Preview

Differences Between Melba Beals And Sophie Scholl

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
651 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Differences Between Melba Beals And Sophie Scholl
Facing and responding to conflict can be very difficult. Melba Beals and Sophie Scholl faced extreme segregation and peer pressure that made them both want to give up on their goals and beliefs, but they stood strong and did not give in. Melba and Sophie both stood for what they believed in at school even when they were looked down upon and hated. The greatest response to conflict is standing up for what is right, what an individual believes in, and standing strong in difficult times, and this is what Melba and Sophie did when they faced peer pressure and segregation.
When Sophie was 14 years old, she had believed that Hitler would make Germany great. At a young age, Sophie thought of her own ideas and thoughts about politics in Germany. Her teachers, who taught and brought up “Hitler Youth”, strongly disapproved Sophie’s thoughts on this. Sophie had often held herself to high standards, claiming, "We all have this yardstick inside ourselves, but it just isn't sought enough. Maybe because it is the most difficult yardstick”.
…show more content…
Later on, teachers pressured and threatened many students to join “Hitler Youth”. “Henry Metelmann’s teacher criticized a boy who held out. "You see, all your friends in class have become members," said the teacher. "Surely so many cannot be wrong in their choice while you are the only one who is right. Remember they are all determined to help the Fuhrer." (Baroletti paragraph 15) Sophie was cast out and looked down upon in school because she refused to join Hitler Youth since she believed in what was right. By standing strong in what you believe in and not giving up even when you are all alone, is a amazing way to respond to

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    According to famous author and Holocaust survivor Alan Grantz, “I shook with helpless and rage, but also with fear. This was what fighting back earned you. More abuse. More death. Half a dozen of Jews would be murdered today because one man refused to die without a fight.”…

    • 944 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Context: In Germany, where Hitler rules, the Huberman’s have adopted a nine-year-old girl named Liesel Meminger. Due to Hitler’s ant-Semitism campaigns, Max Vandenburg had gone for help to the Huberman’s to avoid discrimination and torture in camps, where the Jews were put in. Max felt he had caused the Huberman’s…

    • 1692 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Also, the peer pressure made the students become more active in the Hitler Youth because they think that everyone is doing it so they should also do it. In paragraph 15 Henry Metelmann's teacher said, "'You see, all your friends in class have become members... ' Surely so many cannot be wrong in their choice while you are the only one who is right...' " The teacher is trying to get the kid to become active in the Hitler Youth by saying that everyone else is doing it, so it must be right.…

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Swing Kids

    • 2759 Words
    • 12 Pages

    Peter and his friend Thomas, who was from a well-to-do family, decided one afternoon to "lift" a radio that one of the Nazis had taken from a "traitor" and had given to a "lady-friend." Peter was unable to escape the police, and as a result was told the only way to avoid punishment was to join the HJ (Hitler Jugend or Hitler's Youth, which prepared young boys for further advancement within the National Socialist party). Being a good friend, Thomas joined also; he said "We can't let them split us apart." However, over the course of their training, Thomas went through a change. He began to believe the Nazi propaganda about German superiority, and how everyone else "doesn't belong."…

    • 2759 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    And in fact, many historians have been fairly comfortable to do so. But Christopher Browning’s account of the factors that encouraged regular Germans to take part in Hitler’s hideous plan reveals something of great importance where an event like the Holocaust is concerned. His Ordinary Men seeks to shift perspective away from the notion that those predisposed toward the behavior that perpetrated this greatest of human tragedies were inhuman and accustomed to operating in fashions more sociopathic than militarily appropriate. In doing so, he sets a sizable challenge for himself. Truly, there is no way to address why the German people participated in without elaborating upon some of the most unspeakable acts committed in modern history. To that end, Ordinary Men takes its readers through some difficult narratives that reveal brutal, amoral behaviors that would imply a society impoverished of intellectual, ethical or academic development to that point. Moreover, the base and vile nature of the war crimes committed against a people unprepared to defend themselves and presenting no legitimate antagonism to its aggressor, suggests that the German people themselves were inherently bad people, inclined toward acts of evil and…

    • 1712 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    If we forget, then this event will happen again, so we will not forget so that the event won’t happen again. In this essay, I will be finding sources in the stories The Diary of Anne Frank: A play, Nobel Prize Acceptance Speech, and Parallel Journeys. I will argue that Stand Up and Don’t Forget is the best way of responding to conflict because you will remember and you will not forget it.…

    • 493 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In 2012, it was estimated that more than 172 million people were affected by conflict worldwide. The effect of so many people being affected by conflicts is a way to respond to them. With all the conflicts in the world, people need to be able to respond and react to these conflicts in the best possible way. People can best respond to conflict by believing in what they think is right and persevering through everything against them, so they can show what is morally right, let nothing hold them back, and help others with the same issue along the way. During times of conflict, it is important for people to choose a side they believe in, so they can show what they think is right.…

    • 1168 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    All But My Life Analysis

    • 1298 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The desire for power, fear, and self-preservation can cause people to change in ways one could not imagine. In the story, Night by Elie Wiesel, and Gerda Weissman Klein’s All But My Life, the authors share their tragic experiences from their times in Nazi concentration camps. In Addition, Klein’s All But My Life shows her experience in many different concentration camps for three years and how differently female inmates were treated than male. In Wiesel’s Night, he discusses his experience of being sent to Auschwitz along with his father for a year and how the tragedies he endured transformed his character. In Addition, Klein’s All But My Life shows her experience in many different concentration camps for three years and how differently female…

    • 1298 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Holocaust and war was no joking matter. Millions were executed both intentionally and unintentionally. Men, women, husbands, wives, parents, grandparents, and children; The SS didn’t care. Nor did the Poles, Germans, or anyone at all for that matter. Nobody cared about the “dirty Jews”, the “filthy dogs”, or the “swine dogs”. There were so many insults that it’s impossible to name them all. People were malnourished, lonely, and hopeless. This torture was part of the everyday life of a young man named Lucek Salzman (George Lucius Salton). This boy lost his parents at age 14 and his brother at age 15. He was beaten, he had paint poured over him, his latter was kicked by a German soldier (this ended up causing him to have an infected leg). What this man went through as a child was brutal, but the fascinating part is that he never gave up and he knew that he had a chance. Lucek Salzman had hope in the end.…

    • 2118 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Have you ever stopped to think about how fortunate you are and how facile survival is for you? Survival means to manage to stay alive in any situation using whatever methods required to maintain yourself alive. Today, there are numerous people who have to survive by escaping their homes because of wars occurring there, such as the Syrian refugees. They abandon their homes and almost all of their possessions in order to survive the situation and start their lives anew somewhere else.The Holocaust was a terrible moment in time where millions of Jews and other groups of people were massacred purely because of their beliefs. Under Adolf Hitler’s rule, Nazi Germany slaughtered a countless amount of Jews because he thought that they had committed crimes against them in the past. Two examples of young girls who endured the Holocaust were Anne Frank and Krystyna Chiger, who entered hiding because of the Nazi persecution. Both of these girls were forced to use similar yet diverse survival skills to be able to stay alive during this period of time.…

    • 1283 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Perils Of Indifference

    • 1250 Words
    • 5 Pages

    It takes a lot of courage to stand up to one person, but it takes true bravery to stand up against a whole country of people. “The White Rose” is a story about three teenagers who realized what Hitler was doing to the Jewish people and decided it was time for someone to take a stand. Hans and Sophie Scholl, along with their friend Christoph Probst, decided to make a leaflet to expose Hitler’s malevolent ways. They believed, “It was the duty of the citizen, even in times of war, to stand up against an evil regime, especially when it is sending hundreds of thousands of its citizens to their deaths.”(pg. 82) They knew it was essential for citizens to stand up because they were the only ones who could make the situation better. The suffering people can not stand up to their enemy without help from others, and as one nation it is our duty to help take down evil. The teens were eventually caught and arrested, then sentenced to death for treason. Even though they perished while doing it, these three teens are just one example of citizens who stood up to indifference, and won the battle. They knew how dangerous it would be to stand up to Hitler, but that did not stop them from being an exponent for the Jews. They exposed Hitler to numerous German citizens and got the ones who agreed with them to come out of their shell and stand up too. The story of “The White Rose” shows that if citizens do not do their job…

    • 1250 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Our Secrets

    • 2135 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The holocaust, an event that has been debated upon for many years, lead to the death of millions of innocent people. It was an incident that was planed quite well, secretly. Evil people, you might call them, who do not deserve to be remembered. How is it that a countless number of people were involved in the holocaust and barely any people attempted to put a stop to it? Can an entire society be anti-Semitic? Can an entire society coincidentally be that ignorant? But really, it is these people that we must remember so that a massive destructive event like the Holocaust does not occur ever again in history. Susan Griffin’s essay Our Secret looks at the minds of various people, focusing the most on Heinrich Himmler. It is hard to deny that he is an awful man for what he did, but it is so easy for people to simply judge without knowing the facts behind his madness. Many may not realize this, but who we are today goes back to how we were raised as a child and who we had to look up to. Just as Himmler’s tough life reminded Griffin of her self-experiences, I myself began to think of my own observations in my own house. Writing this essay, I would like to take the chance to point out what could lead a person to being the adult they are today, and who my own brother could possibly grow up to be someday in the future.…

    • 2135 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Empty Love is a relationship based on commitment, lacking any intimacy or passion. An example of Empty Love is a couple staying in a marriage or relationship for the "sake of the children;" Empty Love is characterized by a lack of emotional warmth or heat of passion where partners tolerate each other because of a false sense of duty, obligation, or fear of change.…

    • 588 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In ten years I’ll be 27 , so I will already be out of college and probably married and have 2 kids . The college I plan on going to is UCA (university of central Arkansas) . I want to go to college to become a nurse and help disabled kids . After I get done with that my goal is complete with college.…

    • 238 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Script of Dev. D

    • 3070 Words
    • 13 Pages

    vkt ?kj is rq>s fNRrj iM+us okays gS----- yky & yky VqYys ysdj ?kwesxk dy-----He stops eating.…

    • 3070 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays