Preview

Differences Between Female Japanese and English Mill Workers

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
427 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Differences Between Female Japanese and English Mill Workers
Mark Carrillo
4/12/10
Differences Between Female Japanese and English Mill Workers Despite the fact that Japan and England had many similarities with female mill workers, they still had a few differences. They basically had young children and women working in big dangerous factories making thread or in mines. So how were their experiences different? Female Japanese workers had to work more, they got paid less, and they accepted the role that their society gave them. Compared to English women mill workers, Japanese women worked more. English female workers only worked about 74 hours a week and Japanese female workers worker 91 hours a week (Document 5). This was because the Japanese workers worked longer each day, had less holidays, and worked on weekends (Document 8). English female workers had more breaks, worked shorter hours each day, and did not work on weekends. This is a big difference between female English and Japanese mill workers. Even though in both England and Japan women got pair less than men, Japanese women got paid even less than English women. This is a reason why they had so many workers. Since they paid them less they would be able to hire more workers and increase their production rate. Even though they got paid less, it was for the same reason. Why would they want to pay women less? They paid women less because the women needed money and they would accept any amount given to them (Document 8). Japan and England have different ways they treat women and because of that the Japanese women accepted almost everything they went through in the mills. In Japan the women were treated a little less fairly. Japanese women were more willing to accept their role in society because they couldn’t do much about it (Document 8).This is the reason that female Japanese mill workers got low pay and worked more hours. In their society the men were respected more and had more freedom. Female Japanese workers had to work more, they got paid less, and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    According to the chart in Japan 1892 “Average daily wage of a female silk factory worker is only 13 Sen.” (Doc C) female workers get paid only 13 sen a day. this amount of paid was not enough for a living because at that time a pair of ladies indoor sandals already costs 7 Sen. It is just not right to pay the workers with so little money, especially when the workers spend all their day in the horrible factory conditions working . A survey of the Japanese Silk Worker “70% said the pay was good and 0% said it was poor, overall experience 90% said it was positive.” (Doc F) . Almost everyone said the pay was decent and none of the workers were complaining about the wages. This document is not reliable because as a young female worker , no one would want to work in a harsh condition with low wages especially when you have no choice but agree to work.With all these conditions, it benefits more for the factories rather than outweigh the cost of the female workers because the factories hiring female workers would be better for them because female’s wages are lower than men but they still able to provide the same amount of work as men…

    • 1160 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    From document 5 one can see that female workers in England worked around seventy four hours a day. With a break for breakfast and dinner, and did not work on Sundays. One can also see that Japanese female workers worked much more than those in England. They worked ninety one hours with short breaks and no weekends. Sometimes even longer depending on how busy the factory was. This document shows that female mill workers in England worked much less than those in Japan. From document 6, one can see that the men that are working in these mills in England are making much more than the female workers. The point of view from document 6 is that men are making more money than women. Document 7 shows that the women in England are making one third less than what men are making. Document 8 shows that female mill workers in Japan are making less than half of what the men are making. Document 7 and 8 both show that the point of view is that female mill workers are making better wages than the Japanese workers. Document 9 shows what the Female mill workers could buy in England with their wages compared to those in Japan. The amount of food a Female mill worker in England makes is substantially higher than that in Japan. A female mill worker in England can buy 24 servings of oats in an hour, compared to Japanese mill workers who can only buy ten servings of rice an hour. Showing that Female…

    • 917 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cotton Industry Dbq Essay

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Poor conditions and low pay developed for workers in both countries, especially in japan. Girls were forced to work late in confined space and pay was sparse, on top of that sickness was common and some died from diseases spread in the factories (doc.3). However despite low pay, factory jobs were important for many lower class or farmer families. Many would send their children to work in the factories to provide extra income to their family (doc.4). Also factory jobs provided an escape from those same lower class strata’s for the girls who went to work as they became responsible for themselves and weren’t held back forced to provide for an entire family (doc. 5). This same effect was true in India where the vast majority of workers were recruited from small rural farming villages (doc.9). These similarities are clearly defined as inherent aspects of industrialization in a non-industrialized…

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When looking at the difference at the backgrounds from female workers from Japan and England the show few similitarities between these two areas. In Document #1 England of Japan (Maps), the point of view of this document is that it shows a current map to compare the similar size of the two countries; they both are small island nations. Document #2 Mill Workers: Two Visuals, point of view from this document shows that the two pictures show that life in a factory or mill may seem all nice and clean, but as proof from the other documents shows this is not so. They give the deception of the mills and factories being too good to be true. These pictures also show the majority of female workers, with minimal male interaction. One can infer from the deception that these are advertisements for factories in different areas. A few additional documents that would help better explain the background of the experiences of female workers; One would be a bigger map that shows the entire world, and one that shows real photos of the factories that are not staged or propaganda. Through these two documents we can see that even though there are numerous differences between the female workers in the island nations of Japan and England, there are still a few similarities.…

    • 1922 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Workers were more satisfied with how they were treated in Japan while Russia dealt with strikes because of poor working conditions. In document 4, S. I. Somov, a Russian socialist, recalls his participation in a strike. Being a socialist, it is easy to comprehend why Somov would sympathize with the workers and strike and even join them. He describes how the workers stated various phrases over and over again. The workers were on strike because they ran out of patience, and that their suffering was worse than death. These factory workers must have been treated extremely poorly for them to go on strike. In document 5, Yamamoto Shigemi, a historian, interviews elderly Japanese women who worked in silk factories. In Shigemi's survey, most workers voted favorably when asked about their food or pay and not a single one regretted going to work in a silk factory. A survey pool of 580 is enough to justify the notion that these conditions were similar throughout multiple factories in Japan, and that most factory workers were conent in how they were treated at the time. In document 7, M. I. Pokzocskaya, a Russian physicion, published an article about the treatment of womem in Russian factories. Women were required to work extremely long hours, up to 18 on some days. Actual physical force was also used to make children continue working. Women factory workers were treated as if they…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cotton Industry Dbq

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages

    There is a chart (Doc 7) that compares the amount of female cotton textile workers in Japan and India. It shows that over three-fourths were women in Japan, and less than one-fourth of Indian laborers were women. Another way this document helps show the difference of workers between Japanese and Indian textile factories is that in Japan the percent of women workers slightly increases over the years 1920-1930. In India, the percent of female workers from 1909-1934 decreases, meaning women didn’t work as much in factories. Because India was so patriarchal the women’s job was to stay home and take care of the house. Document 4 is a written concern about how there are many women working in Japanese textile mills. Documents 8 and 10 both consist of a picture from a Japanese cotton mill (Doc 8), and an Indian textile mill (Doc 10). The Japanese mill (Doc 8) illustrates a couple of women working and two or three men just sitting there (most likely supervising.) However in difference to Japan, the Indian mill (Doc 10) shows only male workers, this helps prove that more men worked than women in Indian textile mills. One should approach document 8 with caution because the source seems to be unreliable. The photo is from and official company history, meaning the picture was most likely staged to make it look like a superior place to…

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Traditional works days were 12-14 hours long and the working condition were terrible. The work itself was arduous however they did not receive the respective compensation. Women were exploited for cheap labor and were paid unfairly, often getting paid a meager 8 dollars a week. Many didn’t know what their wages were and succumb to accept anything that was given to aid their families: “At present, no consumer however enlightened and conscientious can know the varying wages paid” (Florence Kelly, Journal of the Political Economy). Florence Kelley believe women had to get paid an adequate wages as they had children to look…

    • 1242 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cotton Industry Dbq

    • 886 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In Japan, they had a higher percentage of workers who were women than in India. During the 1920 the percentage of Female cotton workers was eighty percent which increased to eighty point sixty percent in the year 1930. In India their percentage in the year 1909 was a twenty-two point one percent which decrease to eighteen point nine in the year 1934 (Doc.7). While Japans use of female cotton workers increased in India their female cotton workers decreased. Furthermore, the female workers in the cotton industries of Japan often were young girls who were sent from families to help them survive. They would always work from morning till dark; however their first year working they did not get payed till their second year and so forth. Unlike India, in Japan, the cotton workers would get an increase in their pay each year starting off with 35 yen (Doc.3). Last, mostly in India their workers had to work standing up and weaving using the machines. In Japan, they were capable of sitting down and weave using machines or…

    • 886 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Europe, women were responsible for certain activities and were also treated with respect, while in Japan, they were entirely serving men. The European women were expected to stay home and be trained in household chores, such as farming or sewing, and they didn’t have an option to chose who they want to marry. On the other hand, the Japanese women held a more equal status as Japanese men. For example, the Japanese women were allowed to inherit part of their family’s estate and some women even became Samurais. The use of a feudal system in Japan affected their women by becoming more equal, while in Europe, they were only valued for their work and what they did. Women enjoyed a higher role and status in Japan at the time, due to the feudal…

    • 645 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Have you ever gotten made fun of or discriminated for something that you believe in that everyone else does not? I grew up as a vegetarian. I used to get ridiculed repeatedly for not acting “manly” because I did not eat meat. This memory reminds me of the two heartbreaking stories about the migrant workers who were taken advantage of, and the poor Japanese Americans falsely thought as terrorists. There are many similarities between the Mexican migrant workers and the Japanese people, while there are just as many differences between them as well.…

    • 453 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    As men left their factory jobs to go fight in World War II (WWII), women stepped into their jobs to produce the heavy machinery needed for war and at home to keep the country running. An excerpt from the book The Life and Times of Rosie the Riveter spoke of a young machinist, Celia Saparsteen Yanish, and the transition that women had to make into their jobs doing “men’s work.” Before the war, this country was battling an unemployment problem brought on by the Great Depression. The start of WWII erased this problem, as increased production was needed to produce war supplies and goods necessary during a time of war. Because men were both working and fighting in the war, there were more jobs available than could be filled by men. As new employment opportunities became available,…

    • 1283 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    POSITIVE: The increase in education opportunities for Japanese girls ultimately allowed them to question the status quo and strive to make further changes to better their situation. The Meiji reforms saw widespread changes to the education system by making it accessible to all. This created intense competition for placement in academic schools offering good prospects for entry into a noted university and ultimately enhancing employment opportunities and chances of success, in turn reflecting positively on the ie. NEGATIVE: In traditional society, the ie. had the role of instilling cultural values, whereas in modern Japan, the education system is now charged with that task, teaching junior students the importance of continuity and group identity within a hierarchical context. POSITIVE: Such increased education opportunities for girls gave them the necessary tools to reinforce the ideal of equality of the sexes, introduced by the post WWII democracy, written in the Japanese constitution in form of voting rights and equal opportunity employment, ultimately leading to a dramatic change in the status of women. Statistics also show that one third of Japanese women are entering institutions of higher education and re-entering the workforce as their children enter school. NEGATIVE: On the contrary, some within Japanese society consider such changes to be…

    • 1023 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    We see a technological upgrade in Japan’s military as well as a brand new Constitution. This constitution states that “ all people are equal under the eyes of the law”. Many countries have started a constitution similar to this, and it was a great step into the future. The Japanese take a full turn in the opposite direction they were a hundred years ago, and went from being 100% anti Western, to being totally influenced by the Western Society. Japan becomes an industrial power due to there being many new factories and the production of silk rocketing. There are now new schools, higher education, yet women were still seen as unequal.…

    • 405 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The work day for both these nationalities consisted of the same unreasonableness and unfairness. In England (In Document E), women had horrendous working hours. On weekdays work in a factory work begin at 5:30 am and finish at 8 pm which is a total of 14 hours and 30 minutes. Then in Japan, a work day would start at 4:05 am until 7:30 pm, for a total of 14 hours and 20 minutes. Also to add on to the burden of being exhausted, women were treated unequally when it came to wages. For example (In Document F), a female worker in England questions her wage when she notices that her youngest child makes more than her. She makes a total of 2 shillings a week while her child makes 2 shillings and 6 pence. This inequality also affects the working women of Japan. Japanese males and females work identical jobs, but (In Document H) there is a difference…

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In fact, equal opportunity for women came over twenty years after the United States introduced it (Strober and Chan 1999: 3). Since 1960, the number of employed women in Japan has increased. Women seeking employment were often not welcome in the workplace. If they did get hired for a job, they received much less on-the-job training due to the fact that they were expected to leave their jobs once they got married or had children (Strober and Chan 1999: 8). For this reason, women in Japan occupy the clerical positions in big companies, and are referred to as Office Ladies. There is not much training that is needed for these jobs, therefore not much is lost in the eyes of the company if a woman decides to leave. By 1995, over twenty million women were employed in the workforce (Ogasawara 1998: 17,…

    • 1229 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics