To What Extent Can International Aid Be Really Effective?
TO WHAT EXTENT CAN INTERNATIONAL AID BE REALLY EFFECTIVE?
One cannot help but be shocked to hear that often, medical and food supplies sent to flood victims have never reached the victims but have in fact fallen into the coffers of the officials who were to distribute the supplies to the victims. This is indeed an eye-opener and we wonder how long such activities have been going on undetected. It brings to realisation the truth that among so called humans are beasts which will take advan tage of even the most miserable of their fellow humans. From this the lesson that was learnt was that international aid may not reach the per sons for whom it is intended. In such cases international aid is no aid at all and a waste of time and resources for the nation that attempted to assist. How then can effective help be given?
It stands to reason that when international aid is given, steps must be taken to ensue that the aid reaches the people for whom it is intended. The way to achieve this may not be simple. Often it is the persons in authority who are corrupt. It is very difficult for a nation to give help directly to people in another nation. The United Nations Organisation, or a similar international body, could undertake to supervise the distribution of aid. Here however rises the problem of costs. Also tied with this is time. When too much time is taken for the aid to reach the intended recipients, there may well be further disaster. Perhaps the UNO could set up a body of dedicated men and women, on its own payroll, in every country who can speedily distribute aid to victims of floods and earthquakes. In such cases too, the workers need to be carefully select ed and screened.
More than the help that one nation can give to another during a disaster, it would be more effective to give other forms of help during normal times. A common proverb says, "Give me a fish and I eat for a day, teach me to fish and I eat for a lifetime '. If we follow this wise saying, it would
One cannot help but be shocked to hear that often, medical and food supplies sent to flood victims have never reached the victims but have in fact fallen into the coffers of the officials who were to distribute the supplies to the victims. This is indeed an eye-opener and we wonder how long such activities have been going on undetected. It brings to realisation the truth that among so called humans are beasts which will take advan tage of even the most miserable of their fellow humans. From this the lesson that was learnt was that international aid may not reach the per sons for whom it is intended. In such cases international aid is no aid at all and a waste of time and resources for the nation that attempted to assist. How then can effective help be given?
It stands to reason that when international aid is given, steps must be taken to ensue that the aid reaches the people for whom it is intended. The way to achieve this may not be simple. Often it is the persons in authority who are corrupt. It is very difficult for a nation to give help directly to people in another nation. The United Nations Organisation, or a similar international body, could undertake to supervise the distribution of aid. Here however rises the problem of costs. Also tied with this is time. When too much time is taken for the aid to reach the intended recipients, there may well be further disaster. Perhaps the UNO could set up a body of dedicated men and women, on its own payroll, in every country who can speedily distribute aid to victims of floods and earthquakes. In such cases too, the workers need to be carefully select ed and screened.
More than the help that one nation can give to another during a disaster, it would be more effective to give other forms of help during normal times. A common proverb says, "Give me a fish and I eat for a day, teach me to fish and I eat for a lifetime '. If we follow this wise saying, it would
References: Fraser, A. and Whitfield, L. (2009) Understanding contemporary aid relationships, in L. Whitfield (Ed.),The Politics of Aid: African Strategies for Dealing with Donors (Oxford: Oxford University Press). Mosley, P., Harigan, J. and Toye, J. (1991) Aid and Power: The World Bank and Policy Based Lending.Volume One: Analysis and Policy Proposals (London: Routledge). Riddell, R. (2007) Does Foreign Aid Really Work? (Oxford: Oxford University Press).