Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Comparison Between The Hollow Of The Three Hills And Elephant

Good Essays
1103 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparison Between The Hollow Of The Three Hills And Elephant
Re-sit (Comparison between Elephant and the Hollow of the Three Hills)
Both the stories Elephant by Raymond Carver and The Hollow of the Three Hills by Nathaniel Hawthorne reveal the theme of love. This is done through many emotions such as the portrayal of one’s solitude and grief. The stories highlight the central characters feelings towards loss and failure. They show how one can be deceitful and still expect so much, and how being isolated can really tear a person apart till death or make them realise they need a new start.
In the Elephant every character relies on or is dependent on the narrator. He is in essence their certainty and assured future, without him their lives would become unmanageable. The narrator accepts this. Whereas in The Hollow of the Three Hills, the woman dishonoured her family, rather than helped them. The main character is a woman with an abominable past who tries to run away from her problems. She had such a secret where “no mortal would observe them”. Though the protagonist in Elephant, even though he thought about abandoning his family, did not as he accepted his role to help others. That’s the difference between both of the characters in how they love their families. In Elephant he wants to run but stays as love keeps him bonded to them, he can’t bear being alone. Though in The Hollow of the Three Hills, the protagonist runs away and then realises her regret for deserting a deep affection her family always had for her.
The protagonist in Elephant always feels responsible for his family, “What could I do?” and “I didn’t want him to lose it (his house)”. He cannot run away from his responsibilities, as he feels as if he’s escaping from love, even if it’s love from giving money. Unlike the women in The Hollow of the Three Hills who in hardship left her family to feel “weary and lonesome”. She left her family with pain and aversion towards her and is in regret for this. In Elephant he rather not regret leaving but live in a world where his family can “steal” of him and think he’s being loved.
In The Hollow of the Three Hills, the woman looked upon her husband who she left alone and felt remorse after, so had to visit the witch in order to see how he was. He was not well at all and she broke all the love and trust she built with him, “He spoke of a woman’s perfidy of a wife who had broken her holiest vow”. In Elephant the narrators family members show love but for greediness not because they are heart-broken like the woman’s husbands in The Hollow of the Three Hills. In Elephant the protagonists children would go far lengths to disrespect their father for a materialistic life- “I’ll deal drugs or else rob a bank”. Though he keeps accepting their manipulation for money, “I don’t know what I’d do without you dad” even though he understands he is being exploited but rather have that than have no family.
Both characters in both stories are dissatisfied with their life due to the lack of love in their life. In the Elephant the protagonist is “working hard all day” and “has troubles of his own”, which reveals a strong sense of alienation. In The Hollow of the Three Hills, the woman is alone because she chose to be and now is paying for the continual hold of past and present and will always have the burden of her sins. Unlike the man in Elephant, she is a coward, which is ironic as she put her own self in this situation by not loving her family enough.
In The Hollow of the Three Hills the witch says to the young lady, “Here is our pleasant meeting come to pass according as thou hast desired (...) short hour we may tarry”. The woman’s death is being foreshadowed. It is also suggesting that the two meet because of a greater power which determines fate of the woman. In Elephant, the man’s future life is being foreshadowed as personal redemption and free of security from his family, “streaked down the road in the big un-paid for car” which represents a new start of his own life. A time where he can be led dependent too help others, this is shown be him not paying for the car ride. So love in Elephant has created greed and personal gain but makes the narrator realises that this is not what family is for and he too has a right for a good life. Unlike the women in The Hollow of the Three Hills whose personal greed and choice of leaving her family alone has caused her to lose life, as it was not much of a life but a life of solitude.
In Elephant, the narrator cares a lot for his son, whereas in The Hollow of the Three Hills she left her daughter to die. The man longs for his son to be happy, so sends him money as he says back, “won’t let you down dad”. His child may be selfish but the narrator will fulfil his role of a father and that’s not to let his child down when in times of need. This reveals the real affection he has and the love he wants to maintain in his family. Though the women does the opposite for her daughter as she was left to die of an illness. Hawthorne foreshadows this by writing “into the tone of a death bell” and “like the lamplight on the wall of a sepulchre”. She possessed no care for her daughter as she never put her first. She is now experiencing the consequence of living in guilt, whereas in Elephant the narrator lives in a condition of rituals which results in stagnation. He is being used not loved, but the woman used to be loved and gave it up. Giving up and abandonment was never a choice for the narrator in Elephant, he just saw the error of his ways and cleared them.
So in conclusion both texts, Elephant and The Hollow of the Three Hills centre on characters that are in deprivation of love and both scared of solitude. Love is essential for both, as creates life for them, as the woman clearly lost hers which reveals the importance of it and the difficulty of surviving without it. In Elephant, the narrator realised the importance of independence and how love cannot be achieved by family depending on you for wrong reasons.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    After a traumatic experience some people hide their painful emotions by pulling away and withdrawing from those they have hurt. However, some are able to recognize the pain and harm they have caused from becoming disconnected from those they should be closest to, and do their best to repair the damage. Alice Sebold, Author of The Lovely Bones and Khaled Hosseini, Author of The Kite Runner tell of dysfunctional responses to grief and emotional pain. Abigal of The Lovely Bones, and Amir of The Kite Runner are both emotionally immature, and do not know how to handle their feelings appropriately. Both these protagonists run away from their fears and pain and the ones who hold them close.…

    • 507 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Elephant is the emotional side and Rider is the cognitive side, and in most circumstances, during a disagreement, the Elephant tends to overpower the Rider. One example is skipping the gym. In otherwise the Elephant is responsible when somebody fails to change because emotions suppress the ability to intelligently reason. No doubt, the Elephant is capable of immense strengths such as someone getting things done while on the other hand, the Rider ruminates in situations like decision-making. Thus, changing behavior, with ease requires appealing to both the Elephant for energy and Rider for a sense of…

    • 475 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Intertwined in the stories of “Gwilan’s Harp” by Ursula K. LeGuin, “The Washwoman” by Isaac Singer, and “The Last Leaf” by O. Henry, lays a burden of loss. All of these stories experience the greatest loss when a character dies. Torm, Gwilan’s faithful husband in “Gwilan’s Harp”, a humble, hardworking washwoman from “The Washwoman”, and Behrman, the unsuccessful artist from “The Last Leaf”, all perish in their stories. The characters that die impact the other characters in the story in different ways even though the loss all the characters experience is death. So, despite the authors writing three unique stories with three different lessons, the loss of a character ties them together.…

    • 635 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The authors of both novels succeed in telling a moving story through their different writing styles. The writing in Water for Elephants is replete with colloquial language. The workers at the circus use broken English and common slang. Camel, for example, pleads with Blackie to let go of Jacob by saying, “Blackie, I’m tellin’ ya! We don’t need no trouble. Let ‘im go!” This vernacular lends much credence to the setting and the characters. Although the story is written from the first person point of view, the author’s use of dialogue…

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Keep love in your hearts. A life without it is like a sunless garden when the flowers are dead.”-Oscar Wilde Wilde hints at, that without love, your heart is like dead flowers in a sunless garden. Whereas, if there is love in your heart, your garden is full of blooming flowers. Love is a strong connection between people or objects that means a lot to them. In “Death and Transfiguration of a Teacher” Solari expresses the love between money and poetry. However, “The Handsomest Drowned Man in the World” portrays love between two unique people. In the stories “The Handsomest Drowned Man in the World” and “Death and Transfiguration” both Gabriel Garcia Marquez and Maria Teresa Solari embody love as a metaphor throughout the story.…

    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sara Gruen's title Water for Elephants provides a symbolic study of the fundamental human need for love and acceptance. The primary symbols are revealed through unique characters who struggle to feed deep internal desires.…

    • 578 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The story "Hills like White Elephants" by Ernest Hemingway is a fascinating story about one couple having faced with an unexpected pregnancy. The theme of the story is about the couple's decision between life and death. The main character Jig and The American are in disagreements on weather to keep their baby, or have an abortion. The couple's lack of communication creates the conflict in the story. For example, Jigs says, "We can have all this..." "And everyday we make it more impossible" While this problem is going on, the couple is sitting at a train station in the middle of a valley. Each side of the valley represents either life or death. As Jig moves about in the story, she faces different sides of the valley, which helps to determine the decision she will make. With the many descriptions and symbolism throughout the story, the final decision seems as if Jig is keeping the baby.…

    • 949 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ernest Hemingway’s "Hills Like White Elephants," tells the story of an American man and a girl who is named Jig. They are both sitting outside of a train station in Spain looking across a valley while drinking beer. In “Hills Like White Elephants,” Hemingway discusses the landscape before them, the valley of the Ebro River, that has long white hills. As the American and the girl begin to have a conversation, the girl remarks on the Ebro River of the way it looks. After a while the American asked her if she wanted to do the operation (an abortion which was learned in the author's comment at the end) and explained to her that she would be fine. However, she began to think if she participates in the operation would the American lover still be with her. Nevertheless, the American knows that if the operation is not done he would not be able to do certain things; therefore, he is trying to eliminate the reasons to settle down with Jig. Towards the end of the story, Jig and the American would argue about the operation; even though the American does not want a child.…

    • 571 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Women are treated as though they are very weak. Women were not allowed to live their lives for themselves. A woman has to perform duties and routines in a relationship as the men choose and tells her to do. But there is always a time when people realize that the ways of living should not be the way they are and that they have to change in order to live with their true selves instead of someone else controlling their lives. In many stories, women discover their true selves in order to live a free life. In Ernest Hemingway’s “Hills Like White Elephants” and Kate Chopin’s “The Story of an Hour,” it is clear that both of these authors analyze the topic of self-discovery. These stories show the role of gender and in particular the position of women in different situation. Both women in the stories experience self-discovery and a moment of change in their lives because they are free from the controlled life they had.…

    • 1433 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    It could be the drinking. Alcohol can mess with your better judgment. It makes people say what they are really thinking. Like when the American says “It’s really an awfully simple operation, Jig,” (pg.811). He is just saying what is on his mind. His drunk mind that is. We are talking about an unborn baby that he created. There is nothing simple about an abortion operation. They are both drinking and making life decisions which don’t go good together. You are supposed to make the decisions first then after making the right one you have a good time and drink. What does the elephant resemble? We know what an elephant is but I have never seen a white one. An Albino elephant. The white elephant is the unborn baby that she doesn’t know what she wants to do with. I think a white elephant would be kind of cool but for the story makes it seem like no one wants it. So no one wants the baby. That’s why the girlfriend changes her mind a little about the elephant because she is changing her mind about not having the abortion. It’s as if…

    • 591 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The forest is a main piece of this story. It is the area that hides what Young Goodman Brown is doing, but it also signifies the darkness of sin and distance from faith. The forest is very significant because it symbolizes the loss of morals and how confusion can seep into one’s soul. As Young Goodman Brown makes his way deeper into the forest, the more his attitude and love for Faith change. At first he is pushed by the old man to go on and unconsciously he…

    • 1530 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hills Like White Elephants

    • 1849 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The most remarkable aspect of the short story "Hills Like White Elephants," written by Ernest Hemingway, is it 's rich use of symbolism. The story is rather unique in that it does not have a complete plot line with an introduction leading to an expanded story. Neither are we left with a developed conclusion to the story. The main thrust centers around two characters having a quarrel about certain issues they disagree on. However, Hemingway leaves his reader in the dark as to the background of the two characters, even to the point of omitting specifics regarding the argument itself. Even though Hemingway provides very little detail regarding the characters ' respective pasts or even the current situation, the use of symbolism utilized throughout the conversation allows us to understand something of them through indirect implications rather than specific details. Hemmingway 's clever use of symbolism and allusion allows the reader to understand (again, without making direct reference to specifics) that they are arguing over whether or not Jig (the main female character) should have an abortion. By analyzing the couple 's dialogue we can deduce that the couple is in fact playing mind games, and manipulating each other 's points of views on abortion regarding their unborn child.…

    • 1849 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Close interpretation of the story "Hills Like White Elephants" by Ernest Hemingway leads the reader to an issue that has plagued society for decades. Understanding of the human condition is unveiled in the story line, the main setting, and through the character representation. The main characters in the story are an American man and a female named Jig. The conflict about abortions is an issue that still faces society today. Architectural and atmospheric symbolisms are used to set the mood and outline the human condition. The love bond between the man and Jig is strong; however, the more powerful bond between Jig and her unborn child is sacred.…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    plathos myth

    • 905 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The stories “Myth of the Cave” by Plato’s and “A Rose for Emily” by William Faulkner reveal how people are compelled to live their life in an illusion or a different way rather than to live in reality, thinking that’s how life is supposed to be, not knowing what life really looks like, they make this illusion seem real, at least to them. Even though the plots of the stories are different, they both share similar themes that can relate to each other, such as isolation. In the story “A Rose for Emily” the characters have similar settings in Plato’s Myth.…

    • 905 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This, I believe...

    • 654 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Orwell’s calm and detailed description seems to match the dignity and attitude that the dying elephant withhold as he was fighting against its pain to stand up. Orwell observes the scene in a fashion that conveys to the reader that he is accepting this inevitable tragedy. He could be trying to detach himself from the emotional burden with a nonchalant attitude, merely observing an ordinary scene as a writer, narrator.…

    • 654 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays