Preview

Comparison of Crucible and The Great Gatsby

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
462 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparison of Crucible and The Great Gatsby
Deanna O'Neal. Per1

Pride plays a crucial role in a man's life. It can sometimes be so important that it determines one's fate. The Great Gatsby is truly a story of love and war. "Man meets woman, they fall in love, the lose eachother, woman finds another man, and someone dies." The Crucible however, is a story of society and war against man. "Man is accused of an action, loses respect of the town, has to "protect" his family, (during time of Salem witch hysteria) someone does in the end. The death of these characters are partially based upon the result of their pride and love for others. In the novel Gatsby loved Daisy, he was also "in love" with her though they weren't together for so many years. They had met again, had an affair, and it all came to an end. Gatsby's pride and love for Daisy had led to his death. Of course Tom had contributed but, it was Gatsby who had taken the blame for Myrtle's death. In the book Gatsby would always go to extreme measures to satisfy Daisy, and when Myrtle was killed he took the blame just to protect her. In the Crucible, John Proctor was the character who was killed in the end. His pride wouldn't let him "admit" to conjuring spirits. He had to protect his "name" (reputation) and he had to protect his family. During that time if u were accused of "conjuring spirits" or "witch craft" you then become the worst kind of criminal, the kind that no one could trust, and your "name" was bad forever. John simply did not want to be known for that so his pride could not let him admit to such false "accusations". John and Gatsby are alot alike, being that they both died on the circumstances of protecting their pride, and loved ones. Gatsby was under different circumstances because he did not understand that it would cause death. Proctor was aware that he would face death. Gatsby was protecting Daisy, proctor was protecting his family. It was Gatsby's undying love, and hope for Daisy that

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Near the end of The Great Gatsby, everyone’s wrongs begin to come to light, but punishment varies. Gatsby, a character the novel attempts the reader to like, announces his love of Daisy and his intent to take her away from Tom. This leads to a series of events which include him being murdered by Wilson for killing his wife, while Daisy is actually responsible for that. Daisy, a character set up to be pitied by the reader, also plans to leave Tom for Gatsby, but she kills Myrtle and ends up getting Gatsby murdered instead. Forcing her to return to Tom. It is clear to see how the death of Myrtle is a defining moment for these characters, however, more is hidden in that. Tom, a character portrayed to be disliked, actually walks away victorious…

    • 314 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    works could be associated, one could associate any two works with a dead guy at…

    • 730 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He told them that he wanted to confess so then he live with his wife. "I want my life" (pg 884). They told him if I he confesses he will be safe and not be sentenced to hang. They asked him questions to get more information from him but he did not blame anyone else. "Mr. Proctor, have you seen the Devil in your life? Come man, there is light in the sky; the town waits at the scaffold; I would give out this news. Did you see the Devil?' ‘I did."(885). He is only confessing so then he can be with his and children again not to help them in the witch hunt. He is ashamed that he is lying to live when all of his friends have stuck to the truth and accepted death. "Man, you will hang! You cannot!' ‘I can. And there's your first marvel, that I can. You have made your magic now, for now I do think I see some shred of goodness in John Proctor." (884). He knows that if does sign this that his name will be plagued in the community for the rest of his life and he will not be able to raise his kids being known in the town as a coward. John accepts death with honor and meets a tragic…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gatsby and Daisy’s relationship was mainly just a fantasy created by Gatsby. Gatsby imagined this great life that he and Daisy would have together, when in reality, Daisy was married and could not leave her husband. When Gatsby and Daisy did get reunited, their love sparked again, but never took full effect because of Tom. The idea of “fake love” is also seen in George Wilson and Myrtle’s relationship. Although they were married, they did not have a true romantic relationship. George only married Myrtle because he did not try to make a better life for himself. George and Myrtle were on the same economic level and social class: poor. Wilson loved Myrtle to an extent, but he did not have a deep passion for her as Gatsby did for…

    • 608 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    THE GREAT GATSBY uses symbols to represent the hollowness of the upper class. East vs West is the first symbol he uses to make a separation between old and new rich. Another symbol are the unread books, which represents Gatsby as a fake; as a person who wants to show something he really isn’t. Daisy’s voice is the third symbol, and it represents the ambitious mind he had towards money. Money takes a fundamental role in the story, because thanks to it the characters change and become someone they really aren’t.…

    • 1015 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tom and Gatsby’s relationships with Daisy differ. Even though Gatsby has not seen Daisy in five years, he still loved her very much and stayed loyal the whole time. This shows that Gatsby loves Daisy so much that he would stay lonely and hopeful for years just for her. Gatsby never gave up hope during the time that they were apart. Tom has an affair on Daisy with Myrtle. This shows that Tom isn’t loyal to Daisy and he doesn’t put any effort into their relationship. Tom really uses Myrtle to satisfy one of his needs and Daisy to satisfy another. Gatsby was the only one willing to work and put effort towards him and Daisy while Tom took his and Daisy’s relationship for granted.…

    • 443 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Crucible and the Scarlet Letter are two old stories set in a middle age America that had many problems with its evolution including proclaimed witches. These stories represent the natural differences between society as a whole and the individual they either help or abandon. The Crucible focused on how an individual could never win against a society unless they get help from another society. The Scarlet Letter represents the difficulties of when a communityhas abandoned a person yet continue to connect with them. These stories give the contrast between the different lifestyles people have between these two worlds. People have a private and personal life that reflects themselves…

    • 665 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tom being prosperous, Myrtle felt as if because she is with him that he elevates her to high class. She felt better with Tom because he was important, therefore, with George she felt miserable. Myrtle’s American dream was to become a wealthy man’s trophy wife. For this reason, she has a strong desire for a powerful man to take care of her. Having to allow her money hungry mind to take over, she allows Tom to beat her. Able to play a wealthy woman’s rule being involved with Tom, she began to act like a snob. Later in the novel, George finds out that she is in an affair, but not with whom. In effect, he gets angry and locks her in their apartment over the garage he owns. Working sickly, George tries to make enough money to move out west to get her away from the city. Not respecting her husband’s decision, she tells him “Beat me! Throw me down and beat me you dirty little coward!” (144). She wants him to be aggressive and powerful like Tom, but he refuses. After having a heated discussion with George, she breaks out the apartment and rushes outside. Having seen Tom driving Gatsby’s yellow car earlier, she sees it coming and dashes out on the road towards it. Not being her lover, Gatsby turns the wheel in Daisy’s hands, and tries to swerve out of the way. Tragically being foolish, Myrtle runs in front of the car and gets hit. The blow from the car to her body ended her life. Not only did her death upset both George and Tom, but it also ended Gatsby’s life. After mourning over his wife, George went to Gatsby’s mansion and shot him in his swimming pool, and then took his own life. In the final analysis, because of her selfishness and greedy needs, she not only caused her own death, but also causes the death of an innocent…

    • 516 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Daisy was part of killing Myrtle, but Gatsby was the one who took the blame. Afterwards, Gatsby, who worried most about Daisy, checked for any commotion while Tom and Daisy sat at the kitchen table, but he could tell that “there was an unmistakable air of natural intimacy… and anybody would have said that they were conspiring together”(152-153). Fitzgerald describes Gatsby watching over Daisy to make sure she is alright, while she sits with her husband, contently, like nothing had ever happened. If she was innocent, she would have been honest about killing Myrtle instead of letting Gatsby take the blame.…

    • 869 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Daisy was responsible for Myrtle’s death, that he blamed Gatsby when George Wilson came to…

    • 344 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Act IV John Proctor is in court on the charges of being a witch. This shows that John Proctor will stand up for his friends and tell the truth about not being associated with the Devil, rather than lie and have his friends die. If John Proctor was not a man who stood up to his friends than he would lied and have all his friends die; instead he told the truth and died, while maintaining honor with his friends.This shows that John Proctor stands up for his friends because he will show people in the court that people being accused of witchcraft are being wrongfully accused; giving them a chance at surviving and not being hanged. If John Proctor wasn’t a good friend then he wouldn’t even try to help the women. In The Crucible John Proctor is portrayed as a man who stands up for his…

    • 696 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Crucible, written by Arthur Miller, is a play that takes place during a time period of the witch trials. The entire community is in pandemonium and certain characters are also fighting internal conflicts. Miller uses three characters that shows this internal battle : Abigail Williams, John Proctor who must weigh the importance of his family against his reputation and the Putnams.…

    • 538 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He fell in love with her as a young man and spends several years trying to make in to high society. Daisy comes from a wealthy family and she could never marry anyone below her. Gatsby knows this and has dedicated his entire life to becoming a successful and wealthy man to gain Daisy's acceptance. He throws lavish and expensive parties to see if Daisy will come to one of them. He buys an extravagant mansion across the river from Daisy's house just to be near her. When he finally is reunited with Daisy, it's as if they had never been separated and their love is still alive. Gatsby sees Daisy as he wants to see her: beautiful, innocent, and perfect. But in reality, Daisy has changed. She is now a wife and mother. At the end of the story Gatsby finally sees the true Daisy. He realizes that "her voice is full of money." Daisy is materialistic, fake, and not the kind of woman he wants her to be. Daisy was driving Gatsby's car when she hits and kills Myrtle. To protect Daisy and his dream, Gatsby does not turn Daisy in. Myrtle's husband kills Gatsby because he assumed it was Gatsby who hit his wife. Gatsby's demise comes from his destructive dream for Daisy's…

    • 1014 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In a book a character’s characteristics help to shape a story into a good plot whether their morals are good or bad. The two characters Mr. Jay Gatsby, from The Great Gatsby has characteristics that are comparable to the character Abigail Williams, from The Crucible. The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald is a book that talks about the “Roaring Twenties” and the social problems between the wealthy from a view of an outsider. While, The Crucible by Arthur Miller was about the Salem Witch Trials in 1692. In the books Mr. Gatsby and Abigail Williams both create their own realities, they are stubborn, they are both deeply in love with someone else, and they use their power to their advantage. While others believe that Mr. Gatsby and Sally Owens…

    • 896 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    courseworkgatsby

    • 1756 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Gatsby and Blanche are also victims of their own dreams, as their dreams are too unrealistic and they remain fixated on this dream. Gatsby remains fixated on attaining Daisy, she has married Tom but Gatsby and Daisy rekindle and continue to have an affair and this means that Gatsby achieves his dream. Blanche hopes to achieve romance and a new life but this proves pointless as Mitch (her lover) reveals he intended to go and rape her "I came here for something else, I 'm afraid". This is where the two characters differ as Gatsby has his dreams accomplished but his dreams led to his death and the death of another character, in this case Myrtle who is killed by Daisy driving Gatsby 's car. Blanche does…

    • 1756 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays