Preview

Compare And Contrast Zinn And Foner

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
414 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare And Contrast Zinn And Foner
There was a major difference in the interpretations of Howard Zinn and Eric Foner about the 1900’s. For starters, Both Howard Zinn and Eric Foner are American Historians who have written extensively on forgotten aspects of American History. Their works are often thought of as controversial for their views. When it comes to responding to historical moments Foner is somewhat more forgiving, while he called Zinn in his epitaph “the kind of historian 'that judges and condemns”.
For example, In Zinn's view, Columbus's attitude as the initial point of entry into the Americas led directly to years of slavery, rape, murder, and pillage, as well as the gold fever that struck subsequent expeditions. He points out the documentation of atrocity by Bartolome de las Casas, and how this part of history is often ignored in favor of the Progressive and Industrial archetype. Then in Foner’s point of view Columbus was a great discoverer, the historical development set in motion or symbolized by Columbus's encounter with the New World produced both great good and great evil for different peoples in different parts of the world. Foner's view is more lenient, but still critical, he said “progress sometimes cannot be made without sacrifice, but we must remember and learn from the past instead of ignoring it”. I feel like they are
…show more content…
He was a passionate critic of the national security system and the militarization of American life. Foner has many different works on civil war but he said "It is wrong to think that, during the Civil War, Lincoln embraced a single 'plan' of Reconstruction," he wrote. "Lincoln had always been willing to work closely with all factions of his party, including the Radicals on numerous occasions. The voices of these to intelligent Historians are similar but they still have different train of thoughts towards Remembering and learning from

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Howard Zinn A Peoples History of the United States Chapter 1: Columbus, the Indians and Human Progress Can historians avoid emphasis on some facts and not others? Historians are selective, they simplify and they emphasize what they believe is important and gloss over other things they view as less important. “This distortion is ideological; it is released into a world of contending interests, where any chosen emphasis supports (whether the historian means to or not) some kind of interest, whether economic or political or racial or national or sexual.” p.8 This emphasis assumes that everyone has the same goals and viewpoints.…

    • 920 Words
    • 31 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lincoln's Plan Dbq

    • 306 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Lincoln’s plan was issued in 1863, with the purpose of reconstructing the Union. This plan offered reconstruction of property and pardon to anyone who had anything to do with the rebellion; but this excluded military leaders and Confederate officials. This plan also offered the formation of a new state government, it only needed 10% of voters to pledge loyalty to the United States. Also, last but not least, it passed a law allowing emancipation from slavery. However, this plan was never put in effect thanks to Lincoln’s…

    • 306 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    While Paul Johnson focuses on the accomplishments of the colonists, Howard Zinn’s work is more focused on the atrocities the colonists committed. Howard Zinn starts out his novel with the innocent Arawaks greeting Columbus with a bountiful amount of gifts to which Columbus responds selfishly by demanding they show him where the gold is located. After that, things rapidly decline. Zinn proceeds to highlight the enslavement and harsh treatment of the natives by Columbus and the ruthless genocide of the Indians.…

    • 257 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    On the day that the United States of America declared to become independent, people of the United States began to have a completely different life which started from the new government structure that been established.…

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Annie Haunton Dr. Brandon – G Block 305 American Studies 4 September 2015 History as One’s Interpretation In the opening chapter of A People’s History of the United States, the author, Howard Zinn, admits that he abandons neutrality and presents bias in order to tell the history of the United States from the victim’s perspective. Howard Zinn is a well-known historian and author, who has authored dozens of historical books and articles including You Can’t Be Neutral on a Moving Train and A People’s History of the United States, written three plays, and spoken at many political and social rallies. When his most famous book, A People’s History, was first published in 1980, Zinn’s statements caused an uproar within the scholastic community,…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    At times, history appears to be just like a deliberately curated set of truths, figures, and events that when taken together advance a particular philosophy or perspective. Along these lines, Americans concentrate only on individuals, places, and events that maintain the thought of American exceptionalism. Wars and the success of men dominate the lives of ladies, and Europeans are given priority. The quote by W.E.B. DuBois underscores the intrinsic falseness in imminent history, given that in some capacity there will dependably be editorializing. Howard Zinn likewise reassembles American history in a way that subverts the worldview that had been taught identified with the matchless quality of private enterprise and the white-washing of key defining moments. A People's History of the United…

    • 626 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Gordon interpret the events of the 1800’s entirely different. Both present strong arguments using facts; However, Zinn’s use of statistics makes his argument slightly stronger. To the contrary, both manipulate the facts to support their agendas, which imposes a weakness in their writing styles. A well-rounded argument offers both perspectives on one topic so that the reader can make his or her own inferences. Zinn’s argument screams socialism; while he bashes big business for the sake of the people, he barely refers to the cruel endeavors of the workers. Zinn could have made his argument stronger by referring less to government-corporate relationships and more to worker-corporate relationships. He, also, refuses to see any good in the robber barons’ philanthropy. Similarly, Gordon refuses to acknowledge the effect of big business on the workers in its entirety. However, he does show the opposition’s perspective in his article when he refers to the corporate-competition relationship. With that being said, one can infer that not one author is correct in his opinion of the big businessmen; big business was cruel and kind through their philanthropist…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The book also discussed Lincoln’s position regarding the civil war in that he was at first conservative about the efforts of war against slavery but then shifted to a radical position. Lincoln’s change of position was caused by the also changing circumstances around the war. Some states seceded from the Union to form the Confederate that was proslavery, which made Lincoln think…

    • 523 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Howard Zinn covers early Native American civilization in North America and the Bahamas, the genocide and slavery committed by the crew of Christopher Columbus, and the violent colonization by early settlers. While Paul Johnson stated that “the creation of the United States of America is the greatest of all human adventures”. Their points of views are completely 2 different stories.…

    • 526 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Zinn's Purpose Analysis

    • 431 Words
    • 2 Pages

    On page 7, Zinn stated “ When we read the history books given to children in United States, it all starts with heroic adventure-there is no bloodshed-and Columbus is a celebration.” This quote shows how the winners writes history. History is suppose to be where we can learn from our past and progress as an society, but throughout history, there are always cases that winners writes history and they changed or ignored the facts that are important for our society progress as a whole.…

    • 431 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Late Howard Zinn is a very respectable historian. He is very bold and is willing to state things that cause quite a bit of controversy. Throughout one’s youth we go on learning history in anecdotes and learning important facts such as dates and memorization of legal documents; however Zinn takes a very crucial look at small events and also takes note of who the founding fathers were and what they really wanted.…

    • 597 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Zinn Essay

    • 1734 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In the article How Democratic Is America?, Howard Zinn, an idealist and liberal, spars against Sidney Hook, a pragmatic conservative about the current system of democracy set up in the United States. From the first concept of standards for America’s democracy, Zinn and Hook hold conflicting viewpoints. While Zinn believes that we should “measure our democracy against an ideal (if admittedly unachievable) standard”, Hook believes that “the only sensible procedure in determining the absence or presence of equality from a democratic perspective is comparative). Even though I agree with Zinn’s views on the participation in decisions, access to education and the lacking spirit of cooperation in America, Hook is correct in stating that for one to ignore improvements made from the past is unreasonable.…

    • 1734 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Abraham Lincoln By: Ty Parrish Part I The president that I chose was Abraham Lincoln. He was born in Hodgenville, Kentucky.…

    • 820 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The civil war is considered by many the most important war that our country has endured. During the 5 year Civil War, not only did 620,000 men die, but our nation was left in ruins. It was necessary that our country be rebuilt from bottom up. Abraham Lincoln, said to be the brightest president of his time, had plans and ideas for reconstruction. Unfortunately, these plans were failed to be put in place due to the fact of his assassination on April 14, 1865. Throughout some of the most politically tough years our nation has experienced (1865-1877) lousy presidents were elected, plans and bills failed and succeeded, and struggles with civil rights were prominent everywhere. The United State’s hopeful plans for reconstructing and…

    • 1161 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lincoln was a strong, confident president who remained steadfast in his principles. At a time of crisis he led the nation into an unpopular civil war. He could have gone the easy route, and ignored the Confederate States of America, ergo avoiding conflict. However, he felt that the union was something exceptional, and was worth preserving. Lincoln was less concerned about his own personal life and what people thought of him. He remained strong and he fought for our country and his principles. President Lincoln gave his life and sacrificed the lives of his fellow American so the union would be preserved.…

    • 423 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays