Preview

Compare the Ways in Which Expected Roles Were Determined by Gender in ‘Journeys End’ and ‘the Accrington Pals’. to What Extent Would You Agree That ‘Accrington Pals’ Presents a More Credible Image Than ‘Journeys End’.  

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1757 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare the Ways in Which Expected Roles Were Determined by Gender in ‘Journeys End’ and ‘the Accrington Pals’. to What Extent Would You Agree That ‘Accrington Pals’ Presents a More Credible Image Than ‘Journeys End’.  
Compare the ways in which expected roles were determined by gender in ‘Journeys End’ and ‘The Accrington Pals’. To what extent would you agree that ‘Accrington Pals’ presents a more credible image than ‘Journeys End’. A large proportion of Great War literature suggests that men were socially seen as the superior gender but women were given opportunities to prove themselves in a male-dominated society as a by-product of war. This essay will compare the issues of gender identity and roles at the front line in R.C Sheriffs ‘Journeys End’ and the impact war had on women who stayed home in Accrington, seen in Peter Whelan’s ‘The Accrington Pals’ during 1914 and 1918.

‘Journeys End’ appears to be a more credible drama because of Sheriffs first-hand experience of the war, where as ‘The Accrington Pals’ depicts the more emotional side of war. R.C Sheriff uses Stanhope as an example of how war affected young, intelligent and inexperienced men and showing the reality of war. Stanhope is the stereotypical male of WW1. He is the image of authority, power and patriotism. He is also thought incredibly highly of from the lower ranks. ‘He’s a long way the best company commander we’ve got’. It seems as though men were in the war for a long time but the reality being that the death rate of British officers was higher than that of the lower ranks with the average life expectancy of an officer being fourteen days. The word ‘long’ therefore creates irony within the drama. From the beginning of the drama, we are enlightened of Stanhope’s experience and dedication to his duty, however, Stanhope could be seen as a contradictory figure. His heavy drinking and reliance on alcohol may be a sign of weakness, which could also present Sheriffs use of realism in the drama. Stanhope is far from reluctant to admit he has a drinking problem. ‘Without being doped with whisky- I’d go mad with fright.’ Sherriff’s own experience may have been reflected on in this dialogue as men at

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In Act One of Sheriff’s ‘Journey’s End’ we see Captain Stanhope presented as a highly respected individual by all members of the rank, who has been affected immensely psychologically by the war.…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Second World War greatly impacted the lives and everyday roles of Australian women from 1939 onwards. Women’s roles changed greatly and this had an impact on how society saw women in the workforce. During the war, women were encouraged to get a job as this was considered joining in on the war effort. Women were able to fill positions they had not been allowed to apply for, as they were previously thought to be male jobs. During the war, there was a major increase the amount of women in the workforce and armed forces. World War Two marked a significant change in the way women were seen in the workforce and completely changed the social and gender structure of the labour force.…

    • 262 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ww1 Unit 1 Research Paper

    • 1048 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Source 6, an essay by B. Harrison written in 1993, illustrates the idea of many people that it helped to back up the Anti’s physical strength idea; “the idea that men and women had separate roles because women are, on average, physically weaker than men”. To me this is irrelevant; this idea had been popular in previous years when opponents of suffrage had claimed that women were not worthy of the vote as they could not fight for their country. Yet how on earth can this be argued when the women did so much to ensure the victory of the war? It is evident that even though women were not on the frontlines, without their efforts from home the war could simply have not been won! In this sense they did fight for their country as they put themselves out further than they usually would have to, to protect King and country and to defend what they fought was right. Source 6 conflicts this by arguing that women did not go through “the horrors of the frontline” and that most women stayed at home whilst the men went to war. Whilst this is true, I still do not think that it omits their substantial efforts at home, and this is backed up by my previous point that physical strength was no longer enough to keep the women from having the vote. Somebody had to stay at home and run the country- old politicians were not blamed for staying at home and working in an administration role because they could not fight so why should women be? The final point of Source 6 is that the First World War “pushed all peace time agenda down the line”. Whilst this is arguably valid, once the war was won these issues would inevitably arise once again, and in my opinion it helped to bring them even closer to the forefront, as it allowed women to be seen in a different light, and also helped the suffragettes get out of what was turning into somewhat of a reoccurring rut. I think that the…

    • 1048 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Great War had significant and enduring influence on the lives of all British women. The huge scale of the war resulted in the enormous participation of almost six million men and subsequently an extensive demand for female labour in the manufacturing and services industries. The war resulted in massive social upheaval particularly on the lives women who attained greater freedom despite tighter Government controls. Women's lives were upturned as they were thrust into the labour, social and economic spotlight, something never previously seen in British history. In particular the allies' defeat of Germany relied heavily on the input of women. Women were used extensively in Propaganda schemes run by the Government as a means to encourage men to join the army. Although the end of the war saw most women return to their traditional roles, the contribution of the female population on such an enormous scale would never be forgotten, women had proven their responsibility and capability to function within the 'male' workforce. These trends saw the beginning of the feminist revolutionary movement that sought to bring about justice and equality for all women.…

    • 1337 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the Victorian era, men were more socially accepted because of their gender. They had more social power because society gave more trust, responsibility, and rank to men. The choices women made were based on the men they lived around. Males were the dependents of the woman’s future, whether it was as family, or workers. Yet this was the perspective of everyone, it was not always fair, nor true.…

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Therefore, these artefacts develop beyond Bean's Anzac Legend and prove to us that women endure similar distressing impacts as men do from wars. Furthermore, the Australian army nurses experiences broaden our understanding of Australian Great War experiences by acknowledging that Australian army nurses endured challenging conditions, sex discrimination and permanent tormenting effects that largely impacted on their lives (Moreland Remembers World War 1,…

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Document A shows a woman as a woodcut worker. Before the war, women were stuck in the house, having no input in how their life was run; during the war, they were running society and maintaining the economy. Women also began to libel for their freedom after the war; “What then must my situation be, when my sex, my youth and inexperience all conspire to make me tremble at the task which I have undertaken? But the friendly encouragement, which I behold in almost every countenance, enables me to overcome difficulties, that would otherwise be insurmountable.” (Document J). Furthermore, Molly Wallace is saying that when the men where away, the women were able to run society, so they should be included…

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this, Trotter contrasts completely with the main character, Stanhope. Stanhope is a young man who is erratic and unpredictable. He entered the war wanting to be a hero, and ends up carrying the burden of this image of heroism. Stanhope feels, ‘– as long as the hero’s a hero.’ This shows him trying to be masculine and know it has become a burden.…

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    However, the work done by women during the First World War is believed to be what caught the most attention and proved that they were just as reliable as men. Women became actively involved in a wide variety of day-to-day jobs which only men had worked before. They took over jobs such as nursing, munitions, industry, fire-fighting, drivers, and farming in the Women’s Land Army. Many people within the country were impressed and took on more positive attitudes towards those who worked - women were seen to be more trustworthy and mature, politicians saw them in a new light and had the view that they should be “rewarded” due to “proving their worth” to the nation. Historian Martin Pugh said “Male prejudice against women melted in the face of revelations about their capabilities during wartime and their contribution to the war effort”. These acts of help to the country proved that there was more to women than believed up until this point in time.…

    • 1505 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    ‘The Accrington Pals’ is a play that follows the lives of those effected by the war; both and home and overseas. The role that the women played at home has often been underplayed within World War Literature so the play gives an alternative view of the women’s role. The female characters in the play are stuck in limbo; not free from war but at the same time not directly involved. Looking at the effect on these characters can show the impact that the War had on the country as a whole and gets across the message that the playwright, Peter Whelan, is hoping to portray.…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women of the eighteenth century had very different roles before the Revolutionary War than after, and the movement of gender equality can be attributed to their increased importance in wartime. Before the war, women had primarily one job: manage and care for her household. While men were responsible for a family’s income, security, and overall leadership, women were responsible for the well-being of her home and children. Having many children was considered a wife’s duty, as sons would help their father, and daughters their mother. As a result, a woman’s place was often in the home, and when out in public, they were expected to be quiet, humble, and submissive.…

    • 676 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Do they not plainly inform us, that, because we are females, we ought therefore to be deprived of what is perhaps the most effectual means of acquiring a just, natural and graceful delivery? No one will pretend to deny, that we should be taught to read in the best manner. And if to read, why not to speak?” (Doc J). However, later in history women will be known as the backbone of several prominent wars. During WWI (1914-1918), large numbers of women were recruited into jobs vacated by men who had gone to fight in the war. The women were the ones producing war supplies and materials to help the war effort. Without the women taking over the roles of the men, it is safe to say that America would have suffered greatly during WWI. The wars fought on the battlefield are what most Americans recall in history, but it is what occurred behind the scenes that helped shape this nation into the powerful nation it is…

    • 959 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    While many occupied more traditional roles such as nurses or Daughters of the Regiment, others served as spies, while others actually went into battle alongside their male counterparts. The fact of the matter is, woman who went into battle were forced to conceal themselves, and ultimately pose as men, spending the entire war in disguise. The grit and ingenuity of some of the women discussed in this paper, demonstrate the powerful presence of women during the American Civil War. Women motivated to reunite with their family members at war performed incredible feats in order to find their loved ones while at the same time surviving the gruesome realities of war. Other women single handedly braved danger and death to help their respective sides of war, crossing enemy lines, and gathering or imparting information, and in Thompson’s case, leading to the death of a Confederate General. In the end, the women who served in the Civil War will remain within the pages of history just as valiant, and heroic, if not more so than the men they fought alongside…

    • 2480 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Not every women who went to battle disguised themselves as men, “Daughters of the regiment” engaged in quasi-military work, usually for regiments in which one of their male relatives were serving. These women would do everything from cooking meals to helping out on hospital ships. Some women…

    • 436 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After WWII, Gender roles were challenged, ideals were changed and standards were questioned. Could the war be a cause for these changes? This paper will evaluate men and women’s roles, ideals and standards…

    • 1008 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays