Preview

How Far Did the First Five Year Plan Differ from the Second and Third Five Year Plans?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1303 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
How Far Did the First Five Year Plan Differ from the Second and Third Five Year Plans?
How far did the first five year plan differ from the second and third five year plans?

The first five year plan of1928-32 was created by Stalin for the ideological reason of rapid industrialisation and to boost the Russian economy to catch up with and protect from western cultures. While the second plan of 1933-37 and third year plan of 1938-41 stayed the more or less the same in their social outcomes and success/failures and their poor implementation but differed in the details of their priorities.

The priorities of the first five year plan differed significantly to those of the second of and third year plans, despite the priority of heavy industry continuing throughout them all. The priorities of the first year plan was to industrialise rapidly, due to fear of invasion and being as Stalin stated in 1931 being ‘crushed’ by the western cultures, due to attacks seen on communists in China and the British raid on the Soviet Union, both in 1927. Therefore the main priority was to focus on heavy industry and raising production of coal, steel, iron and oil. Another main priority was to abandon the NEP, introduced in 1924, in order to rid of the remaining capitalists in the country, such as the Nepmen and the bourgeoisie specialists who benefited from the system, which had become unpopular both within and outside the majority of the communist party. This created some social equality, of which whilst attempted lacked in the second and third year plans. This differed slightly from the second year plan in the way that its initial main priority was to re-establish production of consumer goods that had been lacking in the 1st Five year plan. However in 1933 this later changed back to heavy industry seen in the first plan and military spending in response to German rearmament. The first year plan differed majorly from the third year plan as this focused entirely on German rearmament for impending attack and became refined as it was focused on creating a war economy,

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The New Economic Policy, known as the NEP was an economic system used in the USSR 1921-1928. The NEP was introduced after war communism. This was because war communism involved kulaks and other peasants being forced to give up their crops in order to support the army, this in turn made them quite upset and angry which made them destroy crops. This meant that the growth of crops and food was falling back to 1913 standards and Lenin had to do something about it so he brought about the NEP. This was particularly good at the time as it allowed individuals the opportunity to make money and do well for themselves. But it was unpopular to many communists.…

    • 586 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The NEP, abbreviation for the ‘New Economic Policy’, was a number of policies deployed by Vladimir Lenin to improve the conditions of post war USSR. The NEP replaced the system of War Communism which was used between 1918 and 1921. The main motive for the War Communism policy was to support and supply the Red Army with food and weapons during the Russian Civil War. However, after the war the country was in turmoil and the majority of the Soviet Union’s population suffered hardship and poverty. This was when a quick solution was needed to revamp the Russian economy and the NEP policies were the solution. The NEP was made to balance the needs of the well of and the poor. The NEP allowed small business to prosper and make money which seemed popular to the peasants. It had also created more stability within the country in the economical sector but all these successes did not last.…

    • 676 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first plan was introduced in 1928 and ended at 1932 and its main emphasis was on heavy industrialisation. The main aim of the first five year plan was to transform Russia into a communist industrialised country without the need of a capitalist society. Stalin was also scared that the west may try and stop the process of turning communism so Stalin believed that rapid industrialisation which was not provided by the NEP would Russia to grow. A growing threat from west also meant that industrialisation would allow the USSR to increase its armaments. Throughout these years production of certain raw materials grew rapidly. For example coal rose from 35.5 million tonnes to 64.4 million tonnes and pig iron from 6.2 to 7.1 million tonnes. The first five year plan also focused on building the foundation of the industrialisation. Huge engineering projects took place new big industrial complexes were built and huge tractor works were being built in major cities such as Stalingrad to meet the needs for agriculture. This was so that the industrialisation process would become more efficient.…

    • 1294 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    I believe that ideological factor were responsible for Stalin’s decision to replace the NEP with the collectivisation of agriculture and the Five Year Plans as Stalin was disgruntled by the peasants work ethic and continuingly wanted to become more communist and ideological issues were the main contributors that, if changed would make a vast difference to Russia. However, other factors also could have been responsible for Stalin’s decision to replace the NEP with the collectivisation of agriculture and the Five Year Plans such as political and economical aspects. I feel that the main contributor in determining Stalin’s decision was the economic factors that Stalin was determined to industrialise Russia and under the NEP this was not possible.…

    • 1027 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The 5-year plans objective was to dramatically increase industrialization, helped along by collectivization. Within a decade, Soviet Russia became the second most industrial power in the world. The party determined…

    • 1040 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Josephe Stalin DBQ

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Stalin launched his first Five-Year Plan in 1928 by setting up a command economy. The purpose of the Five-Year plan was to create a road map for Stalin’s great goals of industrialization and the development of the Soviet Unions (OI.) Specific goals were set in the areas of electricity, coal, oil, pig-iron, and steel (DOC 2.) The Five-Year plan resulted in strengthening the Soviet Unions economic position and turned it into a powerful industrial state. In an excerpt from The Land of the Soviets its stated, “The rate of industrial growth in the USSR considerably exceeded that of the capitalist countries.” (DOC 8.) This is proven in several charts showing the rapid growth in farming and industrialization (DOCS 2, 3, 4.) Stalin said, “To slow down would mean falling behind. And those who fall behind are beaten. But we do not want to be beaten! One feature of the old Russia was the continual beatings she suffered for falling behind, for her backwardness….” (DOC 1.) This momentum helped arouse Russian pride to motivate the people. Stalin’s method of motivation imposed the people to come together as one and get ahead in order to dodge falling behind or any kind of harm to their country (OI.)…

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Stalin Dbq

    • 887 Words
    • 4 Pages

    To modernize the economy, Stalin came up with Five-Year Plans, which were plans that would rapidly develop the economy over a five-year period by setting up high production goals for heavy industry. In 1928, Stalin gave a speech before launching the first Five-Year Plan. Stalin said that they were falling behind other nations. ”We lag behind the advanced countries by fifty to a hundred years” “And those who fall behind are beaten”, he told the people “you must end our backwardness”. In 10 years, he thought the technological gap between the Soviet Union and the more advanced nations would be filled. He used this speech as a method of motivating the Russian people into participating and supporting his Five-Year Plan. “Either we do it, or we shall…

    • 887 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The five-year plan Stalin became famous for was a stamp on Russia’s history in economics. Granted Stalin did yield some output from the plan, but nothing close to what he had originally intended. With outrageous quotas set for people to meet, and mass shortages occurring, Russia was plagued by incompetent and reckless Stalinist behavior, which he became so famous for. Khrushchev would end up in the same hole, making similar mistakes by trying to outpace America by adding two years to Stalin’s plan and making grain their central icon for output. Khrushchev would implement the virgin land scheme, a gamble with the northern part of Kazakhstan’s barren land for farm development. Because the agricultural development of Russia had never stabilized…

    • 192 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    To a certain extent Stalin did meet, in places, the overly optimistic aims for the Five Year Plans yet this was to be at the cost of millions of lives and the livelihoods of many Russian peasants who were to be ruthlessly killed, extradited or simply stripped of their land and possessions. The success of the Five Year Plans can be judged upon the entry of Russia into the Second World War for this was to be the first big test of the newly industrialised state on the world stage. Stalin had aimed to bring about the complete modernisation of Russia as a country and in doing so had hoped that this would mean that Russia could overtake the Capitalist Nations of the West. Stalin himself was the individual who had proposed such plans for he was the one it may be argued, who wished to achieve an historical role for himself as the successor of Lenin. Evidence of this proposal, putting Russian development at the forefront of his ideas, is illustrated by his speeches in which he calls for the need to "create socialism in one country". His objectives were clear for he gave priority to the recovery of the peasant sector and to the financing of industry, which, he argued, were to become possible due to the prospect of the increased prosperity of the Russian peasantry. However one should also argue that they would probably have occurred anyway and another leader may have attained the same end result yet without the terrible effects upon the Russian population and way of life.…

    • 3200 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Joseph Stalin became the leader of the Soviet Union after Lenin’s death in 1924. In 1928 Stalin began the First Five-Year Plan, an ambitious attempt to quickly modernize the Soviet economy. In the speech below, given in 1933 to the Central Committee of the Communist Party, Stalin explained the goals and results of the Five-Year Plan.…

    • 2022 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Ww1 Notes

    • 277 Words
    • 2 Pages

    7. Five-Year Plans: high quotas of steel, coal, oil, and electricity. Limits were placed on consumer goods (rationing).…

    • 277 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The death of Lenin marked the start of Stalin legacy over U.S.S.R. In his speech The Hard Line, he said “All beat her-for her backwardness: for military backwardness, for cultural backwardness, for political backwardness, for industrial backwardness, for agricultural backwardness.”, not only does this phrase describes the state of U.S.S.R but also Stalin ambition and sensitivity towards his country. Stalin design was to insure that Russia would no longer trail behind the rest of the world as it had done in the past. The Five Year Plan as it was called, would help Russia obtain authority and dominance over Europe. The first phase was to overhaul Russia’s heavy manufacturing and industry. This would include the production of steel, cast iron,…

    • 513 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When in power, Stalin realized that if Russia was to become a key player in the global market, the country needed to industrialize rapidly and increase production. To do this, Stalin introduced the Five-year Plans. Stalin's ultimate aim was to expand industrial production. For this, he developed three Five-year Plans between 1928 and 1938.…

    • 626 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1928, Stalin introduced the first Five Year Plan whereby the New Economic Policy of Lenin was abandoned and a centrally planned economy was put in its place. This idea would ensure forced economic growth. A number of factors contributed to this huge change in the soviet planned economy: Stalin wanted greater control of the economy so that he would have greater control over the Soviet Union as a whole. Stalin also wanted to modernise Russia so that it would match the economies of the western world, saying that ‘Russia was 50 to 100 years behind the west’. The first Five Year Plan was directed by Gosplan who decided to focus on industry in Russia. Gosplan decided to focus on production in manufacturing, transport and raw materials. The first plan concentrated on heavy industry – coal, iron and electricity. The expansion of heavy industry in Russia formed the basis for Stalin’s transformation of the Russian economy. The overall targets were far too high but significant progress was made as machinery production increased by four, electricity almost trebled and oil production doubled. However, there was also poor quality in the production of consumer goods due to concentration on amplifying heavy industry production. The first Five Year Plan was only the start of Stalin’s transformation of the Russian economy.…

    • 1340 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The second five-year plan focused on industry, especially heavy industry. Domestic production of industrial products was encouraged in the Second plan, particularly in the development of the public sector.…

    • 3059 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Good Essays