Rather, the contention was that the "freedom" managed under the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment incorporates the inferred right of same-sex couples to wed, and that the States' activities were denying them of this freedom without due process of law.
Four Justices disagreed, creating four contradicting opinion. Many of the supreme court justices disagreed with the majority stated that same-sex couples had the right to wed. All justices concurred that the Constitution itself does not say anything in regards to marriage. This implies marriage is not a counted right. Indeed, Justice Alito particularly stated, "The Constitution says nothing in regards to same-sex marriage." Because the privilege for same-sex couples to wed is not an identified right, the only way for it to be protected in our constitution is for it to be inferred. The justices stated that