Preview

Case of Ruth

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1489 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Case of Ruth
“Case of Ruth”
Case Approach to Psychoanalytic Theory
From the psychoanalytic perspective, all techniques are designed to help client gain insights and bring repressed material to the surface so that it can be dealt consciously.
Assessment of Ruth
Looking at the symptoms such as anxiety attacks, overeating, fear of accomplishment, fear of abandonment, and so forth—can be interpreted as outward manifestations of unconscious conflicts that have their origins in childhood experiences and defensive reaction to these experiences that are necessary to her as a child.
Ruth is experiencing a split—a struggle between opposing dimensions of herself. This conflict is between the part of her that wants to change and the other part of her that clings to old patterns that were once necessary and have helped her maintain mental stability all her life.
Development of Personality
In reality, Ruth appears to have superficially avoided normal rebellion and have suppressed her sexuality except for adopting a wifely role with the first man she dated. Although she followed the format of using her mother as a role model and having children by an acceptable husband, she apparently abdicated in the struggles of sexuality, rebellion, and identification, leaving these conflicts unresolved.
Her conscious recollection of her parents’ are of a rigid, fundamentalist father and a critical mother and these may had affected her as a child, a wife, and a mother also.
Ruth was socially isolated and that her lack of relationship outside the family was enforced by her parents, at least in terms of dating.
Her reaction to her daughter Jennifer may very likely be related to her own failure to rebel.
Concept of Human Nature
A Freudian view of her father’s harsh reactions to Ruth “playing doctor”—would emphasize the Oedipus/Electra aspects of this father-daughter encounter. Ruth internalized her father’s overly negative attitudes to sexuality.
Her early training by her parents clearly

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Through the plot of A Prayer for Owen Meany, John Wheelwright’s complex relationship with his mother mirrors the dynamics shown in Psychologist Sigmund Freud’s psychoanalytic concept: the Oedipus complex, with his friend Owen Meany assuming the role of the father figure. John seems to be infatuated with his mother, Tabitha, often describing her in ways simply inappropriate for a child to describe their mother. Furthermore, when Owen, who has a crush on her, describes her as having “THE BEST BREASTS”, John not only agrees but further elaborates on her beauty. Moreover, John’s attachment to his mother seems to manifest itself in unhealthy and competitive ways — paralleling the Oedipus complex — such as envy and resentment toward others who receive…

    • 167 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Her goal is to become a doctor, which was very unheard of at the time since “in 1949 only 5.5% of entering (medical) students were women” (Lo). Beneatha is very liberal compared to her mother’s conservative views. Beneatha doesn’t want to have the traditional life her mother and sister-in-law have by getting married and settling down. Her career is the most important thing to her and wants to achieve that by getting an education. Ruth’s standards in men also differ from her female relatives. While she is taken on dates by George Merchison, a wealthy man who could take care of her financially, Ruth finds him incredibly boring and shallow. Joseph Asagai, though poor and non-traditional, has truly captured Ruth’s heart with his sincerity and colorful heritage. Ruth was also brought up when women already had the right to vote or was introduced to it at a young age. This is completely different from the 1800s when Lena was raised when women were punished for voting: “Susan B. Anthony was arrested, tried, and fined for voting successfully” (Rights). Because she was brought up in a time when women were beginning to have basic rights and be considered more equal, it’s not so scandalous that she wants to have a career before a…

    • 933 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    She wanted the best for every single one of her kids. Also, she was missing the great religion aspect of her life. Furthermore, she needed the guidance to get back on track with her life. Consequently, Ruth has stumbled upon something that turned her life around. She found someone that would change her life in the matter of seconds. His name, was Dennis Adams McBride. They met up in the city of Harlem. He was from North Carolin and played a huge role in Ruth’s life. He believed in the Christian faith. He also was black, and for that reason, shows Ruth’s understanding about racism. Ruth was always against it. She even stated she hated people that were racist. Alternatively, they got married after a few years of dat ing. “See, a marriage needs love. And God. And a little money. That’s all. The rest you can deal with. It’s not about black or white” (McBride 233). This more importantly shows her non racism thoughts towards the black community. As a result of this marriage, Ruth converted from a Jew to practicing Catholicism with Dennis. From then on, it was the best for Ruth and Dennis. Unfortunately, a few months into Ruth’s pregnancy with James, she had lost her husband. Dennis ended up dying from lung cancer. Ruth was in shock and she prayed for him ever since. Afterwards, she then had James. When he was grown up, they both shared their Catholic faith and both wanted the best for each…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    8mile - Movie

    • 2031 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Psychoanalysis is a type of therapy that seeks to cure mental disorders by getting patients to talk freely and bring repressed feelings into the conscious mind instead of remaining hidden within the unconscious. This practice is based on Freud's theories of how the mind, instincts, and sexuality work.…

    • 2031 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Kathy asks Ruth why she never pursued the possibility of getting to office job she had always dreamed of. With a barely audible voice, Ruth tells her, “How could I have tried… It’s just something I once dreamed about. That all,” (230). Ruth again shows the idea that her fate is sealed and there was no possibility of defying the life she was given to live.…

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In The Color of Water Ruth's schooling experience is quite different from her son James experience in a public school; however, they do have various similarities as well. To begin, in chapter 9, Ruth quotes “...he would rather pay for us to study privately than go to school with gentiles…” (McBride 80). Ruth had to attend an all white school in a time where the Jews were not appreciated by many people. This is one similarity that James and his mother faced in school; being minorities was a problem to them because racism was the main reason why many times they hated going to school. In school, Ruth didn't have many friends, at most she had one. Due to being bullied and teased by her classmates, she couldn't make many friends. For example, Ruth…

    • 339 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the secrets that Ruth had to battle with when living in Suffolk was being pregnant…

    • 592 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    2. Ruth’s life was a very interesting but emotionally upsetting with how she grew up with her parents and later on when she lived on her own. The first most important events in Ruth’s life was when her father, who she called Tateh, sexually abused her at a very young age when she lived in Sullfolk, Virginia, This impacted Ruth’s self-confidence very much so because her father treated her with no love and kindness but instead treated her like she was nothing important to him. She really felt unloved and not worthy of him because of how Tateh treated her. The second most important even in her life was meeting Frances her first very close friend. Frances was very impactful in Ruth’s Life because she showed Ruth that is was okay to be Jewish in her town and that education is very important. Also another thing that Frances did to Ruth was begin Ruth’s journey toward going to church and begin a relationship with God. The third most important even in Ruth’s life was when she met Peter who she met at her father’s work and later she became pregnant with his child. This was a very important moment in…

    • 887 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    To begin, the narration style of this piece is extremely effective in showing how the two lives are alike and also how they differ. Having both perspectives aids the reader, giving a firsthand glimpse at each person's thoughts by not having to go through another person to state it. One very significant difference in the lives of the two is how their fathers acted. Ruth had a father that “would get in bed with her at night and do things to her sexually that she could not tell anyone about”(42). Her father also had no love for black people, nor his own wife. James, on the other hand had two fathers, both of which were always very kind to…

    • 917 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ruth Frankenberg

    • 867 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In Ruth Frankenberg’s book, White Women: Race Matters. On the Social Construction of Whiteness, her main argument is that ‘race shapes white women’s lives.’ As the reader continues on they are profoundly convinced by her argument. Through the use of gender, race, class, and nation Frankenberg’s analysis is full of incitement and quite telling.…

    • 867 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Submissive vs. Dominance

    • 1427 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The play starts with Ruth; she is the peacemaker in most of the family explosive situations. You can feel how she is exhausted with her life and how dissappointed she is with the way her life turned out. She keeps an upbeat feeling at times and at times she is very low-key for the sake of her family. I would consider her to be a dominant character yet submissive at times when dealing with Walter . This is…

    • 1427 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ruth become pregnant and she's pondering on whether she should have an abortion or not. When Walter return home she planned to tell him so he can help her make a decision. When he returns home Mama says,”You...you are a disgrace to your father's memory.” Mama is disappointed in her son for not stepping up and taking action in stopping Ruth from having an abortion.. She wants him to be a good man like his father was, but he's changing into a bitter man due to the check that his mother has received.…

    • 571 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Ruth's hideous looks are her husband's excuse for treating her like an animal, and eventually leaving her for an ultra-feminine and successful woman. Traditionally in classic fairytales, way before Disney’s time, women characters, or heroines, are played to be what women are meant to be. Meaning, they are to be beautiful, be the mother and wife roles, listen to your husband, and basically have no voice. Ruth is played to be a stay at home wife and mother who is to keep quite of her husband’s actions. Most women back then didn’t have jobs, or there own money, and ones who didn’t have looks seemed to suffer more. What would they do or where will they go without money, status and power? Now, Ruth can see Mary Fisher's shallow and materialistic success and character, and she knows that they are what society respects the most. Mary even said, “Ruth will make her own way in the world. After all, she has the children” (Weldon 56). Ruth doesn't, and shouldn't accept this cruelty, for she knows that there is no justification for her husband and society's ways, and she has to get even. Ruth hasn't got anything too lose, she doesn't have any money, public status, or power, therefore she can plan her revenge without any regrets. Ruth's revenge on her disloyal husband Bobbo, is clearly about getting revenge at society, her husband, and it's ridiculous demands of women and what roles they need to play. Weldon is backlashing on fairytales. Given what we know about fairytales have we ever seen a woman out step her boundaries? Have we ever seen them get the status, the money, and happiness by doing it on their own? There was always a man presented to get them that. For instance Rapunzel, her story is very nice but unrealistic. Yes, she got the handsome Prince and “true love” in the end. But what did she actually do? She was faced upon a curse and it just so happens 100 years…

    • 1583 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Paranoia

    • 1173 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Ruth were two of several girls that were dancing in the woods. In the Puritan culture, dancing is…

    • 1173 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    father did not acknowledge her, nor did he care about her what she did. Eventually leading her…

    • 1065 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics