‘Flaming’ (hostile and insulting interactions between internet users) is not illegal. Online speech is protected by the United States Supreme Court’s 1995 decision in McIntyre V. Ohio Elections Commission which protects anonymous online speech and of course the First Amendment to the United States Constitution which protects freedom of speech. Keen asks “Is today’s law adequately protecting us” (Keen 69)
Take the case of 13 year old Megan Meir, a troubled teenage girl who ended up committing suicide over being told by a fictitious person that ‘… the world would be a better place without you.’ Now this would seem to make a strong case for better laws against the so called “Cyber-Bullying” and perhaps it is, but for someone to take words, harmful as the intent behind them may have been, so literally, to me this indicates a much deeper problem.
Self published content such as message boards and other web pages have made the legal debate on anonymous users even more difficult. Keen cites the case of Dr Lisa Krinsky, a Miami, FL based president of a drug corporation who filed suit against her anonymous flamers on a Yahoo message board. This of course begs the question, if someone is believing everything they read on the internet does it really matter what they think?
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
In his article "Douse the Online Flamers" published in the LA Times in 2008, Andrew Keen discusses 3 major court cases in an effort to show just how backwards the legal system is when dealing with the anonymous people of the internet. People on the internet can ruin anyone's reputation or even their life without the fear of prosecution.…
- 381 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In “Douse the Online Flamers” Andrew Keen writes about individuals who choose to hide behind a façade in cyber crime. He goes on to speak of the unlawful acts inflicted upon innocent individuals of cyber space. Keen reflects on three major cases where cyber criminals are protected under the freedom of speech act while the innocent are left vulnerable. In all three cases, the judges failed the victims of unidentified slander. In his article, Keen forcefully expresses his opinion on why he believes we, as Americans, should take a stand against the anonymity of today’s internet tormenters because too many innocent lives are destroyed due to the cruel intentions of anonymous speech.…
- 428 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The World Wide Web was created far enough back for me not to care about the specific date. It is a great asset for school, work, and general entertainment. But, with all good things there are some negatives as well. The online, once was a new place of discovery, is now a place of caution with danger lurking around the corner. Lori Andrews writes about the privacy issues of the web in her essay, “George Orwell…Meet Mark Zuckerburg.” Already, in her title she emphasizes Orwell’s rational fear of “Big Brother” is happening now on Zuckerburg’s social media site, Facebook. It is not just Facebook that has fallen to data aggregators invading the privacy of anyone online. Peggy Orenstein also discusses online privacy issues in her essay, “Just between…
- 235 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
There are many problems that can result from postings on the Internet. These range from humiliation to unfounded accusations and more. In her essay “The Flip Side of Internet Fame,” Jessica Bennett details problems that some people have experienced as a result of postings that others have made. She describes problems that happen because some websites permit anonymous posts. She also gives examples from the past that show some of the histories of public shaming. Bennett wants people to be aware of these problems, to understand why they are difficult to prosecute, and that they can remain online for a long time.…
- 934 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The World Wide Web was created far enough back for most people not to care about the specific date. It is a great asset for school, work, and general entertainment. But, with all the good things it brings, there are some negatives as well. The internet, once a new place of discovery, is now a place of caution with danger lurking around every corner. Lori Andrews writes about the privacy issues of the web in her essay, “George Orwell…Meet Mark Zuckerburg.” Already, in her title she emphasizes Orwell’s rational fear of “Big Brother” is happening now on Zuckerburg’s social media site, Facebook. It is not just Facebook that has fallen to data aggregators invading the privacy of anyone online. Andrews describes data aggregators as people or companies…
- 1630 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
However, that logic is missed by bullies who continue to torment their victims. It’s bad, because it causes many ill effects, the worst being depression. Depression can lead to suicide. And, DoSomething reports that the effects of cyberbullying make victims 2 to 9 times more likely to consider committing suicide than usual. Aside from depression, bullying makes the victim have a lower self-esteem, more likely to skip or quit school or work, make students receive poor grades, and push the victims towards alcohol and drugs (“11 Facts About Cyberbullying”). These types of effects should be avoided for how badly they affect people’s…
- 498 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Bullying obviously didn't start's on the internet. However, it has become a huge problems with every new technological innovation. User names and a computer screen may makes some users feel invincible and its hard to relay emotion through internet conversation cyberbullies are known for sending harmful and hurtful messages along with extreme cases of lies. Most of…
- 1626 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
4.) To what is known as our world, yet is influenced most of all by the cyber world. To be free and express what we think and believe it’s a delicate topic to talk about, since we don’t all think in the same way. We criticize and even offend our fellow man; this comes to affect them emotionally. On the internet, we are all free to do whatever we decide to do, not caring about our morals, there are occasions in which it leads to humiliate people in the cruelest ways, as symbols of entertainment. As in my opinion, the limit is the humiliation or culpability to innocents. There isn’t much control for these situations; just like it is said by Jim Gohem, “the internet is a loose cannon”.…
- 320 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Every day,thousands of people log onto the internet.There has been much discussion on whether or not individuals should be prosecuted for statements made on social media.Individuals should not be prosecuted for statements made on the internet.While some may argue that people should be charged with fines or even going to jail for making online assertions,there is little evidence to support this.It can infringe upon the First Amendment right,it can discourage children to learn about personal responsibility,and there has been a decrease number of cyberbullying.…
- 393 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
What the author does is he lists three people, all of whom practice the highest level of internet security. They are fugitives hiding from the cyber police. The point I assume he is trying to make is that even if you practice this extreme level of anonymity, you can, and will, still be tracked. So, as a normal user of the internet, if I wanted to stay anonymous, there are ways to circumvent it, but in the end, there is no way of being unseen. This is worrying to a point, and it is why this essay is intriguing to me because I feel like there should be an easier way to stay under the radar.…
- 591 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
According to the fourth annual study on Civility in America: A Nationwide Survey, conducted by global public relations firm Weber Shandwick “for the first time since the survey began in 2010 the Internet/social media has risen into the top ranks of perceived causes of incivility. Of those who expect civility to worsen in the next few years, 34 percent blame Twitter – a significant rise from 2012.”(Shandwick 1) Cyber bullying has become a large issue in the U.S. In Amanda Todd’s video my story: Struggling, bullying, suicide, self-harm, on YouTube is a horrible example of cyber bullying. When she was in the 7th grade, Amanda met a man in an online chat room who talked her into flashing him her breasts. A year later, the man contacted her on Facebook and asked her to 'put on a show ' for him. He threatened to release a picture of her to everyone she knew if she did not. Amanda’s pictures were released and went viral. Other kids at her school saw the pictures and started…
- 1051 Words
- 5 Pages
Powerful Essays -
I think this is a way to show these people who anonymity are cowardice because they don't want other to know their name. If they have the courage, they will occupy their own name to spread the gossip. In the middle of the page, it said” there are few legal means to compel Web sites to police message boards” (220). The author later mention” now some lawmakers are saying those protection are too bored” (220). In this quote is show that victims don't have any right to sue the people talk about him. In addition, since the law is too bored, people cannot trace who are the one to spread the gossip. According to my experience, a lot of people that spread gossip are mostly people who are afraid to be responsible. For example Simon, who is my friend, was always afraid to say something against people he hate in front of them. Because of his lack of baroness, he chooses to hide his name to avoid the responsibility. For me I think this is a sign of weakness since only loser will approach this…
- 636 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
FOSTER: The Megan Meier Cyber Bullying Prevention Act helps to define what is covered under the term “cyberbullying.” For instance, in order for a behavior to be defined as cyberbullying, it must be repeated, hostile, and severe with the intent to embarrass, threaten, or harass. We included the term repeated in our definition so that actions that are a part of an isolated incident, such as telling someone you hate him or her in the midst of a verbal argument, is not considered cyberbullying.…
- 212 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
“On October 17, 2006, Megan Meir, a thirteen-year-old girl in Dardenne Prairie, Missouri, who had been diagnosed with attention deficit disorder and depression, committed suicide because of postings on MySpace, an Internet social networking site, saying she was a bad person, whom everyone hated and the world would be better off without” (John O. Hayward). Throughout the years offensive speech, like hate speech and bullying--online or in person--has become such a controversy whether or not they should be restricted and prohibited. We Americans were given “an amendment to the United States Constitution guaranteeing the rights of free expression and action that are fundamental to democratic government. These rights include freedom of assembly, freedom of the press, freedom of religion, and freedom of speech” (dictionary.com). While these types of offensive acts go on, many violent actions have taken place such as riots, fights, etc. which spark up even more problems in our world today. Many say these types of hate speech and bullying should be prohibited because it causes hurt and pain to others and or one’s self, and we have others who believe limiting hate speech and bullying is going against their freedom of expression. Although some people believe the speech of cyber bullying and hate speech should not be prohibited because the act is taking away their freedom of speech rights, cyber bullying and hate speech, in fact, should be prohibited when the protection and the lives of people are at risk.…
- 1236 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Not all kind of anonymity is bad. People who criticize others’ work might not habituated being criticized about their own work. Using the advantage of being anonymous, people often bully others on the Internet. Like insulting them, or some might even be up to taking revenge against them.…
- 300 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays