Preview

David Kerr's Argument Against Physician Assisted Suicide

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
342 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
David Kerr's Argument Against Physician Assisted Suicide
They stressed the importance of patient autonomy and noted that if physicians assist at birth, they should also have a role in assisting at death. Which is not a bad philosophy.
On the other hand, opponents of physician suicide argue it would violate the doctor's’ hippocratic oath to “do no harm.” But is making a patient lie in a hospital bed suffering actually not doing any harm? They also argue on a more religions moral that if you commit suicide, you are going to hell. Some individuals are not religious at all, and therefore would not care. Another viewpoint of opponents is they believe doctors will be given too much power if assisted suicide is made legal. However, there is a fallacy in that argument as well. Physician assisted suicide is completed by the patient. Meaning doctors would only be able to write the prescription. Not actually force the patient to take the medication.
…show more content…
In David Kerr’s- a cancer doctor of over 30 years- article A Physician’s Perspective on Assisted Suicide he states, “ I have come to understand the need, the duty, and the truth of having excellent end-of-life care. Throughout his article he explains how physician assisted suicide does not go against the hippocratic oath. Like much of the supporters, he examines how supplying the means to end one's life is better than not being compassionate, and making someone suffer for long periods of time. He believes the issue should be decided between the doctor and the patient, much like abortion. Dr. Kerr (2014) does make it clear that he is in favor of this treatment plan. He states, “I have seen enough suffering to last me 1,000 lifetimes. I have witnessed cases so severe, the patients would truly be better off

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Those who are for physician assisted suicide would argue that the patient’s pain and suffering would be saved. They would also argue that the patient should have the freedom to decide to die. They would also argue that the healthcare cost would be lowered, which would lower insurance premiums. The families pain and anger would be somewhat lessened by getting to say their final goodbyes to their loved one. Proponents could also argue that laws could be made to help prevent abuse of physicians just giving out the powerful medication to just anyone and still protect the value of human life. Vital organs could be harvested and saved, In turn saving the lives of many others. Opponents argued in contradiction of physician assisted suicide, they believe that it violates the Hippocratic Oath, they took when they first became physicians. They also argue that physician assisted suicide demeans the value of life in the patients. Opponents believe that physician assisted suicide is…

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The biggest reason to oppose physician-assisted suicide is that there is greater chance for abuses to happen. It is basically like putting fire into a paper bag, which cannot be controlled. After the lethal prescription is given to the patient, there is no guarantee that the patient is going to use it to commit suicide or if the patient is the one who is going to administer the prescription by his or her own will.…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As a doctor, you swear to an oath that is to provide lifesaving medical care and to try and extend life comfortably, the best way you can. In “Physician-Assisted Suicide Is Always Wrong” Ryan T. Anderson states why a physician assisting in a terminally ill patient’s death is ethically and morally wrong. This article that I chose was published on Newsweek on March 26, 2015, but first appeared on The Daily Signal. As the article describes what and how this particular approach works, it goes in great detail to explain why it should not even be an option for physicians.…

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Physicians who are in favor of Euthanasia state that to keep Euthanasia or assisted suicide illegal is violation of the patient freedoms. They believe that any competent terminally ill patient should have the right to choose death or refuse life-saving treatments. The U.S.Constution does not state that the government can keep a person from committing suicide. If Euthanasia was a right, patients could die with dignity and leave others with a positive memory and not what they had become. However, many physicians and medical staff have numerous reasons for prohibition the legalization of Voluntary Euthanasia. The main argument is the notation of the Hippocratic Oath that some doctors take by being part of a (PSA) and prescribing a lethal dosage of a drug could weaken the doctor-patient relationship because of the oath some doctors…

    • 2001 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many people have different opinions on Physician assisted suicide like if it is inhuman and if the illness can affect the patient's ability to make decisions.. Many people debate whether terminally ill patients should have the choice of suicide. Whether people think it is good or bad, many terminally ill patients do not want to suffer and feel they are being forced to die a slow and painful death.…

    • 485 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Hippocratic oath states “I will neither give a deadly drug to anybody who asked for it, nor will I make a suggestion to this effect.” (“Greek Medicine - The Hippocratic Oath." U.S National Library of Medicine. U.S. National Library of Medicine, n.d. Web. 29 Oct. 2016.) “The American Medical Association (AMA) policy states, "Physician-assisted suicide is fundamentally incompatible with the physician's role as a healer, would be difficult or impossible to control, and would pose serious societal risks.” (Pearson, John. "Point: Assisted Suicide Is Unnecessary." Points of View: Assisted Suicide (2016): 5. Points of View Reference Center. Web. 29 Oct.…

    • 697 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A patient should have the liberty of choosing to end their suffering. Although, it may see has an extreme option, is an option the patient should have the right. However, some doctor think that Physician-Assisted Suicide goes against the oath they made. According to the article” Doctor-Assisted Suicide Pros and Cons List”, one of the con of this practice is “Violates the Hippocratic Oath”. Which was that every life is sacred, therefore, commanding respect. So, just because the patients give permission, doesn’t make killing right. Still, by respecting the patient’s wishes and taking him/her out of his/her misery, the doctor is respecting their life. Physician-Assisted Suicide helps the patients in many different ways like being prepare or ending their suffering. Physician-assisted Suicide helps them retain their dignity. Terminally ill, coma, or mentally competent patients are suffering every day. For some, the pain is so much, that they don’t consider themselves “living”. Physician-assisted suicide help patients properly said goodbye to their love ones at their own pace and at their own comfort. It gives them the opportunity to be surrounded by the people they love and the things they love. An article called “Doctor-Assisted Suicide Pros and Cons List” by Nyln.org, it stated that “Physician-Assisted Suicide makes grief easier to handle” (Nyln). Since, everyone its inform of the patient’s…

    • 904 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Most people would agree that the right of a competent, terminally ill person to avoid any unnecessary excruciating pain seems as though it should be a basic human right. To have someone go through more suffering than absolutely necessary seems as though it would fall under the description of an inhumane act, and frankly an injustice against the basic human right of bodily autonomy and integrity. Due to these almost undeniable arguments, physician assisted suicide, in many cases, is seen as a basic human right that we need to be granted access to. Activists argue that it is simply an additional choice that we will be able to make, and that it will surely never be pushed onto anybody or used sinisterly (Maynard 2014). Although this claim is something that we cannot be entirely sure of, as I have continued to research the pros and cons behind physician assisted suicide, I have come to the conclusion that in many cases it truly does seem that the legalization of physician assisted suicide is the best option for everyone involved. It is a means to cease any unnecessary suffering that a person may be going though, and provides a sense of comfort for them during a time in their lives where they are not given many choices besides to deal with what they are going through and try to survive. Additionally, with many of the extreme medical advancements of the 20t century, our goals have been clouded by the quest to…

    • 1407 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    1). Physicians have sworn an oath which does not allow them to take part in the killing of people. Individuals against euthanasia believe that physicians should not take part in directly causing death because they will not be able to keep it under control. Euthanasia would never be legalized without regulations and controls in place. If euthanasia were legalized then doctors would not be breaking any oaths or laws. Physicians are knowledgeable professionals who can provide their patients with all of the information needed to make an informed decision. Physicians should be treated with respect and not judged when they have not done nothing for you to think otherwise. The option of euthanasia would only be given to those who are terminally ill so that they can make their own decision and not prolong suffering and pain for themselves and their families. Gibson explains that “human life is sacred and it is wrong to kill another human” (2008, para. 3). Those against euthanasia believe that it devalues human life and we should only “[do] unto others as we would have others do unto us” (Gibson, 2008, para. 7). Euthanasia gives patients the freedom and respect to make one final decision in their life when they are not able to make any others. This actually shows that they value their life enough to not suffer unnecessarily. They want other to remember them when they were happy and not in pain. Euthanasia can also give patients a chance to donate organs which again shows that they really do value human…

    • 991 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    British moral philosopher, Bernard Williams once said, “Man never made a material as resilient as the human spirit” (Williams). Here Williams tells of the insurmountable human spirit. Through all hardships the will to live prevails, rising above the forces of evil. In the anthology Nine Stories each character has to overcome and cope with evil. From absentee parents, to coping with the effects of war, many of the characters are able to rise above their struggle and continue living with hope.…

    • 2347 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Have you ever known someone that was in so much pain or was so weak that they couldn’t even speak? Many people have. Stephan. "Agree: Physician Assisted Suicide says” Allowing physician assisted suicide would lessen the pain and enable some terminally ill patient’s fairer treatment. Horrible pain and suffering that some patients must endure prior to death could be done away with. Instead of a dragged out death that puts burdens on family members, families could say their goodbyes at a specified time.” It may seem like a horrible thing to say but if you think about it, it is not completely misguided. People around the world are crying because they’re in so much anguish and can’t do…

    • 523 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    When their loved-one passes away, the family would have to struggle with huge hospital bills and possibly large amounts of debt. It is hard for families to see their relatives on a feeding tube and hooked up to other machines to be able to breath. This pain could be lessened if the patient chose physician-assisted suicide because families would be able to say their final goodbyes. “By allowing patients to have this option, we can reduce health care costs, which could potentially lower insurance premiums” (“Crocker”, 2013). It is not necessary to spend thousands of dollars on hospital bills on patients who want to end their suffering. Another reason is doctors and nurses working at the hospital would have more time to work on other patients. This would allow them to save more lives for people who had a higher chance of living and surviving. There is a shortage of medical staff in our country and doctors should spend more of their time to patients that do not want to die immediately. This could also be beneficial to doctors because they could save vital organs of a person going through physician-assisted suicide that could be given to other patients in need. “We have a shortage of organs in this country and there are long waiting lists for organs such as kidneys, hearts, and…

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Even though many believe that Physician assisted suicide should be legalized because it allows one to make their own choice of when to die, as well as dying with dignity. It also allows better care because of all the rules and regulations. Doctors also need to learn to handle the fact that they helped someone die. That is something that can be difficult to accept and sometimes gets to be too much for the doctor to handle. They also need to be able to handle the situation…

    • 1974 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Those in favor of physician-assisted suicide argue that the patients that seek it as a viable option do so because their disease is beyond treatment and other options do not preserve their dignity and right to a peaceful death. In choosing physician assisted suicide, the patient maintains control over their final days and even hours on this earth. They can prepare themselves and their loved ones for their death and knowing when it will happen can often provide a sense of peace. (Cite info in favor of pas here)…

    • 1087 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    My opinion of the issue of physician assisted suicide is that it is wrong in any form to take a life before God or nature says it is time to go. Through our modern era of technological advances to various diseases and illnesses, we can live longer today than before. These advances have made life a little more comfortable to deal with medical condition than in recent years. I believe that if medical professionals get into the business of killing patients will affect public opinion of the medical profession. The medical profession is held to a high standard in public; we go them for advice and treatment of a medical condition. When we set into this situation of asking them to end of life because of the pain and suffering, we are asking the public to decrease the confidence in the medical profession. Another reason we should not get involved in this issue is that there are areas where physician assisted suicide can be abused. Patients could be forced into choosing death over treatments from the doctor or other medical professionals, which can go against the family wishes. The final and most important reason is that taking a life in any form is an act of committing immortal treatment toward a person.…

    • 884 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays