, with the strongest economic and military power, patriarchy didn’t weak until recent years.…

    • 1701 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    He Qi agrees that, “the positive image of China in previous centuries was partly owing to Westerners’ difficulty in accessing to China and fully grasp their cultural practices.” When western missionaries were sanctioned to go to China, they found that their understanding of foot binding was contradictory with what previous western travelers have been described in previous…

    • 177 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Red Scarf Girl Essay

    • 635 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Cultural Revolution was a time of much confusion in china. The memoir Red Scarf Girl by Ji-li Jiang illustrates the chaos of that time. Ji-li’s experiences during this time period led to her point of view changing. Ji-li starts the Cultural Revolution full of progressive thoughts, but this quickly turns to confusion, and leads to an important choice, something that impacts the rest of her life.…

    • 635 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Oh My Aching Feet

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In John King Fairbank’s short story, “Footbinding,” Chinese parents choose to bind their daughters’ feet so they could have a better chance for a good marriage arrangement and success in life. A Chinese custom in practice for decades, “Footbinding spread as a mark of gentility and upper-class status” and as a way “[…] to preserve female chastity” (Fairbank 403). At a very young age, parents tightly wrap their daughters’ feet with cloth to prevent growth and change the shape in order to have small feet. Fairbank tells us, “The small foot was called a ‘golden lotus’ or ‘golden lily’ […]” and more desirable by Chinese men (Fairbank 403). It is a sexual attraction for men-a three inch foot is ideal (Fairbank 405). On the other hand, because of their small feet, foot binding prevents women from doing physical labor, keeps them in the home and safeguards male domination in China (Fairbank 406). Not only does it restrict what women can do, it is a very painful process. Foot binding, a cultural norm in earlier Chinese society, has many negative consequences which outweigh the positive consequences.…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pre-Mao China enforced strict gender protocols which placed women well below the standing of men. Mao realized early on that gaining the support of women would not only ascertain the winning over of ~50% of the population, but would also influence future generations into giving him support. The movie starts with the main female protagonist Qiong Hua being captured and tortured by Nan Batian’s men. Batian is a very rich, upper class slave owning capitalist, and thus is the main antagonist of the film. The movie ends with an army of women, led by Hua, killing Batian and his men. The transition between Hua being a helpless, yet determined character, to becoming a commanding, confident, and most importantly empowered…

    • 543 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    "She walked away but stopped and said that she would be pleased if the soldiers could make the man understand that today’s woman was no longer the victim of a man’s desires. (60). It is clear these ladies did not have autonomy, opportunity, or decision; they just had apprehension and mistreatment. Women were treated very poorly and were not equal to a man in ways, taking everything into account, ladies who lived in China the midst of Cultural Revolution lived in trepidation and under consistent investigation from the administration. They didn't appreciate the opportunities we underestimate, and that is the reason such a large number of people left China to attempt and make another life for themselves in the U.S., like Anchee min did in the…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays