Preview

Hjh History Crown And Authority Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
843 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Hjh History Crown And Authority Analysis
hjhExam Practice: Early Modern British History: Crown and Authority
1. Source 1 implies that Wolsey did genuinely want justice for all in his role as Lord Chancellor. Source 1 is an extract from some of the written advice that Wolsey gave to judges in the court of Chancery; it says “tell the king… although it is the law, it may not be justice”. This shows us how Wolsey, although someone may be breaking the law, wanted their punishment to be fair. It is evident that Wolsey genuinely wanted justice for all through the way that this extract is showing him tell people to challenge the king about the justice system. If Wolsey didn’t feel so strongly about achieving justice for all then he wouldn’t have sent people to oppose the most powerful man
…show more content…
Source 4 is a letter written by Anne Boleyn, and she says “the wrong you have done me has caused me much sorrow”. Anne Boleyn suggests that she was betrayed by Wolsey “seeing myself betrayed by a man who pretended to support my interests”. Source 5 backs up the fact that Anne felt hostility towards Wolsey as it shows us the responses of letters Wolsey sent to the king in the hope that he will be reinstated. Thomas Cromwell wrote to Wolsey saying “None dares speak to the king on your behalf for fear of Madame Anne’s displeasure. Anne Boleyn has often been seen as a key figure in Wolsey’s fall. Certainly she had her reasons to despise the Cardinal as he had broken up her affair with Henry Percy in order that the King could claim his woman. Yet it was not in her interests to support any anti-Wolsey faction because until very late in the divorce proceedings he must has seemed like the one man who was capable of realising her dream of becoming Queen of England. Therefore it would be fair to say that although there was resentment and envy of Wolsey’s position and wealth, there was no long-term noble conspiracy against him because such actions were pointless while he held the trust of

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Source 4, an extract from Scarisbrick ‘Henry VIII,’ gives the impression that Henry gave all power to Wolsey, whilst he “hunted and jousted.” Cavendish then states how the king had “surrendered the cares of the state into the Cardinal’s hands.” This gives the impression that Wolsey had the powers of the king and was in charge of running the country efficiently. This is supported by source 6, where Henry asks Wolsey to watch some of the key nobility as well as “any others of whom you are superior.” This is clearly Henry giving Wolsey freedom to act as he wishes, thus suggesting power being given to Wolsey. Additional evidence of Wolsey’s power, especially over the nobility, can be seen in his work in the Star Chamber where he often imprisoned nobles. In one instance, Wolsey ordered Sir Paulet Angus [named needs to be verified] to follow him for five years in return for the humiliation suffered by Wolsey earlier on in his career. This presents the Cardinal as a powerful figure i8n the government, who could act freely from the king.…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this article G. W. Bernard talks about the reasons why Anne Boleyn was charged and convicted of adultery. The main reason presented is that King Henry VIII wanted to cast Anne Boleyn aside, in order to marry his latest mistress, Jane Seymour. G. W. Bernard argues that King Henry VIII was upset because Anne Boleyn had not produced a male child, and that King Henry VIII found Anne Boleyn’s abrasive character and pride intolerable. G. W. Bernard states that he believes these were the main reasons that King Henry VIII charged Anne Boleyn for Adultery. G. W. Bernard argues, however, that this interpretation does not fit the evidence of Anne Boleyn and King Henry VIII’s marriage. Their relationship, like most relationships, had its ups and downs, but up until around April 18, 1536 King Henry VIII still regarded Anne Boleyn as his wife and did not have any thoughts about discarding her. The first reason behind why King Henry VIII would have wanted to get rid of Anne Boleyn is that she miscarried in January of 1536, possibly giving birth to a deformed fetus. It is said that giving birth to a deformed fetus was evidence of witchcraft, and King Henry VIII might have thought Anne Boleyn was a witch if she had indeed given birth to a deformed fetus. G. W. Bernard argues, however, that if Anne Boleyn was indeed a witch, she would have used witchcraft to ensure a healthy fetus. Also, Anne Boleyn was never charged with witchcraft, and if King Henry VIII really thought her miscarriage was a result of witchcraft, he would have charged her with witchcraft instead of charging her for adultery. The second reason why King Henry VIII would have wanted to get rid of Anne Boleyn was that illicit sex acts were often blamed as the cause for giving birth to a deformed fetus. It is a reasonable claim that King Henry VIII may have seen the fetus as evidence of adultery, and therefore had charged Anne Boleyn with adultery. The third, and…

    • 852 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why Is Charles 1 A Crisis

    • 957 Words
    • 4 Pages

    It could be argued that George purposely used his position on the Privy Council and his ‘good looks’ to gain his position to Charles’ predecessor, as a ‘secret Catholic’. This could account for his ill advice towards both kings. It is known fact that George’s mother was Catholic who selected his wife, Katherine, who was a ‘strict Roman Catholic’ herself. Therefore, it does arguably raise suspicion towards George’s true intentions of seeking the affection and attention of the kings. During this era, Protestantism strived; Catholicism was hated amongst the realm.…

    • 957 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    A monarchial king gets its crown passed down by the king before him. “Powhatan was a leader who got his power from war, marriage and trade of goods” (Townsend). Powhatan was a leader who protected his tribes by going into war when there was a threat from newcomers or neighbors. A Monarchial king would do the same to protect his people from enemies. Powhatan welcomed newcomers only if the newcomers would greet him with goods and would trade while living in the same land. A monarchial kings were more aggressive towards newcomers they would go into war to set boundaries of their land that was not shareable to…

    • 109 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Anne Boleyn was King Henry’s second wife, and she was the very reason why the power of the pope had been taken away. It all started when he wanted a divorce, and the pope wouldn’t grant it, so he took power away from the pope to get his divorce. His marriage didn’t end on the best terms. At the beginning he had loved her like no other. “To such an extent, in fact, that the flames of desire began to burn secretly in the king’s breast, unknown to all, least of all to Anne herself.”(George Cavendish, Cardinal Wolsey’s gentleman-usher.) Cavendish is say that King Henry fell deeply in love with Anne Boleyn. “Absence is already too much for me: and when I think of the increase of what I must needs suffer it would be well nigh unbearable for me were it not for the firm hope I have and as I cannot be with you in person, I am sending you the nearest possible thing to that, namely, my picture set in a bracelet.”(King HenryVIII to Anne Boleyn) He also sends “I think it long since I kissed you,” and “Think your kindness and my fervents of…

    • 721 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Causes of Wolsey's Fakk

    • 1964 Words
    • 8 Pages

    It is possible to argue that the main cause of Wolsey’s fall was opposition from ‘an aristocratic party’. The line that reads ‘There can be no doubt that for long an aristocratic party, led by the dukes of Norfolk and Suffolk, had been hoping to… dispossess him’ clearly supports the above statement. Both Norfolk and Suffolk come from nobility, and at that time it was the nobles who had a lot of influence. However, following Wolsey’s rise to authority, he did not hesitate to use his power against the nobles. This resulted in him having many enemies along the way, with the majority being those from noble backgrounds. On the other hand, it is possible to argue that Wolsey’s failure to secure the annulment of Henry’s marriage with Catherine of Aragon also contributed to his fall. Source 6 consists of a letter written by Anne Boleyn to Wolsey that explains how he couldn’t live up to his ‘fine promises about divorce’, and she ends it by expressing how it brought her ‘much sorrow’. This is a significant factor as it was this that led Henry to the realization that Wolsey cannot actually give him everything he wanted, and made him appear inefficient. Furthermore his inability to annul the marriage angered Anne Boleyn, resulting in her disliking Wolsey even more than she did before. This was highly unbeneficial for Wolsey as at the time she had a lot of power over Henry’s decisions.…

    • 1964 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Do you agree with the view that the main cause of the English Reformation was the character and influence of Anne Boleyn?…

    • 1440 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Letter from Birmingham Jail, King invites Americans everywhere to fight injustice. He declares that all are obligated to work for justice, even above the law. Justice should be protected by politics in order for all people to enjoy certain basic rights.…

    • 387 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Wolsey states that he is “weary and old with service”, which can be seen as an admission to the extensive amount of personal resources he has poured into his work for the King. Wolsey also characterizes those who “hang on princes’ favours” as “wretched”, bemoaning his fate after a long allegiance with the King. As if these words, with their negative connotations, were not enough to display Wolsey’s despair, his last utterance in his speech does. After his contrast with Lucifer, Wolsey expressed one last vow that he is “never to hope again”. This powerful and negative diction strongly suggests that Wolsey has abandoned all hope: the best possible illumination of Wolsey’s emotional…

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    They had all heard the same case, but due to the vast differences in their personal lives, they had all come to different conclusions. With two very strong willed and different individuals arguing, I found it surprising that they had managed to reach a point in which they decided a compromise was best. The idea of compromise, however, brought something completely different into account, the relationship of law and justice. The distinction between the two is very interesting, what really draws the line between the two? Does justice appeal more to emotion and law more to logistics? If that’s the case then how can someone reasonably mix the two in order to get a fair punishment if one is…

    • 504 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Shows rigidity towards law when speaking to Francis – “a person is either with this court or he is to be counted against it.”…

    • 562 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    All three sources only partly agree that Woley’s rise to power was a result of luck. Source C seems to suggest that the rise of power was due to luck, within the source it tells us that one of Wolsey’s main critics, Surrey, was too old to argue against him and his son too young to do so also. Warham has retired and therefore a position of power has opened up because of this Wolsey can now manoeuver his friends into other positions of power to help him, therefore this would suggest that Wolsey at this time had a lot of fortune on his side. Although within all these sources, luck may not remain the main theme it reoccurs throughout each, whether small or large. Source D reflects that’s Wolsey had a fortunate place with the King as Henry was easily bribed with gifts ‘beautifully fashioned dish, a jewel, or gifts of that sort’. Wolsey’s had his very own biographer which was his first servant and hence this creates a bias account as the information Cavendish will be collecting will be from Wolsey and this could be twisted into unreliable information, although most points also have element of Wolsey’s skilfulness it could be argued that King Henry simply favoured Wolsey, or that it was Wolsey’s personality rather than his skill that made the king acceptant of him.…

    • 1050 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The court said that she was “not fit” for their society. Anne was accused and charged with “disturbing the peace of common wealth, slandering ministers and holding private meetings.” (Page 65) Anne believed strongly in the words of the bible maybe just a little more than the minster did. Which they felt opposed a threat.…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During Cardinal Wolsey’s reflective soliloquy, he gives a thorough reaction to his recent loss of position as advisor to the King. Shakespeare utilizes figurative language that compares his plight to nature, biblical allusions, and varying tones to portray Wolsey’s view of career conundrum. Wolsey’ speech is written with thought to each stage of feeling: denial, acceptance, and finally dismay. By the end of the speech, it is evident that Wolsey is at an all time low, with an overly pessimistic view of his future endeavors.…

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Justice of King Lear

    • 671 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Nothing more and nothing less, this is the basis of all consequence and reward in a just society. Although both justice and mercy together are needed to maintain a functioning society, the presence of justice is essential in order to maintain a fair and supportive world. Throughout the play King Lear, by William Shakespeare, many characters experience their own level of justice, both fair and excessive. Justice is essential in any society in order to maintain structure and authority. Justice is also important to ensure the victim feels secure and satisfied after a crime is committed against them and lastly justice allows a person to take responsibility for their actions and grow as a person.…

    • 671 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays