to apply scriptural virtues to the circumstances and challenges he and the colonists would face in creating their new social and political order.
Delivered in first person plural, Winthrop suggests that the Puritans should be one undiversified group for which he speaks, stating more than once that they are “knit together” as “one man” in a bond of common cause and common destiny. Meaning every individual’s fate was bound to and subject to that of the group, these ideas were nothing new however with George Gifford asserting in 1612 that “all true believers are knit together by one spirit”. But while Winthrop wanted his congregation to agree on certain doctrinal fundamentals he was aware there may have been differences of opinion on doctrinal non-essentials, and believed in unity rather than uniformity made for a community.
While for contemporaries the sermon was undoubtedly not too dissimilar from most Puritan teachings the prominence the sermon has today would no doubt be unthinkable.
There is only one brief reference to the Model of Christian Charity that has survived from the seventeenth-century occurring in a request by the Reverent Henry Jacie. In a letter written about February 1634 where he asks John Winthrop Jr. to obtain the Model of Charity, among other things. Subsequently there is no clear mention for two centuries, and no reference to anyone having heard it. Even so it was likely the Sermon was likely performed onboard the Arbella, facilitated by the close quarters. If they were educated men they may have understood that they were hearing a succinct statement on Protestant, and more particularly, Puritan teaching on the state and on man’s relationship to
it.