Preview

Cargill Case Summary

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1035 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Cargill Case Summary
Summary
Kimberly Cargill a licensed vocational nurse who used to work in East Texas Medical Center (ETMC) is serving her death row sentence for the murder of Cherry Walker. Cargill was married in 3 separate occasions and had 4 children. At the time of her arrest and trial she was 45 years old. Cherry Walker (39) was the babysitter and was mentally disabled (she had the mentality of a nine year old). In early June of 2010, a body was found near Smith County Road in Tyler, Texas. After many tests done to the body, it was identified as Cherry Walker’s body. Cherry Walker used to babysit Cargill’s four-year old child before her death. Cargill at the time was on a child custody fight against the court system of Texas. She was on trial and charged for abusing her child. On June 18, 2010 a subpoena was giving to Walker to testify in court against Cargill on June 23, but never appeared. Since Cargill knew that she could
…show more content…
The media did portray this crime as heinous and did made people aware that the “white middle class female” is capable to commit a crime just as the “black lower class female.” Even though society mostly sees African American women as more ‘criminal’ than other races it should not be the case but it is like that. According to Chesney-lind, M. & Eliason, M. (2006), “The construction of some women as ‘bad’, particularly African American girls and women, supports racist notions that are arguably at the core of US culture” (37). Society has manipulated the face of the criminal woman and how she is “suppose” to look like but that is not true. Cargill is the other face of the criminal woman, she is white and not black and she is the ‘bad’ girl (woman). She is paying for her crime just as any other criminal out there it should not matter whether her skin color is white or black, it’s still a

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Tony Costa Case Studies

    • 710 Words
    • 3 Pages

    While being married Costa fathered 3 children. The relationship began getting complicated due to drug use, causing irresponsible and bizarre behaviors. During June of 1966, at the age of 21, Costa brought home Bonnie Williams and Diane Federoff, two hippie girls, promising to take them to Pennsylvania. Costa told the police that he took the girls to Hayward, California after they went missing. Many believed these two ladies were Costa’s first victims, although he was never convicted of killing them. He was suspected of killing 8 girls, Bonnie Williams, Diane Federoff, Barbara Spaulding, Sydney Monzon, Susan Perry, Christine Gallant, Patricia Walsh, and Mary Anne Wysocki. While he was in California he started dating Sydney Monzon, they then moved from California to Provincetown Massachusetts. On May 17th, 1968 Costa stole surgical instruments and various drugs from a doctor’s office. In June of 1969 Monzon was reported missing and never seen again. On September 25th, 1968 his new girlfriend of one week, Susan Perry, disappeared out of the blue. Costa told Perry’s friends that she left for Mexico. Costa was arrested for driving with a suspended license, and for not supporting his children and wife, he was released after 2 months and began hanging around and doing drugs Christine Gallant, she drowned from overdosing, it is suspected that he drowned her but no one knows for sure. On January 29th, 1969 Patricia Walsh and Mary Anne Wysocki were on a trip to Provincetown and disappeared. During a search party on March 2nd ,1969 a woman’s body was found mutilated in the Old Truro Cemetery, this body was Susan Perry’s his girlfriend of one week before she “left for Mexico”. It was said that Perry’s body was found cut up into eight different pieces Two days after the first body was found, Walsh, Wysocki, and Monzon’s bodies were found buried together one and a…

    • 710 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Tom Robinson was a civilized man who was trying to get home from work one day,and Mayella Ewell ruined that for him. In the unfair case of Tom Robinson he was accused of raping a girl he never found interest in.The case had a ruling set before it even started,because he was a black man. There was so much evidence that Mayella wasn't raped by Tom Robinson,some of the evidence were Tom's physical handicap from a cotton gin as well as his left arm being twelve inches shorter than his right and was not able to use his left arm.His color works againt him,the jury decides to believe mayella instead of Tom. Therefore, he was convicted and sent to jail.…

    • 255 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Florida V. Anthony

    • 1059 Words
    • 5 Pages

    On may 24, 2011 Casey Anthony was brought to trial for the murder of her daughter Caylee Anthony. Casey Anthony’s was charged with First-degree murder, Aggravated child abuse, and providing false information to law enforcement. The prosecutor in this case was Linda Drane Burdick, who said that Casey wanted nothing more to live the single woman’s life of partying with her boyfriend, and going to clubs. She hadn’t had a job in years, but lied to her family about going to work. The prosecution argued that Caylee was becoming too old, and would soon be able to speak and tell on her, though it was a shocking theory.…

    • 1059 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ronald Cotton Case Study

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Race, an aspect of diversity led to the arrest and wrongful imprisonment of Ronald Cotton. When Cotton, went to the police station to clear his name, as he heard of the charges, the police had no further ado than to arrest and to charge him with sexual assault. The police charged him with breaking Jennifer’s premises and rape. In the context of this story, one would ask, do minority races have ample presentation in the judicial processes? Again, is the criminal justice system fair and equal to all individuals without regard to race? An impartial response to these questions would be no. Race alone and not substantial evidence led to the wrongful charging and imprisonment of Ronald Cotton. Thanks to the DNA test that the truth came to reveal last, although the suspect had to suffer for over ten years. Also, another woman raped the same night as Jennifer, accused Cotton of her…

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    To say that Ronald Cotton’s experience represents the worst of the American Criminal Justice system is an understatement, he is proof of the countless bumps and flaws it endures. If there was anything Jennifer Thompson was sure of after her attack was that she would put her attacker behind bars and make sure he would never assault another woman again. So while being raped she decided to take mental notes on her attacker that would later help her identify him to the police. After helping put together a sketch of her rapist with the police she was asked to come in for a photo lineup and a physical lineup. That is when she identified Ronald Cotton, an innocent man, as her rapist, saying she was “absolutely certain” it was him. Thompson was then…

    • 248 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the SALON article, White Killers Go To Burger king: Race, Planned Parenthood and our diseased white privilege, Chauncey Devega writes about the sickening hypocrisy of how white perpetrators of mass killings are treated by law enforcement in the United States. Devaga uses examples such as how the Planned Parenthood shooter Robert Dear and the Charleston Church shooter Dylann Roof were treated by police as they were arrested. All of these mass murderers were apprehended by police alive and safe. Dylann Roof was even brought to burger King after his arrest. Devega contrasts this with the injustices that black Americans face on a daily basis. For a black American, even the most mundane interaction with a police officer can have deadly consequences.…

    • 193 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jill Meagher Essay

    • 634 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Sure a security camera got the man’s face and the man was later tracked down and punished by the law, but really it’s too late isn’t it? Jill Meagher had already been raped and murdered no amount of years in prison is going change that is it?…

    • 634 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The consensus of the nation can be summed up by the statement of New Yorker Susan McDougal “I’m sick, you know she killed a little girl and she gets off, goes home and maybe has another baby she can abuse and hurt.” Judgments like that give a green light to questionable people that it is alright to kill your child just as long as you know the prosecution will have a “weak” case against you, and you have a “good “ attorney that will get off! This level of level of ignorance displayed by our justice system is shameful and unacceptable. Our nation has laws based on reason, and our system’s bedrock principle is innocent until proven guilty. It’s a shame those principals weren’t used here. The American Judicial system has a set of rules passed by congress and approved by judges nationwide that establishes, in detail, how trials should be managed and what evidence may go to…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the movie, it showed women being raped and then tossed as if they were just animals. The men in that film abused the women to the point where they believed that they were nothing more than just tools for men to get their pleasure and nothing more. The ones that weren’t killed ended up having kids that only reminded them of the pain they had to endure which made them feel worse. The mentality that they are just tools for men to get pleasure ended up being passed down to black females today as well. Some of them only feel valued when they dress a certain type of way to obtain a guys attention and affection.…

    • 526 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Michael Brown

    • 1021 Words
    • 3 Pages

    This article was informing us on the first, basic information that was gathered about the case. It includes stories from both sides of the case and contradictions of both. Such as, if Brown was actually innocent or not and exactly how many times he was shot. Personally, I’m almost certain that this entire case was taken too far. It seems to me like the races of the victim and the officer have a lot to do with the intensity of the case and what everyone else has to say about it. If races weren’t leaked when the story was, would people’s opinions on it be different? I think so.…

    • 1021 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    wanda jean

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Execution of Wanda Jean is a compelling documentary based on a convicted murderess name Wanda Jean Allen who was sentenced to death in 1989 after shooting her lover Gloria Leathers, whom she met in prison while serving for time in prison for another killing. This documentary shows how the state of Oklahoma continues to execute Wanda Jean to the death penalty in which she had a low IQ, bordering on mental retardation. With the help of family, friends and her legal team, Wanda files for clemency but the Clemency Board denies her plea. Although Oklahoma’s decision may seem to be cruel, I think there are many factors in which why she should of received the death penalty.…

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although there are many people who would recognize the injustice of his behavior, there are also many people who would justify it because of the general stereotype of blacks. The media perpetuates the stereotype of blacks by often emphasizing their gang activity, criminal accounts, lack of education, and poverty levels. Ever since John’s father’s business went under, every offense a black person commits continues to reinforce John’s misconception of the black population. Instead of just seeing the person who commits a crime, he sees a black person who commits a crime. He assumes the reason they commit crimes is because they are black and he looks for reasons to hurt or insult any black people. John Ryan is…

    • 553 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Blacks in Criminal Justice

    • 3162 Words
    • 13 Pages

    “GET THE FUCK ON THE GROUND NOW!” As soon as we turned we saw two African-American teenagers several years younger than us, with silver and black guns pointed directly at our heads. I would’ve never thought in a million years I would be a victim of aggravated robbery (becomes aggravated when a weapon is involved). I livedin my neighborhood for almost twelve years and never once felt afraid to walk alone at night. That night, I was walking home from my grandmothers with a friend; it was only a fifteen minute walk. The street we were walking down was a well lit,rural street, with cars driving through regularly. This area was one of the few places I would’ve thought of being victimized. As we lay on the ground, we were searched for valuables. As I was lying in the middle of the street, one of the guys explained to me, “IF YOU EVEN MOVE YOUR HEAD AN INCH, I’LL BLOW YOUR BRAINS OUT!” After the mugger’s comment I felt him place the cold, hard gun to my head. It was the scariest moment in my life; my whole body was trembling with fear. Once the second gunman cleared my friend’s pockets, the two took off running. The moment they left they fired off several shots. We remained on the ground for five, long minutes. Afterwards we got up, sprinted the remaining distance to my house, and then called the police. I’ve never considered being robbed by an African-American because I don’t associate crime with a color, but after being robbed at gun-point it makes it extremely difficult not to. But instead of blaming an entire race, I sat aside my differences. This is not the case for others. Author Barry Glassner writes, “when it comes to race, the more obvious the pattern the more obscure it seems,” (Glassner 114). When we first hear about crimes that are committed, we automatically assume that the assailant is guilty. Yet often in time it’s not the case.…

    • 3162 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    What Is Crime

    • 575 Words
    • 3 Pages

    One point I found interesting within this chapter is the characteristic of the typical criminal. As mentioned by Reiman and Leighton, the typical criminal is male, young, urban, black and poor (61). Furthermore “that blacks are arrested for violent crimes at a rate more than three times that of their percentage in the national population” (61) which was 13% in 2006. This I found to be troubling because as mentioned in class the relationship between the population number and numbers arrested is disproportionate. From this, the authors write that there characteristics of the typical criminal has a lot of offense on arrest because individuals who commit wrongdoings or crimes may not be arrested. They give the example of whites who blame blacks for any crime and they will be believed without question, calling this method ‘racial hoaxes’. Adding to this is learning that the public losses more money from tax cheating and fraud, consumer deception and embezzlement than from property crime” (64). They write however that these issues do not come up much in the media…

    • 575 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Race and Crime in America

    • 2625 Words
    • 11 Pages

    The public receives much of their impressions and knowledge of the criminal justice system through the mass media. Top-rated television programs, such as Cable News Network (CNN) are delivering news on crime on an everyday basis. What people actually know, or think they know, about the criminal justice system can sometimes be interpreted as a form of ignorance of what is known to be mandatory knowledge in order to be law-abiding citizens in any society. As nonchalant some things may sound the public relies on the media to feed them the lasted and most accurate news, but this is not always true. In today’s American society, race and crime go hand in…

    • 2625 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays