Preview

Comparing Odin And Nelson's The Tragedy Of Othello

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
704 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparing Odin And Nelson's The Tragedy Of Othello
The Tragedy of Othello, the Moor of Venice is a tragedy by William Shakespeare. It is believed to have been written in approximately 1603, and based on the Italian short story Un Capitano Moro . In 2001, Tim Blake Nelson created a modern version of this masterpiece. While the play is set in Venice in the late 1500s and the movie is set in the 21st century at an affluent private school, Nelson does an apt job in comparing the plot, characters and theme of blind trust leading to betrayal .

O is a 2001 American drama film, to compare all the character in Othello, there has the same character one-to-one correspondence between the Shakespeare’s version and modern version akin to their name. It was set up in an upper class prep school, and concentrated
…show more content…
Starting from the character’s way, Odin and Othello are different in some ways due to the time different, but by and large they are similar. The resemblance between Odin and Othello is they all black and living under the watchful eye of others. Another similarity is they both have a high status in their own field. For example, Odin is the main force of the school basketball team and Othello is military general in Venice. Admittedly, they are different just because the historical background. For example, at the beginning of both works, Desdemona’s father Brabantio and Desi’s father were both strongly against the amour between Othello(Odin) and Desdemona(Desi). Nevertheless, under the time different, in O is shown in the racial discrimination way. As the principal of the school, he cannot reveal his …show more content…
Desdemona is Othello’s wife and the daughter of Senator. Whether Desdemona or Desi, they both unswerving in Othello(Odin)’s loyalty, never change until the death approaching. For instance, they both could believed that their boyfriend Othello(Odin) started suspect they had affair. In addition, they cannot believe the truth that they killed by him and without regret because trust is broken. On the other hand, Desdemona and Desi both to have a kind heart. For example, whether in Othello or in O, they wanted to try their best to help their friend Cassion(Michael). They never thought they are some kind of special person in their life and school under their father’s glory. However, the different between Desdemona and Desi is their character strength. In the Middle Ages, the proposition of family is man is the king of the entire family. Desdemona is more as an understanding wife and always yield to her husband. Turn to modern, equality of men and women is the mainstream of society. We can easily see that when Odin tried to have word with Desi and she showed a strong response like “there’s no reason to doubt me! DON’T DOUBT

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The lives we live today contain many moral aspects that would not have been accepted socially fifty or more years ago. Society gives us two choices: to conform or to rebel and escape from society’ restrictions. In the short story “A&P” the author, John Updike, shoes that growing up is a mixture of being rebellious, discovering maturity and the search and desire for individuality. Sammy, the first-person narrator and main character of “A&P”, quits his job for the reason that he seeks to rise above others’ expectations and find himself a career he sees as worthy and sophisticated because he fears to be seen as a “sheep”.…

    • 530 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Both Mary Shelley’s 1818 gothic novel Frankenstein and Ridley Scott’s 1982 film Blade Runner explore the dehumanising effects of technology. Although the texts differ in context they connect through their exploration of transcendent societal concerns. A key theme explored in both texts is the dangers associated with unrestricted and dehumanising technology.…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Desdemona is young, sexual, and recently married. She is the daughter of the Venetian senator Brabanzio. Desdemona and Othello are secretly married before the play begins. While in many ways stereotypically pure and meek, Desdemona is also determined and self-possessed. She is equally capable of defending her marriage, jesting bawdily with Iago, and responding with dignity to Othello’s incomprehensible jealousy. Desdemona is at times a submissive character, most notably in her willingness to take credit for her own murder. The play, then, depicts Desdemona contradictorily as a self-effacing, faithful wife and as a bold, independent personality. This contradiction may be intentional, meant to portray the way Desdemona herself feels after defending her choice of marriage to her father in Act I, scene iii, and then almost immediately being put in the position of defending her fidelity to her husband. She begins the play as a supremely independent person, but midway through she must struggle against all odds to convince Othello that she is not too independent. The manner in which Desdemona is murdered, smothered by a pillow in a bed covered in her wedding sheets, is symbolic. She is literally suffocated beneath the demands put on her fidelity. Emilia is Iago’s wife and Desdemona’s attendant. A cynical, worldly woman, she is deeply attached to her mistress and distrustful of her husband (Shakespeare, 2005).…

    • 985 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Desdemona after leaving her father to be with Othello and accompanying Othello on his voyage to Cyprus has had a similar motivation throughout the piece. Desdemona has wanted to prove that she is a good wife to Othello. By Act three Scene three Desdemona has noticed something is not quite right with Othello. However, she believes that it is just because of what is happening in Cyprus and because he has just been forced to fire his lieutenant for the time being. Desdemona wants to make Othello happy again and she believes by him making Cassio his lieutenant again he won’t be as stressed. Othello approaches Desdemona several times hinting at the “affair…

    • 1192 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Odin says that he was not a rapist or a druggie, or troubled or violent. It is Hugo who is these things, and Odin only fit the stereotype after Hugo manipulated him. Its not the black guy who fits the black stereotype, it's the white guy. Nelson is making a statement, the black stereotype is not justified, it wasn't made by black people, it was created by the racist attitudes and hatred of white people. In the beginning, both Othello and O are not only well-respected leaders, but they are kind-hearted and affectionate people. However, it isn't long before there is a crack in their personalities, in Othello this is a result of Iago being deceitful to Othello, making him think that Desdemona has committed adultery with Cassio, Likewise in O where Hugo makes Odin think Desi has been with Mike. Othello shows his first signs of change when he hits Desdemona in a jealous rage. Lodovico witnesses this incident and says, "Is this the noble Moor whom our full Senate call all in all sufficient? Is this the nature whom passion could not shake? whose solid virtue the shot of accident nor dart of chance could neither graze nor pierce" just like the audience, Lodovico is shocked that Othello would do such a thing as it is not like…

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay Othello Versus O

    • 355 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Although the movie “O” is a production based on Shakespeare’s “Othello”, several differences exist between the two such as women’s social status, Iago’s personality change, and the type of language employed by the characters. Desi plays a strong woman who won't let any man put her down. She stands up to Odin several times during the movie, showing that twentieth century women have higher status in society than they did in Shakespeare's time. In the movie, Desi assertively says, “If you want to be with me don’t ever talk like that to me again, ever!” Desdemona seems much more compliant to her husband's demands, even when she knows that she is going to die. Rather than run, she goes to her bedchamber and gets ready for bed, perhaps suspecting that it will be her last night alive. At the beginning of the play she declares just how loyal she is to Othello by saying “to you [father], I am bound for life and education; I am hitherto your daughter: but here's my husband, and so much duty as my mother showed to you, preferring you before her father, so much I challenge that I may profess Due to the Moor my Lord”(Hall,). Desdemona knows her place in society and that is that she should be loyal to her husband or else she has been an unworthy wife. Iago’s character changes drastically in the movie compared to Shakespeare’s play. He would be considered the perfect villain in the play. He never seems to get fazed when he destroys Othello and Desdemona's relationship, when he makes Othello go crazy or when he kills Rodrigo: “ My medicine, work! Thus credulous fools are caught”(Hall, 124). There are two major motives that drive Iago to destroy Othello’s life. The first being his hatred for Othello for not promoting him. His second motive is his desire for importance in society and Othello is a human being that is blocking his pathway to glory. His character in “O”, Hugo, is a little bit different. He is trying…

    • 355 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Desdemona is Othello’s wife and the daughter of Brabantio. Desdemona secretly married Othello, against her father’s wishes. Throughout the play, Desdemona’s power is not clearly conveyed to the audience, but her presence has an effect. Roderigo is in love with her and her presence has an effect on him- he wants Othello out of the way, so to speak, so he can once again attempt to win Desdemona’s love. As the play unfolds, different aspects of Desdemona’s character are revealed, and blend into a unique personality. Throughout the play, Desdemona is loyal to her husband, but once again, her presence (with Cassio) leads Othello to believe that she is disloyal to him. Her handkerchief plays a pivotal role in the play- by Desdemona dropping it, Emilia gives it to Iago, who then stealthily gives it to Cassio. Othello sees Cassio with the handkerchief and believes Desdemona gave it to…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Desdemona, the daughter of Venetian senator Brabantio, is captivated by Othello’s fables of bravery as a warrior and she falls in love with him. In view of the fact that Desdemona is a “fair” woman and Othello is “an old black ram”, commonly referred to as ‘the Moor’, their marriage indicates that her fate might be tragic. In ‘Othello’, Desdemona is portrayed as a courageous young woman whose character is used against her in plotting her death. The particularly unfortunate event is the irony that the very qualities of her personality that make her a good woman defeated her.…

    • 1489 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The play "Othello" was about a noble Moor, Othello that was in love with a woman named Desdemona. In the Movie "O" the characters name is Odin and that are similar in many ways. Odin (Mekhi Phifer) is a superstar basketball player that is best friends with Hugo (Josh Hartnett). They play on the same basketball team and Odin is the only black student at his school. In the play "Othello" he is the only black person around that is noble. This is one of the similarities that the play and the movie have. Another similarity is that Othello promotes Cassio instead of Iago due to his breeding. In the movie Odin wants to share his most valuable player award with someone else besides Hugo. In both the play and the movie Iago/Hugo gets extremely upset with Othello/Odin and this starts the hatred towards Othello/Odin.…

    • 874 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Desdemona and Othello are deeply in love with each other; that much is obvious. It is also a forbidden relationship, however, because the former is the daughter of a Venetian senator and the latter is a "black ram", an aging Moorish General within the Venetian army with little experience when it comes to romance. He is therefore vulnerable to ambitious men of lower rank such as his ensign Iago, who exploits Othello's marriage with the "maid so tender, fair and happy" that is Desdemona. The seeds of jealousy and ultimately his downfall, planted through the possibility of Cassio as Desdemona's adulterer, are thus nurtured through Othello's inferiority complex. The play uses this jealousy as one of the notions which brings forth Othello's anger and sadness, and by doing so shows viewers that the loving relationship between Othello and Desdemona, something so commonly seen in all societies, may be something fragile or even superficial, something easily destroyed by the assumptions of lust between her and Cassio.…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Desdemona is the last of the characters to evaluate, however she is also the most important. Desdemona is treated very unfairly because she is a faithful wife, who loves her husband very much. However, through the help of Iago, her husband, and Othello suspects Desdemona is cheating on him. This is not true, but still Othello believes his friend long before he would listen to the woman who loves him. Othello then, instead of treating Desdemona fairly in return for her love, argues with and makes fun of her.…

    • 327 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Desdemona

    • 389 Words
    • 1 Page

    Desdemona is the daughter of Brabantio, who is in the upper class of society. Desdemona apparently has many suitors for her hand in marriage, but she chooses to marry Othello instead. Her decision upsets her father as well as Iago and Roderigo. Desdemona is a very well-rounded character and has many character traits. Some of those traits are being independent, witty, and submissive.…

    • 389 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Provide at least three reasons why every student should be required to take general education courses. Explain your rationale.…

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Desdemona is probably the strongest willed character in the play, although she is a woman. Shakespeare takes no shame in making her this, considering the time this was written in. We first see her, defending her recent marriage surrounded by powerful men, whom of which include the duke, her husband, and her father, but shes is not ashamed to assert her belief in the validity of her desires and actions. Desdemona's forthrightness is her demise, because the brilliant Iago recognizes this and uses it against her. Using Cassio who becomes demoted in the play, Iago exploits her willingness to demand and justice, to make him her cause and simultaneously, Othello's enemy. As Iago's plan goes as planned, Desdemona asks Othello to forgive Cassio adding to Othello's suspicions created by his deceitful friend. She keeps pushing him in spite of her husbands growing rage until he declares, The handkerchief that Othello gave his wife at the beginning of the play, is stolen. Her courage is apparent in her refusal to search for it in Act III, scene iv; her willingness to have a voice and shout back at Othello as he abuses her in Act IV, scene i; and defending her innocence when accused Act V, scene ii. Since men have the ultimate power of women. Othello does not believe in, what he takes to be 'shameless lies'. Her courage convinces him all the more that she is remorseless in what he thinks to be her wrongdoing.…

    • 413 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Femininity In Othello

    • 1264 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Initially, Othello falls in love with Desdemona because she is well spoken. For instance, she goes back and forth with Iago confidently while they await Othello’s arrival in Cyprus. But, when her relationship with Othello started to become progressively more abusive, she becomes the “Silent Woman”. She does not revert to this new-found character because she “she lacks verbal resources, but because she cannot understand words without reality to her.” (Corbett 12)…

    • 1264 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays