Preview

Compare and Contrast: "All the Years of Her Life" and "The Gentlemen of Rio en Medio"

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
425 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare and Contrast: "All the Years of Her Life" and "The Gentlemen of Rio en Medio"
The thing about synonyms is that even though they though they might seem like they are the same thing, if put in a different context they can mean something completely different. It's interesting how two characters with very similar traits, goals and morals can be so different when placed in different stories, like when you switch a word for its supposed "synonym".

Don Anselmo and Mrs. Higgins are two very similar people. Both are traditional, respected, a little on the old-fashioned side and good at being seen as proud and confident. But it's their greatest linking factor, their love for their families and communities, which divides them.

Don Anselmo is a proud, traditional and very well respected man who has kept up the tradition of planting a tree for every child in the village to the point where a "gnarled but beautiful" orchard had become a part of his property. And when he is confronted with the request to ask the children to refrain from playing in the orchard, he explains that it is not his choice nor his place, as "the trees do not belong to him". To him, nothing is more important than respecting the honor of his family. And to him, every child in that village whether they're related to him or not, is his family.

On the other hand, Mrs. Higgins has too close of an association with her son to the point where she sees his problems as hers. She has a proud and confident facade that hides a spirit broken by reasons that are out of her control. She appears to blame herself for her son's inability to keep a steady job and lead a good life. Like Don Anselmo she closely identifies herself with her family that in her case seems to have an ill effect on her lifestyle. "You've disgraced me again and again,” she told Albert as they left the pharmacy. She feels as if her son's shenanigans are her fault and this causes her spirit to crumble. This isn't the first time that her family has failed her, which in her eyes translates into failing as a mother.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    In the second example, the influence of Lucy’s mother can be seen in how Lucy has also turned to alcohol to cope with her own depression. Lucy’s mother often found it hard to cope with life, especially when the children were younger. She allowed the eldest child Ted, to take on the responsibility of looking after the children when she felt too…

    • 1817 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    ETHICAL DILEMMAS: THE ALLEN FAMILY The Allen Family    The father and husband is Clifford Allen Pamela, the wife and mother, was currently diagnosed with cancer in the colon. Gary, their son, was diagnosed with Down Syndrome and is currently 24 years of age.…

    • 418 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The two women in the story are Mrs Johnston and Mrs Lyons. Mrs Johnston is a lower class single mother living in a council house in the centre of Liverpool. Her husband has left her, while she is pregnant, for a younger woman after she had given birth to 7 children. Willy Russell portrays her as a superstitious and lonely woman. ‘Oh God. Never put new shoes on a table Mrs Lyons.’ At the beginning of the play, I feel sorry for Mrs Johnston because she has lots of children and loves them all equally but she simply cannot support them financially as a cleaner. How she has let herself get into this position is extremely sad but is also a social comment by Willy Russell on society today. Russell sets Mrs Johnston up as the extreme example of the benefit living, single parent family who live with and by the hand of the social. ‘The welfare’s already been onto me. They say I’m incapable of controlling the kids I got.’ I do feel a bit angry at Mrs Johnston when she gave Eddie away to Mrs Lyons but when I see how Mrs Lyons manipulated her and made her think that she was doing the right thing, I feel sorry for her. The picture is quite complicated; Russell is testing the moral ethics of the audience.…

    • 789 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    She is a working mother, which is unthinkable during this era, considering that she is from old money. She has gone without fillings in her teeth, so that he could have straight teeth, and she has sent him to college; something that a single mother generally can not do, which is a huge success on her part. Although life has taken some negative turns, such as the death of her husband, she thinks of herself as a winner because she has been able to single-handedly provide a promising future for her child. It is evident that Julian is aware of his mother’s sacrifices when it is addressed that he “... did not like to consider all she did for him” (O’Connor, 1965, p, 909). Rather than being appreciative, he attempts to find flaws in her decisions, and scrutinizes her every action. He claims that she made “... a mess of things” (O’Connor, 1965, p. 913), and spends most of his time discriminating her life, although he claims that it would be easier to find faults within her if she had been a violent alcoholic. This unthankful characteristic is a widespread phenomenon in the new generation. Many young adults overlook the great sacrifices and obstacles that their elders have overcome in order to provide a better life for them. Rather than being acknowledged, the majority of these selfless acts go unnoticed everyday. This is tragic, because compassion should not become an endangered…

    • 1603 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Lena Younger, Walter and Beneatha’s mother was a widow who devoted her life to her children after her husband died. When she retired she was waiting for her husband’s insurance money to arrive. With the ten thousand dollars in her hand, Lena decided to buy a 3500 dollar house at Clybourne Park and she was also going to put some money in the bank for Beneatha so she could go to medical school. Those were her dreams, they were so simple and ordinary and also beautiful. She expected everyone to be delighted and surprised of the things she had done with the check and indeed they were, except for Walter.…

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    But when she is unable to live up to those expectations, her world quickly becomes darker. Her mother sharply disapproves of her and favors her own more successful, Dotty. This disapproval leads to impulsive behavior, a precursor to the erratic breakdown she has at the end of chapter seven. Mary at one point describes her grandmother passive-aggressively praising Dotty, and Charlie’s…

    • 1412 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The opposite to Mrs Johnstone is Mrs Lyons; childless, wealthy and under the impression that money can solve any problem, Mrs Lyons also shows how warm and caring Mrs Johnstone is as a mother. Concerned more with her reputation than Eddie or his real mother, Mrs Lyons attempts to ensure that the two are kept as far away from each other as possible. Nevertheless, the “cruel” Mrs Johnstone does not accept Mrs Lyons’ bribe (“…the mother so cruel, there’s a stone in place of her heart…”) and continues to love Eddie. Mrs Johnstone is a typical tragic heroine, whose actions accidently result in a disastrous event and the punishment she receives from that act is quite unfair. More or less, she is a good mother, a woman who makes the best of things and is proud of the fact she is getting by. It was circumstance that caused her to make a pact with Mrs Lyons, a pact that would ultimately result in the deaths of her twin boys.…

    • 522 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The family has gone through hard times, but the biggest fight happens when Walter is planning on accepting money from The Man. Mama is disappointed, but she loves him still. Beneatha is so angry she says “There is nothing left to love.” Mama rebukes her for her comment, and this scene displays the fierce love Mama has for her family. Even though they do not agree with Walter’s plan to give in, the whole family suspects and hopes he will come to his senses and make the right decision. They have faith in him, even though to this point he has not made the best choices. Internally, the choice was difficult, but especially because his son is present, Walter makes the right choice and preserves the dignity of his family. Throughout the play, the family loved and supported Walter, even when he made very bad…

    • 532 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For example Geraldine uses Joe as an outlet for her anger. She sometimes yells or comes off as defensive toward Joe. Geraldine once said to joe “now you listen to me, Joe. You will not badger me or harass me. You will leave me to think the way I want to think, here” (90). She tries to display dominance over what she considers hers and therefore gives herself a sense of control and security. Most of their interactions is dictated by Geraldine and any form of contact requires her permission. For instance when Joe tries to get her to look at the garden she refuses to look. She instead “turned over, away from me” (87). Anything that Joe suggest is shot down and every action she takes is of her own choice. Because of this new attitude, Geraldine and Joe grow further apart. Even if Geraldine does end up getting confidence and forgiving herself, I feel that Joe will have lost all hope and trust in her. Either way, this mother-son relationship is doomed to end badly.…

    • 294 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Bailey the grandmother’s son I would say is a “flat character. In the story his attitude never changes. He’s very quiet and gets pushed around by his mother. I would say that he gets taken advantage of because of this very reason. June Star, Bailey’s daughter and the granddaughter, isn’t very polite in the story. She’s very rude, mean spirited, and seems to be ill willed towards other people. Instead of her being sympathetic when the family got into an accident, she was disappointed that no one in the family was killed. John Wesley, Bailey’s dad and the grandson, is portrayed as a happy go lucky 8 year old boy. When the grandmother mentions going to see the house that she remembers, John seems very excited to be able to explore the secret panel. The Grandmother is characterized as rude and rather pushy with her views. Her son, Bailey, seems annoyed with the way that his mother acts. The reader’s perception of the Grandmother isn’t that great. She shows that she is a racist with her comment that she makes when she sees a little black kid. Her pushiness is what caused the family to get in the situation that they were in in the first place. The Grandmother shows no sympathy for other people. She is the worse out of the whole family.…

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Gilbert Grape Family

    • 682 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Gilbert and family grew up with two parents but it was not until his father had took his own life in with things change causing the mother to go into depression which had lead to her to become a shell of her former self. After the lost of Gilbert father his ,mother refused to move causing her to gain tremendous weight to the point in which she was unable to do the smallest task without some form of assistance. In the eyes fo gilbert as well as the other children she is sceen a bordern since each child has to take on the repsonace abiiltes to insure she as well as aritey the metally inable child functioning. It is later understood that she know that she was a fault in many of the problem in the house but it was not until her passing in which her rolls was truly understood.…

    • 682 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Connie is so use to the ridicule and criticism, that her natural defense mechanism allows her to ignore the hurtful comments. However, the negative comments sometimes become so overwhelming, that Connie wishes for the demise of her mother and herself. “Connie’s mother kept picking at her until Connie wished her mother was dead and she herself was dead and it was all over.” (2/16) This relationship is clearly unhealthy with the woman that should be her first role model, her mother. It is believed that a daughter’s “first love” is her father, and that every child should have a strong male role model in their life. Contrary to belief, Connie’s father has limited to no influence on her or the household. He is not involved with them and has no interest to be. The story states…

    • 1383 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Metaphor

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Besides their similarities, Miss Hancock and Charlottes mother are so different that they contrast each other. Miss Hancock is unmarried woman who encourages Charlotte to be expressive. On the other hand, Charlotte’s Mother doesn’t support or care much about Charlotte’s enthusiasm for the subject. As a child, playing with toys wasn’t allowed because it made a mess “A toy ceased to be a toy once it left the toy cupboard” (p 65). Miss Hancock loves teaching children, so if she were Charlotte’s mother, she would tell her to make as much of a mess as she wants. Miss Hancock and Charlotte’s mother are an example of character foil.…

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hard to Swallow

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Maureen Dunbar just wanted to help. If the father acted the "bad" one in the play, she tried to be the "good" one. She wanted to be the opposite from John Dunbar; she was soft with Catherine, maybe too soft. She aloud her kind of things that are dangerous to aloud to her, like eating alone. In the end she Putted Catherine in a special hospital.…

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    My Son The Man

    • 1076 Words
    • 5 Pages

    She goes on to say at the end of the poem, "he looks at me / the way Houdini studied a box / to learn the way out"(14-16). She is scared that her unwillingness to embrace her son as maturity has made a movement in their relationship; she is worried about the possibility that that he now holds the high ground where there was none already. If the son is effectively attempting to escape her she is no more the loving mother that dealt with him, possibly by herself, however only a part in his ploy. Olds convinced that her son developing into a man means that he will no longer want to spend time with her and that he will immediately want to run away from her as if he is an escape artist. Her son finally felt like he just won the game, “then smiled and let himself be manacled.” (16). When he “smiled”, he knew that he had found the way to freedom. She too knows there is nothing she can do to suppress him anymore. I can relate to this because my parents feel that once we escape the challenge that they set up for us, we are no longer want to have to rely on them and have their love because of the freedom we found.…

    • 1076 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays