1 April 2013
Drug Testing Welfare Recipients
Welfare began during the great depression in the 1930’s then, just like now, there were many families that needed help from the government, and that is why they introduced welfare. In our world today there is social welfare, corporate welfare, child welfare, and many others that one can apply for. Other welfare programs, such as TANF and WIC, have truly made a difference in the lives of American families. Families are kept together, children are healthier and often times, recipients are able to use the welfare to help them as they find a new job. In some cases, welfare might even save lives. But, of course, the system has its flaws, and many argue that tax payer dollars are being wasted. Some citizens believe that recipients of welfare should undergo mandatory drug testing.
There are many pros and cons of drug testing people on welfare. According to stopthedrugwar.com, lawmakers in several states want recipients to submit to random drug testing. Legislatures in at least 28 states are considering drug testing applicants or recipients of public assistant programs. Recently Oklahoma enacted a “drug testing law” another bill awaits the Governor’s signature in Tennessee. As you may have already heard, Florida recently became the first state to require adults applying for cash welfare assistance (i.e., not food stamps and housing assistance) to undergo drug screenings. Florida Gov. Rick Scott defended the new rule by arguing that:
“It’s not right for taxpayer money to be paying for somebody’s drug addiction. … On top of that, this is going to increase personal responsibility and personal accountability. We shouldn’t be subsidizing people’s addiction.”
Is it fair? Many people argue it definitely is. After all, welfare recipients accept millions of American dollars in aid every year. It would only be fair for them to be tested to ensure the assistance is dispersed of properly. Also, many places of employment practice random drug testing. If it happens in the workforce, why would it be unfair for welfare recipients? As quoted by an everyday working mom, “My stance is, I have to take a drug test to go to work, and pay in to this program. They should have to take a drug test to receive these free benefits. Now there has been some debate on whether you should have to pass a drug test for unemployment, and I would stand behind that as well. You most likely had to take a drug test to get the job you had when you were paying into the unemployment program.”
Ultimately, the biggest positive of this program is that it would deter recipients from purchasing and using illegal drugs. This might mean they don't even need the welfare in the first place. Parental substance abuse and dependence have a negative impact on the physical and emotional well-being of children and can cause home environments to become chaotic and unpredictable, leading to child maltreatment. The children’s physical and emotional needs often take a back seat to their parents’ activities related to obtaining, using, or recovering from the use of drugs and alcohol. It could help social workers know when children are around drug abuse, and thus prevent further abuse in families. It could help lower the demand for illegal drugs on the streets. It could possibly even save the system some money, as those who are on drugs would not receive welfare. It could even create new jobs for people to oversee the drug testing.
However, there are many cons of mandatory drug testing for people on welfare as well. One of the biggest negatives is that it is costly. Illegal drug testing is not cheap. It could cost hundreds of thousands of dollars, even if just one of every five recipients was tested. However, this may be rationalized by saying that the cost that drugs have on our society in general would be lowered. Another negative is that some people who are on prescription medication could show false positives, and be discriminated against, even with a doctor's involvement. Many people argue that it is simply an invasion of privacy. Quoted from a welfare recipient, “I don't think testing is justified. The last time I checked, there was not a test for any other public benefit getting financial aid, getting unemployment benefits or a driver's license, getting medical care at a hospital, being able to get the police or fire department or ambulance to come to your home in an emergency, qualifying for veterans benefits, or getting a handicap parking sticker, etc., so I don't see why we should apply this test to some government benefits and not others. There is no rational basis to do so.”
Welfare and public assistance programs are under scrutiny for many reasons. Drug testing of welfare recipients might help our society, or it could even make little or no difference at all. After weighing the pros and cons of this controversy what would you do?
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Most people would argue that drug testing for welfare would be a waste of time and money. I will say personally that is completely false. Drug testing randomly for welfare program, would be a wonderful, and probably one of the only good things, to this already corrupt government program.…
- 501 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Florida Governor Rick Scott made plans to test all welfare recipients to see if they are using drugs before they can receive payments is hardly saving the state any money, according to recent reports. At $30 per test, the state paid $28,800 in drug test reimbursements (960 reimbursements at $30 each, since about 2 percent also didn’t finish the application process) for those who did pass, while saving themselves about $66,000 in payments that did not have to be made for the year to those applicants that didn’t make it through for one reason or another (applicants receive $138 a month, or $1,656 per year).…
- 493 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Welfare is nothing new to the citizens of this country. It is a concept that arose over a century ago. Welfare was made famous by Bill Clinton, in 1996, and it has brought up much controversy. Arguments suggest the welfare system is highly abused by its members while others believe it is the answer to the nation’s poverty. Although the welfare system is state regulated, many people believe it is taken advantage of by underserving people. Often, people with nasty habits, sale their food stamp cards for extra cash, cigarettes, and drugs. Most of the time, these people have children that have to go without because their parent puts their government assistance towards unhealthy addictions.…
- 1145 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
There is much debate regarding this issue. Supporters of requiring drug tests for welfare applicants believe that there will be many people deterred from applying due to knowing they will not pass. They also believe that some will fail the drug tests. These supporters believe this number of people will be so large that there will be a significant decrease in welfare spending. Other supporters have said “substance abuse is a prominent barrier preventing people from making the necessary transition from governmental dependence to self-reliance.”(Targeted News Service) Opponents have said this is a direct violation of our constitutional rights as American citizens. Some have even said it is not right to assume that just because people are poor, they drug users. Other opposers of welfare drug testing have argued that it will not save money at…
- 1822 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
All over the United States Americans are using government assistance money to buy drugs. It has become a major issue in the past years. Americans have figured out how to abuse the system. They are taking the governments money and are fueling their drug addictions. In order to fix this states across the United States have already started drug testing their applicant's. Some states disagree because they believe it is stereotyping government assistance applicants. Even though many jobs also require drug test. Americans in the United States who need financial assistance from the government, should be subjected to a monthly drug test.…
- 969 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In the past ten years drug testing welfare recipients has been a huge issue. While most people are all for it, there are just as many people if not more that are against it. While it may be true that some welfare recipients are doing drugs, all of them are not. It can and will be proven that drug testing these recipients is a waste of time and tax payers’ money. Yes, yours and my hard earned tax dollars are and will be spent on welfare recipients who may or may not be using drugs. Think for a second…what else can my tax dollars be used for? Possible improving badly paved streets. How about fixing that run down playground with the overgrown grass? Maybe the money can even be used toward the remodeling the library of a school. While other states such as Florida have tried testing and been semi-successful other state such as New Hampshire attempt turned out differently. According to Concord Monitor (2013) “while the drug testing was in place there, only 2.6 percent of the applicants failed the test. And the money spent on the testing exceeded the money saved in denied benefits.” This turned out to be a very costly effort for them.…
- 625 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
As of today, over sixteen percent of Americans are receiving some form of welfare benefits. “Welfare is classified as a statutory procedure or social effort designed to promote the basic physical and material well-being of people in need”: Welfare is provided by the government, both state and federal. (http://dictionary.com/browse/welfare) The government receives the money from the taxpayers in order to support welfare recipients. Tax payers are the working class. Seventy-five percent of citizens that are among the social class, also known as the working class, are required to take pre-employment drug screening. When citizens receive welfare; however, they are not required to take drug screenings, even though they receive the funds from the government. Drug tests for welfare recipients will be one way to start saving money in this country.…
- 845 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Should people who want welfare be required to take a drug test? People say the fourth amendment protects them because it states “ unreasonable searches and seizures.” Welfare drug testing is a common way to make sure taxpayer dollars are used responsibly. People who have to pay for other people’s welfare because they can go into work disagree with people who even have to think twice about drug testing being required to receive welfare. Taxpayers who pay on welfare think the government is responsible to make sure that their money is being used correctly and to make sure that drug users don’t receive any funds from the state. Why should we support their drug use, if you want drugs you should be able to pay for your own needs. We shouldn’t support basically feeding into their drugs use and letting them slowly kill themselves. Instead we should provide rehabs and hospital treatments. We don’t need to lock the addict up we need to get them help because they’re cable of so much more than what their setting their mindset do. They’re putting a limit to their goals and success in life. You can do…
- 1019 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Many people are constantly discussing the issue of welfare recipients abusing the system and spending their money on drugs while receiving government assistance. This issue has brought forward a possible solution of states passing legislation that will require welfare applicants to submit to a drug test before receiving any sort of government assistance. Drug testing welfare applicants before allowing them to receive assistance is a positive idea because most employers require drug tests to be taken by applicants pre-employment. This will help make sure that the government funding is being put toward the family and the needs of the household, and also because in the future it will benefit the children growing…
- 955 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
There is controversy about using drug testing for welfare recipients to identify drug addict over states in the United States, and still there are many concerns, so just few states apply it. Still there are a lot of different opinions about it for instance Kasha Kelly, The Kansas state House representative, in Michelle Price’s “2012-2013 data shows only 12 test positive in Utah welfare drug screening” believes that checking people on public assistance for drugs would not only save money, they argue, but put welfare recipients on firmer footing when they get ready to enter the working world. But, Liz Schott, a welfare expert with center on Budget and Policy Priorities, in Alan Greenblatt’s “Should Welfare Recipients Get Drug Testing?” argues testing violated the constitutional ban against unreasonable search and seizure. In my opinion, California should test welfare applicants for drugs because it saves money, it helps abusers, and it is constitutional…
- 1043 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Who exactly is on welfare? Who is collecting and using food stamps these days? The majority of people are lower middle class, working poor to poor caucasion families. Those who can no longer afford to put gas in thier cars and food on the table. Should they be drug tested? Should parents in states with a working wage of 9.00 an hour and a state minimum wage of 5.15 an hour which neither supports a family, pays for the gas required to get to a job, or feed a family, be drug tested, or should the policy makers who do not live under these same standards be drug tested and better yet, forced to live on the wages that they set and believe to be fair and reasonable for working class…
- 1497 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
Drug testing welfare recipients is an excellent idea. For instance, random drug testing would help substance-abusing welfare recipients conquer their drug problems. Drug testing would be very helpful to the ones who are not substance abusing to actually get the help they deserve. It’s also great because most recipients have children which is what the benefits should be for if the recipient has TANF (Temporary Assistance for Needy).…
- 469 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
I believe although the welfare system does help some people who truly deserve it, it is an overall corrupt system. Besides people who really can’t work, such as the elderly or the disabled, it shouldn’t be given out to people as a reward for people who are too lazy to work. I find it acceptable for welfare to be given to those who are looking for employment and really do want to work. But, if people are getting welfare that have no desire to get a job, they do not deserve the financial support of the federal government. Workers shouldn’t have to have money taken out of the check they worked hard for, for people who don’t try. I believe that the only real solution to make sure that welfare checks go to the right people is through drug testing.…
- 222 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The logic behind this legislation is that public tax dollars should not be used to support those who use drugs. However, welfare recipients are not the only ones who receive public tax dollars and are certainly not the only ones who use drugs. People from all socioeconomic levels receive public tax dollars. If it is so crucial to ensure that drug users are not receiving public funds then we should test everyone who receives them,…
- 324 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Specific purpose: I would like to persuade my audience that drug test screenings should be mandatory in order for welfare recipients to receive their money.…
- 898 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays