Preview

Women Gained the Vote Due to Their Contribution during the War: Statement Analysis

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1505 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Women Gained the Vote Due to Their Contribution during the War: Statement Analysis
“Women gained the vote due to their contribution during the war” - how accurate is this statement?

Before 1918, women did not have equal rights. For example, they did not have control in their marriages or any reasonable say in how their country was run. Women were seen as too stupid or emotional to make any rational decisions in important political matters. There is much debate over what actually improved views on women enough to allow them the vote in 1918, when the government decided that including the female vote in the electoral register would extend the franchise. The main idea is that they proved their worth by contributing relentlessly through work during the First World War when the men were away fighting. Others believe it was the work of Suffragists and Suffragettes which helped the cause.

However, the work done by women during the First World War is believed to be what caught the most attention and proved that they were just as reliable as men. Women became actively involved in a wide variety of day-to-day jobs which only men had worked before. They took over jobs such as nursing, munitions, industry, fire-fighting, drivers, and farming in the Women’s Land Army. Many people within the country were impressed and took on more positive attitudes towards those who worked - women were seen to be more trustworthy and mature, politicians saw them in a new light and had the view that they should be “rewarded” due to “proving their worth” to the nation. Historian Martin Pugh said “Male prejudice against women melted in the face of revelations about their capabilities during wartime and their contribution to the war effort”. These acts of help to the country proved that there was more to women than believed up until this point in time.

Before 1850, women had little-to-no control over any of their own affairs. It was accepted that men were the bosses of everything - they were the ones who worked in the marriage while women stayed at home, and they got all

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Before WW1 women had very little policital power and were considered inferior to men. Men didn't see the need for women to have a voice, and that their opinion was not needed. However, when the war began men were sent to war, leaving job spaces to be filled. This was when the women were called upon to fill these spaces. This was an oppurtunity for women to prove their rights for politicial power. Source A1 supports this because it states 'by the end of the war in November 1918, women proved that they were just as important to th war effort as men'. This shows that women were successful in doing so and had been given more political power. This source was taken from a website focused at GCSE students which means alot of research must have been put into the text, making it reliable.…

    • 965 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women get the vote 1916-1919 Women's suffrage groups had existed since the 1870s, but during the war it was hard to ignore their arguments. Women were serving in the war, taking over from the men in factories and offices, holding families together while the men were overseas, and working in voluntary organizations that supported the war effort. They couldn't be kept out of political life any longer. Women got the federal vote in three stages: the Military Voters Act of 1917 allowed nurses and women in the armed services to vote; the Wartime Election Act extended the vote to women who had husbands, sons or fathers serving overseas; and all women over 21 were allowed to vote as of January 1, 1919.…

    • 638 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ww1 Unit 1 Research Paper

    • 1048 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Do you agree with the view that the First World War hindered, rather than helped, the cause of female suffrage?…

    • 1048 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    To understand the reasons behind some women getting the vote in 1918, one must look back at the history of the women’s movement to fully understand the reason female suffrage was sought and gained. In Victorian Britain there was a longstanding and persistent belief that men and women occupied separate spheres. The separate spheres ideology promoted the belief that due to women’s roles in reproduction, they were best suited to occupy the private sphere of home and family. Alternatively, men were designed to occupy the public sphere work and politics . However, this ideology was a direct contradiction to the reality of Victorian women who, in 1871, constituted nearly 32 per cent of the total British labour force.…

    • 2235 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The passing of the nineteenth amendment and the suffrage movement was not only an empowering moment for women in history, but it was also a way for them to break through social norms. Before the passing of this amendment and the uprising of the suffrage movement. From the year 1840 to 1920, women spent around 80 years fighting for their right to vote. Before the Second World War, women were not in male-dominated work fields and this only changed during the Second World War when the US saw a recession in the amount of male troops and medical staff. After this, more women were able to apply for jobs such as aviators and medical staff and many more occupations.…

    • 1340 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Women were not treated as equals with men before the second half of the eighteenth century. They had to marry, obey their husbands and have children, only receiving little education. In the eyes of the law they had little power and men were their superiors. For example, once they were married, everything they owned belonged to their husband, this meant that if they separated the women would be left with nothing, not even her children, as they too, belonged solely to the husband.
Around 1850, the rights of women started to change, as laws were made to improve women's education and rights in marriage. However women were still not allowed to vote in the general elections. Many women considered this as a huge prejudice, and that they would have to carry on being second-class citizens until they received the right to vote because a lot of women thought that having a say in general elections would give them more opportunities and rights.
Before 1918, only men had the vote, even though they had to qualify by meeting the property qualification (which was someone who earned 40 shillings a year and was a freeholder). Therefore, not all men did qualify, but many women did qualify, and as a result could vote in local elections.
As I mentioned above, people had to meet the property qualification in order to vote. Many women did own property of the right value, and so were entitled to the vote. The Married Women's Property Act made even more women qualify, as they could keep their earnings.
Women had to endure the same laws as men and also had to pay taxes, like men. So, the women only saw it fair to be able to vote, which gave women a say in what the laws and taxes were.
One of the arguments used against women's suffrage was that they were considered physically and mentally too weak. Women's argument towards that was that women had become successful monarchs of this country, for example, Queen Elizabeth I and the present Queen of the time, Queen Victoria. If women were suitable…

    • 369 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women first petitioned Parliament for equality in 1649- but were told that it was unnecessary as their husbands represented them in political affairs. 250 years later many people in Britain (women as well as men) still agreed with the Parliamentary response to the petitioners for women’s rights in 1649. However, the women’s suffrage moment in Britain took hold of the country in the 1860’s. Women (over the age of 30) finally won the vote in 1918- although historians are still debating over what was the main cause of women gaining the vote: the militant suffragettes, the more peaceful suffragists or World War One.…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women during World War II were on the home front helping out as much as they could. Many Canadian women never enlisted in the Armed Services, they felt they were needed at home to raise families, crops for food, and to fill the jobs that men had vacated in order to serve their country. Being a young, single woman had its advantages. Job opportunities were everywhere. For married women, the task wasn’t quite so simple, especially if they had children. However, they learned to manage, they were determined to defend their country in whatever way they could and serve they did. Hundreds of Canadian women worked in machine shops, welding shops and manufacturing plants, making the equipment that was necessary to fight a war like bombs and weapons for the men and women in the Armed Services. Not only were they expected to work in the jobs the men had left, they were expected to keep a neat, tidy house and raise children. Luxuries were few and far between. “Women in overalls and a bandana on posters everywhere became a symbol of service to Canada.” (Wilson 267) Teens girls were also contributing during the war; while the mothers were at work, teen girls took care of the children and maintained cleanliness around the house. With World War II came the dire need for employees in the workplace. Had women not step in, the economy would have collapsed. In the end, at the time of the Second World War; females were on the home front doing anything they could to help the war effort and yet at the same time, they were managing to keep their womanly duties stable. These efforts eventually gave women more recognition and led to simple but important changes in the long run.…

    • 858 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Suffragettes Dbq

    • 1087 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The First World War could have been seen as the most important factor in achieving female enfranchisement in 1918 due to it acting as a catalyst which sped up the changing attitudes towards women. As it gave women the opportunity to prove that they really were as worthy of having the vote as men. Foremost amongst these was the fall of Asquith as PM. However, the issue would certainly not have been in the forefront of the Government’s mind without the publicity-seeking campaigning of the Suffragettes, immediately prior to the War. It is difficult, however, to consider this to have been the most important factor, due to the very negative image of Suffragettes that prevailed, and the fact that many WSPU members had defected to the NUWSS. The work of the Suffragists together with the changing laws, led to the increasing politicisation of women. So therefore it can be concluded that the militant suffragette campaign cannot be seen as the most significant factor in helping women gain the…

    • 1087 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women in Role Ww 2

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Life for women during WW2 was bittersweet. Their loved ones were at war, yet they discovered they were able to hold down men's job. This changed their outlook on life and also made themselves and other people realise that they could confidently take on the roles of men; that their part was not just in the home. This change in attitude was brought on in the war and after it they didn't want to go back to being housekeepers after working for so long.The types of work that women did during the war included factory jobs - maintenance work and ship building, in the armed forces - clerical work and transport, nursing and work on the land. Before the war the only jobs women had were teaching and nursing which were both very sheltered. The factory jobs etc made them stronger and more assertive, and after all this experience they did not…

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women being able to finally vote in the 1920s had a big effect on the United States. It changed the United States and made it more democratic. This is because once women were allowed to vote they then became represented whereas before they were not. By the definition, this right given to women made the United States more democratic.…

    • 649 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Bussiness Not Pleasure

    • 628 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The first reason is the war effort the suffragettes put into the war. On 14th August 1914, Britain declared war on Germany. After that the NUWSS (national union of suffrage societies) decided that all political activity would be suspended until the war was over. Some leaders of the women’s social and political union such as Emmeline Pankhurst and her daughter, Christabel Pankhurst, played a big role on recruiting young men into the army. When men left their jobs to go to fight overseas, they were replaced by women, women such as Octavia Wilberforce and Louisa Martindale from Brighton worked as doctors treating injured British soldiers. Many jobs that men did were overtaken by women jobs like tram driver, doctor, factory worker, navy and so on. This gives the government a good reason to give the women the right to vote. The historian Alasdair Gray has the view that the War was the most important influence in women gaining the vote,…

    • 628 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Revolutionary War was a period of time when America would free from its constraints of Britain, and become their own independent nation. The men, the soldiers in the war were credited mainly for the pathway to freedom, but what about the women who also made efforts? Most of the women who stepped forward to help out and pave the way for freedom were looked past, or down upon because women were looked to be subordinate to men. Though the Revolutionary War opened opportunities for minority groups, including women to liberate and develop their individuality. Women's’ movements in the war may have attributed to the suffrage movement in 1920, allowing women to obtain equal rights, and alter their position in society. There were several women…

    • 978 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    women and the war

    • 386 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Historians still have diverse opinions about women and the war; historians such as Arthur Marwick support the reward theory, which states that women were rewarded with the vote after their vital impact on the war effort. Evidence promoting this point like the “Women’s Land Army” shows that the government wanted to honour the women taking up jobs even though these were just woman farmers. For women the war sparked a social revolution.…

    • 386 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Before World War I, a women’s role consisted of domestic labor such as; teaching, nursing, and agriculture. These women were not quite seen as equal to men, or capable of doing what men during that time could. However, by the time the War had begun, many men were being called to serve; the jobs of men were starting to become unattended. The real question was “who could replace these men?” Women were the final answer. Many of the women who were once nursing and teaching were know filling roles that were unoccupied. These women worked for long hours and support and began learning new skills, which caused the result of their roles changing. They were mainly employed in food, textile, and war industries. As more men went off, women took responsibility. By the year 1917, 68% of the women had changed jobs since war began, and 16% had moved out of domestic service. The last 16% were unemployed. Many of the jobs the women were taking gave them the opportunity to show a male-dominated society and that they were capable of so much more, not just of raising children or be liable at home. Women at this period of time took over production lines in factories, and replaced men as police officers, mechanics, train conductors, etc. The war became a result of many families being torn apart as women were forced to take on their new roles. A numerous amount of women were also working for the military. As the document shows, the U.S. Navy and Marine Corpse allowed women to enlist. It has been said, that approximately more than 12,000 women enlisted, and about 400 died during the war.…

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays