Preview

Holmberg's Mistake Summary

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
527 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Holmberg's Mistake Summary
Holmberg’s Mistake is part of the many myths of Western civilization as well as a representation of who has the power to write history. When children are in elementary school they are taught about the European colonizers as being these good people. Children are also taught at a very early age the whole us and them dichotomy however, in a subliminal way. Allan R. Homberg published a book called “Nomads of Longbow in 1952 which, discussed the Siriono population a group of Native Americans in the Beni. Mann (2007) discusses the visit to the Beni, a Bolivian province which was the size of Illinois and Indiana combined (p.1). Mann (2007) argues Homberg saw the Sirono population as uncivilized and as the least culturally advanced group (p.8). As …show more content…
However, he was wrong to assume this about Siriono, Holmberg made the Siriono look like complete savages. The death and disease that spread in their society was not because they were unchanged but truly because of smallpox and influenza (Mann, 2007, p.10). Which can arguably be seen from coming from the Europeans (Zinn, 2009, p.483). What Holmberg did not understand was there land had been shaped by somebody else. Holmberg made the biggest mistake just as the colonists did, where they saw the Native Americans as barbarians or the typical stereotype of the Nobel Savage (Mann, 2007, p.13). This shows how these images of Native Americans pass on to present day and many of the Westerners perspective about them. However, it is through education that the true knowledge about them is given. Holmberg’s Mistake can be seen as a myth and how many assumptions about the Native Americans are incorrect. Assuming and portraying Natives as this “primitive humankind” shapes Western societies thoughts on the Native Americans today. Therefore, Mann (2007) shows that Holmberg did make a mistake and that he did not take the time to actually view the Beni

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In 1491, Charles C. Mann aims to prove a once-widespread belief about Native Americans false. This belief, which he calls Holmberg’s mistake, was first published in the book Nomads of the Longbow by Holmberg himself. Holmberg states that before European influence arrived in 1492, the Native Americans were nothing more than mere savages with lacking religion, no appreciation for the arts past feathered beads, little impact on the natural world around them, and nomadic lifestyles. Charles C. Mann, collecting evidence from various archeologists, paleontologists, and researchers from prestigious universities, sets out to show just how wrong Holmberg was in his thinking.…

    • 488 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “Red earth white lies” by Vine Deloria is by all accounts and standards is a ground breaking book which brings into light the troubling picture of cultural bias against the native American Indians, their origin and historic traditions. In his own words he emphasizes the need of dialog between western science and tribal people and says “corrective measures must be taken to eliminate scientific misconceptions about Indians, their culture and their past”. He goes on to say “there needs to be a way that Indian traditions can contribute to the understanding of scientific beliefs at enough specific points so that the Indian traditions will be taken seriously as valid bodies…

    • 1594 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Columbus, The Indians, and Human Progress,” was written in 1999 by Howard Zinn, and it discusses some of the early interactions between Europeans arriving and colonizing the Americas and the Native Americans who lived there. Zinn quite clearly states the viewpoint of this article, saying he tries, in telling history, “not to be on the side of the executioners.” In other words, Zinn’s article focuses primarily on the effects of the Europeans on the Native Americans, highlighting specific cruelties committed intentionally by the Europeans more than the effects of disease. As far as historical context goes, Zinn covers a wide range of areas, from Peru to the Eastern Coast of North America, and a relatively large range of dates, from Columbus' original…

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    1. Until quite recently, most American history textbooks taught that before Europeans invaded the Americas Indians were savages who lived in isolated groups and had so little impact on their environment that it remained a pristine wilderness. We now know from scientific discoveries that this account was wrong. What is the effect of learning that most of what we have assumed about the past is "wrong in almost every aspect," as Mann puts it on page 4?…

    • 1263 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Karen Kuckerman Analysis

    • 680 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Native Indians were described by many colonists as, “[churlish]”, and … “dignified”, (Kupperman, 1977, p.263). Kupperman’s purpose for initiating the article with the colonists’ views was…

    • 680 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Deloria offered many negative points about American anthropologists, but he also provided a sense of credibility by stating that he spent many years in the reservations studying and learning about the “real” Indians. However, it was not enough credibility or an evidence. It still makes me questioning his paper by him clamming to spent a lot of time in the reservations. There are some anthropologists who also spent a lot of time in the reserve yet are unable to accurately portray the Indians. Since he created such a strong opinion, I feel that it is only fair for him to also support it with something as strong and reliable. Nevertheless, Deloria did a good job in helping the readers stay on track on this lengthy article by highlighted his idea and emphasized his view by writing certain words or phrases in all capital…

    • 594 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Bibliography: -Sherman, Dennis, and Joyce E. Salisbury. The West in the World. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, 2011. Print.…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Holmberg's Mistake

    • 487 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Allen Holmberg was an anthropologist who studied at Cornell University, also serving as the head of the anthropology department. During his time as a doctorate student, he lived with the Siriono, a Native American group settled in Bolivia. Holmberg studied the Siriono people and wrote a book, Nomads of the Longbow, of his findings. Although all of the information found in his book is accurate, Holmberg made a very critical mistake.…

    • 487 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    By the time the 1st world war broke out in 1914 many ordinary British civilians were affected in many aspects. Some of these aspects were conscription, rationing, censorship and DORA. The aim of this essay is to analyze in what way ordinary British civilians were affected by the war. In order to do so I will analyze the different aspect that affects them.…

    • 1301 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the General History of Virginia, using biased language, John Smith portrays the natives as uncivilized, but his portrayal goes deeper than using the word savage. (despite the fact that this is nothing more than a clash of cultures….) Smith refers to the natives as “savages”, barbarians, and “more devil than a man,” and mocks their dress and behavior.…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Penances for the Invaders

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Hunt, Lynn, Thomas Martin, Barbara Rosenwein, R. Po-chia Hsia, Bonnie Smith. The Making of the West: Peoples and Cultures. 3Rd ed. Boston, New York: Bedford/St. Martin 's, 2009. Print.…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hollitz Chapter 1

    • 689 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Although often viewed as inferior, savage and helpless, many historians are starting to discover the intelligence and wisdom the Indians had and shared with the colonists that came to America so long ago. As the settlers slowly began to create a new world on the already inhabited North America, they were plagued with starvation due to a severe drought in the area. Due to the dry lands and the settlers expectations to “rely on Indians for food and tribute,” (Norton 17) they were disappointed to find that the Indians were not so keen to handing out food and help to the strangers that have just come onto their land and begun to settle in such a time of severe weather and starvation. As time goes on, both the Indians and the Englishmen realize they both have what the other needs; tools from the white men and crops, land and knowledge from the Indians. As a result, the chief of Tsenacomoco, Powhatan, and colonist, Captain John Smith on an ideally peaceful, mutualistic relationship to ensure the survival of both civilizations. This agreement will leave the groups in cahoots for 100 of years leading to some disastrous scenarios and betrayals.…

    • 689 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    West

    • 294 Words
    • 2 Pages

    1. Levack, B., Muir, E., & Veldman, M. (2011). The west: Encounters & transformations, vol. 1 (3rd ed.).Boston, MA:…

    • 294 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    It may be seen that European colonialism is something that is vile, as it has totally destroyed the culture and traditions of a group of people, which in turn destroyed their identity. However, in how Okonkwo and his tribesmen practice their tradition, it can be seen that…

    • 1594 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the reading, “Facing East from Indian Country,” Richter tries to tell us the perspective of Native Americans by providing the information of Indian’s side. He points out that we are only given the history record of the time European first meet the Indians by the European because at that period of time, the Indian were still using their own language, and having primeval life. Thus, they did not record the history as the European did. Therefore, in the book Richter provides some examples to show how Indians feel when in the first meet of Indian and European. “In an Indian dwelling, a woman tells her granddaughter about the first meeting between Native people and Europeans...Unable to figure out who the visitors were, the Native people call them ouemichtigouchiou, or woodworkers.”1 Although this is just an imagination, this gives us a picture that how the Indians see the first meeting. Also, Richter explains that those imaginations are connected to other historical events, “…the tale of sailors who ate sea biscuits and drank was told to a French missionary in 1633 by a Montagnais who turn had heard it from his grandmother years earlier.”2 From his explanation, we can know all of the imaginations are connected to those surviving documents. Those imaginations give us a picture that how it looks like in Indian’s view and what the European left behind in the history.…

    • 338 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays