Preview

James William Gibson's Novel, Warrior Dreams: Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1071 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
James William Gibson's Novel, Warrior Dreams: Analysis
English 1A
Fall 2009

Warrior Dreams

This paper will examine the writings and opinion of James William Gibson in his publication of “Warrior Dreams”. I strongly support Gibson’s suggestions about how the world today is negatively affected by the political and popular culture. By supporting his idea I strongly agree that warrior fantasies can easily be obtained from the worlds events. He argues that the shame of defeat of the United States in the Vietnam War by such a skillfully inferior enemy. For most men, their definition of masculinity includes strength, adventure and the will to compete in violent struggles. This theory is reinforced in popular movies, television shows, music, and books that glorify this behavior and have dangerous consequences for our country and even around the world. The seriously threatening and real-world implications that can be found in the political and popular culture varies from all kinds of different movies, television shows, and even video games. Movies that have real world gun fights and bloody cringing scenes like the Saw series movies, and war movies like Saving Private Ryan, Full Metal Jacket, Gladiator and the Rambo series has contributed to the promotion and acceptance of violence in our society. These movies all portrayed a strong leader and warrior hero that was dominant and is what may have led to most warrior fantasies for males that watch these films and cannot control their actions. Especially movies that were about the Vietnam War, showing how different things were during and after the war. For example, when the United States had to deal with an extremely disappointing loss in the Vietnam War, it was almost as if no one knew what to do. The people in America were nearly dazed and confused on how to take action and how they truly felt after the shameful defeat in Vietnam. I also agree with Gibson’s sociological theories and interpretation of response of American subculture after the disillusionment

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The representation of the warrior figure contrasts within The 500 Years of Resistance Comic Book by Gord Hill and AlterNatives by Drew Hayden Taylor. Both comic and play script highlight two spectrums in which the warrior figure can be depicted. They both indicate a more militant perspective in which Warriors are shown to represent their interests and reject those that disagree. 500 years of Resistance largely highlights the physical struggle of warriors against European conquest and colonialism whilst Alternatives represents the recently found use of intellect to argue for Native rights and retain its history. Both texts also acknowledge a diminished warrior figure, one in which is overwhelmed and subordinated physically in Hill’s comic and one that is subordinated socially in AlterNatives.…

    • 2572 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Based on the cultural lens in the book The Things They Carried by Tim O’Brien, the stories “Field Trip”, “The Man I Killed” and “On the Rainy River” shows how a community can expect some of the men to go to war and how the men are ashamed or embarrassed not to go to war like others because of the stereotypical pressure of the community. The men felt like they had to be in war and as a result losing who they are once they experience war. The examples from the chapters shows how the stereotypical expectation in society make the men ashamed and/or embarrassed and how they feel like they have to go to war.…

    • 851 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Mary Anne did not originally dream of consuming the war, yet after converting to the dangerous and edgy lifestyle, she says, “Sometimes I want to eat this place. The whole country -- the dirt, the death -- I just want to swallow it and have it there inside me” (106). The war unapologetically and completely corrupted a young innocent girl and transformed her into a nasty war animal. Tim O’Brien’s dream was to avoid the war at all costs, yet he participated in the war and took a life. War brought out the evil instinct Tim inherited and although he wanted nothing to do with the war, “Beyond anything else, he was afraid of disgracing himself” (121). Norman Bowker’s dream was to find an escape from the war and be at peace with the loss of his friend. However, his guilt would not let him live with himself. He tried to cope with the grief by occupying his time with pickup basketball and odd jobs, but the war made Norman feel so alienated and alone that he physically could not talk about it and thought the best decision was to take his life. The conclusions drawn about men and war are that it brings out the negative qualities in people and although one can physically escape the war, the war never emotionally leaves someone…

    • 1351 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the late 1970’s a time of national trouble that stemmed from the Vietnam War, the American-Iranian Hostage crisis and domestic economically strife, undermined long-held American cultural principles embodied in heroines such as “superman” as a representation of masculinity, America as the “good guys” and the American Dream. As a result these Idealistic dreams of were torn out of American hearts and replaced by more practical, logical “modern” principles reflected in the 1980’s which embraced the modern principles of materialism, consumerism, blockbuster movies and cable TV as an essential part of contemporary American culture. This era of change with heroines being replaced by their logical, “modern” counterparts, anti-heroes as relatable characters that appeal to the American economical dissention while keeping in toe with the principles of the American Dream.…

    • 269 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Russell Banks’s “Lobster Night,” violence wrongly interpreted as masculinity drives the cowardly and weak-minded into a state of delusion. People associate unrelenting strength, fearlessness, and boldness with the idea of manliness, fabricating an inaccurate representation of the male figure - as if all men ever want to do revolves around displaying their masculine nature. While this truthfully may be the case at times, it easily misconstrues the notion of an honorable man, influencing the naïve to believe the only way to portray real manhood involves excessive acts of bravery and determination, occasionally even using unnecessary force to verbally wound and/or inflict physical pain. Growing up with such an idea causes the mind to create excuses and false justifications, fooling itself into a warped version of reality.…

    • 558 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The mythos of America had started long before the era of modern militarism; however, it had boomed in popularity during said era due to John Wayne. It was soon known to be the John Wayne mythos. Said mythos became of the talk of the nation, filling up novels and films, and used as propaganda for the war. It is built on heroism, the idea that America is the impeccable saviour of the world—that they are always right, no matter what the situation is. Despite how bright this mythos seems, it has some extremely negative effects on the American society. This heroic mythos of America is ruining said nation by creating distrust and violent characters among the people.…

    • 1336 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    It is claimed that “sex is the weapon of life, the shooting sperm sent like an army of guerrillas to penetrate the egg’s defenses-the only victory that really matters.” With this being said, sex, and how the sperm must go through several enemy territories to declare victory, is war. Interchangeably, according to William Broyles in his novel Why Men Love War, war is actually sex. The power generated through war and the bonding of individuals “heightens…sexuality” and as a result makes “war…a turn on.” People love war because people love weapons and the power and opportunity to destroy nations, infrastructure, and/or ideas. War therefore is the union between sex and destruction—between love and death. Broyles believes that to fully understand the seduction of the opposite gender, it is crucial to hear the war stories of women. If their voices are heard, the gender-encoding stereotypes in war and the war stories can be denaturalized. We must understand the women’s viewpoint of the war to grasp the importance of ideological power for people, cultures, and humanity overall (Schneider 6). When we reach this understanding and gain insight on “the other side” of war, the parameters of war literature can be altered and we can “re-conceptualize aspects of…war’s political history” (Scott…

    • 2004 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The author does not only use researched data to justify these arguments of media violence or "mock violence"; he also displays some opinions and beliefs of his own, toward these arguments as well. Rhodes discusses his ideas of politicians' impression of media violence as a scapegoat because they do not have control over violence in America. He also gives a good critique in my opinion by saying " Violence is on the decline in America, but if we want reduce even further, try protecting children from real violence in their real…

    • 487 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    History 137

    • 575 Words
    • 3 Pages

    War is and always has been a topic of discussion in the world whether it be in the daily newspaper, a presidential campaign speech or a history classroom. Often we focus on past wars, current wars, fatalities, battles and countless other topics. Then, there is the occasional talk about men that have fought in history’s brutal wars. Veterans could tell story after story of the pain and suffering that they saw and experienced themselves. But you can only begin to imagine. Also seen in the movie Apocolypse Now.…

    • 575 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Red Convertible Symbolism

    • 607 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Brave men in the military who fight for their country are often victims of stereotype. They are thought of as emotionless people whose only purpose is to follow orders; have no sentimental attachments to any materiality or spirituality. On the contrary, Tim O’Brien on “The Things They Carried” and Louise Erdrich in “The Red Convertible” write about the meaning of symbolism.…

    • 607 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mean World

    • 1027 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Everyone is influenced and shaped by society. Society affects our perceptions, our consciousness, and our actions. A majority of the influence, especially on the younger demographic comes through the media; specifically through television. It is important to examine how violence in the media develops a pervasive cultural environment that cultivates a heightened state of insecurity, exaggerated perceptions of risk and danger, and a fear-driven propensity for hard-line political solutions to social problems. The purpose of this essay is to evaluate the impact of television and media violence, as well as the human cost of violent media, and the overall effects on society from watching TV.…

    • 1027 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Society and culture have identified “manliness” as an objective that all “true” men should aspire too. In doing so the masculine gender has become defined not by the individual, but by collective concepts. In times of war these ideas become amplified, because survival is based not only on oneself, but also the man that is standing beside you. From 1954-1975, the Vietnam War would instill specific ideas of masculinity. The male gender developed an acceptance of violence and silent endurance of burden. Writer and Vietnam Veteran, Tim O’Brien, captures these social constructs in his version of “fictional-non-fiction”. Obrien stated that his literature is “for getting at…

    • 1338 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    TV isn't Violent Enough

    • 443 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The immediate and alarmist tone of Mike Oppenheim’s inductive essay, “T.V isn’t Violent Enough” is a flawless example of the ineffective strategy that Oppenheim has taken in conveying his rational and completely biased argument. The described imagery of cinema action scenes are unrealistic and not violent enough; Oppenheim’s essay falls victim to the fallacy of authority and Oppenheim confusion of television not being violent enough with television violence being nonsensical.…

    • 443 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    American Revolution

    • 1702 Words
    • 7 Pages

    “I’m going to make a name for myself. If I fail, you will never hear of me again” Edward James Muggeridge. True to his words he succeeded in making a name for himself and he created the first movie or “motion picture”. Movies are a rollercoaster ride that transcends people into a whole different world fresh out of somebody’s imagination as seen through the genres of horror, drama, and science fiction. The movie business allows people to break through the burden of everyday life. Considering today’s way of life, people would be lying if they did not admit that movies are an influential entity in our culture. Movies have been successful in ingraining values and elements into society. Movies exaggerate, sensationalize and at times even trivialize the matters of society. It has also played a major role in media in positive developments such as fight against racism, fight against gender bias, and spreading awareness about world peace. Author Bill Swanson who wrote the text, “How Films Feed the Mind or When I’m Hungry, I Don’t Want to Eat Candy”, would also agree that movies play a significant role in structuring our society. In his text he explains movies have a big influence to people both physically and physiologically. Swanson states that films are only analogies of the real world that condense time into a two-hour story. Furthermore, Swanson explains movies are part of people’s memories, and many compare and reflect movies into their own personal experience. There are numerous examples in which Swanson refers to movies that are influential and momentous. One of the movies that Swanson proposes is Raging Bull, he quotes that: “Raging bull is the irrational urge to define ourselves by violent acts of control and domination” (Swanson 240). Raging Bull requires viewers to have cultural knowledge in order to fully understand the film. Martin Scorsese presents a movie that many critics would consider a classic. There are many characteristics that make this…

    • 1702 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    Menace to Society

    • 2180 Words
    • 9 Pages

    As a society, people are quick to draw conclusions about certain individuals based on their physical appearance. Many times, it is a misconception of what the individuals being judged are actually like. While searching for a movie that demonstrates individuals’ behavior and their positive or negative interaction within a society, I came across Menace II Society. Menace II Society was the movie that reflects social problems, about the brothers Allen and Albert Hughes. . There are various social issues discussed in this movie such as “drug”, “murder”, “violence”, “crime”, and problems associated with the society. This movie not only reflects about the behavior and attitude of people in the society, but also reflects on the social norms and breaking laws.…

    • 2180 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Best Essays