The themes of these two poems relate to the effects war has on soldiers, whether they are friendly or enemy. “Whether as enemies they fought, or fought with us, or neither; the sand joins them together.” This quote from “Beach burial” shows how pointless war is, and how whether they fight with or against each other, they are equal. “Homecoming” broadcasts this idea through the entire poem, using a wide range of poetic techniques as a backbone.…
Both John McCrae and Wilfred Owen were poets and soldiers during World War One, but they both had different roles and experiences in the war, so it makes sense that each of their poems are different, and relate to what they personally went through. John McCrae was posted as a medical officer, and took care of fallen soldiers. McCrae wrote the renowned poem “In Flanders Fields” the day after presiding over the funeral and burial of his friend Lieutenant Alex Helmer. This funeral shaped John McCrae’s outlook on war, which was revealed throughout his poetry. Wilfred Owen’s outlook on the war is dramatically different than McCrae’s because of his own two traumatic experiences. These traumatic experiences sent him to a treatment center, where…
E.E. Cummings in this poem takes a satirical view of patriotism. Here, more specifically, he pokes fun at the idolization of a system that has led many to senseless deaths. “why talk of beauty what could be more beaut-iful than these heroic happy dead who rushed like lions to the roaring slaughter.” Why should we look up to a nation that has led many of its young like lambs to the slaughter. He sheds light on some of the more negative actions our country has carried out. “they did not stop to think they died instead then shall the voice of liberty be mute?” Cummings asks if their death has silenced our liberty. Here Cummings seem to make a notion that the deaths that occur to protect our freedom negate…
While reading “In Flanders Fields” by John McCrae and “Here Dead We Lie” by A.E. Housman, I made sure to decode every word that the poems contained in order to self-interpret the pieces of literature. These World War I based poems carry significant stories of our once war torn planet. For example, “Here Dead We Lie” is a short, yet meaningful, poem about nationalism and pride towards ones country. In this poem, the author discusses the fact that soldiers often chose to die for their country instead of “to live and shame the land” (Housman 3). Later, he suggests that, since young men believe that life is of great significance, their sacrifices were of great value to the war effort. On the other hand, “In Flanders Fields” expressed the idea that,…
An Irish Airman foresees his death is about a man who has no opinion on the war, ‘those I fight I do not hate, those I guard I do not love’ this is ironic as he has no feeling as to who wins the war yet he is fighting for one side. The theme of the poem is simple and he structure is unbroken and composed, this is contrasts the idea of the poem as the airman knows he is going to die, ‘I know I shall meet my fate’ and therefore the calmness of the poem and the calmness of the airman is seen as peculiar as other people in this situation would be more panicked which is why the airman stands out as he keeps his mind at ease and reflects on his life. The airman who is thought to be Major Robert Gregory shows that he thinks that the war does not make sense to him at all and does not care who wins the war or who loses, as he does not see one as an enemy or one as an ally, ‘those that I fight I do not hate, those that I guard I do not love’ his feelings towards them are so because he lives in a sheltered part of Ireland and he implies if he was going to pick a place to fight for he would pick his hometown, ‘my country is Kiltartan Cross, my countrymen Kiltartan’s poor’ this shows that he is not loyal to Ireland but yet to the people who he sees on a daily basis and the people he cares about in Kiltartan Cross. The war also does not affect the people of Kiltartan Cross as they have nothing left to lose, ‘no likely end could bring them loss. Or leave them happier then before’ this shows that the airman wants to change how badly the people of Kiltartan Cross have been living as there was severe civil war in Ireland, and that the end of the current world war will not affect the state that Ireland is left in. The airman suggests that he did not fight to be labeled as brave and courageous, ‘nor law nor duty bade me fight, nor public men, nor cheering crowds’ this suggests that the airman has not signed up for war because for other people’s expectations or because he was forced to…
Slessor, having been a participating member in World War II, uses his poems, for instance ‘Beach Burial’, to explicitly distinguish the bodies of the dead floating through the water, and the commonality of death. ‘Beach Burial’ concludes by stating “whether as enemies they fought, or fought with us, or neither; the sand joins them together.” This is the persona’s recognition that there are dead soldiers on both sides, yet their humanity is bonded by their common fate of death. Effectively, the unity between soldiers of all nations, is through death. This is all very ironic, when the attitude of war is considered and the purpose of what soldiers are fighting for. However, the race, country and objectives of each person is no longer important upon the passing from one life to another. The war has ended up being what sentences them to death and essentially joins them as one. Regardless of the fact that ‘Beach Burial’ was written from an Australian author’s perspective, it has not pledged allegiance to a single country or alliance, nor does it celebrate a victory. It is instead, a tribute to all who were defeated. Death is an unexpected force that has the ability to change perspective. Kenneth Slessor is best known for his elegiac poems, ‘Beach Burial’ and ‘Five Bells’ and in turn, his ability to construct “a poem of serious reflection, typically involving the lament for the dead.” In these, it is the position of the elegist which Slessor inhabits through a persona, but he is truly, exclusively referencing to himself as the poet. ‘Beach Burial’ is an elegy about the multitude of lost lives through war. ‘Five bells’ along with ‘Beach Burial’ is written to lament the loss of life. His poems have a tendency to illustrate the confrontation of death and the misfortunate experience of those who are grieving the remembrance of a dead soul,…
Before I'm done, I'd like to read a poem about all the people who died and were buried in Flanders Field, where the poppies…
sweet and honourable to die for one's country” (WarPoetry). Likewise, the community in the poem…
The poem, “In Flanders Field” was created to remind the living of the fallen soldiers who were buried in a foreign field. Written by Lieutenant Colonel John McCrae in May 1915. It is believed McCrae wrote the poem in remembrance of his former student and close friend, Alexis Helmer, who died in the conflict. The poppies in the field growing between the crosses inspired John McCrae to write. “Between the crosses, row by row” The poppies are now a famous symbol of remembrance for the fallen soldiers of Canada, British Commonwealth, and the United States.…
involved in a war. Owen opens the poem with a description of a group of discouraged…
In the poem, The British soldiers, referred to in The Charge of the Light Brigade, charged into the Valley of Death with the fear of death, yet they marched into battle with their heads held high. The poem explains the courage it took for the soldiers to march towards the cannons in order to defend their country. As Sean is reading the Poem to Michael, he (Michael) asks Sean why they would risk their lives, referring back to the British courageously marching into the line of fire. Sean replies back with, "you should honor that." He explains…
The poem, In Flanders Field by John McCrae, explains the emotions of the soldiers who fought in World War 1. McCrae demonstrates this with the words he uses to set the changing tone of this poem. The poem switches from pride to depressing and then to a warning which shows how quickly emotions can change in the course of war. In addition to the tone of the poem the theme is also thought provoking.…
By reciting poems such as “In Flanders Fields” by Lieutenant Colonel John McCrae, we shall remember our soldiers. The wreath laying is done at the ceremony to help remember those who have fallen in battle. Near the end of the ceremony, there will be the candlelight tribute. By lighting candles, it recognizes our troops, and increases awareness and provides for a better understanding of the price paid by many Canadians. A poppy shall be worn.…
This poem expresses the emotions of the soldiers during The Battle of Lone Pine. It is able to showcase how the traumatic experiences soldiers had to undergo during the war changed them and how their families will have to adjust to them being different. This poem criticizes war as it argues how killing someone for your country is not worth it as not only are you physically hurting someone but you are also emotionally hurting that soldier's family as they will have to suffer a loss of a father or husband. This poem uses a range of poetic devices such as similes, personification, Rhetorical question and metaphors which helps to convey the horror and emotion of war. The poem is written in first person which helps the reader to better understand…
The second stanza shows his views on war and he shows that the death that occurs is more like slaughter than sacrifice.This stanza shocks the reader as it makes them realise and understand the true horrors of war.In addition Scott effectively presents his critisism on the way people perceive war when he uses two contrasting stanzas.The poet uses graphic vocabulary to create imagery.For instance ‘And mangled limbs and dying groans’.Theese are vivid and descriptive.They make the reader really imagine the agony and pain the people are experiencing.…