Preview

Joanne Lipman Why Tough Teachers Get Good Results

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
393 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Joanne Lipman Why Tough Teachers Get Good Results
Joanne Lipman is the author and speaker of the article “Why Tough Teachers Get Good Results”. She is a Yale educated author, editor and journalist, and wrote the article around age 50. Lipman’s background as a baby boomer contributes to her bias towards the harsher methods of education. Baby boomer statistics about strictness-
Occasion
Joanne Lipman’s stressful high school experiences take place around the late 1970s, when she herself was an impressionable fifteen-year-old student in Mr. K’s class. The author wrote this article because her teacher died; it is her belated, glorified opinion of her late educator.
Audience
This piece is primarily directed to educators and administrators. This article seems like it is attempting to convince them,
…show more content…
education system to return to the old-fashioned methods of strict expectations and less praise. Joanne Lipman wants the audience to feel inspired and determined to restore old-school practices. The author wants the audience to understand, and endorse, stricter teaching methods.
Subject
The subject of the work is in the title; Lipman presents it very overtly. She is writing about tough teachers and their effect on the American education system through the students. Harping on returning to the traditional methods is Lipmans’ calling card throughout the piece.
Tone
The tone of this piece was slightly condescending. Joanne Lipman’s writing has a slightly negative connotation to the formation of her sentences. She cites an abundance of research, but much of it seemed unrelated to the point she was trying to make. Lipman instead relied on a series of opinion statements to prove her point; “Because here’s the thing: it works…. But the conventional wisdom is wrong…. Wrong again.” Her diction seems chosen for the express purpose of glossing over the actual findings of the studies, and instead substituting in what she wants the audience to believe; her flimsy connections to the facts that she wants them to

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Sizer’s book, Horace’s Compromise: The Dilemma of the American High School, is a fictional story that represents the reality of the true educational system. The main character, Horace Smith, is a highly respected English teacher at Franklin High School who is facing the dilemma of many reality educators; the affects of the very controlled, standardized system of high school. Horace is at the age when many teachers are near retirement; however, he isn’t leaving anytime soon. Sizer quotes that “He believes—perversely, he often thinks—that Franklin High is not nearly what it could be. He wants to stay on and make it better.” As an educator, Horace must compromise his natural intuition when it comes to teaching, for he is faced with a muddled school system in which he must abide by. Throughout the passage, Sizer illustrates Horace’s view on how fragmenting the system is on the school and all the different affects it has. Horace believes that “Everything in the school affects everything else.” Horace sees how the system doesn’t directly affect students, but how it mainly affects the teachers, leaving them with little control when it comes to teaching the students. He believes that “The major elements of schooling are controlled outside the teachers’ world.” This exposes the main root of the problem—the standardized system. Horace believes that the state district, which controls the entire system, is overly powerful, only taking consideration to standardized test scores and uses those results to determine how the school system should be constructed, causing the teachers to function rather mechanically in the school setting. Horace’s concept is that “Obviously, they don’t trust us…The folk higher up are sure they know better.” This clearly entails why students face this dilemma as well. Horace describes the students as “conventional,” meaning that the all adhear to accepted standards. He believes that students take advantage of this greatly, stating that “The kids play a…

    • 735 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gary Gossman Essay

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Gary was more than proud of the fact that he gave his students a quiz everyday in his Latin class so that they would remember what they had learned the day before. Gary also wanted his students to apply what they were learning to the real world. While interviewing my grandfather he said, “In American Government, I never gave a student an A unless they did at least two ‘A projects’.” These “A projects” were simple things like interviewing a local politician or going to a town meeting. Gary confided that discipline had been the hardest part of being a teacher for him, but he always had the best strategy for dealing with rowdy students. His plan was extremely simple, “if a student would act up in class I would say, ‘that is a great point. Maybe you should stay behind after the bell so that we can discuss it’,” this phrase would make the color drain from even the worst troublemaker’s face. Unlike his co-workers when he first began working, Gary refused to yell at or hit any of his students. In his forty-two years of teaching, the idea of it never crossed his mind. Being a teacher takes a lot of patience, and just as his father always said, “just know you are smarter than the kids, and that you have more experience than…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Quindlen’s first assertion is “Teaching is the toughest job out there”.(100) To uphold her assertion she uses anecdotes from her own first-hand experience and also quotes by a Pulitzer Prize-winning writer Frank McCourt. Along with these anecdotes she offers an authority from The Department of Education, based off their employee turn-over rates. Quindlen closes her first assertion with an analogy that exposes the effect that teachers have on American Citizens. These anecdotes along with the authority and analogy, make various emotional appeals to the readers. Bringing up anger to the assertion that teachers have the toughest jobs. And also a compassionate effect by persuading the audience to change their outlook on what a teacher’s job actually entails.…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to Lipman article, “ As it turns out, quite a lot. Comparing Mr.K’s methods with the latest findings in fields from music to math to medicine leads to a single , startling conclusion: It’s time to revive old-fashioned education. Not just old-fashioned in the sense that so many of us as kids, with strict discipline and unyielding demands. Because here’s the thing: It works.” (Lipman 6). In addition, this shows how effective a hard going teacher can be. Furthermore, many benefited from the old way of showing “constructive criticism”. An example of students benefiting is when Lipman writes herself, “Psychologist K. Anders Ericsson gained fame for his research showing that true expertise requires 10,000 hours of practice, a notion popularized by Malcolm Gladwell in his book “Outliers”. But an often-overlooked finding from the study is equally important: True expertise requires teachers who give “constructive, even painful, feedback,” as Dr.Ericsson put in a 2007 Harvard Business Review article. He assessed research on top performers in fields ranging from violin performance to surgery to computer programming to chess. And he found that all of them “deliberately picked unsentimental coaches who would challenge them and drive them to higher levels of performance.” (Lipman 10). All in all, Lipman gives an agreeable sense as to why students that don’t apply enough grit are open to failure compared to those that believe in grit and prefer hard hitting…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Identify any examples of bias presented by the author. If none exist, explain how you determined this.…

    • 2051 Words
    • 59 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the freshman year of fall 1994, Ms. Gruwell, who is later also known by her students as Ms. G, introduced herself through her first journal entry. Throughout her entry she wrote about the description of the school and its surroundings. Wilson High School is located in a safe area, but like Ms. Gruwell, you would have noticed that students from all walks of life attended the school. As a fairly new teacher, Ms. Gruwell expresses her nervousness through her entry by formulating questions that she thinks will arise when the students see her. “Will they think I’m out of touch or too preppy?…

    • 1410 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Teachers are, above all, people.” This sentence condenses the essence of this book—Teacher Identity Discourse: Negotiating Personal and Profession Space, by Janet Alsup. Teachers we know in class are usually professional and respectable. However, teachers are humans who have their own feelings and thoughts as well. One’s personal identity may not always works well with his or her professional identity as a teacher. In the book, Alsup indicates that the path one takes to become a teacher is a process crowded with tension, negotiation, and sometimes failures. Becoming a “heroical” teacher is not simply learning “a new set of rules for behavior”. Instead, one has to learn how to integrate his or her personal and professional…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Think about what educational system was like in the early 1900’s. Now think about the educational system today. The educational system has changed substantially since the introduction of public education in the mid to late 1800’s to the modern day educational system that many of us are aware of today. Back in the old days schools used to be equipped with slide rulers, chalkboards, and typewriters. Now modern day schools are equipped with electronic calculators, smartboards, and computers. However, now the educational system needs another adjustment. The educational system today is flawed with the lack of teacher training, the high stress, high workload school environment, and that schools can’t prepare their students for life. Leon Botstein, author of “Let Teen-Agers Try Adulthood” addresses these key issues. However, Botstein states dramatic and head scratching solutions that will leave anybody wondering if Botstein went to school. On the flip side David L. Kirp, the author of “The Secret to Fixing Bad Schools” as well as Horace Mann, author of “Report of the Mass Board of Education: provide…

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dr Grimm Thesis

    • 2032 Words
    • 9 Pages

    My heart raced from the ridiculous amount of coffee I had consumed that morning. I tentatively stepped into the dark, empty classroom and took a seat in the second row. As an English major, I resented the fact that I was required to take US History 201. I disliked history, and I heard rumors that my professor, Dr. Grimm, was a tough grader. The only contingent that caused me to feel slightly happy was the fact that I would be in the same class as Hannah Colasurdo, my longtime best friend. I had known Hannah since I was ten years old, and she had been there for me though my best and worst moments. Little did I know that this history class would cause me to fall to one of the lowest points of my entire life.…

    • 2032 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I Just Wanna Be Average

    • 5995 Words
    • 24 Pages

    Mike Rose is anything but average: he has published poetry, scholarly research, a textbook, and two widely praised books on education in Amer­ica. A professor in the School of Education at UCLA, Rose has won awards from the National Academy of Education, the National Council of Teachers of English, and the John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Foundation. Below you'll read the story of how this highly successful teacher and writer started high school in the "vocational education" track, learning dead-end skills from teachers who were often underprepared or incompetent. Rose shows that students whom the system has written off can have tremendous unreal­ized potential, and his critique of the school system specifies several reasons for the 'failure" of students who go through high school belligerent, fearful, stoned, frustrated, or just plain bored. This selection comes from Lives on the Boundary (1989), Rose's exploration of America's educationally under­privileged. His most recent book, Possible Lives (1996), offers a nationwide tour of creative classrooms and innovative educational programs. Rose is currently researching a new book on the thinking patterns of blue-collar workers.…

    • 5995 Words
    • 24 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Teacher Leadership

    • 1360 Words
    • 6 Pages

    During the 1980 President Regan decided to abolish the Federal Department of Education and to turn education back into the hands of the localities and the state. During these years there were also dramatic changes in ideas about the purposes and content of schooling. By the end of Regan terms school researchers came to the conclusion that basic skills was no longer sufficient enough to be competitive globally. They contended that teaching should be more deeply rooted in the disciplines and much more demanding. Teachers should be able to help students understand mathematical concepts, interpret serious concepts, write creatively and converse thoughtfully about science and history. Reformer proposed changes in politics and policy’s to achieve these goals (Ladd, nd)…

    • 1360 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Elementary students had begun taking standardized tests, the tests ranked teachers in grades 3-5 accordingly. Any person is able to see the “value-added performance” (Kuehn, Larry). Anxiety led to devastating occurrences; “One teacher, distressed by being singled out, committed suicide days after the individual teacher results were released” (Kuehn, Larry). The government did not take this incident seriously, even though they attempted to think about the issues, the final answer was “test better” (Kuehn, Larry). The tests are not accurate, voluminous students do not take the test completely and honestly; those students tend to lower the teacher’s ranking. A teacher can never actually make students try their hardest on the standardized tests; the students must put forth the effort in order for all scores and teacher’s rankings to be a reflection of their…

    • 861 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    As every teacher goes into the workplace, first year, or twenty-fifth, and despite any subconscious fear you might possess of the hideous class you might be challenged to educate, there is always a certain comfort in knowing that, regardless the case, you have the support of your administration to uphold most any rational expectation you place on your students. As the school year drew near, I’m sure this was the case even for Madame Esme, as she seemed eager to start her first year of teaching. She set her expectations high in all aspects and from day one seemed determined to see her students achieve accordingly. She maintained her ideals throughout the year, though, it becomes more evident that her superiors might not share such idealistic values. No case more true than is seen on May 4th. After trying to reach a male student, B.B., who seems to be having behavioral problems related to his home life, Esme finds herself separating her student from a “big pounding fight on the playground” (Codell,…

    • 2832 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Teachers’ profession was affected somewhat by this movement because they were sort of stuck in their traditional way of teachings and found it complicated to integrate subject matter into curriculum that was child-centered; “it presented…

    • 1158 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    McNeely, P, & Oland, D, (4/2002), Are Uniforms a Good way to Improve Student Discipline and Motivation, NES Today, p. 20…

    • 1817 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays