One other shortcoming is the fact that huge numbers of students are grouped together. For example, last year there were 348 students in Navi Mummbai at Universal Tutorials all scoring more than 90 per cent. It is possible that a scenario will emerge wherein all students scoring above, say, 91 per cent in all subjects will have the same cumulative grading. This poses the problem of how do you rank them? What will the admission process for the Standard XI based on?
In an attempt to address the problem a percentile mark has been introduced by the board. The percentile of a student indicates the position or rank of the student in percentage form. The top ranked student will get a percentile of 100. This is calculated by the formula, 'Number of students below student X 100 divided by (total no of students -1). However, this in itself brings its own setback. The grading system may actually lead to more stress and disincentive to performance.
In addition to CBSE, Secondary School Certificates by state boards and those governing the Indian Certificate of Secondary Education are also conducting exams for Standard X and continue to follow the marks system and percentage of mark in each subject. Marks percentage and percentile are not comparable. This leads to an open ended situation particularly for the Standard XI admission process and those seeking admission from CBSE to other boards. This issue is still to be resolved and a decision needs to be made regarding how it will be tackled. CCE grading patterns have a number of disadvantages. First and foremost, the 'Continuous and Comprehensive Evaluation' of students often leads to the said students feeling under pressure and stressed out throughout their school years. The tests themselves will be set using a limited syllabus, meaning students do not receive a broad and varied education in the classroom. This can stunt learning development in later school years and result in pupils that are not well rounded. Teachers will focus more on encouraging students to do well in examinations, rather than teaching them about various subject areas with interest. Pupils themselves will become focused on tests rather than the actual learning, and may struggle to become interested in various academic subjects later in life, causing them to drop out of the education system.
• The impact of receiving comparatively low grades
Those students who achieve low grades may become saddened and discouraged. They will feel undervalued and worthless, which could lead to feelings of isolation. Pupils could be classed as stupid or unintelligent from a very early age, which is unfair as children develop at different rates. This will lead to many students focusing less on their studies, as they feel they can never succeed in the academic world, and more on other aspects of life such as being social and having fun. Some pupils may even become disruptive and misbehave in the classroom, which negatively impacts all students in a school. CCE grading patterns have a number of disadvantages. The other foremost disadvantage of the 'Continuous and Comprehensive Evaluation' of students often leads to the said students feeling under pressure and stressed out throughout their school years. The tests themselves will be set using a limited syllabus, meaning students do not receive a broad and varied education in the classroom. This can stunt learning development in later school years and result in pupils that are not well rounded. Teachers will focus more on encouraging students to do well in examinations, rather than teaching them about various subject areas with interest. Pupils themselves will become focused on tests rather than the actual learning, and may struggle to become interested in various academic subjects later in life, causing them to drop out of the education system.
• A possible benefit of the grading system
As well as making all parties aware of the stage of development a child is at, the grading system could promote healthy competition between the more intelligent students in a class. These students will strive to achieve the best results possible in order to outperform their peers. Although this has many negative implications, it does improve the results of some students - so the CCE system is not all bad
. The Disadvantages of Comprehensive Continuous Evaluation
Comprehensive evaluation assesses students' involvement in sports as part of the curriculum evaluation process.
Comprehensive continuous evaluation (CCE) is an educational evaluation style used in India for evaluating elementary and secondary school students. The assessment system is designed to replaced standardized board examination testing by evaluating students based on academic and personal progress from the start of their education to its completion, or kindergarten through high school graduation. Teachers evaluate scholastic performance, arts and sports involvement and personal and social development. 1. Time Constraints
o CCE requires teachers to spend more time evaluating individual students. While the advantages of this include a broader view of the child's progress and more interaction with the child's parents, it can put additional strain on teachers that negatively influences their ability to assess students. Student conferences are more frequent under this system, requiring teachers to add more hours to their work day. This disadvantage can easily be remedied if parents avail themselves for conferences with the teacher during school hours and if classroom sizes are limited.
Potential for Inconsistencies
o CCE requires all teachers be trained and adhere to the same assessment methods. However, the system is liable to suffer from many inconsistencies. Teachers are charged with assessing cognitive abilities as well as health habits, work habits, cleanliness and cooperation. While a general standard of health habits and cleanliness, for example, may be assumed, the truth is such personal standards can be surprisingly subjective. Training teachers in assessing these values may not provide any more consistent results than standardized testing.
Potential for Prejudice
o CCE is aimed at grooming students academically as well as shaping their...
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The percentile rank tells where a score ranks among the rest of the scores. The percent is a comparison of a score to the highest score possible.…
- 278 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Diller, J. (2011). Cultural Diversity: A Primer for the Human Services. Brooks and Cole Publishing, CA.…
- 1207 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
In the society we live in, one of its major institutions is Education. In the National Curriculum, certain guidelines are set out for a National expected level of achievement for each year group. Some pupils achieve a much higher level than this guideline, whereas others fall significantly below this.…
- 1520 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The range of uniform mark percentages allocated to a particular grade is the same each year:…
- 815 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
If a student completely failed a grade, there next year will be miserable. The concepts are just going to expand on the topics that they learned about the last year. If the student doesn’t understand the basics, how are they going to have success learning about it in a harder level? They will struggle even more than they did the last, and the trend would…
- 487 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Normalization Procedure for Class XII Board Marks In view of large scale variations in the examination system in country, the JEE Interface Group (JIG) decided that for this year (2013), 50% of Boards marks be normalized by equating percentile amongst different boards/examining bodies and anchoring them to All India JEE-Main percentiles, and 50% be normalized by equating each Board’s/examining Body’s percentile with JEE(Main) percentile marks of respective Boards /examining bodies. Accordingly, the detailed procedure for normalization of Board marks will be as follows:i. ii. Note down the aggregate marks (A0) obtained by each student in JEE- Main. Compute the percentile (P) of each student on the basis of aggregate marks in his/her own board (B0) computed from the list of five subjects specified (each marked out of 100). The percentile is to be computed among all students of the board whose subject combinations meet the eligibility criteria of JEE-Main. Determine the JEE- Main aggregate marks corresponding to percentile (P) at the All- India level. Regard this as B1. Also, determine the JEE- Main aggregate marks corresponding to percentile (P) among the set of aggregate scores obtained in the JEE- Main by the students of that board. Regard this as B2. The normalized board score of the candidate will be computed as: Bfinal = 0.5 * (B1 + B2) For the purpose of admission to CFTIs where it has been decided to use the JEE Mains performance and the Normalized Board performance in the 60:40 ratio, the composite score for drawing the merit list will be computed as: C = 0.6 * AO + 0.4 * Bfinal, Five subjects to be used for normalization:1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Physics Mathematics Any one of the subjects Chemistry, Biology, Biotechnology and Computer Science One language Any subject other than the above four subjects.…
- 334 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
students are learning material just to reach a certain score, they are not being taught based on…
- 785 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Lower entry score enlarges the difficulty to achieve satisfied performance; poor progressive assessments cause detrimental effect on the final exam; and large scale of class decreases participation of students. Accordingly, it is essential to rise entry score and set up pre-requisite subjects for particular courses, and embed Peer Assisted Study Sessions across the whole semester. Besides, a better establish progressive assessment system can have profound influence.…
- 1616 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
In some case this causes teachers to make less of an effort with students and so they are put into the lower banded groups. This means that students are only able to get the lower grades in their exams because the maximum they can achieve is a C or in the past a D. This has a massive effect on the data collected in this field. A report by the department for schools and education stated that a third of the most capable…
- 1250 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Percentiles are sometimes called percentile ranks. It’s the most common interpretive schemes used to explain standardized achievement tests. It represents how a student’s scores on the test is compared to scores of other students in a norm group. Norm group is individuals who have already taken the test. Percentile scores range from 1 to 99. So, a percentile is used to as a comparison score. It does not show exactly how items the student answered correctly it only shows if the student did good or bad comparing with other students. For example, suppose 50 students took an exam of 25 questions if one of them answered 20 questions correctly, then he got 80 percent of the items correct. But because we do not know what the other students did we cannot identify his…
- 454 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Percentiles are a way of describing the position of a particular score within a set of scores As per the question, I was looking for one simple sentence to explain the meaning of the statement…
- 2036 Words
- 9 Pages
Good Essays -
An official Manual of Choice Based Credit Systems (CBCS) and Grading is being published for the first time for the use of administrators, teachers, administrative staff and learners to make them acquainted with the Choice Based Credit and Grading system to be implemented at the University of Mumbai with effect from the Academic Year 2012‐13. The following members have contributed for writing of the content of this manual and its preparation.…
- 23378 Words
- 94 Pages
Powerful Essays -
CCE system intends to round development a student in scholastic as well as co-scholastic areas. You might be a topper and achieve 99 marks by cramming but they are useless if you haven’t learnt anything.…
- 379 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Some persons are of opinion that examination is not the sure test of the ability of a candidate. The present examination system is based on cramming and to pass the examination has become more a matter of chance than that of ability. Again, the present system of examination promotes other evils such as copying and even corruption.…
- 496 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
All candidates must receive the same treatment. Examiners must mark the first candidate in exactly the same way as they mark the last. Mark schemes should be applied positively. Candidates must be rewarded for what they have shown they can do rather than penalised for omissions. Examiners should mark according to the mark scheme not according to their perception of where the grade boundaries may lie. There is no ceiling on achievement. All marks on the mark scheme should be used appropriately. All the marks on the mark scheme are designed to be awarded.…
- 2117 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays