Preview

Compare And Contrast Romeo And Juliet

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
621 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare And Contrast Romeo And Juliet
I believe that the first one we watched, the Franco Zeffirelli version, was a better retelling of the play. Even though things like the death of Paris and the death of Lady Montague were taken out of it, they were also taken out of the more modern one, so that has nothing to do with the decision about which is better. The first one did a much better job of immersing you in the story and making you feel like you were in the exact time period that it would have taken place in. The older version also did a better job staying true to what Shakespeare originally was presenting in the play. The second takes much more liberty in what the characters do and how they do it. The more modern version changed many of the things from the original play. Romeo, at one point, took a mind altering substance that …show more content…
The families, as told in the book, were wealthy, but in the Baz Luhrmann version, it seemed as though they were somewhat rich, but they still lived in a poor and run down area. In the first one, it stays much more true to the time period, the clothing, the way that things were done. The setting and outfits made you feel like you were at the first time that Romeo and Juliet was being performed. The only way to make a movie enjoyable, realistic, and interesting is to make the watcher feel as if they are a bystander in the scenes. Even though the more contemporary movie was more relatable, the first was so much more similar to the actual Romeo and Juliet. Since we read the book beforehand, we knew how everything was supposed to be done and what the story was supposed to be like. But out of all of the differences, I believe that the setting was what really makes me believe that the first one was a better representation. It was very similar to what it looked like in the actual day of

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Franco Zeffirelli and Baz Luhrmann reenactments of William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet are wonderful and was and still is very famous for its use of words and the plot of the play itself. All though there are many differences between these two films there are many similarities to the reenactments. The characters from the films had many things in common the character were very funny with their acting and put emotions into their part. The plot line between the two films was very different but had many similarities, the plot was the same by the Montague and Capulet running into each other and then starting an argument leading to a conflict many moments later. The family feud is a strong and very hostile emotion between these two…

    • 246 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Franco Zeffirelli and Baz Luhrmann have both directed a film version of Romeo and Juliet very well, but a movie can not capture everything from the book. So, which movie portrayed the book better? There are aspects of both movies that portray the book better. For example, there could one movie could show the character's personality better than the other one or one movie can show the city of Verona better than the other movie did. Small details of a scene could make a scene in one movie a lot better than on the other. Even the smallest of things like the way the characters are dressed could impact the entire scene. In some scenes, the Baz Luhrmann movie portrayed the book better because of the small details…

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The difference between the play and the movie is the Person Vs. Society because it’s only involving The capulets, the Montagues and the people around them. When Juliet saw Romeo Dead, she commited suicide.She had not thought of what could possibly could go wrong. Instead ,this problem had caused a sentimental shock to society and both families to be heartbroken. But had stopped the feuding.…

    • 684 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The original play by Shakespeare and Zeffirelli and Luhrmann’s interpretation of the play are all different versions of the classical tragic story of Romeo and Juliet. When reading the play or seeing Zeffirelli and Luhrmann’s film we can observe various differences between them. Juliet, being one of the dominating characters of this story can be seen to be recontextualised differently through her personality, looks and role in society.…

    • 896 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The text, the Zeffrelli version, and the Luhrmann version are all different forms of Romeo and Juliet. They are all different by acting and context, but they are all about the same thing. They are both about the same story, Romeo and Juliet. The text has vivid description, the Zeffrelli and Luhrmann version has vivid view and detail but the Zeffrelli version is older and the Luhrmann version is modern. They all tell the same story, and share the same point, but they tell it a different way, and in a different timeline.…

    • 736 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The original play happens around 1500s in Italy. It was a time when people still fought with swords and lived in old decorated buildings. For instance, said, “What I mean is, if they make us angry we’ll pull out our swords” by Sampson (Act I , Scene I).Thus people living that era still used ancient weapons. The movie, in contrast, is set in 1900s in America Florida when people using guns and driving cars. Skyscrapers are full of the city with huge screens rolling the news and advertisements again and again seen from the movie. There is an intense fight with guns and grenades that takes place at a gas station between Capulets and Montagues at the beginning of the movie. It even triggers an explosion, something that could never happen in the original play. Although the plots do not change fundamentally, as both the movie and the play have a fight at the beginning, the movie is not only more modern, but also more exciting and more appeals to contemporary audience.…

    • 864 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    First, I will discuss some of the plot changes that were implemented to adapt to a modern day movie's visual capabilities. If we were to read just the play, the only pictures we would see would have to be imagined. Since we now have the ability to see a movie, the director had to change some of the story to help us visualize some of the scenes. One such example is when, in the play, Tybalt recognizes Romeo's voice at the Capulet masked ball. When Tybalt hears him, he becomes enraged. In the film this is different, Romeo takes off his mask at the fountain, and forgets it there. As Romeo is following Juliet, Tybalt sees him; however, the results are the same. Tybalt becomes angered, and vows to get revenge on Romeo. Another example of a change in plot is when Romeo visits the apothecary. Romeo, in the movie, sees the apothecary in Verona, where as Romeo sees him in Mantua, in the play. Finally when Romeo and Juliet kill themselves, the Friar does not see them first, and the Prince does not say that Mercutio and Paris were his kinsmen.…

    • 428 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Romeo & Juliet Movie and Play The following essay will explain some similarities and differences between the 1968 movie rendition of "Romeo & Juliet"� and the play written by William Shakespeare. Some similarities are the clothing, setting, and ending. Some differences are the characters, and scenes.…

    • 231 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    As for the mood, there a few differences between the two versions of the tragedy. In the dialogue of marriage in the play, Romeo and Juliet are serious and sedate. In Zeffirelli’s version of the play, the marriage scene makes Romeo and Juliet to look almost like fools of young love because they are constantly kissing and giggling. In a marriage, the bride and groom are to be calm and patient because it is an important step in their lives, and the play shows this kind of character. The movie does not portray this realistic kind of character. During the “funeral” ceremony for Juliet, the Friar Lawrence made a giggle because he already knew about the secret plan. This part destroyed the sad and mischievous mood of the scene. Nevertheless, I believe the play and Zeffirelli’s movie did a great job in explaining the tragedy, but the movie could have been a lot more enticing if it weren’t for those minor slip-ups. The play also could have used some help because it felt like the characters lacked some expression unlike the movie, but I cannot criticize which one was better because the play is the way it is to be. One thing that the movie and the play collaborated together, were the props and scenes.…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the movie when Romeo heads to the monument he already had the poison. In the play he goes to the Apothecary and buys the poison. Another thing that is different is the letter. In the movie Friar John ha the letter and has his back turned when they ride past him. In the play John is in the house where a sickness is when Romeo and Balthasar ride past him. A third thing that is different is in the play Paris goes to the monument a little before Romeo. In the movie, it is only Romeo that went to the monument. The fourth thing is related to the third difference. In the play, after Paris sees Romeo they fight. When they are fighting Romeo kill Paris. Romeo then says his goodbyes to Juliet. In conclusion, Act V in the play is way different then the Act V in the…

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A humongous difference between the play and movie is that Romeo is being chased by the police as he is making his way to Juliet’s resting place. In the play this never even happened he just got on a horse and went to the place. Lurman had to include put a chase in there, but that’s just one weird thing in this scene the other one is that Romeo takes a hostage because he gets surrounded by the police. This part was probably not expected by a lot people.…

    • 473 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The well written piece called Romeo and Juliet enunciates the story of two lovers who were from two enemy families, that took each others life in love. Both the 1968 and the 1996 movies of the story have their own way of telling it, each straying a little from the original play. Each version takes and adds elements to Shakespeare's classic story. The two movies have many differences, but they are also very similar in the way they portray the well known story. The 1996 version is a modern way of expressing the masterpiece of Shakespeare. However, the 1968 version of Romeo and Juliet sticks more to the time period the story was written. The two well performed versions of the classic Romeo and Juliet tell the same original story, but in a unique and interesting way.…

    • 588 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are many reasons people like this version of the play and one is the actors. The actors chosen for the roles of the characters represented the characters very well. For example the actor who played Romeo looked the correct age and he pulled the depressed teenager look off which is difficult for most adult actors. Also the actor who played Tybalt was another great choice for the character because the actor is very enthusiastic and dramatic when he talks and is doing something which is the feeling given off about Tybalt when reading the play.…

    • 443 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet is a cherished piece of literature that has been remade into movies many times throughout history. The 1968 version and the controversial 1996 version give different perspectives of Shakespeare's famous play. While the 1968 classical version of Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet should be appreciated, the modern version portrays the complexity of love in a fast-paced society by using narrative and stylistic elements combined with energetic editing in an advanced, creative way.…

    • 1907 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Romeo and Juliet is known perhaps as the best love story in history, and has been performed various times, in different adaptations. In Act 1, Scene V we finally get to see the two young lovers; Romeo and Juliet meet for the very first time at the Capulets party. But what are the pros and cons of the written script and the 1968 movie adaptation of Romeo and Juliet? One of the major downfalls in the printed version of Romeo and Juliet is that it can be hard to get a good feeling of what the characters are supposed to be doing or feeling (laughing, dancing, etc.) due to the language not being modern and the lack of a visual projection.…

    • 652 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays