Preview

Comparing Matthew, Mark, And Luke

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
712 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparing Matthew, Mark, And Luke
These synoptic gospels, Matthew, Mark, and Luke, often tell the same story but have a slight variation. Matthew appears to be the shortest “story” and also seems to be a summary. Mark and Luke tend to go in more detail but also have many differences. These stories are the same because they talk about demon-possessed men. There are two demon-possessed men in Matthew, while in Mark and Luke it has one demon-possessed man. The settings are also very similar; the demon(s) come from the tomb to Jesus in Matthew and Mark, while in Luke the demon comes from the town to Jesus (it also states that the demon lives in the tomb). As the stories progress, the demons each ask Jesus, “what do you want with us, Son of God?” (Matthew). But in Mark and Luke, …show more content…
After the people ask Jesus to leave, Jesus says in return, “Go home to your own people and tell them what the Lord has done for you.” Why wouldn’t it be stated in Matthew about what the Lord has done for them? It also seems different that Matthew’s story is so much shorter than Mark and Luke. This makes sense because each of them could have remembered the story differently; Matthew just didn’t remember a whole lot. Why would the village people ask Jesus to leave their region? Were they afraid of the demon that Jesus had extracted from the men? Why wouldn’t they celebrate with Jesus and call him a hero for casting out the demons? Also, what is the significance in the name Legion? After reading closely and searching the internet, Legion is a group of demons which is stated in Mark and Luke. With these stories, when each one is written, why wouldn’t Matthew, Mark, and Luke get together and discuss what happened so they don’t miss any detail? Or do we want them to write their stories as is and see the differences and similarities they come up with? There is one difference that was not stated in Mark or Matthew. In Luke, the demons begged Jesus not to order them to the Abyss. What is the Abyss? Is it a place of no return? What is so bad about the “abyss”? After doing some research, I found that abyss is basically a bottomless pit, in which it receives not daylight (Lewis). The demons don’t want to end up there because they will no longer be able to take over human bodies or wreak havoc on the earth. Basically, sounds like hell, and if I were the demons, I definitely would not want to go there (or go back for that

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Synopsis: Inmate Kelvin Hall was in violation of R-C2-15 of the inmate handbook. He will be locked down for 10 hours.…

    • 149 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The author does a great job of explaining the different perspective of the different authors of the New Testament. They each see Jesus Christ differently. Mark sees Jesus as the hidden and suffering Son of God. He saw how Jesus was not given the proper recognition even though He was the Son of the Living God. Mark also speaks of the miracles that Jesus performed. The author, Roberto Imperato makes special mention of what a miracle is. He defines it as a special "act of God." It is something that no human can do. The Gospel of Mark, as the author explains is a long introduction to the death of Jesus Christ. In the Gospel of Matthew, he explains the fulfillment of the Jewish hope through Jesus Christ. He also teaches that Jesus is the Messiah, Son of God and the Teacher of New Righteousness. Many of the Pharisees believed that their ways and teachings were the fulfillment of Jewish life while Matthew believed that real fulfillment came through Jesus Christ. Luke views Jesus as a Martyr Prophet and merciful Savior. Luke believes that Jesus is a Martyr prophet because people may react in a negative way and cause harm to the messenger. Luke also sees Jesus as a merciful savior. John refers to Jesus…

    • 943 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Luke’s theme is about new conversion and the rapid spread of Christianity, however, with the addition of the story of Mary and Martha it becomes confusing as to how this story fits in with the overall theme of the Gospel of Luke. However, Luke continues his theme with this story because he wants everyone to know the truth about Jesus. Jesus wanted Martha to stop doing the busywork and focus on the truth of Him and who He is. Before this passage, we have the story about the Good Samaritan who was there to help even when it was frowned upon socially. After this passage, we have where Jesus teaches about prayer. The passage about Mary and Martha go with the Good Samaritan story because Martha was doing what was expected by her culture and society, while Mary was going beyond it and sitting at the feet of Jesus.…

    • 955 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Matthew never plainly states his purpose how the other Gospels state theirs. It is believed that he mainly wrote just to document those events, but just because of this does not mean that he does not show a rich side of Jesus. He shows us that Jesus is the Messiah. With this in mind, he focused more on teaching on Jesus' life and teachings.…

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The book of Luke is a Gospel that contains narrative, genealogy, sermons, parables, and some Prophetic oracles. Luke begins by telling us about Jesus’s parents (Mary & Joseph); the birth of His cousin, John the Baptist; Mary and Joseph’s journey to Bethlehem, where Jesus is born in a manager, a common Christmas story, yet always fascinating; and the genealogy of Christ through Mary. Jesus’ public ministry reveals His prefect compassion and forgiveness through the stories of the prodigal son, the rich man and Lazarus, and the Good Samaritan. While many believe in this unprejudiced love that surpasses all human limits, many others especially the religious leaders challenge and oppose the claims of Jesus. Christ’s followers are encouraged to count the cost of discipleship, while His enemies seek His death on the cross. Passover arrives, and Jesus celebrates the traditional Seder meal with his disciples. Finally, Jesus is betrayed by one of his own (Judas Iscariot), He is tried, sentenced and crucified. Joseph of Arimathea buries him. On the third day some female followers of Jesus, including Mary Magdalene, go to his gravesite but find him gone. He resurrected and arose from the grave as He had miraculously raised others during His ministry.…

    • 1132 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The four authors that wrote about Jesus life and ministry tell the same story in different ways. There are many stories about Jesus and not any one of the apostles told everything that was wrote about Jesus and his life. Even the content about the same story had many different details. I have picked to gospel accounts about Jesus to compare. The two apostles that I picked will compare Luke and Matthew. They both wrote about the same event and they put different theological emphasis on the same action that Jesus did. The two accounts are considered true events in his life. A quick look at the gospels reveals they all address one issue which is Jesus and his ministry. In this, a great amount of overlap can be found in the gospels, more so among the synoptic. If all four gospels are about the ministry of Jesus, Why have all four apostles been wrote about the same event when it would only have taken one to do the same thing. Then why did they write about it and tell the same story in different ways. The question may be asked, why did they write the four gospels? I will look at the gospels of Matthew and Luke in order to look for similarities and differences in there writing.…

    • 3042 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    His understanding of the ‘’mission’’ in Christianity differs to a greater extend with the understanding of Paul and Mathew. While Mathew sees the mission in universal perspective, Luke sees it as a duty to the disciples and the followers of Jesus Christ. For this reason, his work is a direct replacement of Mathew’s ‘’great commission.’’ Another major contradiction between Luke and Mathew is that the former did not only write the gospel of Jesus, but also wrote the Acts of the Apostles and that the latter is Jewish-Christian, hence bringing the difference in interpretation of the mission in Christianity between the two authors. However, it is equally important to appreciate the fact that the authors show some similarities in their writings and that they wrote their books in the same period despite the differences seen in the messages and the texts. Luke like Paul came to rescue people from the confusion they had about their identity. His writing seeks to give direction to the Christians who had lost direction and were wondering if Christianity was an upcoming religion or if it was a continuation of the church left by Jesus Christ. In his writing, Luke emphasizes three things, the Holy Spirit, forgiveness, and forgiveness[iv]. He also makes the poor the center and the predominant heading of his book. Through this he mentions, association that Jesus…

    • 1404 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    As diverse and multicultural as today’s society may appear, the majority of individuals have still heard of the gospels that help make up the Holy Bible. Although there are many in the Bible, the four canonical gospels, Mathew, Mark, Luke, and John, are perhaps the most widely recognized. These four, although composed by different individuals, share many similarities in common such as how those who encounter Jesus after his resurrection behave. Even certain traits that characterize Jesus himself after resurrection are somewhat related.…

    • 958 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Upon close examination of the Gospels of Matthew, Mark, and Luke, it quickly becomes evident that there are many similarities. The similarity is more that the order of the material presented but also the exact wording of long stretches of text, which is not sufficient to be explained on the basis of oral tradition. This forces scholars to presume that there is some type of literary dependence. This would mean that someone copied from someone else’s written work. Luke does mention that there have been several other written materials which could give an indication that the authors/editors might have had one or more of early Gospel sources. However, it is not straightforward as some material is present in all three Synoptics, other material found in only two. Also, the common material is not always…

    • 512 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Mark and Luke remembered three people there, Mary Magdalene, Mary the mother of James, and one more, Salome. Matthew only remembers…

    • 1210 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Gospel of Mark and the Gospel of John each present an illustration of Jesus in both humanity and divinity. However, each gospel portrays Jesus in a different way. The Gospel of Mark focuses on the mortality aspect of Jesus such as the concern of dying. On the contrary the Gospel of John focuses on the spirituality aspect of Jesus, and the revelation of Jesus and the Father being one. Despite the differences in portrayal of Jesus leading up to the Last Supper. Throughout this event both Gospels portrays Jesus’ crucifixion, however, Mark present Jesus similarly to the Passover Lamb. John on the other hand reveals Jesus’ parting in preparation of what to come so that they may believe.…

    • 730 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I really enjoyed reading your essay because you had tackled the response question in a different way from my own. Your essay focused more on the similarities that both Matthew’s and Mark’s stories share. These similarities mostly fell along the lines of Jesus’s actions and teachings. You use several examples from these stories, like how Jesus cured many sick people or how he managed to split a small portion of bread and fish amongst thousands of people. You also emphasized how Jesus was viewed as a giving, selfless, wise and kind figure in both stories. I felt that when you starting out by stating your these similarities in a direct way, you made it very easy to dive into your differences right after. The birth and death of Jesus were…

    • 203 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mark portrays Jesus as a powerful yet unrecognized and suffering Messiah. Stories throughout the gospel show Jesus to have control over storms, water and demons. He is able to heal lepers, cripples and people with withered limps. He also has undaunted authority over everything including sin and Sabbath laws. Yet the theme of the messianic secret is major within this gospel. Jesus often tells people "to tell no one" of the miracles he performs. This theme is part of the climax of Mark 's gospel when Peter proclaims that Jesus is Christ and Jesus responds by giving him strict orders to tell no one. He therefore is the unrecognized Messiah. Mark wrote his gospel to a suffering and fearful faith community. He wrote to inspire faith in them. That is why Mark emphasizes Jesus ' suffering to his readers so that they can relate and see that there is no glory without suffering. He therefore shows that in order to have true dominance one must first encounter suffering, just as Jesus had.…

    • 769 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    management

    • 677 Words
    • 3 Pages

    This aim of this report is to adopt managerial process to analysis and also find a solution to solve the problem that Julie is facing at the moment in the Malard Manufacturing Company.…

    • 677 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Economic Issues Essay

    • 1073 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Poverty. This seven letter word can bring up so many different feelings for so many different people around the world. The one thing that ties all those different people together is the lack of money to support their families and themselves. Most people on the poverty line and below can attribute it to their lack of education. In this essay I am going to be talking about the impact education has on people who live in poverty. It’s not just people who live in the slums of South Africa, but right here in the United States in seemingly good homes who suffer from poverty.…

    • 1073 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays