Preview

Great Depression And Deportation Essay

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
526 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Great Depression And Deportation Essay
Depression and Deportation
I’m going to examine the action of deportation during the great depression and answer questions associated with it. The questions are if whether or not deportation was justified during the years of 1929-1939. Was it a practical solution and whether or not there were problems with the plan? I will be providing insight on the questions and start with the first query while following with remaining two after.
I do not think that the idea of a mass deportation, commonly referred to as repatriation, was or will ever be justified in this context. I feel that when you look at how they went about this deportation, it was completely out of fear and spite. The great depression caused a mass amount of hostility towards immigrants and Mexican Americans like the Martinez family that had to live in a tent near the town of Clovis, just because their employer refused to pay for housing for those seasonal farm workers. (p 63) This caused special regulations to be put in play regarding employment. Many politicians felt that the immigrants may cause civil unrest in the midst of this economic climate and many
…show more content…

More than 400,000 “immigrants” were pressured or deported to Mexico but half of them were natural born citizens of the U.S. Los Angeles lost a third of its Mexican population along with Mexican-born Texans through scare tactics, intimidation and even minor captivity. The costs associated with this movement greatly outweighed the money or jobs they were attempting to gain from deportation. Families were split up leaving underage dependents to be taken care of by the Federal Government through food, clothing, shelter, relief etc. The expenses of transporting, along with everything involved with deportation, ate up the budget and only made the country’s economic status worse (Repatriation During the Great

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Penn Foster Case 3.07

    • 124 Words
    • 1 Page

    For some of the deportees’ deportation is devastated first of all, they leave their love ones behind, they feel like another sentence in jail, others become homeless and violence. As a matter fact, life in Mexico is no future for them, they can’t even support themselves or even help the family they left behind.…

    • 124 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    This action caused drastic emotional changes in the lives of everyone. Many of the ones who were being thrown off did not agree with what was happening. Many argued, “… it’s our land. We measured it and broke it up. We were born on it, and we got killed on it, died on it. Even if it’s no good, it’s still ours”(33). Once thrown off many grew sick both physically and emotionally, some even died leaving others to suffer even more. Although the migration to California caused many families to suffer it helped them by creating that unity among all of them during…

    • 4894 Words
    • 20 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The United States government decided to implement a plan called “Repatriados” to solve the problem of unemployment during the great depression.as the government began enforcing strict immigration laws, Mexicans were round up illegally as they used them as scapegoats. Moreover and authorities acted quickly and targeted Mexicans whose citizenship was questionable, as many of the Mexicans were born in the United States or legal naturalized citizens, once wanted to work the mines now no longer wanted as the mining company assisted to carry the mineros away on their trains.…

    • 89 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thousands to million people get deported yearly. Families here in the United States are afraid everyday; they enjoy every second with their families because they don’t know when it’ll be the last time they see each other. Their families get broken, seperated, and worried. In Aura Bogado’s article, “Jackie Rayos-Garcia Tells About the Deportation of Her Mother, Guadalupe García de Rayos,” she explains the process of deportation in the United States; such as experiences like getting isolated, getting treated like slaves, and deportation. The struggle and suffering of people losing their family members to the government or leaving them here in the United States is being shown.…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    It’s the sad truth and horrific moments like these wouldn’t happen if the U.S hadn’t built a wall. Migrants would be able to come to the U.S. to work which is what they are mostly here for and would leave to be with their families when their contacts are over. According to Sanchez in “Across the Dividing Line,” before the wall’s main priority was to keep mexicans out, there were no restrictions. Many mexicans passed border patrol officers back and forth and they weren’t even asked for a passport because officers knew they were only going to the U.S. for a job, not to settle. All of the migrants kept their word and returned to their families and the cycle continued for several years. This all changed in 1917 when the border enforced its policy. Sanchez says, “ In 1917, the United States Congress passed an immigration act.. placed sunstantive restrictions on those who entered from Mexico. . included a literacy tests, a medical examination, head tax..” (55). Once this act was passed Mexican migrants started to cross illegally because they didn’t have enough money to pay for the head tax, most of them didn’t know how to read and the medical exams were too harsh. The Mexican migrants who did enter the U.S. legally were vaccinated, deloused and fumigated as if they were animals. These rigorous procedures were out of hand and I think it wasn’t…

    • 1301 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Immigration 1880-1925

    • 300 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Immigration was a tedious problem that rose during the period from 1880-1925 and created a lot of tensions. Immigration caused an increase in the population, but took many American jobs in the workforce. The U.S. government did not know exactly how to tackle the issue of immigration, making the situation worse. Negroes, Italians, Jews, and many more were all taking America by storm, leaving the government dumbfounded. The government response to immigration created more problems while immigration was leading to political. social, and economical tensions .…

    • 300 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1940, the American economy was beginning to stabilize from the previous decade of “Great Depression”, in which home foreclosures, unemployment, and hunger was rampant among families across the United States. The continuous Anti-Mexican sentiment was still a popular theme in the United States as noted by the exclusion from President’s Roosevelt’s “New Deal”, repatriation (arbitrary deportation), and propagated segregation. Housing segregation of Mexican-Americans led to the formation of “Barrio’s” and tight knit communities, as housing options were unavailable in many areas. In various instances, home owners stipulated that homes in a particular zip code not be leased to Mexicans; properties for sale also had similar and lengthy stipulations…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Great Depression was the hardest time for many people from the economy result of being unemployed and higher prices causing some people unable to buy food and debt. Immigrants had the toughest time during the Great Depression. Immigrants were viewed with hostility and treated badly. This caused an increase in racism and discrimination, unemployed Asian and African-Canadians were denied from jobs and high risk of being getting deported. For example, Jews suffered a lot from anti-Semitism and prejudice. Also, many jobs were closed to immigrants and employers would put a sign not letting immigrants apply. At the beginning, of the Great Depression nearly ten-thousand immigrants were deported.…

    • 108 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Immigration in the United States is a complex demographic activity that has been a major contribution to population growth and cultural change throughout much of the nation's history. The many aspects of immigration have controversy in economic benefits, jobs for non-immigrants, settlement patterns, crime, and even voting behavior. Congress has passed many laws that have to do with immigrants especially in the 19th century such as the Naturalization Act of 1870, and the Chinese Exclusion Act in 1882, or even the Immigration Act of 1903 all to insure specific laws and boundaries set on immigrants. The life of immigrants has been drastically changed throughout the years of 1880-1925 through aspects such as immigrants taking non-immigrants wages and jobs, the filtration process of immigrants into the United States, and lastly, the foreign policies of the immigrants and their allowance into the nation.…

    • 645 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    On May 26, 1924 congress passed this law that was to be called the immigration act of 1924. This act did many thing that provided limitations, and requirements to be allowed to enter the United States. The United states was a booming country. A lot of foreigners had wanted to enter the country in hopes of finding success. America had a reputation known as the land of opportunity. It had many pull factors such as free enterprise freedom of speech, and religion. America was growing country and was eager to expand, but America was starting to notice that we were receiving the dumb, the poor, and the sick. America decide to act, and set certain limitations on what were expected when trying to enter America.…

    • 1343 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Kevin R. Johnson, Associate Dean for Academic Affairs for the University of California at Davis, says that the Mexican Repatriation should be recognized by the United States Government because of the impact that still affects Mexican-Americans to this day (2). Provided that ignorance is often times the source of race and civil issues, the lack of information may not be in anyone’s control. Researchers and historians are finally seeking new information, but they are finding it increasingly difficult to find facts that are accurate. There have been many questions and debates about the amount of Mexican-Americans repatriated during the Great Depression; however, the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, a government mandated website, inform researchers that the INS kept little record of the Mexican Repatriation. This lack of accurate public information has caused increasing frustration among the relatives and survivors of the Repatriation. They wish to educate people in order to help them understand their struggles. Francisco E. Balderrama, a professor of Chicano Studies and History with a Ph.D., MD., and a B.A. in history through UCLA and Loyola Marymount University, states that “knowledge about this great injustice will prevent other ethnic or racial groups from suffering the same kind of mistreatment, especially during difficult times of social unrest and…

    • 433 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Becoming Mexican American

    • 1320 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Just like African-Americans segregated into virtual invisibility, Chicanos have become part of all levels of American life. Unlike blacks that were torn from there land and brought here in chains, Mexicans, according to Sanchez, had their own country and culture nearby to cherish and remember in hard times. Unlike the Irish, Africans and others who had come across the ocean and were here to stay, Mexicans could and did go back and forth frequently and in considerable numbers, sometimes to stay, but often to their detriment (Sanchez 220). They were subjected to humiliating and sometimes brutal “repatriation” campaigns. They were literally paid by private or government agencies to leave the country, often to get on Mexico bound trains that were chartered at taxpayers dollars specifically for the purpose of taking them “home” (Sanchez 215). The systems demeaned everyone involved. It was none other than the Mexican government in the personage of the Mexican consul-general to Los Angeles that from 1930 to 1932 helped to direct this effort to literally send…

    • 1320 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    *Nevertheless, the number of repatriates was minuscule compared to those who returned to Mexico during the Great Depression. With the deterioration of the United States economy after 1929, between 400,000 and 500,000 Mexicans and their American-born children returned to Mexico. More than half of these departed from Texas. (The term Mexican is used in this article to refer to all Mexican-heritage repatriates, although a significant number of them were Mexican Americans since they had been born in Texas. For Mexican Americans, the term repatriate is actually inaccurate, for one cannot be repatriated to a foreign country.) Depression-era Mexican repatriation from Texas began in 1929, gained momentum in 1930, and peaked in 1931. In the last quarter of 1931 repatriation reached massive proportions; the roads leading to the Texas-Mexico border became congested with returning repatriates. Mexican border towns were also crowded as thousands of returning Mexicans awaited transportation to the interior of Mexico. The number of repatriates declined in 1932 and again in 1933. During the middle years of the depression - 1934 to 1938 - only occasional…

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tolerance in the 1920's

    • 314 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Also during the 1920’s the palmer raids were roaring throughout the nation and many people were deported without trial because of fear and political power that said these deportee’s were communists. No one was safe from being deported especially not if you were a politician against senator Palmer. Palmer used the palmer raids as a way to get rid of his competition so that he would stay as senate.…

    • 314 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Immigrant Neighborhoods

    • 1464 Words
    • 6 Pages

    As it was no longer the ways of social reformers to change how immigrants were viewed, but the American government. Due to the lack of job thought to be crippling the American economy, the New Deal offered Public Works in order to put its’ citizens to work. This program, among others, was government mandated and had to be inclusive of all the people, including immigrants. These programs allowed for the majority of the workforce that had lost their jobs to begin to regain their financial standings and work side by side with others from varying backgrounds. By creating programs that were inclusive to mostly all, it allowed immigrants to feel excepted in their own skin. However, not all immigrants were treated with such open arms, especially the minorities as the low paying work that they once depended on was given to the mass of unemployed. One specific example is the Mexican - American immigrants and migrant workers. It was thought that the reasoning behind the depression was a lack of jobs, and in order to fix this issue, getting rid of those who had their jobs was the answer. In order to fix the issue at hand, jobs had to be taken back, especially from the Mexicans. This was called repatriation, and it was forcibly taking all Mexican migrant workers and transporting them back to Mexico. Law enforcement would come through Mexican neighborhoods and conduct large sweeps of these people, the…

    • 1464 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays