Preview

Is the Reid technique capable of generating false confessions

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
371 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Is the Reid technique capable of generating false confessions
Is the Reid technique capable of generating false confessions, and if so are the safeguards sufficient to insure that these false confessions will not be used against innocent subjects?

I will have to say as in life, nothing is perfect. Yes, the Reid technique is capable of generating false confessions. If certain elements are present then there are circumstances during the interrogation that will produce a false confession. Some of these (obvious) elements are improperly and mishandling of the Nine Reid Steps of Interrogation or failing to recognized specific factors or signs such as the mentally ill, children / young adults, or persons with low I.Q. These facts will inevitably suppress a confession.

As with all fallacies, in order to understand the suspect and situational factors involved in false confessions, more research needs to continue. It is a popular now known fact that studies of false confessions reveal most people who make false confessions are the young, developmentally disabled or mentally ill. However, if a true suspect is foolish enough to fall for police deception, they do so at their own peril (Rhode Island v. Innes, 1980; State v. Jackson, 1983).

I believe if the proper techniques are utilized throughout the nine steps and avoiding the signs of the mentally ill, juveniles, etc. An investigator should overall be successful in obtaining a true confession without suspicion from liberal critics. However, this may be untrue because liberal critics are never satisfied.

A little known upcoming safeguard may be useful in preventing false confessions is called the Gudjonsson Suggestibility Scale (GSS). The GSS is a test that tries to measure how susceptible a person is to coercive interrogation (Gudjonsson, 1984a; 1992; 1997). Studies found the GSS has a sufficient reliability and test-retest stability (Gudjonsson, 1992). If anyone is interested in learning more about the GSS, you can read an article at

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the case, Frazier v Cupp, the Supreme Court ruled deception as an acceptable practice by police investigators during an interrogation (Frazier v. Cupp, 1969). The deception used by the investigator led Frazier to believe his partner had confessed to the murder. The United States Supreme Court ruled, misrepresentation through oral deception by an investigator was acceptable. A case heard in Florida in 1989, Florida v Cayward, defined parameters for deception utilized by law enforcement during interrogations. This case focused on fabricated evidence used to coerce the suspect into confessing. The Florida Appellate Court suppressed the confession on the grounds of eroding public confidence. The court affirmed the use of oral deception, conversely,…

    • 218 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cvsa

    • 1030 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This paper will discuss the various methods and techniques that can be employed in an attempt to beat the polygraph.…

    • 1030 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The questionable police practices are mainly focused on the interview process of the witnesses. One issue was the used of Reid Technique for eyewitnesses. Reid technique is a series of…

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Within the study, 136 residents of the Wynne Unit of the Texas Department of Criminal Justice witnessed a staged theft and provided testimony to the incident (Colwell et al, 2002). The interview consisted of scripts derived from Structured, Cognitive, and Inferential Interview techniques. Participants were assigned randomly to one of the three interview techniques and were measured on their honesty and dishonesty to the questions obtained. Participants randomly assigned to the honest group were instructed to report everything about the incident as truthful as possible. Participants in the dishonest group were instructed to distort the testimony from the honest group to debar the conviction of the staged perpetrator. The interviews were held individually for a duration of one hour and were recorded and videotaped (Colwell et al, 2002). The role of the interviewers was to accurately identify participants who were giving fabricated statements and honest statements.…

    • 511 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This further illustrates that police officers can use multiple tactics other than simple questioning such as deception, a list of narratives, and open-ended questions. Suspects might admit that committing the crime for multiple reasons including mental illness, desire for attention, and to protect loved ones. Corroborated and nonpublic facts are based on police not disclosing facts to the public and how the confessions can be contaminated through the police or expert evidence can all lead to false confessions (Garrett,…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Falsely confessing to a guilty plea is another way in which wrongful convictions may be mete out. However, if a person is truly innocent, what would be so strong so as to compel them to plead guilty? One logical answer is that when the potential to be convicted of a crime exists and carries a mandatory sentence with it, it may be better to plead to a lesser crime, which may carry a lower sentence and allow for a conditional sentence. Stat on number of wrongful convictions. Even a single wrongful conviction is a travesty and injustice to the…

    • 1521 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution forbids the use of coerced confessions in criminal proceedings (Peak et at, 2010). However, internal investigations are a different matter. The U.S Supreme Court case of Garrity v. New Jersey defined what must be done. The case got its start when officers under investigation for fixing citations were ordered to give statements or be fired (Roufa, 2014). The statements were then used to convict the officers and they appealed saying that their statements were coerced with the threat of being fired (Roufa, 2014). The court agreed and what arose from the case was the Garrity rule which states “that if an officer is compelled to provide self-incriminating information or statements, such statements…

    • 335 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Crim Pro outline

    • 19298 Words
    • 61 Pages

    i. While a susceptible mental condition of the person is a factor to be weighed in the balance, suppression is appropriate only where it can be demonstrated that the police exploited that condition by means of coercion and that the confession resulted from the exploitation…

    • 19298 Words
    • 61 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    This leads us back to the analysis of whether or not to Hart’s confessions should be admissible, there are similar reasoning, but slightly varying answers amongst the Justices. It was agreed that the confession Hart made at the scene of the crime and to Mr. Big should be inadmissible. Yet, in regards to the confession made to the undercover officer, there were differing opinions. The two prominent ones being that after considering a prong by prong analysis of the confessions based on the probative verses prejudicial value that that confession should be determined at a new trial. Or that the confession should be dismissed based on the implied social and financial inducement. I completely agree with those who wanted to dismiss Hart’s confessions to Mr. Big and the confession he made at the scene of the crime. Based on the prejudicial influence…

    • 848 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For many years now, there has been an enormous increase in the accusations of innocent defendants of wrongful convictions. Research has shown a number of common factors that appear frequently in wrongful conviction cases, including forensic error, prosecutorial misconduct, false confessions, and eyewitness…

    • 44 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    about their first school day and a false narrative about either an implausible event (abducted by a…

    • 4907 Words
    • 20 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Miranda Decision Case

    • 275 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In NC, for example the percentage of those who confessed after their interrogation from 49 % before Miranda to 16 % after(Cassell,1998). Those criminals that are caught and question, as the questioning goes on, they deny to respond any longer and ask for an attorney.…

    • 275 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Where the increasing amounts of technology are constantly aiding in finding criminals and suspects, nothing has proven to hold up in court better than a confession. Although, there are rules and regulations as to how these confession will be allowed to be admitted into court, just like in all things. These rules and regulations are defined pretty clearly in the fourth, fifth, and sixth amendments of the constitution.…

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    These wrongful convictions played a major role in more than 75% of wrongful convictions overturned by DNA testing (The Innocence Project, 2010). Although eyewitness testimony can be critical evidence before a judge or jury; 30 years of strong social science research has proven that eyewitness identification is often unreliable. The research which was conducted by the Innocence Project revealed that the human mind is not like a tape recorder or video camera; we neither record events exactly as we see them, nor recall the instance exactly how it occurred. Nevertheless, witness memory is like any other evidence at a crime scene, it must be documented carefully and retrieved methodically and quickly, or it can be contaminated (The Innocence project 2010). We as people can carry fibers, through our clothing, skin and hair that can cause the contamination of a crime scene just by not following proper procedure. Furthermore, in these types of cases, DNA has proven what scientists already know, that eyewitness identification is frequently…

    • 2876 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Torture Vs Torture

    • 1648 Words
    • 7 Pages

    From the psychological point of view, if the pressure is high enough, an innocent person may “remember” a crime he or she did not even commit. Even Barry C. Feld’s study states that “a confession is compelled, provoked, and manipulated from a suspect by a detective who has been trained in a genuinely deceitful art.” He admits that detectives manipulate their subjects’ minds to cooperate and give a confession. Along with this data, one way detectives obtain information is by presenting false data, misrepresenting facts, and lying (Feld 221). Detectives do this to make the suspect think that something has happened, even if it is really has not, or vice versa. When the person of interest believes this false statement, he might confess, though it may not be true. He may confess because he thinks that the detectives expect any confession and will not let him go until he gives them some sort of information. In this case, the person of interest, who is under tons of stress, will invent some story to appease the detective. Because this sort of interrogation places the suspect under a lot of stress, society believes that it should not be…

    • 1648 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays