Preview

Fur Trade Ethics

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1111 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Fur Trade Ethics
Each year, billions of animals are brutally slaughtered, solely for the use of their fur for human needs. The fur industry is a completely unnecessary, inhumane, and cruel practice. Although some of our group members had prior knowledge on the industry, the group was shocked after researching and educating ourselves further on the horrors of the fur trade. Killing animals for fur is unnecessary, considering all the cruelty free options that we available today in our modern society. Besides the ethics side of the argument, the fur industry is an environmentally destructive process. Similar to other forms of factory farming, the fur industry is a threat to the earths natural resources. People who wear fur claim that they do so for reasons such …show more content…
While one side has their opinions and ethical beliefs, so does the other side. In this section, we will briefly look into the opinions and reasons to why both sides believe what they do. As mentioned previously, some people use fur products to keep warms, as well as fashion and wealth reasons. These can be respectable reasons for individuals who are in these situations. Another reason why people depend of the fur trade is because of jobs. According to our resources, the fur trade industry employs around 60,000 Canadian residents per year, both full and part-time. Of the 50,000 active trappers, only 25,000 of these employees are of aboriginal status, while the rest are not. It is also recognized that Canadian fur farm owners and trappers make well over $320 million per year on pelt sales alone. The fur trade industry not only supplies jobs to 60,000 Canadians, but it also benefits to our economy by contributing almost $1 billion every year. Fur trades in Canada began in the early 1500’s when a French explorer began trading with Europe. For hundreds of years this has been both socially and economically ethical for Canadians everywhere, up until …show more content…
For instance, we have so many options of other fashion choices that we could choose, which can also tie into “quality of the product”. In the past few years, there have been several companies arising with cruelty-free products including coats, hats, and mittens. The options of cruelty-free products and companies offer an alternative to purchasing and wearing fur. This creates a statement that metaphorically gets sent to the companies that sell fur. It shows that we do not support the idea of trapping and brutally murdering the helpless animals that are involved. Mentioning the treatment of the animals while trapping, we acknowledge the fact that defenseless animals lose their lives every day from hunters who only want their fur and skin. Within the seal hunt, it's been reported that seals slip underneath the surface of the water, where they are left to slowly die and are never found. Regarding the brutality of the animals, we found that the Canadian Marine Mammal Regulations that govern the hunt stipulate sealers may kill seals with wooden clubs, hakapiks, and guns. We also noticed that although the commercial hunt of nursing seal pups is banned, seals are still hunted, leaving over one million seals slaughtered and injured in the past five years. Another reason why some individuals choose not to wear fur is because of their

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Upon winning the Revolutionary War Americans were filled with a compulsion to manifest their destiny. They were Gods chosen people after all. What could possibly come in the way of them achieving what was their God given right, their destiny? The fur trade draws its roots from early exploration in America. The fur trade was an entirely simple concept that relied on pillaging mother nature 's resources to turn the dollar. The fur trade set the mold for the modern day American corporations. It was the first industry in U.S. history to receive a federal subsidy; which is a form of government assistance to help out with financial needs and accommodations (sounds kinda of familiar to thecompanies of today eh?). Fur trading has been going on for centuries, dating back to Jacques Cartier (an explorer from France who would go on to claim what is currently Canada for France) who set voyage through the Canadian wilderness almost five hundred years ago. This industry is a cornerstone in the American business realm, and also in pioneering the early Pacific North West.…

    • 2265 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    American Fur Trading Case

    • 489 Words
    • 3 Pages

    2. Who were the most important stakeholders of the 19th century fur industry? Were they treated responsibly by the standards of the day? By the standards of today?…

    • 489 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The documentary film Blackfish which we saw in our class, was very interesting and scary. The documentary was based on a true story of a killer whale killing its trainer of many years. Till this day no know will ever know what clicked in that mammals head to turn against its trainer the way that it did. When looking at the film, it shows mostly the dangerous side of the mammal and how it was captured at such a young age, and the history it had with killing. It doesn’t really show the side of Sea World, or the trainers that train these mammals to become the best performers that they are. Director Gabriela Cowperthwaite uses shocking footage and emotional interviews to present a convincing case against keeping these wild animals for human entertainment. The thesis of my essay is we should not abuse animals for our own enjoyment. Yes I too have taken my children to Sea World many times, and love seeing these beautiful sea animals, but when you stop and think one second the treatment they actual receive to become what they are today, it is just very harsh. Just like human beings, these animals too like to be respected and treated nicely. Torture will never get them to become what the trainer wanted them to be.…

    • 1339 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Countless scholars deem that the fur trade crooked the Natives into addicts, badly pursuing European commodities, however, it is imperative to distinguish that within this exchange they were able to acquire European weapons and thus shield themselves. In trade for these European exports the Native Americans fabricated the skins of many animals including some spiritually revered once like deer and bears. However, the revenues and need for these animals was noticeably inferior to that of the cherished beaver. The beaver’s fur was well thought out to be more treasured than that of other animals due largely to its two coatings. It comprises of a course external layer as well as a smooth, diminutive interior.…

    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    While they had hunted beavers strictly for practicality before Europeans arrived, they traded excessive amounts of beaver pelts to Euro Americans in the fur trade. Due to a rapidly declining population from introduced diseases and the desire of foreign manufactured goods, such as addictive alcohol and cooking utensils, Native Americans were forced by the market to act as middlemen in the fur trade.3 This shift in perspective is notable because it exemplifies the ability of the market to commodify a natural resource and to motivate people to participate in a society founded on material affluence. Native Americans became tempted by the values of a capitalistic society and engaged an economy that ran on a concept of wealth they did not understand, and this allowed them to see the value of America’s ample resources differently than they…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The trading of goods and technologies between imperial governments and indigenous nations consists of both positive and negative outcomes. In Canada, the fur trade was of significance due to the advanced technology brought by the Europeans to the natives. They brought goods such as axes, wool, tobacco pipes, flintlock muskets, and an assortment of knives in exchange for furs. The aboriginals began to utilize the European goods for the reason that the technology was incomparable to their own. The aboriginals now applied European technology toward hunting and apparel, which allowed them to improve their efficiency and comfort. There were also negative impacts of the fur trade on the aboriginals way of life. The introduction of…

    • 1082 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A rapidly growing trade for the Transnational Organized Crime groups is the illegal wildlife trade. “By its very nature, it is almost impossible to obtain reliable figures for the value of illegal wildlife trade. Experts at TRAFFIC, the wildlife trade monitoring network, estimate that it runs into hundreds of millions of dollars.” (2015). Tigers, Elephants, Rhinos, and even sea creatures like turtles are just a few animals that are being poached for this trade. The elephants for their ivory and Rhinos for their horns, is all that a poacher is after and metric tons of the stuff is being seized. The question to that is, how much is getting through that nobody knows about? Plants, yes plants, and other animals are all being sold for such…

    • 772 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Did you know that more than 50% of the fur in the United States comes from China, where there are no penalties for abusing animals, which are raised in unbearably cramped and run-down cages on fur farms? Animals should have a Bill of Rights because they have emotions, feel pain, and are being forced into painful experiments.…

    • 463 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Bloody Ice Analysis

    • 1017 Words
    • 5 Pages

    “Bloody Ice” is an essay arguing against the mass slaughter of Harp Seals. The author reveals the legal limits for the amount of seals allowed to be killed each year as stated by the U.S. Seal Protection Act and pleads for the further reduction of those limits. The passage argues that the inevitable extinction of the animals and the inhumane methods by which they are killed are cause for severe regulations on seal hunting. In the conclusion of the paper, it is suggested that ranching the seals would reduce impact on seal population and cut down dependency on the seal industry. The essay starts off well, but generally lacks in persuasively arguing its point and is therefore ineffective as a whole.…

    • 1017 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    canadian history

    • 1239 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The article “Women in Between”: Indian Women in Fur Trade Society in Western Canada”, written by Sylvia Van Kirk presents the lives of Indian women in the fur trade. The article title Women in Between is correctly named as it focuses on explaining the role of Indian women in the fur trade and their ability to play an essential part in fur trade society. The article conveys both the positive and negative aspect of being an Indian woman in the fur trade as well as their reasons for marrying European fur traders. The article helps us more to understand the fur trade society by focusing on the motives and actions of Indian women in the fur trade which furthers our knowledge of Canadian history prior to confederation. Women in Between examines through multiple sources of traders observation, the life of an Indian women in the fur trade based on the accounts provided by men. Since it was noted in her article that Indian women, coming from a non-literate society, have not left us with any writings of their own views and their motive for being in the fur trade or deciding to leave. The only historical reference of the lives of women in the fur trade is written by men and mostly European men. Women in Between discusses the unique and complex interactions between the two racial groups, white and Indian and the important role that Indian women played in this interaction. The article makes the argument that Indian women had a preference for living with and marrying the white man. Sylvia also argued that traders perhaps did not treat these women well and that the treatment of these women was disgraceful. The article also points out that Indian women had many advantages from the fur trade and their position as women in between, and therefore they manipulated the situation to improve their lives.…

    • 1239 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    As humans, we have been naturally inclined to eat meat since the start of our existence. But many people believe that using an animal for our own personal gain is very unethical. One such group, PETA (People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals), published “Animals Used for Food” in 2016 on their organizational website, they argue that animals are compassionate just like we are and that people need to be their heroes. PETA’s audience incorporates everyday people in a global aspect. This article combines the rhetorical appeals of ethos, logos and pathos. The author of this article mostly uses the emotional appeal of pathos to help persuade people to help them in their efforts to save the animals.…

    • 261 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Collectively, all these elements affected First Nations people’s fur trade experiences, and led to economic possibilities and social disorder, with implications for Indigenous communities and their relationships with other…

    • 1552 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    John Astor

    • 1285 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The United States of America is a very new country in the world when the fur trade was discovered. The fur trade was initially started by the Indians who would trade with English merchants. They would trade hides for such things as weaponry and advanced tools. Due to the qualities in the furs themselves you can start to see a market value rise for certain pelts. The beaver fur was the highest sought after because of its durability and its water resistant capabilities. With the fur trade ever increasing the French looked to establish a location in which to trade. They chose the eastern portion of Canada and to gain credibility with the Indians they offered them trade items just to begin the long lasting circle of trust between the two parties (Powell County Museum). We would see much of the same trading take place until the migration westward and the birth of our great nation.…

    • 1285 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Atlantic Seal Hunt

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Canadian Seal Hunt benefits Canadian’s in countless ways, by providing employment for many Atlantic Canadians and by also putting money back into the economy. The federal government has said that the value of the seals has exceeded $16.5 million in the year 2005. It has also provided a “significant” source of income for thousands of sealers, which has benefited their families at a time when other fishing options were unavailable, or limited at best. (FAQS: The Atlantic seal hunt, 2009). This “Significant” source of income for thousands of sealers is how many of their families got by, how their children could afford their education, how they could sustain a normal life. Not only is it money in the sealers pockets it’s money in the Canadian economy. All the extra income the sealers are making is being taxed, and these tax dollars are going into resources Canadian’s use everyday, like health care and transportation. Canadians are not only benefiting from the seals in this way. The seals are used for primarily food, fuel and clothing. However beyond that seals are also used for leathers, oil, handicrafts, meat for humans and animals consumption, as well as seal oil…

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    This paper explores disadvantages of detrimental killing and capturing of marine animals. It also discusses ways to stop and decrease the killing and capturing of marine animals and the effects on marine species from keeping them in captivity for people’s entertainment. The disadvantages of killing and capturing marine animals range from the wasting of meat simply because there is not a market for it in the whaling countries (Japan, Norway, and Iceland), to the fact that it is causing many species of whales to the verge of extinction. There is an organization called the Sea Shepherd that hunts down the Japanese whale hunting fleet. The Sea Shepherd’s crew has developed tactics and uses sheer force to stop the Japanese from whaling over their quota of whales. The paper discusses how companies go about capturing marine animals for public display, and goes over how they make money on this business and how much money they make.…

    • 3098 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Best Essays

Related Topics