I relished in my victory because I thought I had finally solved Dr. Grimm’s grading philosophy. The third paper assignment came shortly after. Dr. Grimm assigned us to write a book review on The Radical and the Republican by James Oakes. This book documented the lives and deeds of Abraham Lincoln and Frederick Douglass. My draft ended up being a few hundred words over the limit, and I confidently sent it to my professor to look over. Dr. Grimm always made sure to provide critical yet respectful feedback, but my still fragile self-esteem translated his response to, “You better add more detail if you don’t want to be a failure because right now, this paper is atrocious.” I received that email the day before Thanksgiving Day. I may have cried; that moment remains hazy in my memory. I do, however, recall feeling furious. How dare my professor tell me to add more detail when my paper already surpassed the word limit by nearly three hundred miles. For about an hour, I sulked and pouted. I complained to my mom and Hannah. I called myself an idiot, and I felt sad that nothing I ever wrote would satisfy the sweet, harsh Dr. Grimm. I do not know what exactly happened within me, but when I sat back down to work on the paper, I became overwhelmed with an unexplainable energy and determination. You want more detail, Dr. Grimm? I thought to myself. Okay! Challenged
I relished in my victory because I thought I had finally solved Dr. Grimm’s grading philosophy. The third paper assignment came shortly after. Dr. Grimm assigned us to write a book review on The Radical and the Republican by James Oakes. This book documented the lives and deeds of Abraham Lincoln and Frederick Douglass. My draft ended up being a few hundred words over the limit, and I confidently sent it to my professor to look over. Dr. Grimm always made sure to provide critical yet respectful feedback, but my still fragile self-esteem translated his response to, “You better add more detail if you don’t want to be a failure because right now, this paper is atrocious.” I received that email the day before Thanksgiving Day. I may have cried; that moment remains hazy in my memory. I do, however, recall feeling furious. How dare my professor tell me to add more detail when my paper already surpassed the word limit by nearly three hundred miles. For about an hour, I sulked and pouted. I complained to my mom and Hannah. I called myself an idiot, and I felt sad that nothing I ever wrote would satisfy the sweet, harsh Dr. Grimm. I do not know what exactly happened within me, but when I sat back down to work on the paper, I became overwhelmed with an unexplainable energy and determination. You want more detail, Dr. Grimm? I thought to myself. Okay! Challenged